Cover of I Am America (And So Can You!) by Stephen Colbert

I Am America (And So Can You!)

2,635-word summary 12 min read 240 pages in the book

First published
2007
Publisher
Grand Central Publishing
Pages
240
ISBN
9780446580502
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. The voice, straight from the microcassette
  2. A life in three parts
  3. The jokes that stick
  4. The physical book as a prop
  5. The audiobook and the long promotional run
  6. What does not survive the trip to paper
  7. Who this is for
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this up because I wanted to see how a television character survives without the television. Stephen Colbert's right-wing pundit was a live wire on The Colbert Report, all booming certainty and pointed finger, and the idea of pinning him down between hard covers seemed almost unfair to the page. What I found is a strange and very physical object, part joke, part souvenir, part parody of the self-help shelf. It came out on October 9, 2007, from Grand Central Publishing, a 240-page hardback that spent months near the top of the bestseller lists. Reading it turned out to be a different experience from watching the show, and not only because you cannot hear the studio crowd laughing.

The book was written by Colbert together with the writers of The Colbert Report, and it is built around the fictional life story of the character he plays there. Colbert has described that character as a well-intentioned, poorly informed, high-status idiot, a man certain of his own correctness and armed with very little information. The whole project is an extension of the show rather than a separate piece of writing. He said he wrote it as a parody of the pundit memoirs stacked in airport bookshops, and that he forced himself through Bill O'Reilly's The O'Reilly Factor and Sean Hannity's Deliver Us From Evil to get the voice right. You can feel that homework in the way the book sounds like a man dictating his own press release.

The voice, straight from the microcassette

The opening lines set the tone immediately. "I want you to know that this is the first book I've ever written, and I hope it's the first book you've ever read," Colbert writes, and then, a little later, "I have so many opinions that I have overwhelmed my ability to document myself." The publisher's pitch claims the whole thing was dictated into a microcassette recorder over a three-day weekend, which fits the voice perfectly. This is not prose that was revised into silence. It reads like a man talking fast into a small machine, delighted with the sound of his own arguments.

There is a section called "How to Read This Book" that is one of the best bits in the whole thing. It instructs you, among other things, that "No image of me should ever be removed from this book for any purpose, including but not exclusively: book reports, decorating walls or placing in your wallet to imply our friendship." That line captures the book's central joke, which is that the persona treats his own face as a precious public resource. Elsewhere he promises to deliver his Truth "hot and hard. Fast and Furious." Everything is capitalized when the character thinks it deserves capitals.

That voice carries the entire book. Colbert never steps out of character to explain the joke or wink at you over the page, at least not in the main text. The satire depends on staying in the role, on saying ridiculous things with total conviction and letting the reader supply the disagreement. When it works, it is genuinely funny. When the character's opinions stop being absurd and start sounding like the real thing he is parodying, the joke gets harder to locate, and that is a tension I kept feeling as I read.

A life in three parts

The book is loosely structured as an autobiography of the persona, moving from childhood to adolescence to maturity. Part One is called "My American Childhood" and takes on The Family, Old People, Animals, and Religion. One of the religion chapter's sections is titled "Accepting Jesus as My Personal Editor," which tells you roughly how seriously the spiritual material is meant to be taken. Part Two, "My American Adolescence," covers Sports, Sex & Dating, Homosexuals, Higher Education, and Hollywood. Part Three, "My American Maturity," takes on The Media, Class War, Race, Immigrants, and Science.

The chapter list is the book's best organizing idea. By arranging the jokes as a life story, Colbert gives the pundit a childhood, a dating history, an education, and a career, and then lets him have views on everything. The progress from "The Family" to "Science" is meant to look like a mind maturing, but of course the character never matures at all. He simply acquires more topics to be wrong about. That gap between the structure and the person filling it is the quiet engine of the book.

Part Three also includes instructions on how to retire the book once you are finished with it, and the publisher's material suggests treating it like a flag being folded at the end of the day. It is a small running gag, but it gives the object a kind of ceremonial life. The book is not something you simply read and put down. In the character's world it is a patriotic artifact that must be handled correctly.

Near the end there is the written text of Colbert's White House Correspondents' Association dinner speech, the one that made him famous beyond comedy audiences. It is the one piece of material here that was already proven in front of a real audience, and it lands differently on the page. You can hear the room in it even in silence.

The jokes that stick

The best chapters are the ones where a single silly premise is pushed as far as it will go. In "The Family," Colbert announces that he is against children because he regards them as opponents, a bit of logic that only works if you accept the character's habit of treating every group as a rival political faction. "Old People" claims that senior citizens resemble lizards and that retirement and Social Security are for quitters. One passage about how tough the elderly are remembers a time when they made shoes out of newspaper and twine and lived on a thin stew of the same, sometimes going without so there would be enough newspaper and twine to treat a baby's scarlet fever. The deadpan delivery of that sentence is the joke.

The religion chapter contains a neat little trap. "Here's an easy way to figure out if you're in a cult: if you're wondering whether you're in a cult, the answer is yes," Colbert writes, and the line works because the character says it about other people while sitting inside his own absurd faith. In "Science" he declares that "Reality has a well-known liberal bias" and then compares scientists to cult members for their blind devotion to empirical observation. The joke borrows a phrase that had already been used about the news business and turns it into a reason to distrust the people who study evidence.

The "Homosexuals" chapter argues that Colbert is perfectly comfortable with gay men as long as they marry women and have children, and it warns of a Lavender Armageddon threatening the country. Other pages insist that the liberal media controls the wallpaper industry, that animals should be taught abstinence, and that the children's show Dora the Explorer carries sexual propaganda. These are not arguments so much as provocations, each one a small machine for producing outrage in the character's voice. The Northern Star review called the whole performance the work of a bigot whose ideas are distasteful and ignorant, then immediately noted that readers cannot take it seriously because the figure is a character. That double reaction is about right.

Some of the Fun Zone puzzles are as pointed as the prose. There is a connect-the-dots picture that forms a border along Canada and Mexico, a flow chart for deciding whether you are homosexual, and a maze in which an old man can find happiness by reaching Denny's, Florida, or a bottle of Jack Daniels. The puzzles are genuinely playful, and they also make the book's arguments feel like a game the reader is being invited to play along with.

The physical book as a prop

What separated this book from a pile of columns was its design, and reviewers noticed it immediately. The layout is red, white, and blue. The endpapers show Colbert facing off against himself in a style borrowed from the show's Formidable Opponent segment. Each chapter opens with a photograph of Colbert in his suit surrounded by props that match the topic, standing atop stacks of books with a sword for Higher Education, or clutching a bouquet of roses for Sex and Dating. There are photographs of him throughout, footnotes, and, most importantly, red margin notes running alongside the main text.

Those margin notes are the book's best formal idea. They argue back, correct, and contradict the confident text in the center of the page, in the same spirit as The Wørd segment on the show. The result is a page that disagrees with itself, which is a clever way to build satire into the furniture of a book. A reader can follow the main argument and the rebuttal at the same time, and neither one has to win.

The stickers are the other big physical gag. The cover carries a silver sticker showing a burning book and declaring I Am America a nominee for The Stephen T. Colbert Award for The Literary Excellence. Inside is a sheet of twelve similar stickers so readers can nominate other books for the same honor. A second sheet of red and blue stickers carries phrases like Hell Yeah!, Nailed It!, Show to Mother, I think it, Stephen says It, and It's Morning in Colbert-ica. The book tells you to use them as bookmarks, noting that you should not trust your memory and that these will remind you when you agreed with him most. The Spokesman-Review review called the result a patriotic object, and that seems exactly the right description. The book wants to be handled, stuck on foreheads, and waved around.

The audiobook and the long promotional run

The audiobook came out several days before the hardback and turned the book into a small ensemble piece. Colbert plays himself and also Gil Honeycomb, the oldest man in the world, in a "Stephen Speaks For Me" section in the second chapter. Amy Sedaris appears as Dolores Grierson, an old maid, in the first chapter. Raymond Whitman voices Young Stephen, Evelyn McGee plays Cow #L73NR, and Paul Gilmartin voices God. Kevin Dorff is the guy sitting next to you at the stadium in two chapters, Allison Silverman is Your Soulmate, Paul Dinello plays Austin, a formerly gay man, and Brian Stack plays both Dr. Bernard Brunner and Thomas Bindlestaff. Jon Stewart turns up as Mort Sinclaire, a former TV comedy writer and Communist, and Greg Hollimon is Rev. George A. Lewis, an ex-civil rights leader. Paul Dinello also produced and directed the abridgement, with John McElroy producing.

The "Stephen Speaks For Me" chapters are letters from these invented correspondents, and they are widely considered the strongest written material in the book. The audiobook was nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Spoken Word Album in 2009. It lost to Al Gore's companion book to An Inconvenient Truth, which is a tidy bit of irony for a book that mocks environmental concerns.

Colbert promoted the thing with the same energy he brought to the show. A commercial showed the book erupting from a volcano, borrowed from the old advertisements for Dianetics, and on October 9, 2007, he interviewed himself as the featured guest on his own program. On Meet the Press he raised the idea that the book might be a probe for a presidential run, in the manner of other politicians testing a new book as a precursor to a campaign. He later announced a candidacy, which made the joke harder to separate from the real thing.

The bestseller numbers were substantial. As of April 6, 2008, the book had spent twenty-four weeks on the New York Times Hardcover Nonfiction list and had been number one for fourteen of them. Its first run at the top lasted from late October to early December 2007, after Clarence Thomas's My Grandfather's Son, and it was knocked down by Glenn Beck and Kevin Balfe's An Inconvenient Book. It returned to number one in mid December and held through mid January, when Michael Pollan's In Defense of Food took the spot. For a book of political jokes, that is a serious commercial record.

What does not survive the trip to paper

I want to be fair about the weaknesses, because they are real and several reviewers said the same thing. Janet Maslin, writing in The New York Times on October 8, 2007, under the headline "It May Be a Book, but You Can Read It," argued that the energy of the television show never quite makes it onto the page. She called the book a souvenir for the Colbert Nation and noted that the show's brilliance did not follow it to the coffee table. Katy McCoy, reviewing it in The GW Hatchet, thought the mock pundit worked on screen but felt forced and fake without Colbert's delivery, and she concluded that the book was made to be skimmed rather than read cover to cover.

I felt both complaints while reading. Long stretches of the main text read like material written for a monologue and then typed up, and a joke that is hilarious when shouted by a man in a suit can land flat as a paragraph you read alone at a kitchen table. The chapters have more misses than hits, and a few of the recurring bits wear out well before the book ends. The persona also depends on refusing to break character, which means the reader never gets the relief of a wiser voice stepping in to say that the whole thing is a joke. Some readers will find that commitment brave. Others will find it exhausting over two hundred and forty pages.

There is also the question of who the satire is aimed at. The book parodies pundits who speak in absolutes, but it does so by speaking in absolutes, and the resemblance is close enough that a careless reader could mistake the performance for the real article. Colbert's whole career has involved that risk, and the book does not do anything to resolve it. If you are looking for an argument you can quote in good faith, this is the wrong place. If you are looking for a sustained impersonation of a man who thinks his gut is a source of evidence, it delivers.

Who this is for

This is a book that rewards a certain kind of reader. If you watched The Colbert Report and enjoyed the way the character flattered and betrayed his own audience at the same time, you will find plenty of that here, especially in the margin notes and the Fun Zones. The design alone is worth a look, and the stickers and photographs make it feel like an artifact from a very specific moment in American comedy, when a late-night pundit could plausibly be talked about as a presidential candidate.

If you have never seen the show, a lot of this will not work. The voice assumes you know the character, the segment names, and the running gags, and the book makes no attempt to welcome a stranger. I would hand it to a fan who wants more of the persona in a different form, particularly the audiobook with its cast of guest voices. I would not hand it to someone looking for a conventional political memoir or a work of nonfiction that expects to be taken at face value. What Colbert made here is a joke you can hold in your hands, and its strengths and limits both come from that fact.

FAQ

Is I Am America a novel?

No. It is a satirical humor book written in the voice of Colbert's Colbert Report character and presented as a mock guide to American life.

Who helped Colbert write it?

He wrote it with the writers of The Colbert Report. The audiobook features guest voices including Amy Sedaris and Jon Stewart.

How well did the book sell?

It reached number one on the New York Times hardcover nonfiction list and stayed on the list for 24 weeks, including 14 weeks at the top. The audiobook was nominated for a 2009 Grammy for Best Spoken Word Album.