Cover of Visions of Sugar Plums by Janet Evanovich

Visions of Sugar Plums

2,193-word summary 10 min read 160 pages in the book

First published
2002
Publisher
St. Martin's Press
Pages
160
ISBN
9780312306328
Series
Stephanie Plum (#8.5)
Reading options
What's inside (7 sections)
  1. A houseguest who will not leave
  2. Sandy Claws and the problem with elves
  3. Fire, lightning and a collapsing roof
  4. Christmas dinner and a surprise date
  5. The honest verdict
  6. Key takeaways
  7. FAQ

I picked this one up because it was the only Stephanie Plum book on the shelf without a number in the title. It is a holiday novella, the first of the Between the Numbers stories that slot between the numbered novels, and it lands between Hard Eight and To the Nines. St. Martin's Press published the first edition in November 2002, 160 pages of it, and I read it in one sitting on a rainy December afternoon. The shortness turned out to be the whole experience. There is no room here for the slow build of a regular Plum book, and what you get instead is a brisk, sugary sketch that races from one joke to the next.

The setup takes almost no time. It is a few days before Christmas and Stephanie is standing in her kitchen with a coffee and a to do list, feeling nothing like festive. She has no tree, no presents, and no lights in her apartment, while the malls are packed with shoppers she would rather not meet. Then a man appears in her kitchen. He does not knock. There is a small pop and he is simply there, leaning against her counter as if he has every right to be. Stephanie is a fugitive apprehension agent for Vincent Plum Bail Bonds, so strange men in her apartment are not new to her, but this one is a different proposition. He calls himself Diesel, and that is all the name he offers.

She fetches the gun she keeps in the cookie jar, only for Diesel to point out that it is not loaded. He is amused rather than threatened. He says he has come to help her find a man named Sandy Claws who has skipped out on his bail. Stephanie is not exactly thrilled to have a passenger, but a bond skipper is a bond skipper, so she lets him tag along.

That opening is the best thing in the book, I think. It drops you into the Plum world without a single explanatory sentence and assumes you know that a gun in a cookie jar is normal in this part of Trenton. If you already know Stephanie, it feels like coming home. If you do not, it is a strange introduction, and the novella never really stops to fix that.

A houseguest who will not leave

Diesel follows Stephanie to her parents' house in the Burg, and this is where the book settles into its real rhythm, which is the Plum family at Christmas. Grandma Mazur takes one look at him and decides he would make a fine new stud muffin, a phrase she uses with cheerful lack of shame. She asks after Joe Morelli, Stephanie's on again, off again boyfriend, and Stephanie has to explain that Morelli is a Trenton cop and that Ranger, the dangerous mentor she usually works with, is out of town. Diesel charms the whole household, vanishes without warning, and then turns up again with Stephanie's car after having borrowed it without asking.

Morelli arrives for dinner and the mood tightens, because he can tell that Diesel is more than a harmless houseguest and because Diesel flirts with Stephanie in front of him. Before anyone can have a proper conversation, Morelli is called away on police business, chasing the power outages that have been plaguing the city. The family keeps baking. Stephanie's mother retreats to a corner with a splash of Four Roses, which she does because Valerie, Stephanie's sister, has walked back into the family after a failed marriage and a positive pregnancy test. Valerie locks herself in the only bathroom and refuses to come out. Stephanie enjoys her perfect sister's discomfort for about two minutes, then helps Diesel get Valerie out through a window, an exercise that involves a lot of awkward lifting and a good deal of sexual tension that Stephanie would rather not feel.

The family's holiday plans give the book some of its best throwaway lines. Grandma Mazur announces that she intends to go to a viewing at Stiva's Funeral Home in the hope of spotting a younger stud muffin among the mourners, which is the sort of remark she makes entirely without irony. Lula turns up to size up the situation and delivers the verdict that Diesel is fine and that it is not fair for one woman to have cornered the market on hot men. I laughed at that, even though it is the kind of joke Evanovich has made many times before.

Through all of this Diesel keeps doing things that cannot be explained. He appears beside Stephanie's bed in the morning with coffee for two. He opens locks without touching them. He vanishes in a mall and reappears in her car. Stephanie never gets a straight answer about what he is, and the book does not really try to give one. He is a man with a gift, and that is that.

Sandy Claws and the problem with elves

The trail leads Stephanie and Diesel to the home of Elaine, Sandy Claws's sister, where the family is busy baking cookies for a small army of elves. Sandy Claws, whose real name turns out to be Sandor Clausen, is a toy maker who missed court on a burglary charge. On paper he is a simple bond skipper, the kind of minor case Stephanie might close in an afternoon. In practice he runs a toy plant staffed by elves who behave like a street gang, throwing cookies at anyone who asks questions and treating the place as their own territory.

Stephanie calls Connie Rosolli at the bail bond office for information, though most of her attention is taken up by the family crisis. At one point she thinks about recruiting Randy Briggs, a little person she knows who could plausibly apply for work as an elf and report back. Randy refuses, because the job pays and he is not about to bite the hand that feeds him. I enjoyed that little beat, because it is one of the few moments in the novella where a character acts from plain economic self interest instead of being swept along by the joke.

It gradually becomes clear that Sandy is not the danger. He is a decent man who happens to make toys and employ difficult workers. The real problem is a man named Ring, whom Diesel describes as one of the unmentionables, a person with powers he has turned toward revenge. Ring can manipulate electricity. He can throw lightning, though age has made his control shaky, and the shakier it gets the more dangerous he becomes. Diesel's own assignment, it turns out, is bigger than helping collect a bond. He is hunting Ring, and Stephanie has been pulled into the middle of it.

Fire, lightning and a collapsing roof

From here the novella turns into a series of escalating mishaps. Ring attacked the area with fire and electricity, but his aim is poor. A firebomb takes out a neighbour's garage instead of Sandy's house. Stephanie gets a call from Valerie at the mall asking for Christmas shopping advice, and Diesel senses trouble and turns the car around just in time. Sandy refuses to abandon his work even after the attack, which is either stubbornness or devotion to the toy business, and probably both.

The strangest scene takes place at the toy plant, where the elves behave like a mob and pelt visitors with cookies. A full scale elf riot breaks out and Christmas trees get destroyed in the chaos, including the replacement tree Stephanie has somehow managed to acquire. Her car also gets wrecked in one of Ring's attacks, which is a running gag in this series and happens often enough that I stopped being surprised. Diesel and Stephanie finally locate Sandy on Christmas Eve, but Stephanie cannot bring herself to make an ordinary arrest, because the man is needed to finish the toys and keep the holiday intact. Before anything can be decided, the factory starts to come down. Diesel uses his strength to pull Stephanie, Sandy, the elves and everyone else clear of the falling structure.

Stephanie and Lula escape in Lula's Firebird with elves clinging to the car and shredding the Christmas trees they have tied on top. Lula keeps her foot down until the last one is flung off with a windshield wiper in his hand. It is a very funny image, and it is about as far as the book goes in terms of action. Ring's powers sound frightening on the page, but the confrontations are staged broadly and resolved quickly, which suits the tone but leaves the threat feeling weightless.

Christmas dinner and a surprise date

The last chapter pulls back toward the family. Stephanie gets home with only hours to spare and goes into a panic about cards, presents and the rest of it. Morelli gives her a friendship ring and is careful to say it is not an engagement ring, since their earlier attempt at that did not work. He is still wary of Diesel, and with good reason, but the two men never have the showdown the setup seems to promise.

Her shopping trip is played for easy laughs. She is at the mall at the last possible moment, surrounded by the same staggering shoppers the opening warned us about, and she cannot remember who still needs what. Valerie rings her from one of the stores to ask for advice, which is rich coming from a sister who has just dropped a pregnancy on the family. The tree Stephanie finally brings home is one she worries looks as if it grew next to a nuclear power plant, and that image made me grin.

At the Plum family dinner, Grandma Mazur misplaces her dentures, Valerie's news hangs in the air, and Mary Alice, Stephanie's young niece, announces that she no longer believes in Santa. Then Grandma introduces her new date, and it is John Ring. The electricity in the room goes strange almost at once, the Plum family tree catches fire, and Ring escapes in the confusion. Diesel chases him down and captures him, which finishes the job he actually came to do. Mary Alice decides to wait for Santa after all, and the rest of the family joins her. At midnight Sandy Claws arrives with elves and presents, explaining that Diesel told him what had happened and that he has come to put things right. The next morning Diesel tells Stephanie he has to leave now that Ring is caught, though he says he will be back.

Mary Alice's loss of faith is the closest thing the novella has to a theme, small as it is. The child decides Santa is not real, the family gathers around her, and by the end she chooses to wait for him anyway. Evanovich handles it lightly, without a speech about the meaning of Christmas, and the arrival of Sandy with his elves and presents settles the question in the simplest possible way. It is sentimental, certainly, but it fits a story built around a toy maker and a man who pops into a kitchen with no explanation.

That ending is pure confection, and I mean that in the nicest way. It ties up the family worries and the supernatural thread in the space of a few pages, and it leaves Stephanie's Christmas intact. It also explains why Diesel disappears from the main novels after this. He was created for these holiday stories, and he went on to lead the Wicked spin off series, which tells you how much room Evanovich saw in him.

The honest verdict

I had a good time with this, but it is a small book with small ambitions. The comedy is broad, the elves are funny, Grandma Mazur gets some of the best lines, and the Plum family dinner is the sort of scene that makes the series feel like a warm place to visit. The problem is that the plot runs on coincidence and convenience. Diesel can do anything, Ring's menace never feels real, and the resolution arrives because the story needs it to rather than because Stephanie earned it. If you are looking for a tight mystery, this is not it.

It is also a book written for people who already know these characters. The jokes about Lula, about Valerie and Kloughn, about Morelli and Stephanie's disastrous car, all land because you have met them before. A newcomer will spend half the book wondering who everyone is and why the pregnancy subplot matters. Even the title assumes you are in on it, since the sugar plums never amount to much beyond atmosphere.

Still, I can see why fans keep this one in rotation. It is short, it is silly, and it delivers the particular pleasure of spending a few hours with a family that argues over dinner and clearly cares about one another. Read it in December, after you have met Stephanie in the numbered books, and it will probably make you smile. Read it first and you may wonder what all the fuss was about.

FAQ

Where does Visions of Sugar Plums fit in the Stephanie Plum series?

It is a holiday novella published in 2002, the first of the Between the Numbers books. It falls between the novels Hard Eight and To the Nines, so readers often call it book 8.5.

Who is Diesel?

Diesel is a mysterious man who can appear and disappear, open locks and bring coffee to Stephanie's bedside. He first shows up in this novella to help find Sandy Claws, then went on to headline Evanovich's Wicked series.

Is this a good place to start reading Stephanie Plum?

It works better as a treat for existing fans, because the humour depends on knowing characters such as Grandma Mazur, Lula and Morelli. A newcomer may find the plot too slight and the shorthand confusing.