Cover of There Will Be Bodies by Lindsey Davis

There Will Be Bodies

2,152-word summary 10 min read 368 pages in the book

First published
2025
Publisher
Minotaur Books
Pages
368
ISBN
9781250906731
Series
Flavia Albia (#13)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A villa buried under fifty feet of ash
  2. An informer, not a detective
  3. Chains, a locked room, and a death ten years old
  4. The eruption as a private wound
  5. The wider empire and its edges
  6. The cover and the strange business around publication
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

The first line of this book is a joke, and it is a terrible one. Flavia Albia's husband Tiberius Manlius has taken over a building firm that is nearly bankrupt, and he tells his workmen that there will be bodies when they clear out the cut-price villa his uncle has bought. He means bodies in the ordinary building-site sense, the sort that appear in a bad joke at a dinner party. Ten chapters later I realised the joke had been sitting there the whole time, waiting to become literal. That is the trick the whole novel turns on, and it is a good one. Davis has always written dialogue with a dry, almost offhand rhythm, and she uses it here to make the awful things arrive without announcement. A line that sounds like a building-site wisecrack in chapter one turns into a piece of evidence you keep thinking about much later. It is a neat piece of construction, and it made me go back and reread the first pages.

I picked this up because it is the thirteenth Flavia Albia book and the first one to leave Rome. I had grown used to the series as a set of cases conducted among the markets, apartments, and temples of the city. Moving the investigation out to the Bay of Naples changes the temperature of the thing. The city scenes are crowded and quick. This one is slow, hot, and full of ash.

A villa buried under fifty feet of ash

The setting does a great deal of the work. The villa is at Stabiae, and ten years after the eruption of Vesuvius in 79 AD it has to be dug out of roughly fifty feet of compacted volcanic debris. Davis is very good on the sheer labour of that. Nobody is strolling into a sealed Pompeian house and brushing dust off a fresco. They are shifting a hillside, and the men doing it are trying to do it cheaply because the man paying for it does not want to spend money. Davis keeps the workmen in view rather than treating them as background. They are the ones whose hands find the bodies, and they are the ones whose conclusions about those bodies matter, because they have been digging in volcanic ground for weeks while the owners have been drinking Alban wine. There is a quiet argument here about who actually knows a place. The men with the shovels know more about the villa than the people who own it, and the novel keeps returning to that imbalance.

That man is Tullius Icilius, a rich, controlling warehouse owner who keeps his nephew Tiberius on a short leash. He wants the job done on the cheap, and he expects the bodies that come out of the debris to be what everyone assumes they are: eruption victims who suffocated where they stood a decade earlier. The assumption is so natural that the novel barely has to argue for it. When the first corpses appear, chained, the reader and the workers alike file them away as another oddity of a disaster that killed thousands.

The seller, Sextus Curvidius Fulvianus, is elderly and bland in a way that made me distrust him immediately. He turns up for dinner, drinks Alban wine with the family, and lets Flavia play the dutiful matron while she quietly sizes him up. That scene is the nearest the book comes to a drawing-room mystery, and Davis uses it to show how Flavia works. She is watching people while they watch her, and she has learned that the most useful thing a suspect can do is relax.

An informer, not a detective

It helps to know who Flavia is before the bodies start piling up. She is the adopted daughter and professional successor of Marcus Didius Falco, the character Davis wrote about in an earlier series. She works as a private informer in first-century Rome, which is a useful distinction. She is not a magistrate with a warrant and a budget. She is a woman who finds things out, and whose standing in the world is always slightly uncertain because of what she does and who her father was. That uncertainty is the engine of the longer series. Falco was a couldn't-keep-his-mouth-shut sort of investigator with a talent for landing in trouble, and Flavia inherited the trade without inheriting the same freedom to make a mess. She has a household, a husband, and a business to manage, and she works around all three. Watching her balance those obligations is half the pleasure, even when the case itself is slow.

This is the first case in the series set outside the city, and the change of scenery exposes how much of Flavia's method depends on being a Roman among Romans. At Stabiae she is an outsider twice over. She is a city woman in a rural district, and she is a woman doing a man's job in a place where the local hierarchy is not about to make room for her. Davis folds that into a subplot about the friction between urban and rural communities, and it never feels pasted on. The people who own the villa and the people who work the land have different ideas about what a life is worth, and the dead are going to be sorted by those ideas.

There is also a strain of misogyny running through the book, handled in Davis's usual dry way. Flavia is treated as a wife first and an investigator second by nearly everyone she meets, and she uses that assumption when it suits her. When it does not, she is irritated rather than heroic about it. I have always liked that about her. She is a professional, not a crusader, and the books are better for it.

Chains, a locked room, and a death ten years old

The case proper begins when the digging starts turning up things that do not fit the story of a simple eruption. Among the bodies recovered are chained corpses. People do not normally wear chains to their deaths in a volcanic disaster, and once that detail is on the page the reader starts looking at every other assumption again. Then the previous owner of the villa turns up. He has not suffocated in the ash. He has been laid out in a locked storeroom.

From there Flavia is working on a death a decade old while trying to stop another one happening in the present. A large inheritance is in play, which gives several people a reason to want the past to stay buried. The caretakers are suspicious. Friends cannot be trusted. A Sicilian pirate is sniffing around the property, which is exactly the sort of complication that turns a tidy Roman inheritance dispute into something messier. His presence is a reminder that a villa on the Bay of Naples belongs to a world of shipping and money that Rome's courts can only partly control. The case keeps widening in small ways like this. Nobody announces a new thread. It simply appears, and Flavia has to decide whether it matters. Davis keeps several threads going at once, and the pleasure is in watching Flavia separate the ones that matter from the ones that are noise.

I will not pretend the plot is tidy. It is not. The book is more interested in the accumulation of small inconsistencies than in a single clean reveal, and that can make the middle feel slow if you are used to a faster mystery. But the payoff is that the ending grows out of details the reader has already seen. There is no last-minute invention of a culprit nobody has met. Everything has been sitting in the ash from the beginning.

The eruption as a private wound

What lifts the book above a country-house whodunit is the way Davis connects the official history to Flavia's own past. She once searched Campania with her father for relatives after the eruption, and she never found them. That piece of biography is introduced almost casually, and it changes the whole emotional weight of the dig. This is not an abstract archaeological site for her. It is a place where the ground is full of people who disappeared, and she is one of the many who came looking and came back empty-handed.

That connection is what makes the book's treatment of the eruption more than set dressing. Davis writes about the event as a historical fact with a human scale attached to it, and she resists the temptation to turn it into spectacle. There are no grand set pieces here. There is a villa, a team of workmen, a pile of debris, and a woman who knows what it means to search a region for people you will never find. The history and the case comment on each other without either one swallowing the other.

The book also carries one of Davis's more cheerful inventions, a prefatory character chart headed "Characters, mainly alive." It is a small joke, but it tells you how the author wants you to approach the thing. This is a story about people who are mostly still breathing, and about the ones who are not. The chart is funny. The body count is not.

The wider empire and its edges

Kirkus called the result historical fiction of high quality, propelled by an intricate whodunit, and argued that this is arguably Flavia's most complex and layered adventure. That seems fair. The praise for Davis's research is deserved too. The picture she gives of the wider Empire is not the Rome of marble and senators. It is the Rome of building contracts, inheritance law, suspicious neighbours, and men trying to get a job done without paying for it.

That is the series at its best. Davis has always written about ordinary Romans doing ordinary and often shabby things, and she has never mistaken the Empire for its monuments. Stabiae lets her do that with a whole region rather than a single city block. The tensions between the capital and the provinces, between people with money and people with callused hands, sit under the mystery without ever being stated as a theme. Her prose suits this material. The sentences are plain and unshowy, and the jokes arrive in the middle of serious business, which is how they do in real conversation. When she wants to make a point about power, she gives you a contract or a dinner rather than a speech. That restraint is why the book can afford its one grand image of a head in the embers. Everything around it is deliberately ordinary. When Flavia notices something, it is usually because she understands a social arrangement that everyone else takes for granted.

There is a fair criticism to make here. At 368 pages the book has room for more than the case needs, and a couple of the subplots circle back rather than forward. If you came for a tight procedural, you may find the dig sections heavy going. I did not mind, because the slowness is part of the point. Digging is slow. People who want to keep a secret are patient. The book asks you to be patient too.

The cover and the strange business around publication

The British first edition has a cover showing a battered sculptural head half-buried in glowing embers. Davis identified the figure as Tyche, the goddess of fortune and the inventor of dice, wearing a mural crown. Once you know that, the image reads as a neat piece of irony. Fortune is exactly what the people in this book are trying to control, and the dice have already been thrown by a dog bite and a volcanic eruption.

There is an odder footnote to the publication. Two days before the book came out, Davis reported that an AI-generated review misrepresenting the novel had been posted on social media. She later noted that it had been taken down. Nothing about that is in the story, and I mention it only because it is hard to think of a more fitting piece of noise to surround a book about bodies in the ash and the stories people build over them. A fake account of a book is still an account of a book, and it still has to be dug out.

I closed this one with the sense that Davis is still finding new things to do with a character who has been around for thirteen cases. Moving Flavia out of Rome was a risk. It works because the city was never the point. The point was a woman who notices what other people overlook, and a past that does not stay buried no matter how many feet of ash you put on top of it.

FAQ

Is There Will Be Bodies set in Rome?

No. It is the first Flavia Albia novel set outside Rome, taking place at Stabiae on the Bay of Naples about ten years after Vesuvius erupted in 79 AD.

Do I need to have read the earlier Flavia Albia books?

It helps to know that Flavia is the adopted daughter and successor of Marcus Didius Falco, but the mystery stands on its own and introduces its own cast.

When was the book published?

Hodder & Stoughton published it in Britain on 3 April 2025, and Minotaur Books published the 368-page American hardcover on 22 July 2025.