Cover of The Beautiful Mystery by Louise Penny

The Beautiful Mystery

2,262-word summary 10 min read 373 pages in the book

First published
2012
Publisher
Minotaur Books
Pages
373
ISBN
9780312655464
Series
Chief Inspector Armand Gamache (#8)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A body in the abbot's garden
  2. Beauvoir's private war
  3. The men in the stalls
  4. The chant that should not exist
  5. How the case breaks
  6. What I liked, and what grated
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked this one up out of order, which turned out to be a strange way to meet it. The Beautiful Mystery is the eighth Chief Inspector Armand Gamache novel, published in 2012, and it assumes you already know who Gamache is, what the Sûreté du Québec is, and why its senior officers keep fighting each other. I had read enough of the series to follow along, but the book is built as a closed room with the door locked from the outside, and I think that is why it works so well. It takes a detective, his second in command, twenty-four monks, and one dead man, shuts them all in a monastery in the Quebec wilderness, and lets the pressure rise. The edition I read was the 2012 Minotaur Books hardcover, 373 pages, and it is one of those books where the setting is not decoration. The place is the puzzle.

A body in the abbot's garden

The monastery is called Saint-Gilbert-Entre-les-Loups. For most of the book the monks and the police translate that as "Saint Gilbert Among the Wolves," but near the end the abbot corrects it: the better reading is "between the wolves," a place of perpetual choice. The Gilbertines are a tiny surviving branch of an order that fled the Inquisition centuries earlier and ended up deep in the Canadian bush. They live under a vow of silence that they break only when they sing, and what they sing is Gregorian chant. They do it remarkably well. A rough recording of their voices escaped the wilderness a couple of years before the novel opens, spread first through other monasteries and then became a sensation. Pilgrims and reporters came looking for them. They turned everyone away.

The money from that recording was not a small thing. It paid for geothermal heating and solar power, and it kept a crumbling building standing a little longer. But it also split the community down the middle. One faction, led by the prior and choirmaster Frère Mathieu, wanted another record, interviews, television, concerts, an end to the silence. The other, around Dom Philippe the abbot, wanted the old rules kept. So when Mathieu is found dead in the abbot's private garden, killed by a heavy blow and clutching a scrap of vellum covered in chant notation, there is no shortage of people who might have wished him gone.

Gamache and Inspector Jean-Guy Beauvoir arrive with a local Sûreté captain named Charbonneau, travelling by boat through rough country and then, effectively, sealed in. A stranger cannot hide here. There is nowhere to go. Penny is working the oldest shape in crime fiction, the country house murder, and she has simply swapped the snowbound mansion for a cloister. I admired how completely she commits to it. The monks have taken a vow of silence, which makes them trained observers of one another and of the two policemen now poking around their days. Every glance and every absence counts.

Beauvoir's private war

The emotional weight of the book sits with Beauvoir rather than with the monks. At the start he is quietly happy. He has fallen in love with Annie Gamache, the chief inspector's daughter, and they are keeping it secret while they wait for the right moment to tell her parents. He is also sober, after a serious struggle with painkiller addiction. That recovery is fragile, and the monastery case arrives on top of another wound. Both men are still carrying the aftermath of a raid in which several Sûreté officers were killed and Gamache and Beauvoir were badly hurt. Beauvoir was in a video of the shooting that got out, and that leak is a trigger for him.

I want to be fair about this part of the story. On the one hand it gives Beauvoir a real interior life, and it makes the monastery's calm both seductive and briefly dangerous to him. On the other hand it drags a long series arc about police corruption into a book that, for a while, seemed happy to be a contained mystery. You can feel the wider story pressing on the walls. Gamache's enemies in the Sûreté have not forgotten him, and the men who run the force have their own scores to settle.

Chief Superintendent Sylvain Francoeur turns up partway through, ostensibly to oversee the investigation. He is a career rival of Gamache and genuinely resents the older man's record of refusing to look away from corruption. Francoeur is clever about where to press. He suggests to Beauvoir that Gamache has lost interest in finding who leaked the shooting video, and he dangles opioids within reach. The relapse that follows is one of the harder passages in the book, and it is handled without spectacle. What I found interesting is that the threat here is not a monk with a grudge. It is a senior policeman who knows exactly which button to push, and who pushes it while wearing a uniform.

The men in the stalls

Penny spends a lot of pages simply introducing the twenty-four monks, and I did not mind the slow build. Dom Philippe, the abbot, is courteous and shrewd, the sort of man who notices nearly everything and admits very little. Frère Mathieu, the victim, was a gifted singer and a difficult man, the driving force behind the recording and the push to modernize. Frère Luc is the newest arrival, young, softly spoken, the porter who spent much of his time alone in the gatehouse and whom hardly anyone really knew. Frère Raymond handles the geothermal machinery. Frère Charles is the community's doctor. Frère Simon serves as the abbot's secretary. Each gets a moment, a habit, a way of speaking.

The friction between the abbot's men and the prior's men is the novel's engine. The vow of silence means no one says outright what they think, so Gamache has to read tiny things: who sits where in the chapel, who is alone after Lauds, who lies about where they were. One of the quiet ironies is that the same discipline that makes the monks holy makes them hard to question. They watch. They do not confide. And beneath the quarrel about recordings and television sits a plain fact that only a few of them know: the building itself is still in danger of collapse, and the money from the CD is all that is holding it together.

Then there is Frère Sébastien, a Dominican who arrives from Rome claiming to represent the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. He is polite, insistent, and not remotely interested in the murder at first. He admits eventually that he has come for the Gilbertines' book of chants, which he regards as a priceless artifact. His real hunt is for the starting point of Gregorian chant, a single original note from which everything else descended. The monks believe their music is closer to the divine source than anyone else's. Gamache, watching the intensity in Sébastien and in Frère Luc, finds something unsettling in that kind of certainty. I liked that the book treats faith seriously here without asking the reader to share it, and without mocking it either.

The chant that should not exist

The scrap of vellum in the dead man's hand is the clue that changes everything. It carries notation for a piece that is not proper Gregorian chant. It has instruments. It may even be sacrilegious. Penny uses the prologue to explain what is at stake. The earliest chants were so old that they predated written music, passed from singer to singer by memory, and their simplicity was said to have a powerful effect on those who heard them. They became known as the beautiful mystery, and the Church spent centuries trying to find their origin point. If the Gilbertines really possess that origin, their book is worth a great deal to a man like Sébastien.

The truth about the parchment is more human and more painful. The music was written by a young former novice named Émile, and it was presented as something ancient when it was not. Frère Luc was drawn into it, asked to supply words for the new composition and coaxed into a solo role by Mathieu. For Luc, the piece was not a clever fraud but a profanation of the word of God. When Mathieu moved to remove him from the choir, Luc saw his whole world tipping. That is the motive the investigation finally uncovers, and it is a motive made of pride and fear and religious conviction rather than money. It is also deliberately close to the surface of the book's main theme, which is how a community decides what is allowed to change.

I should note one thing about the structure here. The novel is quiet for a long time, and then the last few chapters move fast. That uneven rhythm is intentional, but it caught me out. I was settling into the daily round of bells and prayer and quiet work, and suddenly I was in a feverish interrogation.

How the case breaks

Gamache works the murder the way he works everything, by watching where people go. After Lauds, only one monk was demonstrably alone, and that was Frère Luc, in the porter's office where nobody visited him. The abbot is a harder proposition. Dom Philippe is observant enough that Gamache cannot believe he missed the killing entirely, so the chief considers two explanations: either the abbot did it, or the killer was the one monk the abbot did not know well, the newest one, the one who kept to himself. The abbot also tells a small, transparent lie about being in the basement near the geothermal plant, which Gamache comes to read as a deliberate move. Dom Philippe knew one of his monks had killed Mathieu and chose to put himself in the line of fire rather than let the community be torn apart by suspicion.

The breakthrough is a piece of theatre. Gamache asks Sébastien to sing Mathieu's strange new chant in the Blessed Chapel, hoping the music will force a reaction. The Dominican's voice fills the space, and Luc breaks. He confesses to the killing. A few pages earlier, when Mathieu's death is being pieced together, Luc says of the dying man, "He wasn't the man I thought he was." The line lands hard because it is really about a stolen certainty. Luc had believed Mathieu was leading the community toward God. Instead he saw him as a man willing to dress a modern composition in the robes of something sacred.

The cost of solving the case is high. Beauvoir overdoses while the confrontation is unfolding, and Gamache has to choose between finishing the interrogation at speed and getting his inspector to treatment. Francoeur, meanwhile, makes one last play, telling Beauvoir that Gamache does not care about him and does not need to be sent away to rehab. For a moment Beauvoir believes it, and he leaves on the float plane with Francoeur and Luc while Gamache stays behind. The abbot, who has lost a prior and now a murderer, tries to console the chief inspector. They talk about the monastery's symbol, the two wolves, and the old answer about which one wins: the one you feed. Gamache looks up at the north wind and thinks he hears a plane far off, then it is gone. It is a bleak, open ending for a book that has spent three hundred pages inside a place that seemed to stand outside time.

What I liked, and what grated

The music writing is the best thing here. Penny makes chant something you can almost hear, and she connects it to the plot rather than leaving it as atmosphere. The prologue's account of a sound older than written notation gave the book a mystery inside its mystery, and I found myself caring about the origin of the chants as much as about who swung the blow in the garden. The closed-circle design is elegant too. Twenty-four suspects, all of them bound by a vow that makes lying awkward and silence automatic, is a genuinely good puzzle box.

The parts that did not work for me are the parts that belong to the series rather than to this story. Francoeur's maneuvering felt at times like a separate novel running in the background, and the Beauvoir subplot ends on a note that is not resolved here. That is partly by design, since the corruption thread is picked up again in How the Light Gets In, but it does mean this book never quite finishes its own emotional argument. I also found the middle stretch slow, with long stretches of chapel and garden that I enjoyed in the moment but that could have been trimmed. A reader who wants a brisk procedural will likely get impatient.

I would hand this to someone who likes their mysteries slow, atmospheric, and morally untidy, and who does not need every thread tied off at the end. I would be careful with a reader coming to the series cold, because so much of the weight depends on knowing what happened to these people before. But as a self-contained puzzle about a choir, a lie, and a monk who could not bear what his friend had done, it is a strong and unusually resonant book, and the abbey of Saint Gilbert is a place I remember clearly long after the details of the case faded.

FAQ

Is The Beautiful Mystery part of a series?

Yes, it is the eighth Chief Inspector Armand Gamache novel and was first published in 2012. The corruption subplot involving Sylvain Francoeur continues into the next book, How the Light Gets In.

Who kills the prior in The Beautiful Mystery?

Frère Luc, the newest and least known monk, kills Frère Mathieu after being drawn into a false chant and threatened with removal from the choir. Gamache draws him out by having the Dominican Frère Sebastien sing the controversial composition in the chapel.

Do I need to read the earlier Gamache books first?

The murder works as a self-contained puzzle, but much of its emotional weight depends on knowing Beauvoir's recovery from addiction and the Sûreté corruption arc from earlier novels.