The Unquiet Grave
2,253-word summary 10 min read 368 pages in the book
- First published
- 2025
- Publisher
- HarperCollins
- Pages
- 368
- ISBN
- 9781460766828
- Series
- Cormac Reilly (#4)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
I have been reading Dervla McTiernan for years, and The Unquiet Grave is the fourth book to feature her detective Cormac Reilly. It came out in 2025 from HarperCollins and runs 368 pages. I sat down with it expecting a familiar kind of comfort, and I got that, but I also got a tighter and stranger book than I anticipated. This is a police procedural with a puzzle at its center, and McTiernan is very good at making the mechanics of an investigation feel like something you are living through rather than watching.
A body in the bog
The novel opens on the peat bogs of Northern Europe, and this is one of those settings that does a lot of work before anybody says a word. Bogs preserve things. They give up bodies that have been buried for centuries, still intact, with strange wounds that suggest ritual torture and human sacrifice. McTiernan understands the eerie potential of this, and she sets the book's tone in the opening pages. There is a reason a body in a bog is more unsettling than a body anywhere else, and she knows exactly what it is.
When a corpse is found in a Galway bog, Cormac assumes he knows what he is looking at. Another ancient victim, someone who died a very long time ago and was kept strange by the peat. Closer examination proves him wrong. The body is identified as Thaddeus Grey, a local secondary-school principal who vanished two years earlier. That shift, from archaeology to a missing person case, is the moment the book properly begins. The past has not stayed in the past. It has walked into the present wearing a suit and a name badge.
McTiernan is careful about the difference between what the bog gives up and what it means. A body can be preserved for a very long time without telling you who killed the person or why. The strange wounds are the part that invites a story, and the novel is smart enough to treat them as evidence rather than as proof of something supernatural. Cormac's first reading of the scene is the reasonable one, that this is a relic of a violent past. The book's real work begins when that reasonable reading turns out to be wrong. That gap between what the evidence seems to say and what it actually means is where the strongest chapters live.
I liked the way McTiernan handles that reveal. There is no grand speech about the evil that men do. She simply lets the fact sit there: a man who disappeared two years ago has turned up in a bog with the kind of wounds usually associated with ritual sacrifice. The investigation starts from the idea that this might be a very old pattern repeating itself, which gives the case a dimension that a straightforward murder mystery would not have.
The case that made him
Cormac has spent years trying to escape the shadow of the 1993 case that made his reputation. That earlier case is one of those things that follows a detective around forever, the achievement that other people remember and that he would sooner forget. McTiernan threads it through this novel quietly, as a pressure rather than a subject. You can feel how tired Cormac is of being defined by something that happened decades ago, and you can feel how badly he wants this new case to be about something other than himself.
The investigation moves slowly, and I mean that as a strength rather than a complaint. McTiernan is patient about the unglamorous parts of police work. The case does not break open in a single flash of insight. It inches forward, with false leads and dead ends and the kind of grinding persistence that real investigations require. Critics called this a brisk, moody police procedural with an effortless command of pace and suspense, and the briskness is in the momentum of the writing rather than the speed of the solution. Things happen quickly on the page even when the case itself crawls.
Galway is a real presence in the book, as it has been throughout the series. McTiernan writes the city and its surrounding landscape with a sureness that comes from knowing a place well. The bog is the obvious example, but the smaller details of local life matter just as much. This is a novel where the setting is not a backdrop you could swap for anywhere else without changing the story. The Irish landscape, the weather, the rhythm of a small community, all of it shapes what the characters can and cannot do.
There is a theme here about persistence, and McTiernan has spoken about it directly. She said she wanted to write about the quiet, determined persistence it takes to uncover something others would rather leave buried, and the personal, possibly irreversible cost of doing the right thing. That is exactly what Cormac is doing. He is a man pushing at a case that other people would prefer to let settle back into the peat, and the cost of that pushing is measured in the damage it does to the people around him.
A personal life in pieces
The investigation is complicated by Cormac's personal life, which is in rough shape. His former girlfriend Emma Sweeney is in trouble. Her new husband has disappeared in Paris, and the French police will not open a case. Emma comes to Cormac with this problem, and it pulls his attention away from the bog at exactly the wrong moment. The parallel is hard to miss: two missing men, two sets of unanswered questions, and a detective who cannot quite keep them separate in his mind.
I appreciated that McTiernan lets Cormac be genuinely distracted. He is not the kind of detective who can shrug off a personal crisis and focus entirely on the job. His difficulty keeping his mind on the work is part of who he is at this point in his life, and it has consequences. There is a real cost to caring about too many things at once, and the book is honest about how that cost shows up in small professional failures rather than dramatic ones.
Emma has always been one of the more interesting people in Cormac's world, and her storyline here gives her more to do than simply be the former girlfriend. Her husband's disappearance in Paris is its own mystery, and McTiernan uses it to ask what happens when the authorities decide a person is not worth looking for. The French police refusing to open a case is a bureaucratic detail, but it carries a lot of weight. It says something about whose lives get investigated and whose get filed away.
Peter Fisher is back as well, and his presence steadies the book. Longtime readers will be glad to see him, and McTiernan clearly wanted to bring back the familiar circle of Cormac, Peter, Emma, and Ireland. There is a comfort in that, a sense of returning to a well-built house. But she is not simply repeating old formulas. The relationships have moved on, the people have changed, and the comfort comes from recognizing them rather than from seeing them frozen in place.
The killer keeps working
Just as Cormac believes he has found Thaddeus Grey's killer and is hours from making an arrest, the case breaks open in the worst possible way. Another mutilated body is discovered on the opposite side of the country. Two days later a third turns up. Press attention intensifies, and what looked like a solitary crime becomes a manhunt for a killer who may have struck before.
That sequence is where the book shifts gears, and it is very effective. Up to that point the investigation has been narrow and local, focused on one missing principal and one bog. The second and third bodies widen everything. Suddenly the wounds that suggested ancient ritual sacrifice might be a signature rather than a historical curiosity, and the killer might have a history that stretches back further than anyone has mapped. The pressure on Cormac becomes enormous, and McTiernan makes you feel every hour of it.
The press attention is handled well too. It is more than background noise. It changes the shape of the investigation, because a case under public scrutiny becomes a different animal. Every decision gets watched, every mistake gets amplified, and the people who would rather leave things buried have more reasons to stay quiet. McTiernan understands that a manhunt is as much about information control as it is about catching somebody, and she builds that tension steadily.
The portrait of the people involved is another strong element. Critics described the book as complex and multi-layered in its portrait of self-obsessed, sociopathic men, and that is a fair reading. McTiernan is interested in the kind of person who can compartmentalize a terrible act and continue with an ordinary life. Thaddeus Grey was a principal, a man with a job and a place in a community. The men connected to this case are not cartoon monsters. They are people whose ordinary lives sit on top of something ugly, and that is far more disturbing.
I should mention the tone, because it surprised me. McTiernan called writing this book an absolute romp after the heavier What Happened to Nina, and that shows. There is an energy here that is closer to mischievous than grim. She is enjoying the chase, and that enjoyment is contagious. This is not a book that wallows in its own darkness. It is a procedural with a pulse, and the lighter touch makes the genuinely grim moments land harder by contrast.
What works and what does not
The pacing is the book's strongest asset. Critics called it a clever and complex police procedural mystery with many intertwining threads, and that is accurate. McTiernan keeps several plates spinning without dropping any of them. The bog case, Emma's Paris problem, Cormac's personal history, and the emerging pattern of killings all move forward at once, and she finds a rhythm that lets each thread get its moment. When the book is firing, it moves with a confidence that makes you willing to follow it anywhere.
The suspense is real. McTiernan knows that the most frightening part of a case like this is not the violence itself but the possibility that it is not finished. The second body and the third body are terrifying precisely because they prove the killer is still out there and still working. That escalation is handled without hyperbole, and the result is a book that is genuinely hard to put down once the manhunt begins.
My complaints are modest. The number of intertwining threads means a few of them get shortchanged. Emma's Paris storyline is compelling, and I wanted it to be given more room to develop than the main investigation allows. There are also moments where the complexity of the case feels a little engineered, as if the puzzle is being made harder in order to stretch the book to its length. At 368 pages it never drags badly, but I noticed a few passages where the confusion seemed manufactured rather than organic.
I also found the ending less satisfying than the setup. Without spoiling specifics, the resolution does not fully account for everything the book has raised. The theme of doing the right thing at personal cost is strong, and the emotional resolution lands, but the procedural mystery leaves a few loose ends that bothered me more than they should have. That is a matter of taste. Some readers will find the ambiguity honest. I found it slightly frustrating after such a tightly built investigation.
Who should read it
That matters because of what McTiernan has said she wanted from this book. After the heavier What Happened to Nina, she wanted a romp, and she wanted to bring back Cormac, Peter, Emma, and Ireland. She also wanted to write about the cost of doing the right thing when the people around you would rather leave the truth alone. The ending is where those aims pull against each other. A romp wants momentum and a clean finish, while a story about the personal cost of persistence wants to leave something unresolved. The book leans toward the second, which is the more interesting choice, even if it left me wanting a little more closure on the procedural side.
I would recommend The Unquiet Grave to anyone who enjoys a smart police procedural with a strong sense of place. It works perfectly well as a standalone, though readers who know the earlier Cormac Reilly books will get more out of the relationships. The Galway setting, the bog, and the slow accumulation of clues make it a good choice for people who like their mysteries atmospheric and their detectives flawed.
If you like your crime fiction tidy and fully resolved, this will test you a little. McTiernan is more interested in the cost of the work than in delivering a neat bow at the end. What Happened to Nina was the heavier, more emotional book. This one is a romp by comparison, a detective story with an engine that runs hot and a willingness to let the darker questions linger. For me that combination works. It is a brisk, well-made addition to a series that has earned its place, and it left me looking forward to wherever Cormac Reilly goes next.
FAQ
Is The Unquiet Grave part of a series?
Yes. It is the fourth Cormac Reilly novel, set in Galway and featuring the detective's familiar circle of colleagues and family.
When was The Unquiet Grave published?
It was published in 2025 by HarperCollins, runs 368 pages, and carries ISBN 9781460766828.
Who is Thaddeus Grey?
He is a local secondary-school principal who vanished two years before the novel opens, whose preserved body is found in a Galway peat bog.





























