Cover of The Girl in the Ice by Robert Bryndza

The Girl in the Ice

2,492-word summary 11 min read 394 pages in the book

First published
2016
Publisher
Bookouture
Pages
394
ISBN
9781910751770
Series
Detective Erika Foster (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (10 sections)
  1. A detective sent back to work too soon
  2. The body beneath the ice
  3. The family who want the questions stopped
  4. The women nobody counted
  5. A team that slowly comes around
  6. The answer in a photograph
  7. The lake and the grave
  8. What works and what grates
  9. Key takeaways
  10. FAQ

I picked this up during a cold spell, which probably explains why the image of a young woman frozen under a sheet of ice got under my skin so quickly. It is the first of Robert Bryndza's Detective Erika Foster books, published in 2016 by Bookouture, and it introduces a detective who is very good at her job and badly damaged by it. What I found was a police procedural with a serial killer at its centre and an argument about class running quietly underneath. It works best when it stays with the investigators rather than the villains. By the end I had a clear sense of who Erika was and why she keeps making enemies, along with a few annoyances I could not quite shake.

A detective sent back to work too soon

Erika Foster is a Detective Chief Inspector who has spent six months at home after a drug raid she commanded went badly wrong. The raid happened in Manchester, where she worked before this book moves her to London. Her husband Mark, also a police officer, was killed in it, and four other officers died with him. Erika was the commanding officer, so the blame and her own guilt stick to her. Bryndza gives her an immigrant's background to explain part of that outsider feeling. She was born in Slovakia, came to Manchester at eighteen to work as an au pair and learn English, met Mark there, and trained as a police officer alongside him. Even after twenty-five years in Britain she is treated, and tends to treat herself, as someone a little apart.

That history matters because the book is as much about a woman rebuilding a career as it is about a murder. She is transferred to Lewisham Row in south London, handed a fresh team, and told in fairly plain terms that her last big operation left five people dead. Colleagues watch her. Her new boss, Marsh, is sceptical and sharp with her, and a DCI called Sparks would plainly prefer her to fail. Bryndza does not soften any of this. Erika arrives with a short fuse, drinks too much alone at night, and can be cold and rude to people trying to help her. She is not always a likeable person, and I found that honesty about her more interesting than most of the plot turns.

The personal grief is not decoration. It is the engine that drives her into the case and the reason she takes risks a more stable detective would avoid. When the body turns up, she throws herself into the work partly because the work is the only place she still feels useful. Bryndza returns to Mark's memory at intervals, never letting the reader forget what she is carrying, and the final pages come back to it directly.

The body beneath the ice

The victim is Andrea Douglas-Brown, twenty-three years old, rich, and the daughter of Lord and Lady Douglas-Brown. She is engaged to marry Giles Osborne, a wealthy man, and the book makes clear that the attraction has little to do with his looks or his personality. The opening reaches back to her last night. Andrea storms out of a pub after a fight, drunk, and walks up a lonely hill on a dark street in a south London park, trying to find a signal for her phone. A car draws up beside her. She knows the driver, which is why the moment turns from awkward to frightening, and she runs into the trees of the park. She stumbles and drops her phone and her purse in the dark. The figure from the car catches her, drags her back, binds her arms and legs, and strangles her.

A week later a young boy finds her body under the ice of a frozen lake in the park. Her fingers are poking through the surface. A park worker heard a phone ringing, and the phone was still working when she was found. The pathologist estimates she had been in the water for at least seventy-two hours, which lines up with the cold snap. It is a striking opening image, and Bryndza earns it by making the discovery feel like an accident that shatters an ordinary winter morning.

Because Andrea's father is a lord with influence, the media descend and the case becomes a priority. Erika is put in charge, with an instruction that she is not to ask painful questions or do anything that might damage the family's reputation. Anyone who has read a crime novel can guess how well that instruction sits with her. The scene is set for a collision between a detective who wants facts and a family that wants quiet.

The family who want the questions stopped

Erika's early interviews with the Douglas-Browns tell her what the official story cannot. The family wants the investigation managed, not solved. Simon Douglas-Brown protects secrets and uses his position to lean on people, and the pressure reaches into the police hierarchy. Erika is told to keep the family name clean and to accept the tidy version of Andrea as a privileged young woman with everything to live for.

What interests Erika is the gap between that version and the facts. Andrea spent time in a rough neighbourhood and a pub known for trouble, and she was there with a man who was not her fiancé. Bryndza uses these details to pull the investigation away from the comfortable story the family prefers. Erika keeps asking why a socialite with a perfect life would end up dead under the ice in a public park, and the people around her keep deciding that she should stop asking.

The friction extends beyond the family. Some of the male officers resent being led by a woman with a ruined reputation, and they make her work harder at every chance. DCI Sparks is openly hostile. Marsh oscillates between anger at her methods and a grudging recognition that she gets results. I believed the team politics more than I believed the higher-level conspiracy. Bryndza has Erika fighting what the author called sinister forces in the British establishment, and that part of the book is drawn in broader strokes. Lords, pressure from above, and a family closing ranks are familiar machinery, and the novel never quite makes them feel specific.

The women nobody counted

The strongest thread in the book is the one Erika pulls when she starts looking at older cases. Andrea's death begins to resemble the murders of three prostitutes, young women strangled with their hands bound and dumped in water around London. Those deaths went nowhere. The women were poor, foreign, and in Britain illegally, and the police and press treated them as disposable. Nobody gave them the resources that are suddenly lavished on the daughter of a lord.

That contrast is the book's moral centre, and Bryndza handles it without a lecture. The point comes through in the paperwork and the reactions: the same method of killing, the same water, and a completely different level of attention because one victim had a title and money. Erika's insistence on treating those earlier deaths as part of the same case is what makes her a good detective and what puts her at odds with her superiors. Once the possibility of a serial killer is on the table, the investigation widens. The team has to reconstruct Andrea's movements, work out who knew her, and try to protect the next likely victim.

As Erika closes in, the killer starts to pay attention to her. She is watched, then threatened, and the danger to her becomes another reason her bosses want the case wrapped up. Her career is already on a knife edge after the Manchester raid, so every risky step carries a cost. Bryndza keeps the pressure on her rather than on the wider city, and that choice keeps the book grounded even when the plot starts to pile up coincidences.

A team that slowly comes around

Erika does not win her team over immediately. Detective Kate Moss and Detective Peterson keep their distance at first, along with the forensic specialist known as Strong. Moss is a lesbian married to Celia, with a child called Jacob, and Peterson is black and single. Bryndza gives them enough private detail to feel like people rather than functions, and they grow into the story as Erika's directness and refusal to follow the easy path start to earn their respect. Their loyalty at the end is hard won, which is why it lands.

The investigation proceeds the way a procedural should, with records checked, phones traced, and accounts examined. Erika finds money moving between Simon Douglas-Brown, Andrea's fiancé Giles Osborne, and a man called Igor. The three men have an answer ready when questioned: the transfers paid for an exotic tree from New Zealand. It is a neat bit of misdirection and the men are unbreakable under interview, so the money trail leads nowhere she can use. Meanwhile Erika disobeys orders, pokes the media, and irritates politicians and senior officers in equal measure. She is relentless in a way that is both admirable and exhausting.

There is a cost to all this momentum. The book moves quickly, and some of the discoveries arrive a little too smoothly, as if the evidence is waiting to be found exactly when Erika looks for it. A few reviewers have noted that some twists border on the farfetched, and I understood the complaint. The plotting is engineered, and the reader can feel the hand on the wheel at times. What kept me going was the procedural texture and the sense that Erika's flaws were driving the mistakes as much as the author's need to keep the pages turning.

The answer in a photograph

The breakthrough comes from a place nobody takes seriously. Erika goes back to the Douglas-Brown house and studies the photographs on a corkboard, pictures of the younger daughter Linda with her cat, Boots, and the family together. Linda has a mental handicap, and the adults treat her as someone whose account does not matter. Erika notices that one person is missing from the images. She leaves a recorded message for Moss asking Peterson to question Linda about the cats, then goes into Linda's room to look around.

Linda tells Peterson that David killed her cat and all those women. David Douglas-Brown is Andrea's brother and Simon's son, and he is the killer. He rapes and murders young women, and his father knew what he was doing. The money moving through those accounts was Simon's way of covering for his son and supplying him with victims. Andrea found out what David had done and threatened to go to the police, so David strangled her and hid her body under the ice. He is also responsible for the deaths of the other women Erika connected to the case, including a woman called Ivy.

I found the reveal clever but slightly uncomfortable. The decisive witness is a young woman with a mental handicap whose importance everyone has dismissed, which gives the scene real poignancy, but the mechanism that gets Erika there, a missing face in a set of photographs, feels tidy beside the messier business of the earlier investigation. David confronts Erika in the house, hits her until she is unconscious, and puts her in the boot of his car alongside the body of another prostitute. He drives off with Eurostar tickets in his pocket. It is a conventional thriller trap, sprung efficiently, and it works.

The lake and the grave

Her team tracks Erika through her phone. Once they learn David has tickets for the Eurostar, they work out that he must be heading for the station, and Marsh authorises Moss and Peterson to take a helicopter. From the air they see David's car go into the water near the station. The helicopter lands and Peterson runs into the lake and gets Erika out of the car. It is a physical, straightforward rescue after all the talking, and it is the moment when the team she has spent the book alienating shows exactly what she means to them.

The aftermath is brisk. David is arrested and charged. Sir Simon falls into disgrace and loses his title. Marsh, who has spent most of the book needling Erika, shows a softer side and tells her he will be there as a friend. In the epilogue, three months on, Erika stands near Mark's grave with Edward. Moss calls to say the team misses her and wants her back. Erika promises she is coming, then breaks down talking to Mark about how much she misses him and how hard life has become. She ends by telling herself she needs to get a grip and try to move on.

That ending is the right choice for this book. The killer is caught, but the grief is not resolved and nobody pretends it is. Erika's decision to return to work is a small, stubborn thing rather than a triumph, and it fits a character who has spent the story being hard on herself and everyone else.

What works and what grates

The case for the book rests on Erika herself and on the class argument underneath the mystery. Bryndza writes a flawed lead who is capable, prejudiced in her own way, and genuinely driven by a sense of justice. The scenes in which she insists that the dead prostitutes matter as much as the socialite are the ones I remember. The team around her, particularly Moss and Peterson, gives the procedural a warmth that balances her coldness, and the frozen body of the opening is an image the novel does not waste.

The case against it is the machinery. Some twists are a touch farfetched, the establishment cover-up is broader than it needs to be, and the final few chapters bring several threads together with more neatness than the rest of the book earns. Readers looking for a gentle mystery, or for a puzzle that plays fair at every step, may find the violence and the coincidences too much. This is a novel for people who can enjoy a rough, driven detective and a story willing to say that money changes how a murder is investigated. It is not a book that offers comfort, and it is better for that honesty.

If you like character-led crime fiction with a procedural spine, the Erika Foster books start here with a strong sense of who she is and what she is running from. Go in expecting a messy lead and a plot that sometimes strains for effect, and the parts that work will land harder. I closed it wanting to know how Erika would handle a second case, which is probably the truest test of whether a first novel has done its job.

FAQ

Is The Girl in the Ice the first Erika Foster book?

Yes. It was first published in February 2016 and introduces DCI Erika Foster, who transfers from Manchester to a south London police station after six months of leave.

What is the book mainly about?

It follows Erika's investigation into the murder of a young socialite found under ice, while she tries to rebuild her career after the deaths of her husband and four colleagues in a raid she commanded.

Is this a cozy mystery?

No. It is a violent police procedural with a serial killer, a good deal of personal grief, and a plot that sometimes relies on farfetched twists.