Cover of Jack & Jill by James Patterson

Jack & Jill

2,646-word summary 12 min read 432 pages in the book

First published
1996
Publisher
Little, Brown and Company
Pages
432
ISBN
9780316693714
Series
Alex Cross (#3)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. Two murders, two kinds of horror
  2. Jack and Jill go public
  3. The White House task force
  4. A boy with a grudge
  5. The truth about Jack and Jill
  6. What works and what grates
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I came to this one straight from the first two Alex Cross books, and I could tell within a few pages that Patterson was working with a bigger budget this time. Jack & Jill was first published in 1996 by Little, Brown, the third entry in the series, and the first edition hardcover runs 432 pages. It is the book where the stakes stop being local. The killers in the first two novels went after kidnapped children and abducted women; here the target list reaches all the way to the President of the United States. That escalation is exciting, and it is also where the book starts to creak a little under its own ambition.

What I remember most is the opening move, because it sets up the whole design. Two murders happen at roughly the same moment on opposite sides of Washington. One is polished and theatrical. The other is ugly and close to home. Patterson cuts between them, and for the rest of the novel Cross will be pulled in both directions, trying to work a case that belongs to the neighborhood and a case that belongs to the country.

Two murders, two kinds of horror

The prologue introduces Senator Daniel Fitzpatrick in his Georgetown apartment. A man using the name Sam Harrison lets himself in, and an ash-blond woman greets him with a whisper of "Jack." He answers "Jill." The pair handcuff the senator to his bed, film his last moments, and then Jack shoots him execution style. They leave a note built around the old nursery rhyme, the same kind of doggerel that gives the book its title. It is a bizarre, staged killing, the work of people who want an audience.

Across town in Garfield Park, a different kind of killer is at work. A man disguised as a homeless person lures a six-year-old girl with colorful balloons and beats her to death with a bat. The victim is Shanelle Green, and her body is left at Sojourner Truth Elementary, four blocks from Cross's house and the school his own son Damon attends. There is no audience here, no camera, no clever note. It is the murder of a child, dumped where the people who knew her will find her.

Alex Cross is a deputy chief of detectives in Washington and a trained psychologist. He is also a father raising Damon and his daughter Jannie with the help of his eighty-one-year-old grandmother, Nana Mama, the woman who raised him. His partner and oldest friend, John Sampson, wakes him with the news about Shanelle. From that first phone call, the child case is personal in a way the celebrity case can never be. His son walks the same halls. The school is part of his daily life.

The early investigation goes in a direction that feels, at first, like a tidy solution. A local informant points them toward Emmanuel Perez, a man rumored to molest children. Perez dies in a chase when he falls between two rooftops. Child pornography turns up in his apartment, and on paper the case looks closed. But the real killer is still out there, gloating from a distance that the police have grabbed the wrong man. When a second child, seven-year-old Vernon Wheatley, is found dead with the same pattern of injuries, Cross knows a serial killer is at work. He quietly gathers a small team of detectives to keep pursuing the child murders on their own time, off the official record.

That decision is one of the best things in the book. Cross is not a vigilante exactly, but he understands that the machinery of a police department will not give a case involving poor Black children the same attention it gives a case involving senators and movie stars. He works the child case in the margins, and the book is at its angriest and most clear eyed in those passages.

Jack and Jill go public

The couple who killed the senator are not finished. They murder a television newswoman named Natalie Sheehan in her suite at the Jefferson Hotel and leave another mocking rhyme. Cross builds a profile of the pair: likely white, persuasive, highly organized, and hungry for attention. The profile is smart, but Patterson keeps interrupting the detection with flashes of the killers at work, and those scenes tell us more about their theater than the police ever learn.

There is a moment where Cross loses his temper with his superior, Chief of Detectives George Pittman. Pittman shoves him during an argument, and Cross shoves back, physically, in front of witnesses. He knows the moment it happens that he has probably damaged his career. It is a small, human beat in a book crowded with large ones, and it gives the later suspension real weight.

The killers escalate in ways that feel designed to humiliate the authorities. They send CNN a video manifesto. They execute an actor named Michael Robinson at the Willard Hotel. They kill General Aiden Cornwall at his home in Virginia, and when Cornwall's nine-year-old son sees what happens, the boy is shot too. At the Kennedy Center, a young law student named Charlotte Kinsey is murdered, and it emerges that she was the President's mistress. Jill then calls the White House on a private line and tells President Thomas Byrnes that his assassination is already a done deal. The message is not subtle. The whole point is that they can reach him whenever they want.

This is the stretch of the novel where the pace is most reliable. Patterson keeps chapters short and ends many of them on a new body or a new discovery. It is the technique that made the earlier books so easy to race through, and it works here too, even when the plot mechanics are thin. I kept turning pages because I wanted to know who was behind the rhymes, and because I wanted the child killer caught before another child died.

The White House task force

Cross is pulled onto the Jack and Jill investigation at the FBI's request, over his own objections. His superiors want their best homicide investigator on the case the cameras are watching. He is summoned to the White House, where a crisis team has assembled: Secret Service agent Jay Grayer, Chief of Staff Don Hamerman, CIA Inspector General Jeanne Sterling, and General Cornwall, before his death. Hamerman explains the detail that makes the case explode in scale. "Jack and Jill" is also the Secret Service code name for President Byrnes and the First Lady. After each murder, someone has been calling the Secret Service to say the killers are practicing for the big one.

Cross meets the President, who promises full cooperation, and the investigation shifts into the world of federal agencies. At CIA headquarters, Sterling tells Cross that the Agency keeps a list of freelance contract killers, men it calls ghosts, and that one of them may be Jack. A photojournalist named Kevin Hawkins, a former CIA assassin with extreme right-wing ties, becomes the leading suspect. Hawkins is a convincing red herring for a while, and the chase to catch him, which ends with him slipping away, is staged with the kinetic energy Patterson is known for.

The task force material is the most obviously researched part of the book, and it is also the part that dates fastest. There are meeting rooms, chain-of-command arguments, and long explanations of how the Secret Service plans a route. Some of it is genuinely interesting. Some of it reads like a writer making sure the reader knows he did his homework. I found myself skimming a few of the briefings, then snapping back to attention whenever the killers did something terrible.

Running alongside all of this is Cross's growing attachment to Christine Johnson, the principal of Sojourner Truth. She is smart and direct, and she is married to a lawyer named George. Cross meets her while working the child case, and the attraction is clear almost immediately. This is where the book starts to feel like it is borrowing a subplot from a different, softer novel. Cross is grieving, isolated, and drawn to a woman in crisis, and the circumstances are awkward enough that the romance never quite settles. It gives the ending a place to land, but it also pulls attention away from the cases at the moment the plot needs the most focus.

A boy with a grudge

The child case breaks open through an unlikely piece of period technology. The Prodigy online service alerts Sampson that one of its subscribers has been posting details about the murders that no ordinary member of the public should know. The account leads back to the home of Colonel Franklin Moore, where suspicion falls on the colonel's thirteen-year-old son, Sumner. Cross and Sampson raid the house and find it empty, with Shanelle Green's bloodstained blouse left behind as proof of what has been happening. Then Sumner turns up dead, killed in the same manner as the other children. He had been framed.

The real killer is another thirteen-year-old, a classmate named Danny Boudreaux. Danny has stopped taking Depakote, a medication prescribed for a mood disorder, and the book ties his violence to that decision. He murders his foster parents and vanishes. Later, fixated on Cross as the father he never had, he goes to Christine Johnson's house to force a confrontation. He shoots George Johnson dead and holds Christine at gunpoint, demanding that Cross come to him.

Cross flies back from New York and walks into the house as the boy instructed. What follows is one of the sharper scenes in the novel. Cross arranges himself and Christine on opposite sides of the room so Danny cannot aim at both at once. When the boy fires at Christine, Cross tackles him and tears the gun away. Danny suffers a grand mal seizure and, in the moment before he goes under, whispers that he is afraid and does not know where he is. Cross says he understands. That admission shakes him, because recognizing something of himself in a child who has murdered strangers is not a comfortable place to end a case. The writing here is surprisingly gentle, and it gives Danny a kind of tragic weight the rest of the thriller does not always allow its villains.

The truth about Jack and Jill

The assassination plot reaches its climax at Madison Square Garden, where President Byrnes has decided to speak rather than hide. Sara Rosen, a White House staffer of nine years, is revealed as Jill, the woman who has been feeding Jack information from inside the administration. On the morning of the speech, she meets Sam, her partner in the scheme, at the Peninsula Hotel. After a final intimate encounter, Sam shoots her with a silenced pistol, puts a poem in her hand, and drives back toward Washington, calling his wife and daughter along the way and thinking of himself as a patriot.

At the Garden, Kevin Hawkins, disguised as a female FBI agent, detonates a concussion bomb near the stage. The Secret Service rushes the President into a predetermined escape tunnel, and Hawkins is waiting inside. He fires five shots. Cross had been arguing for a change of route; he arrives to find Byrnes bleeding on the floor. The President dies, and Vice President Edward Mahoney is sworn in. For a moment it looks as though the case is closed, with the killer cut down and Jill dead in a hotel room.

It is not. Searching Sara Rosen's apartment days later, Cross finds an unmarked tape inside a cassette box for Hitchcock's Notorious. The uncut footage of the Fitzpatrick murder shows the killer's face, and it is not Hawkins. The real Jack is Brett Sterling, a decorated former Army colonel and the husband of Jeanne Sterling, the CIA official Cross has been working beside. Cross and Grayer arrest Brett at a suburban stoplight. At the Sterling home, Jeanne explains that she and her husband acted as patriots to stop a foolish amateur of a president from dismantling American intelligence. She shoots Grayer through the pocket of her robe and runs for the garage with her three-year-old daughter as a shield. Cross chases her down and subdues her.

The aftermath is deliberately unsatisfying. Both Sterlings are found dead in their cells at Lorton Prison, apparently poisoned, and there is evidence that Jeanne fought whoever killed her. Their deaths close off the larger conspiracy before anyone can explain who else might have benefited from the President's death. Cross thinks about the Kennedy assassination and concludes that there are too many logical suspects. The truth, he decides, may never be known. It is a bleak note to end on, and it fits a book that has spent hundreds of pages insisting that the people with the most power are the ones best able to disappear.

Cross is suspended over the confrontation with Pittman and goes home. Christine arrives at his door one night, and he lets her in. On Christmas Eve, while he is decorating the tree with his children, Gary Soneji, the kidnapper from Cross's first case, calls from wherever he has been hiding. Soneji tells him he left the family cat at the house months earlier, which means he has been watching them for a long time. Cross hangs up and goes back to the tree. The monsters, the book says plainly, never really leave.

What works and what grates

The great strength of Jack & Jill is its engine. Two cases, two very different kinds of danger, and a detective who cares about both for different reasons. When the book is moving between the celebrity murders and the child murders, it is hard to put down. The short chapters do their job, the discoveries arrive regularly, and the ending of almost every section makes you want one more section.

The weaknesses sit in the same design. The conspiracy is so layered that the reveal depends on a tape turning up in a cassette box, a piece of luck that feels more convenient than earned. The Prodigy subplot and the cassette tape now read as period artifacts, which is charming in a way but also a reminder of how much the book relies on the technology of 1996. The romance with Christine Johnson never fully convinces, and the ethics of Cross's pursuit of a married woman while her husband is about to be murdered are stranger than the book seems to notice.

There is also a problem of scale. The first half of the book is tense because the threat is close to Cross's family and his neighborhood. Once the story widens to include the CIA, the Secret Service, and the President, the child murders, which were the most gripping material, get pushed to the background until the final act. Danny Boudreaux's seizure and confession are powerful, but they arrive after the book has spent a long time asking the reader to care about a federal task force instead. I kept wishing the two plots had been given equal weight for more of the run.

Still, I finished it wanting the next book, which is the main thing a thriller has to accomplish. It is not the cleanest or the most believable of the early Cross novels, and it is not the kind of book that rewards a close reading. It is a fast, often brutal story about a man trying to hold two worlds together while both come apart. For readers who like the series, that is more than enough. For anyone who wants a tight, realistic police procedural, the rhyming notes and the presidential conspiracy may ask for more patience than they deserve.

FAQ

Is Jack & Jill part of a series?

Yes, it is the third Alex Cross novel by James Patterson, following Along Came a Spider and Kiss the Girls, and it uses the same series name as those earlier books.

Who are Jack and Jill in the novel?

The names are used by killers who leave nursery-rhyme notes at the scenes of prominent victims. The figure called Jill is White House staffer Sara Rosen, while the original Jack is eventually revealed to be Brett Sterling.

When was Jack & Jill first published?

It was first published in 1996 by Little, Brown and Company, and the first edition hardcover runs 432 pages.