Women Who Run with the Wolves
2,331-word summary 10 min read 560 pages in the book
- First published
- 1992
- Publisher
- Ballantine Books
- Pages
- 560
- ISBN
- 9780345377449
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
Why I opened this book
I picked this up because it kept turning up in arguments about books that change how people see themselves, and because the premise sounded slightly strange. A thick volume about women and wolves that was neither a novel nor a nature guide. It turned out to be a 1992 collection of Jungian psychoanalytic essays, published by Ballantine, that treats old fairy tales as if they were dreams waiting to be interpreted. The book spent 145 weeks on the New York Times bestseller list across three years, an odd feat for a book of five hundred pages built around myth and story. I wanted to know what kind of writing could sustain that kind of interest. What I found was something that is by turns illuminating, maddening, and genuinely moving, and that asks the reader to take nursery stories seriously as a kind of instruction for living.
The stories did not come from textbooks. Estés says they were handed to her by family, by people she met traveling, and by patients in her practice. That origin matters for how the book reads. These are tales that have been told aloud, and the prose often sounds like someone speaking rather than writing an article. She is a trained analyst, and she never fully leaves the clinic behind, but the voice is that of a storyteller who believes a story can do work on a person.
The Wild Woman and the bones
The guiding idea is the Wild Woman archetype, an instinctual knowledge Estés believes lives in every woman. She describes it as the part that knows when to stay and when to leave, when to let live and when to let die. It is not a person or a goddess to be worshiped so much as a layer of knowing that gets buried when life becomes all rationality and dutiful functioning. When a woman loses contact with it, she becomes depressed, doubtful, ashamed, and able only to perform the business of the day. The book is an attempt to dig that layer back up.
The opening image, and the title of the introduction, is Singing over the Bones. It comes from the first chapter's tale of La Loba, a wolf woman who lives in the desert and collects bones. When she has gathered a complete skeleton, she sings over it until the animal comes back to life. Estés reads the scene as a picture of creative work. Gathering the bones is the slow labor of dream work, art, dance, and attention. Singing them alive is the act of speaking from a place of deep love so that dead ideas and dead powers can move again. It is a lovely piece of interpretation, and it sets the pattern for everything that follows: a tale is told, then slowly unpacked into psychological tasks.
That pattern is the book's great strength and its great weakness. Estés is a gifted close reader of a story's mood. She notices what a tale is feeling before she says what it means. At her best she makes a familiar story strange again, so that you hear it as a danger or a promise instead of a children's bedtime fixture.
Predators, keys, and a doll in her pocket
The second chapter takes up Bluebeard, the man who marries a young wife, leaves her his keys, and warns her away from one door. She opens it, finds the bodies of his earlier wives, and stains the key red. When he discovers her disobedience he means to kill her, but her sisters arrive and kill him instead. Estés treats the husband as the natural predator of the psyche, the force that wants a woman to remain innocent and ignorant so she can be controlled. The red key is knowledge, and the point is that curiosity about the dark corners of a life is a survival skill rather than a moral failing.
She spends real time on the question of why young women are caught by such figures, and her answer is that they have been trained not to trust their own alarm. The predator arrives with charm, looks, and money. A woman who has been taught only to be nice will read his danger as attraction. This is one of the sharper passages in the book, and it is written with a plainness that cuts through some of the surrounding ornament.
The third chapter moves to Vasalisa the Wise, the girl with a doll in her pocket. In the tale, a mother dies and leaves her daughter a doll that will answer questions. Vasalisa is sent to the witch Baba Yaga for a light, and along the way she has to sort seeds, navigate darkness, and face the terrifying old woman. Estés lays out nine tasks drawn from the story, among them allowing the too-good mother to die, exposing the crude shadow, asking the mysteries, and standing on all fours. Some of these readings feel earned. The doll as an inner voice that tells you which way to turn is a clean and useful image. Others feel stretched, as if every detail of a tale has been assigned a job whether it wants one or not.
By this point a reader also starts to notice the tone. Estés writes in long, rolling sentences that accumulate images. She uses phrases drawn from many languages and traditions, and she is willing to assert that the Wild Woman has been called La Mujer Grande in Spain or Dakini in Tibet. The effect can be exhilarating, and it can also feel like a claim that all cultures are saying the same thing. That tension comes back later.
Love, belonging, and the creative life
The middle of the book widens out from danger into the questions of how a woman loves, where she belongs, and how she keeps making things. The chapter on Skeleton Woman is probably the most memorable piece of interpretation here. A fisherman hooks a dead woman's skeleton in his net and is terrified. She follows him home, and he finally covers her, sits with her, and cries over her. The skeleton comes back to life and, in the version Estés tells, drinks his tears. She becomes his wife. Estés reads this as the life, death, and life rhythm of love: the way affection requires that something old die, that a person sit with what is bony and frightening, and that tears are part of the repair rather than a failure of it. It is a strange tale and a beautiful reading of it.
The Ugly Duckling gets a chapter about exile and finding one's pack. Estés is interested in the child who does not look right, the one who is frozen out because the group cannot classify her. She inventories kinds of mothers, including the ambivalent mother, the collapsed mother, and the unmothered mother, and connects a girl's sense of exile to the freeze of feeling and creativity that can follow. Here again the writing is strongest when it stays close to a single image, like the duckling simply being the wrong shape for the pond it was born into.
The Red Shoes chapter is where the book gets most practical. The old tale of a girl whose beautiful red shoes will not stop dancing, carrying her away from home and eventually to an executioner, becomes a catalog of traps. Estés names eight of them, among them the gilded carriage that stands for a devalued life, soul famine, injury to basic instinct, trying to sneak a secret life, cringing before the collective, faking it, and the dancing out of control that belongs to obsession and addiction. This is the nearest the book comes to a self-help program, and it is hard to argue with the idea that a woman should notice when something she wanted has started to move her body against her will.
Two later chapters extend the creative theme. Sealskin, Soulskin tells of a woman who loses her seal skin and with it her sense of self, and who has to dive back into the water to retrieve it. Estés makes a case for intentional solitude and for the idea that a woman has an inner ecology that needs tending. The Clear Water chapter brings in La Llorona, the weeping woman, along with poison in the river, the Little Match Girl, and the Three Gold Hairs. Water stands for the creative life, and the question is how to keep it from being fouled by other people's demands and by the fantasy mill that keeps a woman dreaming about making things instead of making them.
There is also a short, odd chapter on heat and sacred sexuality, with the Dirty Goddesses, Baubo the belly goddess, Coyote Dick, and a story set in Rwanda. It is the loosest section in the book, and it reads like material that did not quite find a home elsewhere.
Rage, scars, and the underground forest
The later chapters are the ones I found most surprising. The book does not end at gentle intuition. It goes into anger and injury. In Marking Territory, the tale of the Crescent Moon Bear follows a woman who climbs a mountain to find a bear that can cure her rage. Estés treats rage as a teacher that points toward a boundary that has been crossed, and she lays out four stages of forgiveness with the old legal words forego, forebear, forget, and forgive. These are not presented as a command to excuse harm. They are closer to a map of what a person does with anger over time, and the distinction matters.
Battle Scars, membership in the scar clan, deals with secrets as slayers and with what Estés calls the dead zone, a place where feeling goes when something unspeakable has happened. The chapter is short and rather compressed, and it contains the piece of scholarly pushback worth knowing about. The folklorist Barre Toelken faulted Estés's reading of Bluebeard for mixing versions of the tale from separate cultures, and saw in it a habit among Jung-influenced writers of building large theories on a single version that happens to support the theory. Whether or not you accept that criticism, it names a real risk in the method. When every detail of a story must mean something, the story can start to sound like the analyst talking.
The longest and most ambitious chapter is La Selva Subterránea, the underground forest, built around the Handless Maiden. A young woman loses her hands, is cast out, wanders, and eventually reaches an orchard and a series of figures, among them a gardener, a king, a mage, a queen mother, and the devil. Estés follows seven stages: the bargain made without knowing, the dismemberment, the wandering, finding love in the underworld, the harrowing of the soul, the Wild Woman's domain, and the wild bride and bridegroom. It is easy to get lost in the scaffolding. It is also where the book's claim that old tales describe initiation is at its most convincing. The maiden has to be cut down to a state where she can be remade, and the hands that are lost are the hands that once held an ordinary life.
After that the book quiets down into Canto Hondo, the deep song, a short meditation on shadowing, then general wolf rules for life, then a final piece called The Wolf's Eyelash and an afterword on story as medicine. The afterword states the book's case plainly, that stories heal by putting a shape around experience that ordinary language cannot hold.
What works, what drags, and who it is for
The best thing here is the reading of individual tales. If you take the La Loba chapter or the Skeleton Woman chapter on their own, you get a compact and memorable argument about how a person comes back to life after something has gone dead inside. Estés has an ear for the moment in a story where the feeling turns, and she can make a scene from a hundred-year-old tale land with real force. The book also has a generous spirit. It is not scolding. It assumes the reader has been through something and offers company rather than a grade.
The drag is the length and the repetition. The Wild Woman is resurrected in chapter after chapter, and by the time the argument reaches the underground forest, the same point about trusting instinct has been made in so many costumes that it loses some of its shock. The prose is thick with invocation, and readers who want a clean thesis and a clean method will feel buried. The claim that an archetype found in one tale is the same force named in traditions across the world is asserted more often than it is argued, and Toelken's objection about the Bluebeard material is not a trivial one. There is also a fair concern, which Estés herself would reject, that the book risks treating all women as having the same inner life. Her defenders answer, with some justice, that she is describing a psychological pattern and not telling anyone how to live.
This is not a book to skim, and it is not a book for someone who wants ten concrete exercises. It rewards a slow reader with a taste for myth and for language that takes its time. I would hand it to someone who loves fairy tales and wants to know why they keep returning to certain images, or to someone in a long stretch of creative silence who can bear a book that talks about silence for five hundred pages. I would be careful about handing it to a reader who wants a tidy answer. Estés offers a voice, a set of stories, and a way of listening. She does not offer a checklist, and the book is better for it, even when it is also too long.
FAQ
Is Women Who Run with the Wolves fiction or nonfiction?
It is nonfiction: a collection of Jungian psychoanalytic essays that retell and interpret fairy tales, first published in 1992 by Ballantine Books.
Do I need to know Jungian psychology to read it?
No. Estés writes for a general audience using familiar tales like Bluebeard and the Ugly Duckling, though the archetypal framework is assumed throughout.
Does the book offer a step-by-step self-help program?
Not really. It is a long, lyrical work of interpretation with an afterword on story as medicine, rather than a structured set of exercises.





























