Cover of The Wonder by Emma Donoghue

The Wonder

2,298-word summary 10 min read 291 pages in the book

First published
2016
Publisher
Little, Brown and Company
Pages
291
ISBN
9780316393874
Reading options
What's inside (7 sections)
  1. The girl in the cabin
  2. The watch
  3. What the manna was
  4. Milk and fire
  5. The questions under the floorboards
  6. Key takeaways
  7. FAQ

I picked this one up because Room had wrecked me and I wanted to see what Donoghue did next with a child in danger. The Wonder came out in 2016, published in the United States by Little, Brown and Company, and it takes place in the Irish Midlands in the late 1850s, within living memory of the famine. It is a short book, 291 pages in the first American edition, but it reads like a locked-room mystery with the door nailed shut from the outside. The mystery is simple to state and horrible to sit with: an eleven-year-old girl says she has not eaten for four months, and a crowd of people would very much like that to be true.

The girl in the cabin

Elizabeth Wright goes by Lib, and she is twenty-nine, English, and widowed. She trained as a nurse under Florence Nightingale during the Crimean War, and she carries that training like a badge and a shield. The hospital where she works sends her on a two week assignment in Ireland, to a village where a local committee has raised money for an unusual job. A doctor, a priest, and several prominent men want someone impartial to watch an eleven-year-old named Anna O'Donnell. Anna has not eaten since her birthday four months ago. She says she lives on manna from Heaven. Pilgrims have started coming to the cabin, and the committee wants a respectable witness to either confirm the marvel or expose the cheat.

Lib arrives expecting a fraud. That is the first thing the book gets right about her: she is not a believer and not a cynic so much as a professional with a job to do. She is assigned to share the watching with a nun, Sister Michael, who is warmer and more diplomatic than Lib and who treats the village with the patience of someone who has lived among it. The two women take turns. One sits with Anna during the day, the other at night, and the rule is that no food passes to the girl while they are in the room. Lib measures everything. She watches the frequency of Anna's breathing, the color of her skin, the state of her teeth and tongue, the small movements she makes when she thinks no one is looking. She writes it all down in a notebook, because a nurse's record is the only argument she trusts.

Anna herself is the surprise. Lib expects a sly child running a profitable trick, and instead she finds a girl who is thin to the point of alarm, feverishly pious, and utterly convinced of her own story. She speaks in the language of the Bible because she has been raised on it. She talks about manna as a fact, the way another child might talk about breakfast. She is polite, watchful, and strangely calm. The tourists who troop through the cabin want a miracle to look at, and they leave satisfied. Lib, who has to stay and count the hours, begins to notice that the girl looks worse every morning.

The watch

Donoghue structures the middle of the book around the sheer physical grind of observation. Lib sits in a chair in a small cabin while pilgrims pray in the yard and a journalist named William Byrne hangs around trying to get a story. Byrne is Irish, experienced, and not easily impressed. He has covered the famine, which means he has seen what a starving body actually looks like, and he has no patience for people who romanticize it. Lib initially keeps him at a distance because a reporter is exactly the kind of witness who could turn her careful notes into a sensation. As the days pass and her own certainty erodes, she starts to rely on him. She even introduces him to Anna, a small professional betrayal that says more about Lib's loneliness than she would admit.

The book's real subject starts to show itself here. The watch is not neutral. By gathering in the cabin to prove a miracle, the committee has created the conditions in which a sick child cannot be fed. Everyone involved has an interest in the fast continuing: the priest because a living saint is good for the parish, the doctor because he has staked his reputation on the case, the family because attention brings money, and the neighbors because a wonder in the village is something to be proud of. Lib is the only person whose interest is supposedly the child, and even she is constrained by the rules she agreed to. She begins to understand that she has been hired not to find the truth but to certify a story everyone has already chosen.

The fasting girls are not invented. Donoghue notes in her author's note that cases like Anna's were recorded across Europe and North America for centuries, mostly girls whose families and communities had a reason to believe, or to pretend to believe, that they could live without food. That history gives the novel its teeth. Anna is not an oddity in a vacuum. She is the latest version of something people keep wanting to be true, and Donoghue is interested in the hunger of the onlookers as much as the hunger of the child.

One of the quiet strengths of the book is the way it keeps the English and Irish viewpoints in friction without turning either into a lesson. Lib arrives with the confidence of an empire's nurse, certain that her training and her notebook can sort out a village's superstition. The committee resents being inspected by a woman who has come to tell them what is real in their own parish. Donoghue writes that friction in small exchanges rather than speeches, in who gets addressed and who is ignored, in the way an English accent lands in a room a generation after the famine. Nobody in the cabin is neutral, and the longer Lib sits there, the harder it becomes for her to pretend she is. Her tiredness is partly the job and partly the effort of holding on to a role that the village keeps handing back to her.

What the manna was

The explanation, when Lib finally reaches it, is both mundane and intimate. Anna's mother has been feeding her chewed food through a kiss, morning and evening, a mouthful at a time passed from mother to daughter under the cover of affection. It is not food in any sense a nurse would recognize, but it has kept the girl alive for months. The detail is deliberate. Donoghue makes the "miracle" depend on the most ordinary and physical of acts, a mother's mouth against her child's, and then makes that act impossible once the watching begins. Since Lib arrived, Anna has been refusing even the kiss. She is not surviving the fast. She is dying inside it.

Byrne sees it before Lib will. He tells her plainly that Anna is in the last stages of starvation, and Lib's training finally overrides her need to be right. What follows is the worst part of the book, because the people who could save the child are the same people who assembled the audience for her. Lib argues with the doctor and the priest. She says the watch is killing her. They say they have done everything that can be done, and they mean it, in the way that people mean it when their own good opinion is at stake. Anna's mother is no help either, and here Donoghue opens the second and darker mystery.

Anna is not fasting for Heaven. She had an older brother named Patrick who abused her for years. He is dead, and Anna believes he is in Hell. She wants to die so she can be with him. The mother knew about the abuse and blamed the child for it. The priest knew too, and he blamed her as well. That is the novel's cruelest turn, and it is handled without a speech. Donoghue does not pause to explain the theology of a frightened girl who would rather be dead than blamed. She lets Lib piece it together from what people refuse to say, and the silence of the adults is the loudest thing in the cabin. The miracle was never about God. It was about a child who had been taught that she was the guilty party, and who found a way to make the world applaud her disappearance.

Milk and fire

Once Lib understands what Anna wants, the rescue becomes a kind of negotiation with a dying child's beliefs. Lib cannot simply order her to eat, and she will not lecture her about sin. Instead she offers Anna a cup of milk and tells her that drinking it will kill her, that she will be born again as a younger girl named Nan, an eight-year-old with no sin attached to her. It is a falsehood built out of Anna's own language, and Anna accepts it. She drinks. The scene is quiet, which is what makes it work. There is no convert's joy, no sudden change of heart. A child who has been denied ordinary food for months takes a cup of milk because a nurse she has come to trust tells her it will let her start over.

Lib then hands the girl calling herself Nan to William Byrne, who is waiting to take her away. She sets the O'Donnell cabin on fire and tells the committee she panicked after Anna died. The plan depends on a nun's vision. Sister Michael has seen William riding off with Anna on a horse, and when Lib tells her the child is in a better place, the nun chooses not to say what she saw. That small act of mercy carries more weight in the book than all the arguments about evidence. The committee accepts the story because it is the story it wants. A dead fasting girl is more useful to them than a live one who might explain how she survived. That is the sharpest criticism the book makes, and it lands without a raised voice. The same men who demanded proof of a miracle do not ask a single hard question when the miracle conveniently ends in a locked cabin with no witness left to interview. Their relief is more telling than their faith. Lib understands that she has escaped with two lives by handing them a conclusion they preferred over the truth, and she does not pretend otherwise.

The last movement jumps forward. On a boat to Australia, Byrne and Nan are traveling as a widower and his daughter. Lib is on the same ship, posing as a widow. They intend to make a family of it. The ending can feel sudden after all the tight, claustrophobic work that came before, and some readers will find the happy arrangement too neat for a novel that has spent two hundred pages arguing against comfortable stories. I think it is deliberately provisional. These three people have agreed to tell a new story about themselves, and the book allows them that without pretending the old one has been undone. Donoghue is not naive about what a fresh start costs. She simply lets her characters buy one and step aboard.

The questions under the floorboards

What stays with me is how carefully the book separates faith from the people who use it. Anna's belief is real, and Sister Michael's goodness is real, and neither of them is the target. The target is the deal struck around them: the daughter's body offered up so the adults can feel something grand about themselves. Donoghue, who grew up in Ireland and writes with a clear eye for the authority of men who mean well, sets the English nurse against the Irish village without letting either side become a caricature. Lib's certainty is a form of pride, and the committee's certainty is a form of vanity. The girl in the middle pays for both.

There is also a plain procedural pleasure in watching Lib work. She checks the mouth, the pulse, the weight, the urine, the temperature. Her notes are boring on purpose, and their boringness is the moral center of the book. Written down carefully, a child's decline becomes impossible to explain away. Donoghue trusts that record-keeping can be dramatic when the record is the only thing standing between someone and a story that will swallow them. The particular authority of a trained woman, dismissed in a room full of men, gives the novel its quiet fury.

The book is not without its lags. The middle weeks of the watch necessarily repeat themselves, and Lib's arguments with the committee circle the same ground a few more times than I needed. Byrne sometimes functions as the person who says out loud what Lib has not yet worked out, which flattens her a little. And the Australian coda asks us to accept a very fast reimagining of three damaged lives. Still, these are complaints about pacing and compression, not about the premise. A novel this controlled can afford a chapter that drags, because the next one usually closes the trap.

I closed it thinking about the tourists in the yard. They come to see a girl who is not eating, and they go home fed on wonder. Lib sits beside her with a notebook and a lamp, doing the unglamorous work of noticing that the child is dying. The distance between those two responses is the whole book. Donoghue does not tell us which one is more human. She just makes us watch what each of them costs, and lets the cup of milk land like a small, stubborn answer.

FAQ

Is The Wonder based on a true story?

The novel is fiction, but Donoghue drew on documented cases of fasting girls reported in Europe and North America over several centuries. Anna O'Donnell and the Irish village are invented.

What year is The Wonder set in?

It is set in the Irish Midlands in the late 1850s, within living memory of the Great Famine, and was published in 2016.

Why does Anna stop eating?

She says she lives on manna from Heaven, but the novel reveals that her mother secretly fed her chewed food and that Anna wants to die to be with the brother who abused her.