Cover of The Kitchen God's Wife by Amy Tan

The Kitchen God's Wife

2,896-word summary 13 min read 415 pages in the book

First published
1991
Publisher
G. P. Putnam's Sons
Pages
415
ISBN
9780399135781
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. A mother who keeps her cards close
  2. Helen's threat and the bargain between women
  3. Weili, left at six
  4. Wen Fu
  5. The long way out of China
  6. What Pearl finally says
  7. The parts that strain, and the parts that hold
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this one up because a friend called it the angrier, more honest cousin of The Joy Luck Club. That description held up, though not quite the way I expected. Amy Tan published it in 1991, her second novel, and she drew parts of it from the story of her own mother's life. On the surface it is about a Chinese mother and her American-born daughter who can barely bear to share a room, and about a first husband named Wen Fu who makes a young woman's life a small, steady hell. What surprised me is that the angrier book is also the more tender one. By the last page I found myself forgiving people I had wanted to shake two hundred pages earlier.

The novel has two voices. The first is Pearl Louie Brandt, a speech therapist in San Jose who works with children and has been hiding a multiple sclerosis diagnosis from her mother for seven years. The second is her mother, Winnie, who takes over for the long middle of the book and recounts what happened to her in China before she came to America. The present-day story covers only a few days in San Francisco in January 1990, built around an engagement party and a funeral. The story Winnie tells stretches across decades and a war. That gap between a short frame and a huge confession is the engine of the whole book.

A mother who keeps her cards close

Pearl gets a phone call from Winnie asking her to come up to San Francisco for the engagement party of her cousin Bao-Bao. Pearl goes because she feels she has to, not because she wants to. She lives fifty miles away with her husband Phil, a pathologist, and their two daughters, Tessa and Cleo, and she has built a life that feels more American than Chinese. Her marriage, her work, her address, all of it sits at a polite distance from the world her mother came out of. She loves Winnie, but the love comes wrapped in obligation and a low hum of guilt.

Two days before the party, Winnie calls again with news that her elderly aunt, Auntie Du, has died. The funeral is set for the day after the engagement dinner. So Pearl packs up the family and heads north, carrying two events she would rather not attend and one secret she has kept for seven years. The multiple sclerosis is hers. Everyone in the family knows about it except Winnie, and Pearl has decided that is how it will stay. Tan is very good at the small mechanics of avoidance here. Pearl dodges, she delays, she tells herself the timing is wrong, and all the while the reader can feel the truth pressing against the inside of the scene.

At the engagement dinner Pearl sits through the toasts and the banter, and afterward at the Buddhist funeral for Auntie Du something finally gives. She cries for her father, Jimmy Louie, a Baptist minister who died when she was fourteen, and she realizes she has never really let herself grieve him. In her will, Auntie Du leaves Pearl a small household altar to the Kitchen God. This is a modest object with a strange story attached to it. As a man, the Kitchen God was a liar and an abusive husband who treated his wife badly and took all the credit for her work. As a deity, his job is to report to the Jade Emperor on who has been good and who has been bad over the past year. Pearl inherits it without much ceremony, and it sits in her kitchen like an accusation she has not yet learned to read.

Helen's threat and the bargain between women

The person who forces the whole book into motion is Helen, Winnie's oldest friend and her partner in the flower shop. Pearl has always believed Helen is her aunt, a relative by marriage, but that turns out to be a story the family told for practical reasons. During the party, Helen pulls Pearl aside and says she has a malignant brain tumor. She says she does not want to die with unfinished business, and she threatens to tell Winnie about the multiple sclerosis if Pearl will not do it herself. It is a cruel move dressed up as honesty, and Pearl is boxed in by it.

Helen then does the same thing to Winnie. She lets Winnie know that Wen Fu, the first husband nobody in the family talks about, has died of heart disease, and she says that with him gone there is nothing left to fear. She threatens to spill Winnie's whole buried history to Pearl unless Winnie tells it herself. The trick works on both of them. Later we learn the brain tumor was invented, a lie Helen tells to make a mother and daughter say the things they have spent years swallowing. I had mixed feelings about this device. It is manipulative, and Helen is unapologetic about it, but the book treats the manipulation as a kind of rough mercy. Helen knows these two women will never open up on their own, so she gives them a deadline.

That is when Winnie asks Pearl to sit with her in the kitchen, and the novel changes hands. From here until near the end, Winnie does the talking. She begins with her childhood name, Jiang Weili, and the mother who walked out when she was six. The told story is not a neat set of revelations delivered one after another. It comes out in bunches, with interruptions, arguments, second thoughts, and long stretches where Winnie is clearly deciding how much her daughter can take. The messiness is what makes it feel true.

Weili, left at six

Winnie was the child of a wealthy Shanghai family. Her father, Jiang Sao-yen, owned a textile factory and had several wives. Her mother, the wife who raised her, had wanted a different life and a different marriage, and she vanished when Weili was six. One day the mother took her daughter into the city for a gorgeous outing of movies and sweets and walks through busy streets. The next morning she was gone, and Weili was never given a straight answer about where she went or whether she was dead. That scene of a perfect day followed by an empty bed stayed with me. It is the first of many times in this book when a small kindness is followed by a cruelty that much larger.

After her mother disappeared, Weili was sent to live with an uncle and his two wives on Tsungming Island, so that she would not remind her father of the wife he had lost. The household was split between Old East and New West, the traditional half and the half modeled on an English manor. She was treated as a guest rather than a daughter, and the only real warmth came from her cousin Peanut, a girl her own age who became the sister she never had. Weili withdrew into the greenhouse and into herself. Tan is attentive to the way a child builds a private world out of the corners she is given.

At Chinese New Year in 1937, the two girls go to the market stalls, have fortunes read, and watch a play in the square. There they meet Wen Fu, a charming young man who plays the dragon in the performance and flirts with Peanut. He starts as Peanut's suitor, passing notes through Weili, but when he learns which girl has the richer family, he switches his attention to Weili. She is suspicious of him and says so, but she is also flattered and lonely, and the match is arranged. Her father agrees to it and warns her that a wife must be obedient. He sends a huge sum into town for her dowry, and she later discovers that his other daughters received dowries many times larger, and that he knew Wen Fu came from a questionable family. The message is plain: she was never the daughter he was willing to fight for.

Wen Fu

Wen Fu enlists when China goes to war with Japan, and he joins the air force group led by the American pilot Claire Chennault. Weili eventually learns that he got in using his dead brother's name and credentials, and that when his squadron meets real combat he turns and runs. Nobody challenges him because of his family connections and his rank. What follows is a long account of a marriage built on humiliation. Wen Fu is physically violent, sexually cruel, and in constant control of the money and the story. He enjoys frightening her most when they are alone or when he can make her look foolish in front of others. Reading it is hard going, and Tan does not let the reader look away.

The one lasting good thing in this stretch is Weili's friendship with Hulan, the wife of Wen Fu's boss. The two women become allies in a world where every other door is shut. They are called sisters, and the bond carries the rest of the book. Their children are born into the war and into Wen Fu's house. Weili's first daughter, Mochou, is stillborn. A second daughter, Yiku, falls ill and dies after Wen Fu keeps the doctor from treating her because he is playing mah jong. A son, Danru, dies of plague while Weili is away trying to win a divorce. She ends several later pregnancies because she cannot bear to bring more children into Wen Fu's keeping. Each loss is reported in a few plain sentences, and the restraint makes them land harder than a page of explaining would.

There is one bright thread in all of this. At a military party, Weili meets Jimmy Louie, a Chinese-American man who is drawn to her immediately, and they dance. He is kind in a way she has never known, and he becomes the person she imagines a life with. He is also the man Pearl has always been told was her father. The novel lets the reader sit with that comfort for a while before it takes it away.

The long way out of China

Winnie's escape is the part of the book that reads like a thriller, though the stakes are entirely domestic and legal. After the war she returns to her father's house and finds him frail and unable to speak after a stroke. Wen Fu's family moves in and starts stripping the place of its valuables while the old man watches, powerless. Weili goes looking for Peanut and runs into Jimmy instead. They talk, and she sends her son to stay with Hulan and his family while she works out a way to leave. Then the boy dies, and Jimmy is sent out of the country when Wen Fu finds out where Weili has been. He promises to return in two years and supports her with letters and money from America.

Weili is arrested for deserting her husband and is given a choice: go back to Wen Fu, or go to prison. She chooses prison, and serves part of a two-year sentence before Auntie Du uses her connections with corrupt officials to get her out in 1949. Jimmy writes to ask her to come to America and marry him. What follows is a scramble of forged and tricked paperwork. Weili manipulates Wen Fu and his new wife into signing divorce papers, but he finds her, tears them up, threatens the plane tickets, and rapes her at gunpoint. She gets the gun away from him. With Hulan's help she overpowers him, throws his trousers out the window, and grabs the tickets. She leaves by plane the next day, just before the communists take Shanghai and seal the borders.

Then comes the detail that has been gathering force for two hundred pages. Pearl was born less than nine months after that last assault, which means Jimmy was almost certainly not her father. Wen Fu was. Winnie has carried that suspicion across an ocean and a quarter century, and it explains the distance between mother and daughter in the opening chapters. She watched Pearl for signs of Wen Fu in her face and temper, and she could never bring herself to say why. It is a staggering secret, and the book handles its timing a little too neatly, as if one more revelation will tie every thread at once. Still, the emotional logic holds. Winnie's silence was never about shame alone. It was about fear that the past had followed her into her daughter's body.

What Pearl finally says

When Winnie finishes, Pearl tells her about the multiple sclerosis. It is a small, plain sentence after all that opera, and that is exactly why it works. Mother and daughter have each handed over the thing they were most afraid to say, and the air between them changes. Winnie promises to help fight the disease and immediately worries that it is Wen Fu's fault, an echo of the old habit of blaming him for everything. But the mood here is not triumph. It is two people who have finally met each other, late, and who have a lot of lost time to make up.

Helen eventually admits the brain tumor was a lie. She made it up because she knew neither woman would speak first. This revelation made me like her more, not less. She is a busybody and a manipulator, but she is also the person who saw two people drowning in the same room and decided to throw a rope. The trip to China that the women plan at the end, partly to look for herbal treatment for Pearl, feels less like a tidy solution than like a first step. Tan does not pretend the disease is cured or the history is settled.

The ending image is the one that gave the book its title and the one I keep thinking about. Winnie goes into a shop and finds a small altar figure of a goddess with no name. The shopkeeper says she is bad luck and sells her cheap. Winnie takes her home, burns the picture of the Kitchen God, and sets the new figure in Pearl's altar. She calls her Lady Sorrowfree, the wife of the Kitchen God, a woman who endured everything, got no credit for it, and stayed strong. It is a quiet act of revision. Instead of worshipping the husband who lied and reported on everyone, she honors the wife whose story was never told. That choice is the whole novel in one gesture.

The parts that strain, and the parts that hold

I want to be honest about what dragged. The middle of this book is a long run of one horror after another, and after a while the beatings, the rapes, and the dead children begin to feel like a catalog rather than a story. Tan keeps the prose controlled and the scenes short, which is a strength in small doses but wears on you over a hundred pages. Wen Fu is also written as close to pure evil, a coward and a womanizer with almost no redeeming dimension, and the book loses a little complexity because of it. The convenient timing of his death, Helen's fake illness, and the near miraculous last escape all make the ending feel arranged.

There is a real question about whether the mother-daughter story gets crowded out. The book is so busy proving how much Winnie endured that Pearl, who opens the novel, spends much of it offstage. When she comes back at the end, her illness is dealt with in a few pages, and I wanted more time with her own fear and anger. This is a complaint about emphasis, not about the writing, which is clean and exact throughout. Tan has a gift for the sentence that states a hard thing without decorating it.

What holds it together is the idea in the title. The Kitchen God of the legend is a liar who reports to heaven on human behavior, and his wife is the one who suffered through his life and got nothing for it. Winnie refuses to let that story stand. She takes the altar Pearl inherits and renames the figure on it, turning a symbol of a woman's silence into a symbol of a woman who survived and chose to speak. Mother-daughter friction, the weight of old secrets, the damage of war and marriage, all of it feeds into that one act. The book is about a woman deciding that her story deserves a place on the altar too.

I would hand this to a reader who liked The Joy Luck Club and wanted the harder version of it, or to anyone interested in how immigrant families pass love and fear down without ever saying which is which. I would be careful with a reader who wants a gentle story about culture and food. There is plenty of food in these pages, but it is served in a house where somebody is always waiting for the other shoe to fall. That tension is the point, and Tan never lets you forget it, even when the kitchen is finally quiet.

FAQ

Is The Kitchen God's Wife a sequel to The Joy Luck Club?

No. Published in 1991, it is Amy Tan's second novel and stands on its own, though it returns to the mother-daughter relationships and Chinese-American identity that made her first book well known.

Who is the Kitchen God's wife in the novel?

The Kitchen God of the legend is a dishonest husband who reports to the Jade Emperor on human behavior. At the end, Winnie replaces his picture with a nameless goddess she names Lady Sorrowfree, honoring the wife who endured his life and got no credit.

What is the secret Winnie has kept from Pearl?

Winnie suspects that Pearl's biological father is Wen Fu, the abusive first husband she escaped, not Jimmy Louie, the man Pearl grew up calling father. She leaves China while pregnant, and Pearl is born less than nine months later.