Cover of Manhattan Beach by Jennifer Egan

Manhattan Beach

2,251-word summary 10 min read 438 pages in the book

First published
2017
Publisher
Scribner
Pages
438
ISBN
9781476716732
Reading options
What's inside (10 sections)
  1. A visit to the Styles house
  2. The father who left
  3. Becoming a diver
  4. Dexter Styles
  5. Lydia at the beach
  6. What really happened to Eddie
  7. The ending
  8. What to make of it
  9. Key takeaways
  10. FAQ

I picked this one up because Egan's A Visit from the Goon Squad had impressed me with its formal tricks, and I wanted to see what she would do with a straight historical novel. Manhattan Beach came out in 2017, published in the United States by Scribner, and the first edition runs 438 pages (ISBN 9781476716732). It is set in Brooklyn from the Depression into the second world war, and it follows a girl named Anna Kerrigan who grows up to become the first female diver at the Brooklyn Navy Yard. It is quieter than Goon Squad and far more conventional in shape, but it has an undertow that kept me thinking about it after I closed the book.

A visit to the Styles house

The novel opens in late 1934 with eleven-year-old Anna accompanying her father Eddie to the home of Dexter Styles, a gangster who lives in a mansion on the shore of Manhattan Beach in Brooklyn. Eddie was once a vaudeville performer, then a stockbroker during the roaring twenties, and the Depression ruined him. Now he works for almost nothing as a bagman for a corrupt union official named Dunellen, an old friend. He has come to ask Styles for a job and for money, because his younger daughter Lydia is severely disabled and the family needs to buy her a wheelchair.

Anna knows none of this. Egan writes the scene through the watchfulness of a child who is trying to read the adults around her. While Eddie talks business, Anna is left with Styles' daughter and a nurse, and she walks down to the water. She puts her bare feet into the icy surf to prove to herself that she can stand it, and the cold produces a sharp, almost pleasant ache. She feels a mix of attraction and dread at the ocean's edge, and she wonders what would be exposed if all that water should suddenly vanish. Her father always joked that it would be dead bodies. That small exchange, funny and ominous at once, sets the tone for the whole book, which is about what the water hides and what it eventually gives back.

Styles notices the girl's bravado. For him it is a minor moment, one of countless small impressions in a life built on power. For the reader it lodges in memory, because the novel is built out of just such moments, the seemingly trivial details that later turn out to matter. We will return to that beach and to that man. The title itself points there, to a stretch of Brooklyn shoreline that is both an actual place and a state of mind. Egan keeps returning to the water as a way of thinking about what a person can know and what stays permanently out of reach.

The father who left

After that opening, Egan jumps forward several years. Anna is now nineteen, working at the Brooklyn Navy Yard and measuring small metal parts with a micrometer, while also taking classes at Brooklyn College. Eddie is gone. He left the apartment on an ordinary day and never came back, and Anna could not even recall which day it was. The truth arrived gradually, like nightfall. She supports her mother and Lydia with her Navy Yard wages. Her mother pours everything into Lydia, who has turned almost entirely inward, watching the world around her but not speaking or moving, and Anna loves her sister with a fierce, doomed tenderness that Egan evokes with painful realism.

Egan fills in the earlier years in pieces. At fourteen Anna lost her virginity to a neighborhood boy named Leon in their building's cellar, meeting him secretly and keeping it from her father. These scenes are frank and unsentimental. They show a girl who is hungry for experience and who understands, even young, that her family's needs come before her own. The apartment is modest, the Irish heritage sits in the background, and the sense of a household holding itself together by sheer will is one of the book's quiet strengths. It is the kind of domestic portrait Egan is very good at, where a single gesture can carry more weight than a page of explanation.

The mystery of Eddie's disappearance hangs over everything. Anna believes he left because he could not bear Lydia's disability, and that belief shapes how she reads the world and the men in it. Egan is interested in how a single missing fact can reorder a life, and in how the stories we tell ourselves to get by are often partial or flatly wrong. The novel keeps circling that gap. Structurally, she handles this by shifting the close third person among Anna, Eddie, and Dexter, letting us shadow each character's inner life in turn. That mobility is a reminder that nobody in the book possesses the whole story. Anna's mother, too, is a figure of quiet damage, a woman who has poured herself into caring for Lydia and has almost nothing left for the daughter who is still there. Egan does not judge her. She simply shows what a family can become when one member consumes all the available attention.

Becoming a diver

The chapters at the Navy Yard are the book at its best. Anna sees a professional diver at work and decides she wants to do that kind of job. She pushes her way into the training despite the objections of Axel, the diving officer, and becomes the first woman diver at the Yard. It is important to be honest about the history here. There were no women divers at the Brooklyn Navy Yard during the war, and Egan has acknowledged as much. She wanted Anna down in the water anyway, and she prepared by meeting Andrea Motley Crabtree, the first woman diver in the US Army, and even struggling into a standard Mark V diving suit with its heavy brass helmet and lead boots. She also talked with a machinist who had worked at the Yard during the war. That research shows on the page.

The diving passages are the most physical writing in the book. The suit weighs around two hundred pounds. Every movement is slow and deliberate, and Anna works on underwater repairs to the hulls of warships. Egan describes the work with a tactile clarity that makes you feel the weight and the cold and the confined vision through the helmet glass. Diving delivers Anna to a place that seems to sit outside ordinary life, as if she had pushed through a wall and found a hidden chamber just beyond it. It is also the one arena where the men around her cannot dismiss her, because the suit and the rope and the water do not care that she is a woman. Watching her win that small, hard-won authority is the real thrill of the novel, and it lands because Egan never cheapens it with a speech.

Dexter Styles

Anna's search for her father leads her back to Dexter Styles. She accompanies a coworker to one of Styles' nightclubs, and there she recognizes the man from the beach years before. He has married into New York society and risen to be a crime boss with a string of clubs, and he is a far more complicated figure than the gangster of genre fiction. Egan writes him in close third person, showing a man driven to define himself against his father and acutely aware of how power can rearrange a person's place in the world. He is charming, polygamous in his private habits, and quietly ruthless when crossed.

Anna hides that she is a Kerrigan. She lets Styles see her as a woman rather than as Eddie's daughter, and she probes him gently for information about her missing father. What begins as calculation turns into a one-night stand. Egan handles the affair with the same cool honesty she brought to Anna's teenage encounters. There is attraction, there is risk, and there is the unequal power of a world-weary man and a young woman who is using what she has. Anna is not presented as a victim, but she is not entirely in control either, and the book does not flatter her about it. That refusal to soften her is part of what makes her such a compelling heroine.

The nightclub world itself is rendered with real attention to the period, from the clothes to the music to the way money changes hands. Egan clearly enjoyed writing Styles, and his chapters have a velocity that Anna's more restrained sections sometimes lack. This is also where the book most obviously flirts with the trappings of noir, for better and for worse.

Lydia at the beach

The strangest and most affecting scene comes when Anna asks Styles to take Lydia to the beach. The sister who never speaks or moves briefly wakes up there and says something. It is a small, flooded moment, written in a kind of musical fragmentation, and it changes both Anna and Styles. For Anna it is a glimpse of the person her sister might have been if the world had treated her differently. For Styles it cracks something in a man who has built his life on keeping feeling at a distance. Egan risks making the scene mystical, and it largely works because she has earned it through all the quiet caretaking that came before.

This is also where the novel's interest in the limits of language comes into focus. Egan writes about how hard it is to truly know another person, and how a single moment of recognition can rearrange everything you thought you understood. The ocean both hides and reveals, and Lydia's few words function like something surfacing from deep water. It is the sort of scene that a less careful writer would milk, but Egan keeps it brief and lets the reader do the work.

What really happened to Eddie

Egan withholds the full story of Eddie's disappearance until late in the book, and this is the choice that divides readers. We rejoin him as a third mate on a cargo ship called the Elizabeth Seaman, and in his chapters we learn what drove him out of Brooklyn and what the war has made of him. He had to leave to save his family, and the life he has built since is both smaller and stranger than the one Anna has imagined for all those years. The sections are expository in a way the earlier chapters are not, and by the time they arrive the narrative has lost some of the urgency that carried Anna through the Navy Yard. I felt that drag in the final third. Still, the reveal recontextualizes Anna's lifelong assumption about why her father left, and it is satisfying to have the missing fact finally put in place.

The ending

Styles ends up dead, killed in the violent world he moved through, and Anna is pregnant by him. She relocates to San Francisco and reconnects with her father. The ending resolves the outer plot but stays true to the book's interest in partial knowledge. Anna gets her father back, but not the father she constructed in her head, and she carries a child that binds her to the man who may have known the truth all along. Egan does not tie everything into a neat bow, and the ambiguity feels appropriate. The last pages read less like a verdict than a slow surfacing, which is the right note for a novel so taken with the sea.

What to make of it

Critics were split, and I understand both reactions. The Guardian called it a work of remarkable cinematic scope and praised Egan's social realism and her portrait of a woman whose will is larger than her circumstances. Vulture complained that she piled on artifice and leaned too hard on cinema clichés in the gangster scenes, and that the historical authenticity felt strained. Entertainment Weekly said the book tried to be too many novels at once, part gangster noir, part war romance, part immigrant tale, and part story of the sea. There is some truth on both sides. The gangster material can feel borrowed, and the late reveal is handled more like an explanation than a discovery. But the diving chapters and the portrait of Lydia are fine enough to justify the book on their own.

The book did not go unnoticed. It was named to the 2017 National Book Award longlist in fiction, and Time magazine put it among its ten best novels of that year. Those honors make sense given the ambition on display, even if the execution is uneven. If you liked the formal play of Goon Squad, be prepared for something more traditional. This is a historical novel with a crime story braided into it, and it asks for patience with a slow burn. It is not for readers who want a tidy, propulsive mystery. It is for people willing to stand in the cold water for a while and see what comes up. The 438-page Scribner edition is substantial, but the density is in the accumulated details rather than in the sheer length. Give it time, and the things that seemed like digressions start to connect. By the end, the girl who dipped her feet in the surf at eleven has become a woman who goes down into the dark deliberately, and that arc is the quiet achievement the book is really about.

FAQ

Is Manhattan Beach based on a true story?

No. It is historical fiction. Egan made Anna a Navy Yard diver even though no women held that job there during the war, and she researched the details with real divers and a former Yard machinist.

Do I need to read A Visit from the Goon Squad first?

No. The two books are unrelated in plot and share only their author. Manhattan Beach is a conventional historical novel rather than an experimental one.

Is Manhattan Beach part of a series or does it have a sequel?

No. It is a standalone novel with no series and no announced sequel.