Corelli's Mandolin
2,247-word summary 10 min read 544 pages in the book
- First published
- 1994
- Publisher
- Secker & Warburg
- Pages
- 544
- ISBN
- 9780436201585
- Original title
- Captain Corelli's Mandolin
Reading options
What's inside (10 sections)
What I expected
I picked this up because it kept turning up in lists of books people loved, and because the title promised something small and intimate. What I found was a novel that refuses to stay small. It begins with a doctor on a Greek island and ends with firing squads, political purges, and a man holding a mandolin in a room several decades later. Louis de Bernières published it in 1994, and the first edition runs to 544 pages. That length is not padding exactly, but it is restless. The book keeps stepping away from the story you think you are reading to tell you about somebody else, then comes back to it. Some of those detours are the best things in the book. Others are the reason it took me a while to finish.
The doctor and his daughter
Dr Iannis lives on Cephalonia with his daughter Pelagia. He is the island's physician, a widower, and a man who has appointed himself its unofficial historian. He is always writing: notes on cases, observations on the weather, a private history of the place and its people. He is a rationalist with a dry, argumentative turn of mind, and much of his energy goes into debates with Father Arsenios about God, science, and which of the two has the better claim on the truth. Iannis is funny in a way that older men in novels often are not. His certainty is genuine, and so is his kindness, and the two never quite cancel each other out.
Pelagia learned medicine by watching her father work. She is not a doctor in any official sense, but she can set a bone, judge a fever, and help him with patients who arrive at the house at all hours. She is engaged to Mandras, a young fisherman, and when war comes in 1940 he goes off to fight the Italians in Albania. At first the letters arrive. Then they stop. Pelagia keeps working and keeps waiting, and the waiting becomes its own kind of life.
One of the quieter achievements of the opening chapters is the way de Bernières handles those letters. Mandras is not a man of many words on paper, and he has a literate comrade writing home for him. The comrade puts more of himself into the letters than Mandras would recognize, so that the words Pelagia treasured were partly written by a man she had never met. It is a neat, slightly cruel idea, and it quietly undermines the whole romantic setup before the real rival has even appeared on the island.
The island itself is almost a character. de Bernières gives us its harbors, its steep roads, the heat of the summer and the confinement of the winters, and the way everyone knows everyone else's business. That closeness is what makes the occupation so claustrophobic. There is nowhere to hide a secret in a place where a new face is noticed within the hour, and the doctor's house, with its patients coming and going, is a kind of public square. Iannis's history of Cephalonia is more than a hobby. He is trying to fix the place in words before someone else fixes it in blood, and his stubborn, fussy prose is one of the novel's quieter pleasures.
The captain moves in
In 1941 Italian and German troops are posted to Cephalonia, and the locals treat them with a careful, uniform coldness. The occupying officers need somewhere to billet their men, and Captain Antonio Corelli ends up installed in the doctor's house. Pelagia is determined to hate him. She has her reasons, and the novel is fair enough to let her keep them for a while.
Corelli is difficult to hate, though. He is a conscientious officer who wants, above all, to have a peaceful war. He cooks, tends the garden, repairs things, and plays his mandolin, an instrument he has named Antonia. He sings Neapolitan songs in a voice that unsettles people who have decided he is the enemy. He and Iannis talk for hours, and the doctor's guarded respect comes slowly, which makes it worth having. There is a scene in which Corelli plays for a group of islanders and the music does what politics and orders could not do: for a few minutes they stop treating him as a uniform. Pelagia's resistance thaws in the same way, by degrees, without a single grand declaration.
de Bernières is very good on the small negotiations of an occupied town. The Italians want eggs and wine and obedience; the islanders give them the minimum and take whatever they can back. Corelli's evident embarrassment at being an occupier does not absolve him, but it changes the arithmetic. People begin to ask him for favors. He plays at weddings and funerals, he listens to Iannis's long monologues, and he gradually becomes the strange officer who lives with the doctor rather than the captain of an occupying force. The change is convincing because it is incremental. Nobody declares him a friend. They simply stop closing the door when he comes past.
Running alongside this is the story of Carlo Guercio, an Italian soldier serving in Albania. Carlo is a closeted homosexual who loves a man named Francesco, and Francesco is killed by Greek troops. Carlo's grief is sensual and theatrical and unlike anything else in the book. He drifts through the war pursuing pleasure and memory, and he becomes Corelli's friend. I found these chapters striking and also a littlestrained, as though de Bernières had started a different, darker novel in the margins of this one. Carlo matters later, in a way I did not expect, but his earlier scenes sometimes feel like a detour with no signposts.
Mandras comes home
Mandras returns from the mainland changed. He has been fighting, he has been ill, and he can see that Pelagia's feelings have moved on. The man who went away to win her is back and finds that the war has made his claim on her weaker, not stronger. He leaves again, this time to join ELAS, the communist partisan organization operating on the Greek mainland.
de Bernières does not romanticize the partisans. His ELAS is capable of cruelty toward civilians and of attacking other resistance groups for the crime of being ideologically adjacent to the occupiers. That is an unpopular thing to say in a novel about occupation, and I respected it. Mandras gradually turns from a fisherman into a political man, and the transformation is not presented as an improvement. His mother, who has never cared much for Pelagia, grows colder and more suspicious as the months pass. The island is being pulled apart by arguments that have little to do with who liberated whom.
The armistice and the firing squad
The pivot comes in 1943, when Italy surrenders and the Germans turn on their former allies. On Cephalonia the Italian division resists and is defeated, and the German command orders mass reprisals. Officers are led out in groups and shot. de Bernières writes these scenes plainly, men queueing, men refusing blindfolds, the small negotiations over last words and cigarettes. The restraint is what makes them hard to read. There is no grandstanding here, only the terrible bookkeeping of an occupation settling a score.
Before the collapse, the novel has been careful to show how thin the Italian hold on the island actually is. The soldiers are bored and badly supplied, the officers argue among themselves, and the locals have perfected the art of doing exactly what is required and nothing more. The German arrival changes the scale of everything in a matter of days. Orders that had been abstractions become lists of names. Corelli, who has spent the war trying to minimize the harm around him, suddenly finds that his period of grace is over, and that the identity he had begun to put aside, that of the enemy officer, is the one that will decide whether he lives.
Corelli is condemned with the others. Carlo Guercio, who has survived his own war and found his way back to the island, steps in and shields Corelli with his body when the firing squad fires. Carlo dies. Corelli is wounded and left for dead, and a Greek man who has been hiding surviving Italians carries him back to Pelagia's house. From this point the novel changes temperature. The gentle occupier is now a fugitive in the basement, and every kindness shown to him puts the people who love him in danger. Pelagia and Iannis nurse him while German patrols search the neighborhood. When he is strong enough, Corelli escapes by boat to Italy. Before he goes he promises to return when the war is over, and he leaves his mandolin, Antonia, with Pelagia for safekeeping.
That instrument is the novel's central object, and de Bernières is patient with it. For hundreds of pages it sits in the house, collecting dust and meaning, long before anyone picks it up again.
The occupation that follows
The Germans leave and the communists take power. Dr Iannis, an intellectual and a freethinker, is exactly the sort of person the new order distrusts. He is sent to a camp along with several friends, who protest his treatment and are punished for it. Pelagia is left to run the house and the practice alone, and the book is good on the petty machinery of the new regime: the informers, the denunciations, the way old grudges get settled under the language of justice.
The camp scenes, when Iannis eventually returns to describe them, are intentionally flat. He does not offer a speech about suffering. He reports absurd rules, petty officials, cold, hunger, and the behavior of men who have been given a little power over other men. The friends who protested his arrest fare worse than he does, and he carries their names back with him. Pelagia, meanwhile, has to learn to run a household and a medical practice under a system that regards her father's skills with suspicion. She does it without drama, which is how the book earns the respect it asks for her.
Mandras comes back a third time, now literate and steeped in the new ideology. He has read Pelagia's letters from the years when she was writing to a man who could not write back properly. He knows she never loved him. What follows is an attempt to force himself on her, and then the arrival of his mother, who understands enough to repudiate her own son. Ashamed, Mandras kills himself. The whole episode is over in a handful of pages, which is both the book's strength and its weakness. It refuses to milk the moment, but it also refuses to sit with the damage it has done.
A baby girl is left on Pelagia's doorstep. She adopts the child and names her Antonia, after the mandolin. Iannis eventually comes home from the camp, shaken and altered but alive. Antonia grows up, marries, and has a son whom she names Iannis after the doctor. The years pass in a few brisk paragraphs, and the novel arrives at its last movement with the war long behind everyone who lived through it.
The last visit
Many years later Corelli returns to Cephalonia. He is now a famous mandolin player, a man whose name is printed on concert programs rather than army rosters. The meeting with Pelagia is not the sweeping romantic payoff the title might lead you to expect. de Bernières keeps it small and slightly awkward: two people in a house, a conversation with a great deal left unsaid, and an instrument that finally has a part to play again. The book will not pretend the war can be reversed or that the decades apart amount to nothing. The relationship survives as a memory and a decision rather than as a prize. I found that more moving than a passionate reunion would have been, though I understand why some readers come away wanting more warmth from the ending.
What stays, what grates
The book's biggest problem is its tone. It opens as a comedy of occupation, full of farce and eccentric locals, and then turns to mass execution without always making the shift feel earned. Carlo's chapters are lurid and occasionally feel imported from another novel. de Bernières has a weakness for the elaborate comparison that runs one beat too long, and several characters, Father Arsenios in particular, are drawn as types rather than people. The book is long, and at least two of its threads could have been trimmed without loss.
What does work is worth more than the flaws. Dr Iannis is a fine creation, a man who argues with God and with his daughter and remains stubbornly decent through two occupations. Pelagia's slow accumulation of authority is handled without fanfare. Most importantly, the novel insists on showing Italian soldiers as individuals, frightened and vain and musical and capable of decency, rather than as a faceless army. That is its moral center. The execution scene is dreadful and clean, and it lands because the book has spent hundreds of pages making you care about the men in the line.
The last thing I kept thinking about was not the reunion. It was Iannis at his desk, writing down the history of a place he knows is about to be described by other people, in other languages, with other reasons for doing it.
FAQ
Why are there two titles, Corelli's Mandolin and Captain Corelli's Mandolin?
The 1994 novel was first published in Britain as Captain Corelli's Mandolin by Secker & Warburg and released at the same time in the United States as Corelli's Mandolin. It is the same book, not a sequel or a different story.
Is Captain Corelli's Mandolin based on a true story?
The occupation of Cephalonia and the mass execution of Italian officers after the 1943 armistice are real events. Bernières has denied that Corelli was based on the Italian captain Amos Pampaloni, and Pampaloni said the novel misrepresented the Greek partisans.
What happens to the mandolin called Antonia?
Corelli leaves it with Pelagia when he escapes to Italy, and it stays in her house for the rest of the novel. It is picked up again only when he returns many years later.





























