Tara Road
2,020-word summary 9 min read 488 pages in the book
- First published
- 1998
- Publisher
- Orion
- Pages
- 488
- ISBN
- 9780752814476
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
The house on Tara Road
The novel opens with two teenage sisters, Ria and Hilary Johnson, talking about their futures. Ria is sixteen and dreams of travelling the world. Hilary is older and more practical. It is an ordinary conversation in an ordinary Dublin house, and it is the beginning of a book that is about how lives turn out differently from the ones we imagine for ourselves.
That opening conversation is worth pausing on. Hilary is practical and settled; Ria wants to go everywhere. The book does not treat the dream as foolish, and it does not make the sister who stays home the sensible one. Instead it spends four hundred pages showing how a person can travel without leaving her own street, and how another can go to America and still be living inside the same unresolved story. The swap at the center of the novel is a literal journey for both women and a figurative one for each of them.
Ria takes a job at a Dublin real-estate firm and becomes fast friends with her coworker Rosemary Ryan. Then a charismatic new colleague arrives. Danny Lynch is charming, ambitious and immediately attractive to Ria. He shows her a grand but damp and shabby old house at Number 16 Tara Road and tells her he dreams of owning it one day. His enthusiasm is contagious, and Ria adopts the dream as her own. Their first visit to Tara Road is a date they always remember: 28 December 1982.
Maeve Binchy published this in 1998, and it became an Oprah's Book Club selection the following year. It was adapted into a 2005 film starring Andie MacDowell and Olivia Williams, with Binchy herself making a cameo appearance at Colm's restaurant. The novel is long, warm and densely populated, and it belongs to the kind of fiction that treats a neighborhood as a character. Tara Road is not just a street. It is a system of relationships that the plot will test and rearrange.
The marriage
Danny secretly undercuts his own employer. He approaches the property mogul Barney McCarthy directly with ideas for selling a stalled mansion, telling Ria that he is doing it for their future together. He goes to work for McCarthy, Ria becomes pregnant, and they marry. She throws herself into renovating Number 16 Tara Road into a warm, welcoming home, known for her cooking and her company. For a while the dream works.
The renovation of Tara Road is one of the book's most affectionate passages. Ria turns a damp, decaying house into a home by cooking for people and keeping the door open. Binchy understands that a house in her fiction is never only a building. It is a record of who has been welcomed into it. Ria's talent is hospitality, and for a while it seems enough to hold a marriage together. The book is careful to show how much work she puts into that idea, and how little help she gets.
Then the cracks appear. Danny spends more and more time with Barney McCarthy and Barney's mistress Polly. Ria likes both Barney's wife Mona and Polly, which makes her feel oddly guilty about the affair. That detail is very Binchy. The betrayal is not presented as a simple matter of a bad man and a wronged woman. Ria's affection for the people around her complicates her own sense of what she is entitled to feel.
The neighborhood fills with characters. Rosemary remains Ria's closest friend. Ria's widowed mother Nora blossoms in the new environment. A recovering alcoholic restaurateur named Colm becomes part of the street's life. Ria and Danny have two children, Annie and the tactless Brian. The book spends a great deal of time on these people, and the time is not wasted. When the central crisis arrives, it matters because we know who will be hurt by it.
The crisis comes when Ria proposes a third child. Danny admits that he is involved with a twenty-two-year-old woman who is pregnant and wants a divorce. The world Ria has built collapses. Everything she made, the house and the family and the neighborhood, was constructed around a marriage that was not what she thought it was.
The swap
Through a chance phone call about a house swap, Ria connects with Marilyn Vine, an independent, private, career-centred American woman living in a New England college town. Marilyn is separated from her husband Greg and has never come to terms with the death of her only son. The two women, who have never met, agree to exchange homes for the summer. Ria goes to America hoping for distance and courage. Marilyn goes to Ireland to recover in quiet, not realizing that Tara Road will be the least quiet place on earth.
Each woman carries a deep secret she believes can never be revealed to the other. That is the structure of the book. Two women live inside each other's lives, and each learns the truth about the other's pain without being able to speak about it directly. It is a clever device for a novel about friendship, because it makes intimacy possible before trust exists. They are, quite literally, inside each other's houses.
In Connecticut, Ria discovers a latent talent for hostessing and catering. She entertains half the neighborhood, finds a sense of community she never had in Dublin, and begins to see herself as a person apart from Danny. She is drawn into Marilyn's world, including Greg's visiting brother Andy. The American sections give the book a second setting with its own rules, and Ria's arrival there is a kind of rehearsal for the life she might build after the divorce.
In Dublin, the reserved Marilyn is first exhausted and irritated by the constant visitors. She slowly opens up. She gardens, befriends Colm the handsome restaurateur, and grows close to Ria's children Annie and Brian, helping them with their problems. Living inside Ria's abandoned life forces Marilyn finally to face the grief she has suppressed for a year and a half. She weeps, and begins to heal.
Marilyn's story is the darker of the two. Her only son is dead, her marriage is over, and she has made a life out of keeping people at a distance. The New England college town she lives in is described as orderly and quiet, which is exactly what she wants it to be. When she arrives in Dublin she is overwhelmed by the noise and the constant arrival of visitors. The book is very good on the way grief makes a person defensive. Marilyn's irritation is not snobbery. It is the reflex of someone who has learned that letting people close means having more to lose.
Colm is important here. The recovering alcoholic restaurateur is one of the warmest figures in the novel, and his friendship with Marilyn gives her a way back into the world without demanding that she explain herself. Their relationship is handled delicately. It is not a new romance so much as a reacquaintance with the idea that another person's company can be pleasant. Ria's children Annie and Brian also draw her out. Brian, who is tactless, has a way of saying what others are thinking, and Marilyn finds herself answering him honestly.
What they learn
At first each woman resents hearing how well the other is doing. Ria is irritated that Marilyn has bonded with her children and with Colm. Marilyn is irritated by Ria's social whirl. The resentment is small and human, and it turns gradually into understanding. They are not competing, exactly. They are each seeing a version of the life they might have had, and it takes time to accept that the other person's happiness is not a judgment on their own.
The secrets come out. Marilyn learns of Danny's betrayal, and Ria learns about Marilyn's dead son. Rather than destroying them, the knowledge deepens the bond. That is the book's central argument about friendship. The thing you fear will make you unbearable to another person is often the thing that makes you legible to them. Ria slowly reclaims her self-worth and realizes she does not need Danny to validate her. Marilyn prepares to return to America able to feel joy again.
At summer's end the two women finally meet face to face. They discover that they have altered the course of each other's lives and have become firm, permanent friends. It is a deeply satisfying ending, and it is earned by the patient accumulation of small scenes. Nothing is resolved by a coincidence or a sudden revelation. The women change because they spend a summer living in each other's circumstances.
The book's methods
Binchy is a master of the ensemble. There are dozens of characters here, and almost all of them are given a speech pattern, a want and a place in the neighborhood. Rosemary, Nora, Colm, Mona, Polly, Barney, Annie and Brian are not functions of the plot. They are the reason the plot has weight. When Ria's marriage fails, it fails in front of people who will have to keep living with her, and that is a different kind of consequence from the isolated disaster of a more solitary novel.
The prose is plain and conversational. Binchy does not reach for lyricism, and she is not interested in the kind of irony that keeps a reader at a distance. The book asks you to care about these people, and it does not apologize for asking. That directness was sometimes dismissed as sentimentality, but it is a deliberate choice. A novel about a woman rebuilding her life after betrayal needs to believe that ordinary kindness matters.
The parallel structure is handled cleanly. The chapters alternate between Dublin and New England, and the two threads comment on each other. Ria's social abundance is set against Marilyn's isolation. Marilyn's reserve is set against Ria's openness. Each woman begins as the opposite of what the other needs, and by the end each has borrowed something from the other. It is a tidy design, but the characters are specific enough that it never feels mechanical.
Where it strains
The book is long, and the neighborhood material sometimes slows the main story. There are subplots here that could have been trimmed without losing anything essential, particularly the details of Barney McCarthy's business dealings. The character of Danny is also drawn too broadly. He is charming and manipulative in equal measure, and the book never quite explains how Ria, who is intelligent and observant, failed to see him clearly. The twenty-two-year-old woman he impregnates is barely a person, which weakens the moral complexity of the affair.
There is also a question about the title's location. Some retellings and the film give the restaurateur a different surname from the BookRags summary I consulted, and the exact name is not important to the story. What matters is that Tara Road is a place where people notice what happens to each other. That is the book's real subject, and it is handled with a generosity that is rare.
The novel was an Oprah's Book Club selection in September 1999, which tells you something about its reach. It is a book built for discussion: two women, two houses, two griefs, and the question of what a friendship can do when it is formed in the dark. The 2005 film, with Andie MacDowell and Olivia Williams, simplified some of the neighborhood material, but it understood the central device. Binchy's cameo at Colm's restaurant is a nice piece of self-placement in a book that is so invested in the idea that ordinary places matter.
I finished it feeling that I had spent a summer in a place I would remember. That is the particular achievement of Binchy's fiction. The plot resolves, the women are changed, and the neighborhood goes on. The last meeting between Ria and Marilyn is quiet, with no grand statement about friendship. They simply sit together, having already done the thing that matters. After four hundred pages, that restraint feels exactly right.
FAQ
Is Tara Road based on a true story?
No. It is a work of fiction by Maeve Binchy, though its Dublin neighborhood and the details of domestic life were drawn from the kind of close observation she was known for.
Was Tara Road made into a film?
Yes. A 2005 adaptation starred Andie MacDowell and Olivia Williams, and Binchy herself appeared in a cameo at Colm's restaurant.
What is the house swap in the novel?
Ria and Marilyn, who have never met, exchange homes for the summer. Ria goes to New England to find courage, and Marilyn goes to Dublin to grieve in quiet, which Tara Road makes impossible.





























