Cover of Our Wives Under the Sea by Julia Armfield

Our Wives Under the Sea

2,286-word summary 10 min read 240 pages in the book

First published
2022
Publisher
Picador
Pages
240
ISBN
9781529017229
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. The wife who came home and stayed in the bath
  2. Six months with the lights off
  3. The Centre, the counsellor, and the internet
  4. When the body stops keeping its promises
  5. What Miri does at the water's edge
  6. The parts that did not sit right
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

The wife who came home and stayed in the bath

I picked this up because someone told me it was a ghost story in which the ghost is still technically alive, and at the time that sounded like exactly the kind of trouble I wanted. Julia Armfield's first novel came out in 2022 with Picador and runs to about 240 pages. It is a short book that reads much longer, the way a bad night does. It is about a marriage, a submarine, and a body that cannot be persuaded to hold one shape.

The first line has stayed with me:

The deep sea is a haunted house: a place in which things that ought not to exist move about in the darkness.

That is the book in a sentence, though Armfield spends the rest of it showing that the haunted house can also be a flat in England with a dripping tap and a bathtub that is never empty.

The wives are Miri and Leah. Miri writes grant applications for nonprofit groups and narrates the parts of the story that happen after Leah returns. Leah is a marine researcher working for an organisation called the Centre, and her chapters take the form of a journal kept during the dive that went badly wrong. Leah was meant to be away for three weeks. She was gone for six months. When the Centre finally sends her home, it offers almost nothing by way of explanation, and Miri has to build a routine around a wife who is in the room and steadily leaving it.

I want to be careful about describing what follows, because the nastiness here is in how ordinary it is. Leah does not grow a roar or a set of teeth. She becomes quiet, then she starts using the bath, then she never leaves it. Her gums bleed. She gets nosebleeds. She moves food around a plate and eventually stops eating and asks for salt stirred into water. Her skin takes on a wet, pearly cast, as though she has been underwater a very long time, which in a sense she has.

What unsettled me most was not the body horror but the manners of it. Miri keeps making cups of tea. She keeps asking, gently, whether Leah wants to go to the doctor. Leah keeps saying no. Two people who clearly love each other spend entire chapters failing to say the one thing that matters, and the silence between them gets heavier than anything waiting outside the submarine.

Six months with the lights off

Leah's half of the book is the dive. She goes down in a small submarine with two colleagues: Jelka, a Catholic woman with a habit of talking to saints, and Matteo, a former fisherman who mostly wants the job to be over. The Centre has sent them to look at the bottom of the ocean. They descend through the sunlit and twilight layers, into the midnight and abyssal dark, and then something gives. Communication with the surface cuts out. The submarine is still supplied with air and filtered water, but it can no longer be steered, and it keeps sinking until it settles somewhere it should not be able to settle.

What follows is a long exercise in waiting. There is food, there is oxygen, there is no way home and no one to tell them when they will be. Days stop separating from one another. Leah tries to keep a record, but time goes soft at the edges, and her journal becomes less a log of research than a place to put the things she cannot say out loud. She had hoped to discover something. Instead she finds that her memories of Miri are thinning out, and that the sea outside the hull is the only thing that still feels solid.

Jelka fares worse. She begins to hear a voice that the others cannot hear, and she takes to standing under the shower in her clothes, as if water might drown out whatever is speaking. Matteo's patience wears down into anger. Leah tries to keep the peace, but her attention keeps drifting back to the darkness beyond the glass, and to the possibility that it is not empty. The book never confirms what they heard. It lets the doubt do the work, which is the right call. The reader sits in the same dark as the crew, with the same useless store of facts.

Then, near the end of Leah's account, two things happen quickly. Jelka slips into the antechamber and opens the outer hatch, and the sea comes in with the force it has been holding back the whole book. After that the power returns, inexplicably, and Matteo wants nothing more than to take them up. Leah insists on turning on the exterior lights first. She sees an eye as large as the submarine windows, and something enormous moving past it. In a moment that is faintly ridiculous and very sad, she writes her name on a piece of paper and holds it up to the glass. She wants the thing to know who she is. The submarine rises. All she can think about is getting back to Miri.

The Centre, the counsellor, and the internet

Miri's chapters happen on land, and they are in some ways the harder reading. While Leah was missing, Miri called the Centre again and again and got the same smooth reassurances. No one would tell her where the submarine was or whether the crew was alive. Then the number was disconnected and the website disappeared. Armfield has said that part of the horror came from the clanging bureaucracy of not being able to get an answer, and you can feel it in these pages. The fear is not only for Leah. It is the small, daily hassle of being told to wait by people who know more than they are saying.

Once Leah is home, the Centre recommends couples counselling. Miri drags herself and Leah to a session with a therapist who is, in Miri's words, tall and straight both in the sense of her sexuality and in the sense of her everything else. The session cannot really happen because Leah cannot get out of the bath long enough to attend. It is a funny line and a bleak one, and the book is full of that mixture. There is humour in Miri's voice, but it is the dry kind that comes from having nowhere else to put things.

Miri also goes looking for company online, reading threads from people who have lost someone. One post stays with her: that the hardest part of grief is not the loss itself but accepting the aftermath, the fact that the person is gone and the world has carried on anyway. I found that line almost too direct, and then realised it is the exact problem Miri is living. Leah has not died in any way a doctor would recognise, but Miri is being asked to grieve her anyway, to release a woman who is still breathing in the next room.

Two other people steady the book. There is Carmen, a friend who drops in and says ordinary things. There is Juna, the sister of Jelka, who calls Miri after Leah's return. Juna knew someone who went down in that submarine and did not come back the way Leah did, or did not come back at all. Miri cannot bear to hear what happened to Jelka and walks out of the coffee shop. Her avoidance is not written as a flaw to be corrected. It reads as the only thing she can do that day.

Running underneath all of this is Miri's mother, who died after an illness that changed her in ways Miri still cannot wholly forgive or forget. Miri has not been able to sell the house by the sea. She remembers her mother's body, the neighbour's television voices coming through the wall, the strange, unwelcome intimacy of caring for someone who is partly gone already. Armfield keeps folding that old grief into the new one, and the effect is less a theme than a repeated physical sensation. Miri has done this before. She knows how it ends, and knowing does not help.

When the body stops keeping its promises

The middle of the book is where the transformation gets difficult to watch. Leah starts vomiting saltwater. Layers of skin come away in the bath and collect in a ring around the tub. She loses sensation in parts of herself. She cannot breathe properly out of the water, so Miri keeps the bathroom steamy and the taps running, and learns to live with the sound. The flat begins to feel like an extension of the submarine, a small sealed place with a hostile environment pressing on all sides.

Then comes the moment I keep thinking about. Miri comes home and Leah turns a corner, and one of her eyes simply gives way, the socket running with seawater. There is no scream, no music, no authorial nudge telling us what it means. Armfield just puts it on the page and lets Miri keep moving. I read that scene twice, once in disbelief and once to see how it was done, and both times the plainness of the sentence was what got me.

After that Miri calls Juna, who comes immediately. Together they wrap Leah in towels soaked in saltwater and drive her to Miri's mother's house by the coast. The drive is handled in a few lines, which is a good decision. Anything longer would have tipped the book toward procedure and away from the thing it is actually about, which is a woman carrying her wife toward the water and not knowing whether she is saving her or saying goodbye.

What Miri does at the water's edge

The ending is the part I have argued about with myself since finishing. Juna tells Miri what she already knows: that holding on is a kind of refusal, and that Leah is not going to be the person she married again. Miri takes Leah into the sea and lets her go. Leah, or what is left of her, looks back once with the one eye she still has, and then she is gone, dissolving through Miri's fingers into the water. The last pages are quiet. There is no last-minute rescue and no explanation of the creature, no file marked declassified, no answer to what the Centre was doing. The book ends where grief ends, which is not anywhere comfortable.

It put me in mind of Orpheus, and I was glad to see that Aida Edemariam made the same connection in her review, because the shape is there even if Armfield never names it. A wife goes down where the living cannot follow, and comes back, and the other wife has to decide whether to look. Armfield has also said the book grew out of an interest in the crossover between queer women's fiction and the sea, and it shows in how unselfconscious the marriage is. No one in this book has to explain why these two women matter to each other. The ordinary texture of their life together, the films and the tea and the bad jokes, is doing more plot work than any reveal about the monster.

That is also, I think, where the book is most itself. Armfield opens with epigraphs from Moby-Dick and Jaws and fills the chapters with references to The Fly and Shivers, but she is not writing a creature feature. The monster is never the point. What Leah becomes is a way of making Miri's situation physical, and the horror lands because the marriage was real first. Near the end Leah remembers Miri saying that every horror movie ends the way you know it will. The book knows it too, and goes there anyway, which takes a certain nerve.

The parts that did not sit right

I should be honest about the things that frustrated me. The Centre is deliberately vague, and I accept that the vagueness is the point, but there are moments when it feels less like a mystery than a handed-in plot device. A shadowy organisation that never explains itself is a very convenient villain, and the book leans on it more than once. I also think there is a stretch in the middle where Miri's online grief forums and the neighbour's television voices start to feel like homework, as though Armfield is checking off the research she did rather than letting the story breathe.

The ending's logic is emotional rather than literal, and readers who want to know what Leah saw in the deep will not get a straight answer. I happen to think that is the right choice for this book, since the deep is doing the work of everything that cannot be brought back up, but I can see why it would irritate someone who wanted a cleaner resolution. The book was awarded the 2023 Polari Book Prize, and it is easy to see why it was celebrated, but it is not a book that rewards a search for neat meanings.

What I keep coming back to, though, is the bath. Armfield understands that grief is often a matter of routines you cannot stop performing, of asking someone if they want tea when what you mean is please stay. Long after the sea and the submarine had faded from my mind, I could still see Miri standing in a steamy bathroom, talking to a wife who was no longer able to answer. That image is the book. Everything else is just water.

FAQ

Is Our Wives Under the Sea a horror novel or a romance?

It is both. Julia Armfield alternates between body horror and the ordinary texture of a marriage, and the romance is what makes the horror hurt.

Who are Miri and Leah, and what happens to them?

Miri writes grant applications and waits at home; Leah is the marine researcher whose deep-sea dive strands her for six months. The chapters alternate between their two perspectives.

Does the book explain what Leah saw in the ocean?

No. Armfield leaves the creature and the Centre's motives unexplained, so readers looking for a concrete answer to the mystery will be disappointed.