The Golden Enclaves
2,564-word summary 11 min read 416 pages in the book
- First published
- 2022
- Publisher
- Del Rey
- Pages
- 416
- ISBN
- 9780593158357
- Series
- The Scholomance (#3)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
I came to this book with a puzzle in my head. The second Scholomance novel had ended with Orion Lake shoving El Higgins out through the school gates and staying behind to face a monster, and I could not see how a third book was going to follow that without undoing it. Del Rey published The Golden Enclaves on September 27, 2022, and the answer Novik gives is to refuse that tidy sort of undoing. This 416 page hardcover picks up in the seconds after the gate closes, and it spends most of its length asking what it would cost to put a person back together when the whole world has been built on a lie. It closes the trilogy, and it is stranger and angrier than I expected.
A grief that cannot be mourned
The opening is deliberately grim. El lands in a clearing in Wales, where her mother Gwen waits, and she immediately tries every spell she knows to get back inside the school. Nothing works. Her classmates broke the Scholomance off from the real world and cast it into the void, a formless place outside reality, and the girl she loves is sealed inside it with Patience, a colossal maw-mouth. A maw-mouth is not a monster that kills you and finishes. It swallows wizards and keeps them conscious, devouring them forever, so El cannot even tell herself Orion is dead. She spends days unable to move, stuck in the particular misery of someone who has lost a person and has no permission to grieve.
What loosened that grief for me was the book's insistence on its own machinery. Novik's world runs on rules about mana, the energy a wizard draws from the world around them, and malia, the stolen life force that produces the creatures called maleficaria. Enclaves are the wealthy wizard families' answer to the mals, sheltered pocket dimensions where children grow up safe. El carries a copy of the Golden Stone sutras, an ancient Sanskrit text about building enclaves that run on clean mana rather than stolen lives. It is the thing her parents dreamed of, a world where no child has to be sacrificed for safety. When Gwen sees the sutras in El's hands, she breaks down and tells the truth she had kept back.
Gwen and El's father, Arjun Sharma, stole the sutras out of the Scholomance when they were students. They left the payment open, with no limit written into the bargain, and the universe collected across the years that followed. Arjun was consumed by a maw-mouth. Gwen escaped alone and pregnant. El was born carrying a destructive power she never asked for and a prophecy of doom attached to her name. It is a hard scene, and it made me angry on El's behalf in exactly the way the book wants. She is furious too, and she tells her mother to leave her alone. The prophecy that has shadowed her whole life turns out to be a debt notice.
London, and a monster that should not be there
Liesel arrives at the Welsh commune with news that pulls El out of herself. Liesel was the Scholomance valedictorian and is now a new member of the London enclave, and she says London is under attack and not likely to survive. A maw-mouth has broken through the damaged wards. El is, as far as anyone knows, the only wizard alive who can kill one of these things on her own, so she goes. An enclave wizard named Alfie swears a magical oath to repay her and helps bring her in.
London is a wonder to her and a rebuke at the same time. The enclave has gardens that look like something out of a storybook, green and safe and beautiful in the middle of a country that has no room for such things. El understands what that beauty costs, because she knows where malia comes from. She hunts the maw-mouth and, in a flash of rage, invents a killing spell that disintegrates it on the spot. It works better than anything she has done before, and it terrifies the enclave council, who suddenly have a weapon they cannot control in their gardens. She names her price: the gardens open to independent wizards during business hours, so people who live outside the enclaves have somewhere safe to stand.
The council agrees, then tries to trap her with a compulsion spell. Christopher Martel, the Dominus of London, attempts to enchant her, and this is where the book shows its political teeth. El is not the sort of heroine who accepts a seat at the table in exchange for being useful. She escapes through the forgotten half-real spaces underneath the enclave with Yancy, a rogue wizard whose crew lives in the discarded remnants of old magic. Yancy explains how abandoned places persist in the void, and El has the realization that changes the shape of the whole novel. If the void still holds things that were cast out of the world, then the Scholomance may still be reachable. Orion may not be gone.
New York, and the doors in Portugal
That hope sends El and her friends to New York City, where Chloe arranges a meeting with Orion's parents, Balthasar and Ophelia Lake. Balthasar is an artificer who makes magical devices, and he assumes El has come angling for an enclave seat. El loses her temper with him, because she has come for one reason only: to kill the monster inside his son and end the suffering of everyone it holds. Balthasar is undone by this, stunned that someone loved his boy so plainly. The warmth of that moment is immediately soured by the mother.
Ophelia is a maleficer, a wizard who deliberately destroyed her own capacity for clean mana so she could work entirely in stolen life force. El sees it in an instant. Novik is very good at this kind of recognition scene, where a person's whole moral character is read off the way they handle power. Ophelia offers help anyway, because helping serves her. She gives El a power sharer tied to New York's mana store and the coordinates of the Scholomance doors in Sintra, Portugal. El takes the box because it is the only road back to Orion, and she knows the price is written into the gift.
At Sintra the school is cold, silent and crumbling. Every mal that used to be trapped inside is gone. In the gymnasium they find Orion sitting in a pavilion, apparently whole, but when he sees them he advances with the blank calculation of a predator. El holds up a pry bar and tests her shield against him, and his touch against it feels exactly like a maw-mouth probing for a way in. He stops when she threatens him, and then, haltingly, says her name. They use an obfuscation pendant to lead him out and fly him back to Wales. Gwen takes him to an ancient roundhouse deep in the forest, sheltered by a huge yew tree, and spends a night pouring healing into him. The light exhausts the yew and nearly kills Gwen. When Orion comes out he is himself again, but shattered. Gwen tells El she could not heal him, only give him hope. Whatever Ophelia did to him is part of him now.
Beijing and the secret under every enclave
The middle of this book is a sequence of crises in different cities, and the one in Beijing is the worst. Liu, another of El's friends from the school, is trapped under a compulsion of secrecy tied to spells her family received from the Beijing enclave. El and Orion fly there and find Liu strapped inside a metal cylinder, being slowly pressed down to become the enclave's new foundation. This is the secret the novel has been circling, and Novik delivers it without softening the horror. An enclave is founded by crushing a living wizard into a maw-mouth and using it as an anchor point in the void. Every safe, beautiful garden in the series rests on one of these.
El turns the council members to stone, tears down the wall hiding the wider assembly of contributing wizards, and performs the Golden Stone foundation casting while the enclave teeters on collapse. Liu is pulled out alive. When the exhausted El is attacked, Orion intervenes, and the attackers simply vanish into him. At the airport he tells her what that means. He has never killed a mal. He has devoured them, absorbing everything they were, the way a maw-mouth does. Ophelia fused a maw-mouth into him when he was an infant, making him a wizard with a direct line to the void who could eat mals and channel stolen mana back to New York. He swallowed Patience and all the centuries of people inside it. He asks El to let him go to his mother, the one person who might undo what she did, and kisses her goodbye.
I want to say something about how this lands, because the book is asking a hard question and does not flinch from it. Orion is both victim and weapon, and the people who love him keep being asked to treat him as a problem to solve. El's refusal to do that is the emotional spine of the novel. It is also where the plot gets tangled, because the enclave politics pile up fast. There are mana sharing arrangements, competing Dominus figures, alliances that shift between paragraphs, and a great deal of specialized vocabulary. I needed to slow down in this stretch. Novik trusts her reader to keep up, and I am not sure the trust is always rewarded.
The war at the doors
El starts saving enclaves that are under attack and slowly understands that she is causing the attacks she is answering. Killing maw-mouths releases their prey, and the maleficaria that used to feed the maw-mouths have begun hunting wizards instead. She warns Ibrahim in Dubai, saves that enclave with the Golden Stone method, and then goes to her father's family compound outside Mumbai. There she meets her great grandmother Deepthi, the family's prophetic seer, and learns why the prophecy drove El and her mother away all those years ago. Deepthi shaped it to hide El from Ophelia, who was looking for a counterweight to the weapon she had made in Orion. Ophelia engineered the year when no Scholomance student survived graduation, sacrificing a whole class to create the thing her son became. Deepthi warns El never to return to New York.
A war breaks out at the Scholomance doors in Sintra, between the New York enclave and the Shanghai enclave with their allies. El arrives to find the estate closed to mundanes and wizards gathered from everywhere. She is pulled to the Shanghai side, where Li Shanfeng, the Dominus of Shanghai, explains his history with Ophelia. Both of them spent decades building enclaves and sending the maw-mouths they created into each other's territories, especially into countries too weak to object. Neither could stop. Now that El and Orion have destroyed most of the maleficaria, the maw-mouths have turned on wizards, and the old game has come home. Shanfeng has been waiting for El, because he believes she is the one who can kill Orion.
Ophelia arrives with Orion, intending to show him off and terrify every enclave into submission. Orion sees El and deliberately releases the hope Gwen gave him, letting the maw-mouth take over. It devours wizards in the cavern, and El throws up a shield across the space. He pushes through. His face breaks the surface and he says, "El. Please." That is the whole argument of the book in two words, and I found it genuinely painful. With Aadhya and Liu at her side, El opens the sutras and takes hold of him. She fuses her killing spell with the sutras' plea for golden shelter and the Scholomance's founding promise into one working. Liu and Aadhya join their mana, then the rest of the wizards on both sides, and the devoured lives are released while the stolen mana drains away. Golden light fills every fracture and replaces the old maw-mouth foundations with a new one. Orion gasps and says he will stay.
What I carried away
The aftermath gives El a life rather than a victory lap. She hands the sutras to her father's family along with a casting method Liu works out, so that a chorus of strict mana casters can lay golden foundations without her. She takes on the work of hunting the maw-mouths beneath every enclave one by one, destroying each and forcing the enclave to open its doors or fall. It has to stay secret, because enclaves will never volunteer to change. Deepthi's family provides warnings and Liesel coordinates a global network from London. Orion stays in the rebuilt Scholomance as its guardian, fighting mals and protecting the children, and plans to join El in the summers. In the last scene they sit together in the gymnasium pavilion, among fruit trees and birdsong, and El admits it is, actually, a bit nice.
That ending earns its small pleasure, and most of the road there is worth travelling. Novik's great strength here is that her magic has consequences you can follow. Power is treated like an economy, with debts, hoarding and people who get rich because others are kept outside the gates. The enclaves are not innocent shelters, and the book keeps finding new layers of complicity in them. It is also very good on the particular cruelty of loving someone who is suffering and being told by everyone that the kind thing is to end them. El's refusal to take that easy road, and her willingness to build something instead, is what made me care.
The criticism I would make is the one Kirkus made in its review, that this is a high concept adventure which does not always trust its readers to follow. The enclave mechanics are genuinely complicated, and the book introduces them late and all at once. A few of the confrontations are resolved by new spells assembled at speed, which can feel like clever engineering doing the work of character. There are stretches where I was more impressed by the system than moved by the people inside it. But the emotional core holds. Orion's "El. Please" and El's answer to it are simple, human things, and they sit at the center of a book that is otherwise about debt, foundations and the politics of who gets to be safe.
I would hand this to someone who has read the first two books and wants a real ending rather than a tease. I would not start here, and I would not give it to a reader who wants their fantasy politics neatly explained at every step. Read it as the close of an argument the trilogy has been having from the beginning: that safety built on someone else's suffering is not safety, and that the people written off as monsters are often the ones who have been paying for everyone else's comfort. It is a dense, often furious book, and it finishes on a note of guarded hope that feels earned rather than decorative.
FAQ
Do I need to read the first two Scholomance books before this one?
Yes. The Golden Enclaves opens moments after The Last Graduate ends and assumes you already know El, Orion, the school and the rules of mana and malia.
Is this the final book in The Scholomance series?
Yes. It is the third and last volume of the trilogy, published in the United States by Del Rey on September 27, 2022.
What exactly is a maw-mouth in this book?
It is a monster that swallows wizards and keeps them conscious while devouring them forever. The story reveals that enclaves create them by sacrificing a wizard as a living foundation.





























