Cover of Nightbane by Alex Aster

Nightbane

2,353-word summary 10 min read 416 pages in the book

First published
2023
Publisher
Amulet Books
Pages
416
ISBN
9781419760907
Series
Lightlark (#2)
Reading options
What's inside (7 sections)
  1. Thirty days to get ready
  2. The year she forgot
  3. Maren and the old curse
  4. Two futures at a bridge
  5. What works and what grates
  6. Key takeaways
  7. FAQ

I picked up Nightbane because I had just finished Lightlark and hated leaving Isla Crown on that cliff. This is the second book in Alex Aster's Lightlark series, published in 2023 by Amulet Books, and the hardcover runs 416 pages. It picks up in the same breath the first book stopped in, which I appreciated. A lot of sequels make you wait through a recap. This one opens a vault and gets straight to the trouble inside it.

Isla has won the Centennial. She has broken the curses that doomed the six peoples of the island, killed the tyrant Aurora, and taken a place among the rulers. She now holds authority over two of those peoples, the Wildlings and the Starlings, and she is in a relationship with Oro, the king of Lightlark. The trouble is that she does not feel ready for any of it. She is still learning what her powers can do, and she would rather slip into the island's nightlife than sit in a council room. Aster makes that avoidance feel true. Isla is nineteen and has spent most of her life being protected and lied to. Being handed two courts and a crown would unnerve anyone.

The book begins with her opening a vault in the Palace of Mirrors, the one she found in the first book but could not unlock. Something inside blasts her backward with a power that tastes like death, and she sees a vision of darkness swallowing the world. Then Grim's voice says her name and tells her to come back to him. Grim is the ruler of the Nightshades, the man she loved before the events of Lightlark, and the man she betrayed and barely remembers. The vision convinces her and Oro that he means to destroy the island to force her return.

At a party, Grim sends an illusion that shows everyone they know dead and the island ruined. His message is simple: she has thirty days to vacate, and in thirty days he is coming to destroy Lightlark. That countdown gives the book its engine. The other rulers gather to defend the island, with one important exception. Cleo, who rules the Moonlings, has a son who died because of the curses, and she has reasons of her own to want the old order gone. She and her people sail away to join Nightshade. I liked that Aster gave Cleo a real grievance instead of making her a random villain. Her choice is legible even when it hurts Isla.

Thirty days to get ready

The preparation stretches across the middle of the book, and it is the part I found most uneven. Isla is told to train, to recruit, and to remember, and she resists all three for a while. She takes in former enemies, a rough group called the Vinderland, and wins over fighters who would sooner see her fail. She bonds with a giant cat named Lynx, who turns out to have been bonded to her mother before her, a quiet bit of family history that lands better than some of the louder reveals. She watches Azul, the Skyling ruler, lead by listening to his people, and she decides to bring that habit home by making the Starling court more democratic. That choice is one of the clearest signs that she is growing into the role instead of merely inheriting it.

The rebels are a problem the book handles in stages. Isla is abducted by masked riders and, when she tries to break free, accidentally unleashes her Starling power and kills several of them. That frightens her into taking her training seriously. Oro takes her to Remlar, an older figure with ancient powers, who untangles her Nightshade abilities from the Wildling and Starling ones that have been masking them. The first memory comes back in the aftermath. She retreats to the Wild Isle, to a place called the Place of Mirrors where only Wildling magic works, and spends weeks training from sunrise to dusk with Oro. Those chapters have a clean, physical rhythm. They also let the romance breathe, which is something the book needs after a first volume built on tension and withheld truth.

Two things push her forward. Dreks, black winged beasts, attack her coronation and kill more than two hundred people. And an oracle tells her that her memories are the key, that everything she needs to know is already in her head and all she has to do is remember. The oracle scene is one of the few moments where the book admits its own structure. The plot is a lock and Isla's past is the combination.

The year she forgot

The memories come back in pieces, and they turn the book into a different story. Isla was raised in isolation on Wild Isle. She used a starstick, a small object that teleports its holder, to slip out of her castle. On one of those trips she landed in the Nightshade palace and was mistaken for a woman who had volunteered to spend the night with Grim. She kissed him before she came to her senses, then stabbed him and fled. Grim traced the starstick and worked out who she was, but he let her keep it. She came back with a vial of Wildling healing elixir as an offering. He smashed it. She challenged him to a duel, he won, and he told her never to return to his lands.

She went back anyway, to a dark market where she needed skin gloves for the Centennial, and got in trouble again. She stabbed a man who attacked her, guards chased her, and Grim had her thrown in a cell. This time he offered a deal. Help him find a powerful sword and he would ally with her at the Centennial. The sword matters because of the dreks, creatures born from a scar across Nightshade that opened when the curses were first spun. An ancient Nightshade ancestor had cursed warriors into unbeatable beasts and made a sword to control them, then a later ancestor cursed the sword so no Nightshade ruler could wield it. Grim needed someone with Isla's strange immunity to curses to handle it.

They spent months working toward the blade, through a cave guarded by a dragon and trapped at every turn, and in that time they fell in love. Grim showed her a field of nightbane, the flower used to make Wildling healing elixir, and the two peoples struck a bargain: elixir in exchange for hearts from people who were going to die anyway. When they finally reached the sword, the dragon attacked, and Grim used his power to save her. Because he had revealed himself, the sword vanished. It found her later. By then Grim had realized, from the starstick, that the general who had vanished twenty years earlier while following a lead with the same kind of object was Isla's father.

The last of these memories are the hardest. Grim explains that Lightlark is a small copy of the real world, and that a portal built into the island's foundation can reach it, though using it would destroy the island. He can open it, but only a Wildling ruler can work the door. Cleo knows the secret too and wants the portal for a reason of her own: the other world can bring the dead back, and she wants her son. Then Grim tells Isla the sword's price was her life. He needed her immunity to break the curse on it, and that would have killed her or cut her life short. Isla feels betrayed, and that is where her memory stops.

I will say this for the flashbacks: they are the strongest part of the sequel. The year with Grim has a shape that the present-day plot never quite manages. There is a goal, a journey, a growing bond, and a cost. Aster writes the nightbane field and the dragon fight with more ease than she writes the council scenes, and I found myself caring about those months more than the thirty-day countdown they are meant to explain.

Maren and the old curse

The rebels turn out to be less simple than the abduction suggested. Isla lets them take her a second time, and the leader pulls off her mask: it is Maren, a Starling she had been working with to rebuild her people's newland. Maren explains what the rebels found while studying the old curses. Long ago, a king's ancestors had a Nightshade weave a set of binding curses called the nexus, designed to keep the people weak and obedient. Everyone was born with one ability, and their lives were tied to their ruler's so the power could never be overthrown. Maren believes the only way to break it is for King Oro to die.

Isla refuses. She agrees that the nexus is cruel, but she will not trade Oro's life for it, especially once the memories return and she understands how much she stands to lose. This is the book's sharpest moral knot, and I wish Aster had spent more time on it. Maren has a coherent argument, and Isla's refusal is emotional rather than reasoned. The debate is over almost as soon as it starts, and the rebels fade back into the background until the battle needs them.

Two futures at a bridge

Before the war, the oracle tells Isla the future has split in two and neither path is more certain. It will come down to her choice between Oro and Grim, and one of the two will die by her hand. Isla and Oro make a plan: she will use the bond she shares with Grim to cut his powers so Oro can kill him. But by now she remembers enough to know that Grim's story is not the simple one she was told, and she cannot bear the plan she helped make.

The battle itself is crowded. Cleo fights alongside Grim because she wants her son back. The dreks arrive and turn the tide against Lightlark. Isla goes to a bridge near the Palace of Mirrors to confront Grim, and Grim and Oro fight while she tries to decide. Her final memory returns in that moment. After Grim revealed the sword's cost, they made up. He went out to face a new wave of dreks believing he would not come back, and she used their bond to take his power and portal to him. She broke the curse on the sword to save him after he was stabbed, and a wave of Nightshade power swept outward and killed everything nearby except him. It killed her too, and she died in his arms. Grim bound her life to his to keep her alive, a temporary fix that sent him looking for a permanent one in the other world.

Back in the present, Grim is about to kill Oro. Isla takes his powers as planned. Oro rises to strike, and Grim says that if he dies, Isla dies too. The bond is revealed to the man who never knew it existed. Isla also understands that the vision of death she saw at the vault was not a warning about Grim at all. It was a memory of what she did at the bridge. Then Grim adds one last fact: he and Isla are married. He gave her a necklace instead of a ring, apologized, took her memories, put the starstick back in her hand, and sent her home to the Wildling palace.

The ending refuses a clean answer. Isla agrees to go with Grim if he stops the war. She tells Oro she loves him, and then tells him she loves Grim too, and because Oro's power lets him read intent, he knows she is telling the truth. The fighting is still going when the book closes, and the bigger questions about the portal and the origin of the curses are left open. I admired the nerve of it, though I understand why readers who wanted a resolved victory felt shortchanged. This is a middle volume, and it behaves like one.

What works and what grates

Aster knows how to keep pages turning. Short chapters, a hard deadline, and a mystery about Isla's own mind make this easy to race through, and the flashbacks give the emotional weight the present plot sometimes lacks. The best ideas here are concrete: a flower that makes healing elixir, a giant cat that links Isla to her mother, a king who rules by listening, a woman who demands freedom from a curse everyone else has accepted. Those details stick. I also liked watching Isla take her role seriously, even if she arrives late to it. Her decision to share power with the Starling people is the most adult thing she does in either book.

The usual complaints about Lightlark apply here. History arrives in long explanations, often in dialogue that sounds like a summary rather than a conversation. The love triangle circles the same three people for chapters at a time, with Isla weighing one man against the other while the deadline ticks. The prose turns purple under pressure, with feelings arriving in waves of familiar fire and shadow imagery. Several developments happen because the plot needs them to: a mask comes off at the right moment, a memory returns in the middle of a fight, a portal gets opened by accident and is immediately useful. On a first read the pace hides most of this. Thinking back, I could see the seams.

Who should read it. If you finished Lightlark wanting more of Isla and Grim and more of the world's history, this delivers both in quantity. If you wanted the curses settled and the triangle resolved, you will find more questions and a larger war. I read it in two nights and enjoyed most of it, then spent the next day arguing with the ending. That is a fair description of the whole experience: a book that gives you plenty to talk about and not quite enough resolution to feel finished.

FAQ

Is Nightbane the second Lightlark book?

Yes. Amulet Books published it in 2023 as book two of the Lightlark series, following Lightlark from 2022. It is listed under the series name Lightlark with order 2.

Does Nightbane end the series?

No. It closes with the war still underway and several questions about the portal and the origin of the curses left open, so a later book is needed to resolve them.

Who is Maren in Nightbane?

Maren is a Starling who had worked with Isla on rebuilding her people's newland. She leads a rebel group that wants King Oro dead in order to break the ancient binding curses.