Cover of Skin Game by Jim Butcher

Skin Game

2,249-word summary 10 min read 608 pages in the book

First published
2014
Publisher
Roc
Pages
608
ISBN
9780451464392
Series
The Dresden Files (#15)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A crew of old enemies
  2. The sword that breaks
  3. Opening the way to Hades
  4. Nicodemus breaks his word
  5. The shape of the con
  6. What holds up and what strains
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked this one up because the previous book had left Harry Dresden on an island with a new body, a new mantle, and no idea how any of it was supposed to work. Skin Game is the fifteenth Dresden novel, published by Roc on May 27, 2014, running 608 pages in the American hardcover edition with ISBN 9780451464392. It is a heist novel wearing a wizard's coat, and it may be the cleanest entry point in the whole run for a reader who already knows who these people are. Butcher opens with Harry stranded on Demonreach, unable to reach his allies in Chicago, and suffering from headaches that turn out to be caused by a parasitic spirit growing in his head. Queen Mab arrives with an offer. She will help with the parasite if Harry takes a job for her.

Demonreach itself is a strange setting for the start of a caper. The island in Lake Michigan is a prison built by the original Merlin, and Harry is its Warden, which means he can sense the thing he is supposed to guard and very little else. Cut off from the city, he is reduced to talking to the spirit of the place and to the spirit in his own skull. Butcher uses the isolation to strip Harry down to the parts that matter: his stubbornness, his guilt about what happened to the people close to him, and a temper that the Winter mantle has made more dangerous. The book is at its best when it remembers that Harry is not a hero who enjoys this work. He is a man who keeps agreeing to jobs he does not want because the alternative is worse.

The job is a robbery. Harry is to join a crew assembled by Nicodemus, the black robed villain who has been a problem for the White Council for centuries, and steal something from the vault of Hades, lord of the Underworld. Harry trusts Nicodemus about as far as he can throw him, and he trusts Mab even less, so he insists that Karrin Murphy come along to watch his back. That decision shapes nearly everything that follows.

A crew of old enemies

The first stretch of the book is the patient machinery of a caper: meetings, recruitments, and quiet tests of loyalty. Harry sits down with Nicodemus and learns who else is coming. There is Binder, a mercenary with his own people; Hannah Ascher, a warlock wanted by the White Council; and Anna Valmont, the only surviving member of the crew that stole the Shroud of Turin back in Death Masks. Valmont's presence is the first sign that Nicodemus has been collecting specialists, not friends. Her specialty is getting into places that are not supposed to be entered, and the rest of the team is chosen with the same care. Nobody here arrives by accident. There is also Deirdre, Nicodemus's own daughter, and Goodman Grey, a shape shifting mercenary who is half human and half naagloshii.

Harry brings the group a sample taken from an insider named Harvey Morrison, a man who works close enough to the target to be useful. Morrison does not last long. Tessa, one of Nicodemus's associates, intervenes and kills him before he can say much, which tells Harry exactly how disposable everyone in this operation is, himself included. Bit by bit the target is named: the Holy Grail. The object is not just a prize for a collector. In the Dresden Files it is a thing of real power, and Hades keeps it somewhere even gods would hesitate to enter.

The spy in their midst turns out to be Waldo Butters, the medical examiner who has helped Harry more times than anyone has a right to count. Harry catches him following the crew and chases him down with some assistance from Bob, the skull spirit who usually would rather not be involved. Binder's people join the pursuit, and the chase ends on the street in front of Michael Carpenter's house, where Nicodemus catches up with Harry, Murphy, and Butters all at once. This is where the book stops being a heist and becomes a very personal fight.

The sword that breaks

Murphy draws Fidelacchius, one of the Swords of the Cross, and faces Nicodemus. She is tricked into using the sword against a man who is deliberately helpless, and the weapon shatters under the weight of that choice. Murphy is badly wounded. It is a brutal piece of writing because the trap works on the best instincts in her: she sees a threat and acts, and the sword's rules punish her for it. Nicodemus has spent centuries learning how to turn other people's virtues against them.

Michael Carpenter has always been the series' argument that goodness is a choice rather than a condition. He takes in supernatural refugees, he refuses to break his word, and he treats Nicodemus as a man who might still turn. Uriel's gift of Amoracchius and a measure of his Grace is not a cheap reward. It is the universe briefly agreeing with Michael's assessment that a man who keeps his word deserves a weapon that can back it up. Nicodemus recognizes the shift and walks away, which is the correct response.

Michael Carpenter then steps out and offers a trade. He will leave the protection of his angel guarded house if Nicodemus lets Harry, Murphy, and Butters go. Nicodemus accepts, and before Michael can walk out, Uriel appears and hands him Amoracchius, another of the Swords, along with a portion of his own Grace so that Michael can actually fight. Nicodemus decides the bargain is no longer worth his trouble and leaves. The wounded crew ends up at the Carpenters' house, where Harry also reconnects with his daughter Maggie for the first time since he saved her life in Chichen Itza. That quiet scene is one of the few moments in the novel where nobody is trying to use anybody.

Opening the way to Hades

The heist proper begins with a break in at a high security vault owned by John Marcone, Chicago's criminal power broker. Harry opens a Way from that vault into Hades' own vault in the Nevernever, the spirit world that sits behind ordinary reality. The entrance is guarded by a sequence of gates, and the crew pays for each one. Ascher opens the Gate of Fire. Harry opens the Gate of Ice. The final gate, the Gate of Blood, requires a death freely given, and Deirdre allows her father to kill her so that her spirit can open it. The sequence is grim and it lands, because Deirdre has been presented as a person with her own mind right up to the moment her father spends her.

Once inside, Harry and Valmont find an altar holding the Grail. They also find four other artifacts connected to the crucifixion of Jesus, and Harry realizes that this is not a treasure room. It is an armory. Hades stops time to speak with him privately and explains that the vault holds objects too dangerous for the world until someone with the knowledge and the discipline to wield them comes along. Hades is not a villain in this scene. He is a curator with a very long memory, and his conversation with Harry reframes the entire job. He is one of the more interesting figures Harry meets in the series because he has no interest in conquest. He is a steward who keeps objects that would let the wrong person do real damage, and he has arranged matters so that only someone who understands the cost of power can reach them. In a book full of people who want things, Hades mostly wants to keep what he already has safe.

Harry acts on that knowledge while everyone else is distracted. He slips three of the artifacts into Valmont's bag and hides a fourth in his sleeve, then lets Nicodemus take the Grail. That quiet theft is the hinge of the plot, because it means the real robbery was not the one Nicodemus planned.

Nicodemus breaks his word

Nicodemus takes the Grail and then turns on Harry and Michael. Harry has called him out for murdering his own daughter, and that anger finally cracks the deal with Mab: Nicodemus orders Ascher and the Genoskwa, a violent Bigfoot like creature, to attack, along with Grey. Ascher is revealed as the new host of the fallen angel Lasciel, and the Genoskwa carries Ursiel. By breaking the agreement, Nicodemus frees Harry to fight back without violating Mab's terms.

Harry had planned for this. In a flashback we learn that he hired Goodman Grey beforehand to stand beside him when the deal went bad. Grey takes on the Genoskwa and Ursiel. Harry fights Ascher and Lasciel and eventually buries her under a rockfall. Michael faces Nicodemus, and before the blades are drawn he makes one last appeal to the man's humanity, which is the only thing Michael has ever had to offer him. Nicodemus runs. Grey blinds the Genoskwa long enough for the three of them to escape, and Harry triggers the Gate of Ice on the way out to crush their pursuer.

The escape does not go cleanly. Nicodemus slips away ahead of them and heads for Michael's house, which traps Harry, Grey, Michael, and Valmont in Marcone's vault until Binder helps them get out. The final confrontation happens at the Carpenter home. Butters picks up the shattered remains of Fidelacchius, and the broken sword responds by producing a blade of light in the manner of a lightsaber. He drives Nicodemus off and, in the aftermath, agrees to become a Knight of the Cross himself. Molly Carpenter, now the Winter Lady, arrives in time to draw the parasitic spirit out of Harry's head, which closes the private problem that started the book.

The shape of the con

The ending reveals how much of this was arranged by people who were not in the room. Harry works out that Mab, Hades, and Marcone allowed Nicodemus to carry out the heist in order to destroy his reputation, as revenge for the time he kidnapped Marcone and the Archive. The vault was never really secure, the Grail was never really the point, and Nicodemus was being handled the whole time. Harry confronts Mab and Marcone with his conclusions, which is satisfying precisely because nobody denies them.

The personal resolutions are handled more gently. The crew splits a backpack of diamonds Valmont took from the vault. Grey refuses a share and asks for one dollar from Harry as his fee, a small joke that also keeps him clean of what happened back in Chicago. Harry uses that share as weregild to pay for the death of one of Marcone's vault guards. He visits Karrin in the hospital, and the two finally stop circling each other and agree to try being something more than partners. A late conversation with Michael about Harry's future as the Winter Knight keeps the larger story alive without resolving it.

What holds up and what strains

A few small choices are worth noting. The one dollar fee for Grey is a perfect character beat: a mercenary who refuses blood money will still take a token payment. The weregild to Marcone's guard acknowledges that a man died in a vault during a job that was supposed to be clean. And the hospital scene with Karrin does not try to solve everything between them, which is why it works better than a grand declaration would have. Butcher trusts those quiet moments to carry weight, and they do.

The best thing Skin Game does is give a very old character a new set of problems. Harry is not solving a murder or stopping a coup here; he is trying to keep a group of dishonest people from killing each other while an immortal villain plays them all. The dialogue has the dry, hard edged rhythm the series is known for, and Michael's appeal to Nicodemus is a genuinely strong scene because it asks whether a man who has done evil for centuries can still be reached. The Butters sequence, from spying in the street to holding a broken sword that lights up in his hand, is the emotional payoff the book earns.

The cost of the structure is a long middle section where everybody has to be introduced and briefed. Fifteen books in, the cast is enormous, and several characters get a scene that exists mostly to remind the reader they are present. The religious material, with fallen angels possessing warm bodies and crucifixion relics sitting in a divine armory, is heavy handed in places, and the theological machinery sometimes feels like it arrived from a different book. The ending also moves fast through several major status changes, especially Murphy and Harry finally committing to each other, after spending hundreds of pages earned by not quite saying it.

It debuted at number one on the New York Times best seller list and was a finalist for the 2015 Hugo Award for Best Novel, and the reputation is deserved. This is a full blown caper with a mystery inside it, and it asks a sharper question than the series usually does: what is the difference between a thief and a man who arranges a theft for a moral reason? It is not a place to start. It is a very good place to be fifteen books deep.

FAQ

Do I need to have read the earlier Dresden Files books first?

Yes. This is the fifteenth novel and it leans on Changes, Ghost Story, and Cold Days, so Storm Front is the real starting point.

What is the heist in Skin Game?

Mab sends Harry to help the villain Nicodemus break into the vault of Hades in the Nevernever and steal the Holy Grail, with a crew of specialists and old enemies.

Who is Nicodemus in The Dresden Files?

He is a recurring antagonist who has troubled the White Council for centuries. In this book he leads the vault robbery and kills his own daughter Deirdre to open the final gate.