Cover of The Lord of the Rings: Weapons and Warfare by Chris Smith

The Lord of the Rings: Weapons and Warfare

2,297-word summary 10 min read 218 pages in the book

First published
2003
Publisher
Houghton Mifflin
Pages
218
ISBN
9780618390991
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. A companion built for the space between page and screen
  2. Blades, mail and the objects people remember
  3. The battles taken apart, one encounter at a time
  4. The other side of the field
  5. A thousand images and the people who made them
  6. Where the companion loses its footing
  7. Who should actually read it
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this book up because I had watched the extended editions of the films more times than I care to admit, and I wanted something that lived in the gap between the movies and the novels. What I found was neither a novel nor a standard guidebook. It is a large, glossy reference volume published in 2003, the year the third film reached cinemas, and it treats Tolkien's war as though someone could file a military report on it. That premise sounds odd when you describe it. In the hand, it works better than it has any right to.

A companion built for the space between page and screen

Chris Smith had spent five years as the Tolkien editor at HarperCollins before he wrote this, and that experience shows in the way he moves between the source text and Peter Jackson's films without getting precious about either one. The cover title is short, but the first edition carries the subtitle An Illustrated Guide to the Battles, Armies and Armor of Middle-earth. That subtitle is a fair description of what is inside. This is an inventory organized around the things people who love the story tend to argue about: who carried which blade, how a particular army was dressed, and what a siege actually looked like when the cameras were rolling.

The timing matters. In 2003 the film trilogy had just finished, and there was a large appetite for anything that could extend the experience a little longer. Smith's answer was a companion that drew on the production material behind the movies rather than on Tolkien's prose alone. Christopher Lee, who played Saruman, wrote the foreword, and Richard Taylor of Weta Workshop contributed an introduction. Those two names tell you where the book's sympathies sit. It is as much about the making of a cinematic war as it is about the war itself, and that double focus is its defining feature.

The result is a book you can read in two very different ways. You can skim it as a picture book, which is how a lot of readers will use it, or you can read the text closely and come away with a genuinely detailed account of how the conflict was staged across both page and screen. It does not demand that you choose between the two versions of the story. That is a small kindness, and it is one of the reasons the book has lasted longer than most film tie-ins from the same year.

Smith's background also explains the book's tone. He had worked with writers as different as Robin Hobb and Stephen King, and he writes with the confidence of someone who has spent years around fantasy authors and their readers. He knows which details this audience cares about, and he knows that a fan will happily accept a page of careful explanation if it is attached to a good picture. The chapters are short and self-contained, which makes the volume easy to dip into. You can open it at any point, spend ten minutes on a single battle or a single suit of armour, and close it again without feeling that you have lost the thread.

Blades, mail and the objects people remember

The opening sections deal with the personal equipment of war, and this is where the book is at its most straightforward. Smith walks through the swords, daggers, bows and armour that define the important characters, pairing a short piece of description with images drawn from the films and from the workshop that built them. Anduril gets the attention you would expect. So do Sting, Narsil and the mithril shirt that Frodo wears beneath his travelling clothes.

What lifts this above a simple catalogue is the willingness to explain why an object matters narratively. The mithril shirt is not interesting because it is light and strong, though it is both. It is interesting because it turns a quiet act of loyalty into a physical fact that a reader can picture. The book keeps making that move, taking a prop and tracing the scene that gave it weight. A blade stops being a blade and becomes the moment a character decides who he is.

The armour section is particularly good on the difference between the peoples of the story. Rohan's riders, Gondor's infantry, the Uruk-hai and the armies of Mordor are each treated as distinct fighting cultures with their own gear and habits. Smith does not invent these distinctions; he pulls them out of descriptions scattered through the novels and then shows how the film designers turned them into something you can see. If you have ever wondered how someone decides what a soldier from Rohan should look like next to a soldier from Gondor, this is the book that answers that question in pictures.

There is a pleasing amount of attention paid to the unglamorous tools of war as well. Siege ladders, battering rams, catapults and the great gate at Minas Tirith all get their due. The book understands that a battle is decided as much by logistics and engineering as by heroic individuals, and it gives those details room. That is a refreshing change from retellings that only want to talk about the famous duels.

Bows and arrows receive the same careful treatment as the swords, which is welcome because archery is easy to overlook in a story dominated by famous blades. The book looks at the different kinds of bows carried by the peoples of the story and at the way archery is used in specific fights, from the opening encounters to the defence of the walls. Even the simple act of equipping an army becomes interesting when it is laid out this clearly, and the matching illustrations make the comparison immediate rather than abstract.

The battles taken apart, one encounter at a time

The largest portion of the book is given over to the major conflicts, and here Smith commits to a method. Each encounter is introduced, then examined through specially commissioned battle plans that show where forces were positioned and how the fighting moved. The text then works through what happened and why it mattered. This is the part of the book that justifies its existence, because the plans give you a view of the action that neither the novels nor the films can provide on their own.

Helm's Deep is the obvious showcase. The book lays out the geometry of the hornburg, the position of the defenders and the way the attacking force pressed the assault, then connects that layout to the choices the characters make under pressure. The Pelennor Fields get similar treatment, with the separate threads of the battle tracked until they converge at the gate. The Black Gate receives less space but is handled with the same care, and the smaller fights at Weathertop and in the Mines of Moria are folded in as examples of a different kind of combat.

Reading these chapters in order is like watching a war documented by someone who has access to both the generals and the film crew. Smith is careful about the difference between what Tolkien wrote and what Jackson put on screen, and he flags the places where the two diverge instead of smoothing them over. That honesty is useful. It stops the book from pretending that the films are a direct transcription of the novels, which is a temptation that many companions of this era could not resist.

The battle plans themselves are the kind of feature that either delights you or leaves you cold. I found them absorbing. They reward the reader who likes to orient himself, who wants to know where Aragorn stood when the wall broke and how the riders arrived when they did. If diagrams are not your thing, you can ignore them and lose very little, because the prose accounts stand on their own. But they are the book's best idea, and they are executed with real clarity.

The other side of the field

One of the smarter choices Smith makes is to give the enemy's war machine the same attention he gives the heroes. The armies of Mordor and Isengard are not treated as a faceless crowd but as forces with their own equipment, their own methods and their own chain of command. The Uruk-hai in particular come across as a deliberately engineered fighting force, and the book connects their design to the broader industrial quality of Saruman's warfare. That framing gives the conflict a texture that a simple good-versus-evil account would miss.

The great siege engines built for the assault on Minas Tirith are handled with real interest. Smith describes the scale of the preparations and the way the attackers meant to break the city, then sets those plans against the defence mounted inside the walls. It is the closest the book comes to pure military history, and it is some of its strongest writing. You can feel the logic of the siege, the way each side tries to answer the other, and the desperate arithmetic of defenders who know they are outnumbered.

This is also where the book's approach proves its worth. By concentrating on material rather than morality, Smith avoids the trap of turning the story into a sermon. The orcs get described the way an arms inspector might describe a threatening arsenal, and the effect is more unsettling than any amount of villainous dialogue would be. The enemy is dangerous because it is organized, not because it is loud.

A thousand images and the people who made them

The illustrations are the other half of the experience, and the publisher's description of roughly a thousand photographs, paintings, maps, sculptures and sketches is not marketing inflation. The book is dense with visual material, and much of it had not been published before this volume appeared. Concept art, costume studies, models and behind-the-scenes photographs sit beside stills from the finished films, which means you can watch an idea travel from a sketch to a finished shot across a few pages.

That is where the Weta connection pays off. Richard Taylor's involvement gives the book access to the workshop's design process, and the images of armour and weapons in various stages of construction are among the most interesting things here. You see a sword as a drawing, then as a prop, then in a character's hand. For anyone with even a passing interest in how a fantasy film is assembled, that sequence is worth the price of admission on its own.

The maps deserve a mention too. These are not the clean, elegant maps of the novels but working documents, full of terrain and movement, designed to explain a battle rather than to decorate a front endpaper. They suit the book's purpose exactly.

Where the companion loses its footing

This is not a flawless book, and the criticisms are not hard to find. The first is structural. Because Smith has organized the material by topic and battle, there is very little narrative momentum. You cannot read it the way you would read a history, following one argument from start to finish. It is a reference work, and it sometimes reads like one, with a rhythm of introduction, plan, explanation and illustration that becomes predictable after a hundred pages.

The second problem is tone. The book was published at the height of the film trilogy's popularity, and a few passages slip into the breathless register of a promotional brochure. The foreword and introduction are effusive, and Smith's own prose occasionally follows them into a kind of uncritical enthusiasm. If you want a cool analysis of the politics of the war, or a skeptical account of how the films changed the story, you will not find it here. This book admires its subject, and it never pretends otherwise.

There is also a question of audience. The uninitiated will struggle. The book assumes you already know who is fighting whom and why a particular name matters. It is not a place to start with Tolkien, and it is not a replacement for reading the novels or watching the films. Readers looking for a first introduction will find themselves surrounded by names and references that carry no weight yet.

Finally, at a little over two hundred pages in the first edition, it is not a short book, but it is not a long one either. The generous illustrations take up a great deal of space, so the actual text is thinner than the page count suggests. Some readers have felt shortchanged by that ratio, especially if they were expecting a dense scholarly study. I think the balance is about right, but it is worth knowing what you are buying.

Who should actually read it

For anyone who loves the films and wants to understand how their battles were imagined and built, this is close to essential. It gives the visual side of the story a seriousness that tie-in books rarely receive, and the battle plans offer a way of seeing the action that is genuinely new. Readers who enjoy military history, costume design or the mechanics of filmmaking will find plenty to keep them turning pages.

For a Tolkien scholar, the book is likely to feel slight. It does not offer new textual readings, and it is more interested in the films than in the novels. But Smith never claims to be writing scholarship. He is writing a companion, and he does that job with real care and an obvious affection for the material. Read it for what it is, a handsome and intelligent guide to a war that never happened, and it delivers exactly what it promises.

FAQ

Is this a novel or a guide to the films?

It is an illustrated nonfiction companion published in 2003, not a novel. It examines the weapons, armies and battles of the films and the source novels with chapter-length analysis and diagrams.

Does it cover Tolkien's books or only the movies?

Both. Smith draws on Tolkien's descriptions and on the production design of Peter Jackson's films, and he points out where the two differ rather than treating them as the same thing.

Do I need to know the story before reading it?

Yes. The book assumes familiarity with the characters and battles, so it works better as a companion after reading the novels or watching the films than as an introduction.