That Summer
2,372-word summary 11 min read 416 pages in the book
- First published
- 2021
- Publisher
- Atria Books
- Pages
- 416
- ISBN
- 9781501133541
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
I nearly skipped this book because I thought I already knew the title. There is a young adult novel called That Summer from 2012, and I assumed this was it. It is not. Jennifer Weiner published her That Summer in 2021 with Atria Books, a 416 page novel about a Philadelphia wife, a stranger with a fake name and the wreckage of a night on a Cape Cod beach thirty years earlier. The confusion is worth clearing up because the plot here has nothing to do with a girl revisiting her parents' divorce. What Weiner wrote is a #MeToo era story about a survivor who decides, very deliberately, to walk into the life of the woman who married her attacker.
The woman who cannot sleep
Daisy Shoemaker is thirty-eight and lives in a comfortable house in the Philadelphia suburbs with her husband Hal, a lawyer, and their fifteen-year-old daughter Beatrice. She teaches cooking classes, does volunteer work, keeps a beautiful home and has plenty of acquaintances and no real friends. She lies awake at night without knowing why. Weiner is careful to show the shape of the life before she takes it apart. Daisy's father died when she was fourteen, and the family's money problems ended her plan to attend Emlen, the New Hampshire prep school her older brothers went to. She met Hal at twenty; he was thirty-three and an Emlen classmate of her brother Danny. She left college, married him and was pregnant two years later. Now her daughter is the one facing trouble at Emlen, after protesting how the school handled the sexual assault of her roommate.
Into this settled unhappiness comes an email error. Messages meant for another woman named Diana start arriving in Daisy's inbox because the two addresses differ by a single punctuation mark. The other Diana writes to apologize. They exchange a few notes, agree to meet for a drink in New York and get along immediately. "Diana Starling" presents herself as a single businesswoman in her fifties, glamorous and unhurried, someone who chairs meetings and reorganizes corporations while Daisy is driving carpools and making dinner. After they say goodbye, Diana goes into the ladies' room and takes off her elaborate disguise. She is the girl from the prologue, and although she likes Daisy, she has decided to ruin her life.
That prologue is the engine of the book. With only a few pages Weiner establishes a summer in the 1980s when fifteen-year-old Diana worked as a mother's helper on Cape Cod, met an older boy named Poe from Emlen and went with him to a bonfire party on the beach. Something happened at that party. Weiner does not spell it out at once, and the delay is the source of the book's tension. When the truth arrives, it is a gang rape by Poe and two of his friends, an act that scatters Diana's college plans and shapes every choice she makes afterward. Written in the shadow of #MeToo, the novel is less interested in the assault itself than in the decades of ordinary life that sit on top of it.
Three voices, two summers
The story moves between three points of view: Diana, Daisy and Beatrice, and it keeps two clocks running. One is the present, with its emails, cooking lessons and looming confrontation. The other is the summer of the bonfire, which arrives in fragments. Weiner used a similar split timeline in her earlier novel Big Summer, and the technique asks the reader to hold two versions of the same woman in mind at once. There is the fifteen-year-old on the beach and the composed consultant in the hotel bar, and neither fully explains the other.
That structure is the cleverest thing about the book. It lets Diana's anger build in the present while the past keeps adding fuel. It also lets Weiner withhold the worst details until Daisy, and the reader, have already met Hal as a husband rather than a stranger. A lesser novel would open with the assault and treat everything after it as aftermath. Here the assault is a delayed revelation, which changes how the reader judges the comfortable house in Philadelphia and the man who comes home to it each evening.
The cost is that the present-day chapters sometimes feel thin beside the past ones. Daisy's insomnia and her vague dissatisfaction are well observed, but her daily life is mostly a setup for a revelation she will receive from someone else. Beatrice's chapters have the same problem in reverse. She is given a strong opening position, a girl willing to challenge her school over how it treats assault survivors, and then the book has no real use for her once the secret is out.
What happened after the bonfire
The past chapters are the strongest part of That Summer. Diana drops out of college and is struggling when the woman who employed her on the Cape offers her the use of a cottage. She takes a job at a restaurant in Provincetown and meets Michael, the man who cares for the cottage and the neighboring houses. Michael is patient and kind, and Diana slowly trusts him. They marry and buy the place. She tells him she is not sure she wants children, and she tells him she dreams of revenge. While he is working at another beach house, she sees a photograph of her attacker. Poe is Hal, Daisy's husband.
Weiner handles this stretch with a quiet, accumulating anger. Diana is not written as a woman frozen at fifteen. She builds a working life, a marriage and a home, and the fantasy of revenge sits inside it like a second job she never quits. Her cosmetics and the invented name are tools, not a costume she wears for fun. Michael is the novel's quiet achievement. He does not try to talk Diana out of her anger or offer to carry it for her. He listens, asks practical questions and lets her keep the cottage and the plan. Their marriage is written in small exchanges rather than grand declarations, which makes Diana's confession that she still dreams of revenge land harder. She is not a woman waiting to be rescued. She is a woman with a list and the patience to work through it.
When she searches for the men, she poses as a researcher at Emlen and goes through the yearbooks. She identifies the two boys who joined Poe, and she finds the name of a woman Hal bragged about in his senior shoutouts. She calls the woman and asks whether Poe could have raped someone. The answer she gets is a flat, chilling line: anyone is capable of anything. Looking through old photographs, Diana realizes that Daisy's brother Danny was there and saw what happened.
A friendship with a plan behind it
In the present, Diana calls Daisy with exciting news: she is moving to Philadelphia. Daisy gives her a cooking lesson and asks casually about Hal and his old school friends. Daisy mentions Danny and the fact that he later came out as gay. Diana files that away. She is building a map of the household she intends to enter.
The map turns ugly. Diana buys a gun and begins stalking Brad, the divorced alcoholic who works at a Starbucks and was one of the three boys at the bonfire. She confronts him. He apologizes, which is not what she wants; she says she wants him to suffer. He kills himself. The scene is short, and the book never quite decides what to do with it. A woman seeking accountability watches a man take his own life, and the narrative moves on to a dinner party.
Daisy, for her part, has started to notice things about Hal that she once let pass. He drinks too much, makes remarks about women that would once have been called harmless and accuses people in the house of stealing. Weiner plants these details so the reveal will feel inevitable, and on a cold reading it does. What is missing is any real sense of how Daisy understood them at the time. A woman married to the same man for nearly twenty years does not simply file such things away. The book gives her no interior argument about it, which makes her final decision easier than it should be.
Daisy and Diana host that party together. In private, Diana confronts both Danny and Hal. Danny apologizes. Diana leaves abruptly. Daisy goes to Diana's Philadelphia apartment to try to talk, but the doorman says no one by that name lives there. She calls instead, and Diana agrees to meet. Over that meeting Diana finally tells the whole story, and Daisy runs to the bathroom to be sick. When she comes back, Diana is gone.
What follows should be the novel's emotional center: a wife learning that the father of her child is a rapist. Weiner gives it less space than you might expect. Daisy calls Danny and asks why he let her marry Hal. He admits he could have done more, says he was in love with Hal and mentions that he told their mother. Daisy confronts her mother, who remembers Danny saying something about a wild high school party that got out of hand. The pieces fit. Daisy's reaction is a slow, practical assembling of facts rather than a collapse, and the book never fully reckons with the years she spent beside him. Her daughter Beatrice, meanwhile, has been pushed out of Emlen and is filling the freezer with dead animals she finds for her taxidermy projects. Beatrice has a sharp political sense and a point of view of her own, and then the plot mostly forgets her once the truth comes out.
The slippery deck
Daisy calls Diana and says she wants to meet on the Cape. Danny calls Hal in a panic, and Hal calls Daisy to say he is coming too. The showdown takes place on Diana's deck, with its view of the water and the house Michael keeps up. Before Daisy arrives, Diana mentions that the deck is slippery and that one of the posts is loose. It is a strange thing to say out loud.
Hal arrives. He and Daisy argue, and he stumbles, reaching out to her to steady himself. For a moment Daisy considers letting him fall. Then she tells him she wants a divorce. That is the entire confrontation. There is no shove, no confession in front of witnesses, no call to the police. Diana's hint about the post leads nowhere, and the revenge plot that gathered a gun and a suicide dissolves into a woman leaving a marriage.
Hal is not arrested, charged or publicly named. He loses his wife, and that is the full extent of the reckoning. Weiner seems aware of the gap, because Diana's speech about the wives and mothers who build comfortable nests for violent men is the sharpest writing in the book. But a speech is not a consequence, and the novel offers no mechanism by which the men in it answer for what they did. One of them is dead by his own hand, another is merely divorced, and the third disappears back into the past.
Afterward, Daisy and Beatrice spend the summer on the Cape. Daisy cooks at Diana's restaurant, and Diana, Michael, Beatrice and the dogs settle into something like a family. The final chapter, titled Coda, returns to a fifteen-year-old girl on a beach, this time Beatrice, who paddles out on a board and politely refuses a boy who tries to talk to her. It is meant to echo the opening and to suggest a girl who will not need someone else to tell her what happened to her. The image is graceful, and it arrives after a book that spent so much time on a fifteen-year-old girl in the same place that the symmetry feels earned rather than cute.
What the book gets right and where it stalls
Weiner writes about women's anger and female friendship with real warmth, and Diana is the reason to read. Her disguise, her careful Beatrice-like study of old yearbooks, her conversations with Michael about whether revenge can be a way to live, all of it gives the novel a pulse. The details of Daisy's cooking classes and the Philadelphia suburbs are specific and unshowy. The question the book keeps asking, about the wives and mothers who make comfortable nests for violent men, is a serious one and Diana says it aloud in a sharp speech about enablers.
The trouble is that the book builds one story and finishes another. The disguise, the burner email, the gun, the stalking and the hints of violence all promise a revenge thriller, and then Weiner swerves into a softer account of women sticking together. Readers can reasonably want either one. What is harder to accept is how little the ending explains. Diana's move from wanting to destroy Daisy's life to sharing a restaurant and a summer with her gets almost no attention. Hal faces no consequence beyond the end of his marriage, which sits uneasily beside the book's own insistence that rape culture is protected by exactly this kind of quiet. Daisy's awakening feels rushed, and her daughter's protest plot, set up with such care, goes nowhere. A reviewer at Jen Ryland Reviews called the ending anticlimactic after the deck warning, and that matches the feeling of closing the book: a lot of loaded guns, and no use for any of them.
I still think the novel is worth reading, mainly for Diana and for the past chapters, which are tighter and angrier than the present-day ones. It is a book about the long half-life of a single night, and it understands that the people left holding the memory are the ones who keep paying. It is less convincing about what justice would look like, or whether it can happen at all. The Coda suggests the next generation might do better. After the compromises that came before it, that is a hopeful note rather than an earned one.
FAQ
When was That Summer by Jennifer Weiner published?
Atria Books published it on May 11, 2021, as a 416 page hardcover with ISBN 9781501133541. It is not the 2012 young adult novel of the same name by Sarah Dessen.
Is this the same book as Sarah Dessen's That Summer?
No. Sarah Dessen published a young adult novel with the same title in 2012. Weiner's 2021 book is an adult novel about a Philadelphia wife and a survivor of a campus sexual assault.
Does the novel end with a violent confrontation?
No. Diana hints that the deck is slippery and a post is loose, but Daisy only tells Hal she wants a divorce. The family then spends a quiet summer on the Cape.





























