Cover of Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood by Ann Brashares

Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood

2,382-word summary 11 min read 338 pages in the book

First published
2005
Publisher
Delacorte Press
Pages
338
ISBN
9780385729352
Series
Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants (#3)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. Four stories and a pair of jeans
  2. Lena and the drawing class
  3. Tibby, Brian, and the window
  4. Bridget and Eric at the soccer camp
  5. Carmen, Good Carmen, and the baby
  6. What holds it together
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I read Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood after the second book, and the change in the four friends is the first thing you notice. Ann Brashares published it in 2005 with Delacorte Press, and my copy is the 338 page hardcover, ISBN 9780385729352, third in the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants series. This is the last summer before college. Every chapter carries the low hum of a goodbye nobody wants to say out loud.

The premise has always been improbable. A pair of jeans bought in a thrift store fits four girls with different bodies, and the pants travel between them each summer. By book three the magic is taken for granted. The pants are less a device now than a ritual, a way of saying that Lena, Tibby, Bridget and Carmen still belong to each other even when they are in different states.

It is worth remembering where the pair came from. The four friends found them in a thrift store during the summer before their sophomore year, when they were all about to be separated for the first time. The jeans fit each of them, which made no sense and did not need an explanation. In the first two books the pants were a plot engine, a physical object that could be mailed from Greece to Alabama and cause trouble on arrival. Here they are quieter. They show up as a reminder rather than a cause, and Brashares seems more interested in what the girls have learned about each other than in the trick itself.

That choice is right for a third book. A gimmick that carried two novels would start to feel mechanical if it kept producing the same kind of trouble. Instead the magic has become a habit, which is closer to how friendship actually works. You do not think about the thing that connects you until you are about to lose it.

Four stories and a pair of jeans

Brashares gives each girl a section, and the switches between them are abrupt. One chapter you are in a drawing studio, the next you are at a soccer camp in Pennsylvania, and the person you were just with is gone. The school library journal review of the book called that abruptness a problem for reluctant readers, and I see the point. It took me a few pages each time to settle into the new voice.

I also think the structure is the reason the book works. These are four people who are about to stop sharing a town. Cutting between them without a bridge mimics the way their lives are about to split. The pants are the only thing that crosses the gaps, and each transfer feels like a small act of loyalty.

The other thing that has changed is the stakes. In the first book the girls were surviving a summer apart. Here they are deciding who they will be when nobody is watching, and the choices are about art school, marriage proposals, pregnancy and family. It is a heavier book than the ones before it, though it never forgets to be funny.

Lena and the drawing class

Lena's section is the one I remember most clearly. Her grandfather has died, and her grandmother Valia has moved in with the family. Valia is lonely and homesick and complains constantly, which makes the house tense. Lena's refuge is a figure drawing class at an art school, something her parents do not approve of because they want her to study something practical.

Then her father walks in on the class and sees her drawing a nude model. He forbids her from continuing and tells her he will not pay for her to go to the Rhode Island School of Design. That scene made me angry on Lena's behalf, and I think Brashares meant it to. It is the moment a parent's fear turns into a rule.

The instructor, Annik Marchand, tells Lena to try for a scholarship instead. Lena builds a portfolio of drawings of her family and of Paul Rodman, the young man who comes to stay with Carmen. The drawings become a way of seeing people she has been avoiding. She notices her sister Effie's anger about her leaving, her mother caught between Lena's wishes and her father's, her father afraid of a world he does not understand, and Valia wanting someone to listen to her misery rather than ignore it.

Lena mails the portfolio, wins the scholarship, and gets her father's permission to go to art school. It is a clean resolution, and it is also the part of the book where Brashares spells out the lesson a little too plainly. The horn book review complained that the novel tells readers what each girl has learned. Lena's arc is the clearest example of that habit.

Paul Rodman is the young man staying with Carmen who becomes one of Lena's drawing subjects. Putting him in the portfolio is a smart move by Brashares, because it forces Lena to draw someone outside her own family while claiming that she is only drawing the people she knows. Her family is the actual subject, though. The pictures let her see a household where everybody is frightened of something and nobody is saying it. Valia wants to be missed. Effie wants her sister to stay. Her mother wants both things at once. Drawing them is how Lena stops treating them as obstacles.

I also liked that Brashares lets the father remain a decent man who is simply scared. He is not a villain, and the book does not ask us to forgive him for a speech. He forbids the class because he cannot imagine a life in art, and his permission at the end costs him something. That is a more useful model of a parent than the cartoon versions this kind of novel often gives us.

Tibby, Brian, and the window

Tibby's story starts with a date. Brian asks her to the senior party, and she has feelings for him but is afraid of what admitting them will do to their friendship. At the end of the night he kisses her and tells her he loves her. It is the sweetest scene in the book, and it lasts about a page.

The next morning her little sister Katherine falls out a window and injures her head while Tibby is supposed to be watching her. Tibby blames herself completely. She decides that the accident happened because she was thinking about Brian, and that taking chances only leads to harm. She starts avoiding him. This is the darkest of the four threads, and Brashares handles the guilt without making a speech about it. Tibby sits with a mistake and cannot be talked out of it.

Near the end she becomes Christina's unwilling labor partner. Carmen has drafted her to stay with her mother, and Tibby ends up helping Christina deliver without her husband or Carmen in the room. It is strange and uncomfortable and exactly the kind of thing that makes Tibby stop hiding. She helps someone be brave, and then she can be brave herself. She stops avoiding Brian and the two begin a relationship.

I found this arc more convincing than Lena's because the lesson is earned through an action. Tibby does not announce that she has changed. She changes in a delivery room, where there is no time to perform being fine.

What makes the guilt believable is its logic, even though it is wrong. Tibby decides that if she had not been thinking about Brian, she would have been watching Katherine. The two things cannot both be true in her head, so she treats affection as a kind of danger. It is a very young person's way of thinking, and Brashares does not correct it with a lecture. She lets Tibby sit with a child's disastrous certainty until real work interrupts her.

The scene with Christina is also the moment when the four girls' stories brush against each other without the pants doing any of the work. Carmen is the one who asks Tibby to take the shift. Christina is the one who needs her. Brian is the person Tibby has been avoiding. All three threads arrive in the same room, and the resolution belongs to Tibby alone. That is the best engineered chapter in the book.

Bridget and Eric at the soccer camp

Bridget takes a job coaching at a youth soccer camp in Pennsylvania and discovers that one of the other coaches is Eric, the boy she fell for in the first book. He has a girlfriend. Brashares sets this up as a test of whether Bridget will put someone else's relationship ahead of her own feelings, and she does, mostly. They are paired together as counsellors, so avoiding him is not an option.

They build a friendship, and then Bridget gets a high fever. Eric carries her to his cabin and stays with her. She wakes to find him holding her. She tries to slip out of his arms without making a sound, he wakes up, and he leaves camp for several days without explaining. It is a neat piece of character writing. Bridget reads the departure as a betrayal and stops competing for his attention. She pours herself into training her team instead, and her girls beat his team in the camp championship.

The reveal at the end is that Eric went back to New York to break up with his girlfriend because of Bridget. He tells her they were always meant to be, and they get back together. I wanted to believe that more than I did. The breakup happens offstage, which keeps the book clean, but it also means we never see him make the hard choice. The championship victory belongs to Bridget, and the romance comes to her as a reward for not asking. That rubbed me the wrong way.

Carmen, Good Carmen, and the baby

Carmen's section is the best of the four. Her mother Christina is pregnant, and Carmen is stuck looking after a cranky Valia while trying to work out where she belongs. She considers going to the University of Maryland instead of Williams, her first choice, so she can stay close to home. The fear underneath that is simple: what if her family moves on without her?

At the hospital with Valia she meets Win Sawyer, a college student who volunteers there. They are drawn to each other, and Carmen is careful about why. She calls the version of herself Win sees Good Carmen, and she is afraid he will not like the rest of her. That invention is so specific to a certain kind of anxious teenager that I laughed and then felt bad for her. She is not being coy. She believes there are two of her, and that only one is lovable.

Christina goes into labor four weeks early. Carmen calls Tibby to stay with her mother and asks Win to help her find her stepfather David, who is away on a work trip. The baby is born, a boy, and Carmen names him Ryan. In the aftermath Win and Carmen kiss and leave the hospital hand in hand. Carmen decides to go to Williams after all. She works out that Good Carmen is not a separate person but part of her, and she talks Lena's parents into letting Valia return to Greece.

That last act matters more than it sounds. Carmen spends the book taking care of a woman who makes her miserable, and she ends by arranging Valia's happiness anyway. It is the most generous thing any of the four does.

Naming the baby is the other quiet triumph in her section. Carmen chooses Ryan, and in doing so she steps into a role in the family that is not defined by being the daughter who might leave. She has been afraid of being replaced by a new child. Instead she becomes the person who welcomes him. The book does not dwell on the irony, which is a relief.

Win's role is smaller than the romance plot suggests. He is mostly a witness to Carmen being herself, and the point of him is that she cannot keep the two versions of herself apart once she cares about him. That is a better written relationship than Bridget and Eric's, because the reader sees Carmen take the risk. She lets him see the part of her that is tired and unfair and scared. He stays. The kiss at the hospital matters because of what came before it, not because of the setting.

What holds it together

The four stories do not connect as tightly as the ones in the first book. The passing of the pants is mentioned, but it is not the engine of the plot the way it was before. What holds the novel together is the shared situation: all four girls are standing at the edge of college and trying to decide which parts of themselves to keep. Brashares is good at the small embarrassments that come with that, and less good at resolving them cleanly.

Publishers Weekly praised the way each friend's struggle is spliced into the others, and also noted that a couple of the plot points strain belief. Eric's sudden appearance as a camp coach and his offstage breakup are the ones I would flag. The horn book criticism about spelled-out lessons is fair too. Several sections end with the character stating what she has worked out, as if the reader might miss it.

Still, the book understands something that a lot of books about teenagers get wrong. The girls do not need to be fixed. They need to be seen by the people around them, including by each other. Carmen's worry that her family will move on without her is the real subject of this novel, and it is answered not with a grand gesture but with a new baby, a name, and a decision to go away to college anyway. Two of the four films in the series draw on this book, and I can see why. It is the one where the friendship finally has to survive distance.

FAQ

When was Girls in Pants published?

Ann Brashares published it in 2005 with Delacorte Press. The hardcover runs 338 pages with ISBN 9780385729352.

Is it part of a series?

Yes. It is book three of the Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, following The Second Summer of the Sisterhood.

Which of the four girls gets the most attention?

Carmen's thread is the fullest, centered on her mother's pregnancy and her fear that the family will move on without her.