Cover of Dreamland by Sarah Dessen

Dreamland

2,823-word summary 13 min read 250 pages in the book

First published
2000
Publisher
Viking
Pages
250
ISBN
9780670891221
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. The sister who left on a birthday
  2. Trying on a new life at school
  3. Rogerson and the smell of a different world
  4. How the dream closes in
  5. The last afternoon at her own front door
  6. Evergreen, and the letters that arrive
  7. Where the book is strongest, and where it strains
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I came to Dreamland expecting one of Sarah Dessen's warm suburban novels, the kind with a quirky best friend and a summer job that changes everything. What I found was a much harder book. It was first published in September 2000 by Viking, a 250-page hardcover, and it follows a sixteen-year-old named Caitlin O'Koren through a year in which almost every kind of safety she has known falls away. Dessen had already written Keeping the Moon, and her readers knew her as a writer who took teenage feelings seriously. Here she took them somewhere darker. The book is still in print, and a paperback from Speak appeared in 2004, but the edition I read against is that original Viking one.

The story is told in three parts, and Dessen names them after the people Caitlin is trying to become or escape: Cass, Rogerson, and Me. That structure gives the book its shape. Each section is a version of Caitlin looking for a script to live by, and each one fails her in a different way before she can write her own.

The sister who left on a birthday

Caitlin has grown up in the long shadow of her older sister, Cassandra. Everyone calls her Cass. She is the one with straight As, the soccer star, the senior class president, the Homecoming Queen, the girl with a place at Yale already waiting. Caitlin is the other sister, the one on the B honor roll, the one who hears about Cass's achievements at the dinner table. Even her name is a kind of secondhand gift. Their mother's best friend is the next-door neighbor Boo Connell, whose real name is Katherine and who hates it, and Caitlin was named for Boo, the Irish version. Cass's name was always cooler, Caitlin notes, but being named after Boo meant something special, so she never argued. That small detail tells you a lot about how this girl sees herself: loved, but second.

Then, on Caitlin's birthday, Cass runs away. She does not go to Yale. She goes with her boyfriend Adam, and she disappears from the family's life without a proper explanation. Their mother, Margaret, is frantic at first and then consumed by grief. She tries to contact everyone Cass knew. She knows, as Caitlin does, who Cass ran off with, but knowing has not made it easier. In the weeks that follow, Margaret sinks into a depression that leaves her distracted and distant. She spends her afternoons in front of the television, watching a tabloid-style talk show that Adam works on, hoping for a glimpse of her daughter in the background. It is a painful little habit, and Dessen does not mock it. A desperate mother will take a glimpse however she can get one.

Next door, Boo and Stuart Connell offer a different model of how to live. Boo has been like a second mother to both girls, and Stuart is an artist. They are vegetarian hippies, warm and untidy, the opposite of the ambitious O'Korens. Caitlin has always found them odd and comforting in equal measure. When her own house goes quiet, the Connells' kitchen becomes one of the few places where someone is actually paying attention.

Before she left, Cass gave Caitlin a dream journal for her birthday. It is a slight, ordinary object, and it becomes the most important thing Caitlin owns. She starts writing in it as if she were talking to Cass, addressing her absent sister directly, pouring in the things she cannot say anywhere else. The journal is a lifeline and a hiding place at the same time. Dessen returns to it throughout the book, and it is the clearest sign of how badly Caitlin wants someone to listen.

Trying on a new life at school

With Cass gone and her mother adrift, Caitlin decides she needs to change something about herself. The first changes are small and suburban. The school year begins, she goes to parties with her friends, and she tries out for the cheerleading squad. Making the team is partly a bid for attention at home, a way to do the kind of thing that might make her parents look up. For a while it works a little. Caitlin gets a taste of being noticed, of having a role that is hers rather than Cass's.

There is a moment early on when the cheerleading cracks. During a stunt, Caitlin falls from the top of a pyramid of girls. She is not seriously hurt, but the fall shakes her. It is one of those incidents that does not change anything on the surface and yet leaves a person uneasy in her own skin. Caitlin keeps going through the motions, but the ground feels less solid than it did.

Her best friend, Rina Swain, is a popular cheerleader who pulls her toward the ordinary life of parties and school. Rina is one of the people who keeps trying to reach Caitlin even after Caitlin has started to slip away. For a long time, Caitlin thinks of herself as someone who is fine, someone who is simply trying new things. That is how the story gets its terrible momentum. Nothing announces itself as a fall.

Rogerson and the smell of a different world

Caitlin first sees Rogerson Biscoe at a gas station, and later he turns up at a party, bringing drugs for the other kids. He is not a student at her school. He is a fifth-year senior with a police record, a BMW and a small but thriving business selling pot. He is also charming, good-looking and entirely sure of himself. When he leaves the party, he invites Caitlin to come with him, and she goes.

This is the moment that many readers find hardest to accept. A girl who has just met a drug dealer gets into his car alone, and the story asks us to believe that she does it because it is something she has never done before and something Cass never did. Dessen explains it in Caitlin's own voice, and whether you buy it depends on how willing you are to accept that a lonely sixteen-year-old in a daze can make a choice that looks reckless from the outside. I found it strained, but I understood what it meant. Caitlin is not choosing Rogerson so much as choosing a life in which she is someone new.

At first the new life feels like freedom. Rogerson is attentive and fascinating. He says things no one at school says. He introduces her to smoking pot and to Corinna, a woman in her mid-twenties who went to the same high school as Caitlin and Cass. Corinna ran off with her boyfriend Dave, was disowned by her parents, and now lives in a small farmhouse. She is kind to Caitlin in a way that feels grown-up and dangerous at once. The two become best friends, and when Caitlin is not with Rogerson she is usually with Corinna, chain-smoking and talking.

Caitlin starts skipping school and cheerleading practice so that Rogerson will not have to wait when he comes to pick her up. It is the first clear sign that her life is being reorganized around his schedule. Her old friends drift off. She loses her place on the cheer squad. Her mother is still absorbed in her own grief and in that television show, so there is no one at home asking the questions that might stop her. Meanwhile, Caitlin keeps filling the dream journal, writing to the sister who is not there, describing a life that is getting harder to explain.

How the dream closes in

The relationship turns physical, and Caitlin later says that when she and Rogerson have sex it is the only time she feels safe. On Christmas Eve she finally agrees to sleep with him. That line is one of the saddest in the book, because it tells you how thoroughly she has come to measure safety by his moods. She is not happy in the way a girl in a romance is happy. She is relieved, briefly, because for a little while he is gentle.

Then he starts hitting her. The first time is in the car, when he is angry about something she has done. He hits her in the face. Afterward he apologizes for hours and is so careful with her that the apology feels like proof of love. A pattern sets in. He strikes her only where clothes will cover the mark, and Caitlin learns to dress accordingly. She hides the bruises. She retreats into a numb kind of isolation in which the beatings do not seem to register as anything unusual. This is the dreamland of the title, a gray state where she drifts through her own life and watches herself from a distance.

What Dessen does well here is show the logic from the inside. Caitlin does not stay because she is stupid. She stays because each violent episode is followed by a stretch of attention and tenderness, and because she has come to believe that this attention is all she has. The book makes a horrible kind of sense of her thinking. After a hit, she knows there will be a grace period, and she waits for it. She reaches for Rogerson through the pain, convinced that he loves her because he is sorry. It is hard reading, and it is the point.

Rogerson himself is not written as a flat monster. He is the son of a man who abuses him, and Dessen gives readers a small, reluctant measure of sympathy for him, as Kirkus noted when the book came out. That choice complicates the story without excusing him. He deals drugs because he can, he drives his BMW like he owns the town, and he uses people. His cruelty toward Caitlin is his own, even if the pattern began with his father.

Rina, meanwhile, keeps trying. She takes Caitlin out for a day of fun, a trip to her stepfather's lake house, hoping to pull her friend out of the haze. Caitlin goes, but she is terrified the whole time, because she knows Rogerson is waiting outside her own house. She keeps trying to call him and he never picks up. The day is ruined before it begins, not by anything Rina does but by the pull of a boy who has taught Caitlin to fear what happens when he is ignored.

The last afternoon at her own front door

Caitlin leaves the lake house and walks home. Rogerson is parked in front of her house. She gets into his car, and he is furious. The anger escalates into another beating, and this time he shoves her out of the car and keeps at her outside, in public. It is the moment the story has been building toward. Her mother comes out, shoves Rogerson away from her daughter and calls for help. A neighbor calls the police. Rogerson is arrested.

I want to be careful about how I describe what follows, because the book is clear about the outcome but not interested in a tidy courtroom payoff. What matters is that the spell breaks in the most public way possible. Caitlin has hidden the bruises for months, dressing to cover them and keeping her own counsel. Once the violence happens where other people can see it, the secret is no longer hers to keep. The family, which has been fractured since Cass left, finally has to act.

Accounts of the book differ on the exact occasion of that final confrontation, with one review placing it during a large family gathering at the house, but the core is the same in every telling: Rogerson's abuse becomes visible, Margaret intervenes physically, the police are called, and Caitlin is pulled out of the relationship by force rather than by her own decision. She is still crying for him as he is led away, which is the honest and uncomfortable part. Dessen does not pretend that an arrest instantly cures what months of abuse have done.

Evergreen, and the letters that arrive

Caitlin enters the Evergreen Rest Care Facility after Rogerson's arrest. She is there for drug addiction, for the pot and the chain-smoking and the habit of numbing herself, but the fuller problem is that she still loves him. Rehab is not presented as a quick fix. She starts counseling and improves slowly, in stages that feel believable rather than miraculous. The book spends real time on the ordinary work of getting better: talking, being alone with herself, learning to accept the people who have not given up on her.

Two letters arrive, and they are the emotional hinges of the recovery. The first is from Corinna, who has left Dave and moved to Arizona. She is trying to forget her past and hopes Caitlin will come see her someday. It is a note from someone who understood the farmhouse life, and it shows that a person can walk away from a bad arrangement, even if the walking away takes years. The second letter is from Cass. She explains that she never wanted to go to Yale. She was having a hard time and could not bear her parents' plans for her future, so she left to live a life she could choose. She stayed away because she knew that if her parents found her, they would try to bring her back.

That letter does something the family has not been able to do for itself. It gives Caitlin a way to understand her sister without waiting for her to come home, and it quietly reframes the whole opening of the book. Cass did not vanish because she stopped caring about Caitlin. She left for the same reason Caitlin is now in treatment: to escape a script written by other people. The parallel is not spelled out, and it does not need to be.

Rina brings one more piece of news. She ran into Rogerson at the Quick Zip, the local convenience store, and he brushed past her without speaking or looking her in the eye. Caitlin takes this in and realizes that she has to be ready for the next time she sees him. It is a small scene, but it marks the shift from being someone things happen to, to someone who can prepare herself.

At the end, Caitlin is released. Before she leaves, she takes a photograph of the new her. She compares it with an old photograph she once tore up and has since taped back together. That image of a damaged picture made whole again is about as explicit as Dessen gets. Her family throws a welcome-home party, and Cass is there as the special guest. The ending is hopeful without pretending that nothing happened.

Where the book is strongest, and where it strains

The great strength of Dreamland is its patience with a hard subject. Dessen wrote this years before teen books about dating violence were common, and School Library Journal's Karen Jensen has said it was the first book she read that dealt with relationship violence at all. The novel treats a girl's confusion as something to be understood rather than judged. It also understands the role of the parents. Cass's flight and Margaret's depression create the vacuum Rogerson fills, and the book is as much about parental pressure as it is about one bad boy.

There are real limits. Kirkus called the book intense and exhausting, and that is fair. The three-part structure, with the dream journal as a framing device, can feel deliberate in a way that shows the seams. Some readers have objected that Rogerson's control gives way to violence rather suddenly, when real abuse usually escalates in smaller steps, and that the book leans too heavily on physical blows as the proof that something is wrong. One recent reviewer also flagged dated elements, including casual cruelty toward people of lower means and language that has not aged well. Those are worth knowing before you hand this to a younger reader.

A few of the plot turns ask for a lot of trust. Caitlin leaving a party with Rogerson after a single conversation is the big one. The cheerleading accident and the sudden slide into a drug dealer's world can feel like doors swinging open too quickly. Yet the emotional logic holds. Dessen is not writing a cautionary pamphlet in which a sensible girl makes one bad choice. She is writing about how a person who already feels invisible can mistake being seen for being loved.

The last scene gives Caitlin a taped-together photograph and a house full of people who came back. I closed it wanting to know how she was doing a year later, which is probably the best thing a book like this can do.

FAQ

When was Dreamland first published and by whom?

It first appeared in September 2000 from Viking as a 250-page hardcover. A paperback edition from Speak followed in 2004.

Is Dreamland a typical Sarah Dessen romance?

Not quite. Reviewers describe it as much darker than her other books, centered on dating violence, drug use and recovery rather than a light romance.

Does Caitlin get out of the relationship?

Yes. After Rogerson beats her in public outside her house, he is arrested and she enters the Evergreen Rest Care Facility, where counseling begins her recovery.