Cover of Winter Street by Elin Hilderbrand

Winter Street

2,340-word summary 10 min read 256 pages in the book

First published
2014
Publisher
Little, Brown and Company
Pages
256
ISBN
9780316376112
Series
Winter (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (7 sections)
  1. Room 10
  2. The three older children
  3. Bart in Afghanistan
  4. Margaret comes home
  5. What the book does well, and where it strains
  6. Key takeaways
  7. FAQ

I came to Winter Street in the wrong season on purpose. It is a Christmas novel set on Nantucket, and I read it during a stretch of gray November days when the island in my head was either a summer postcard or nothing at all. Elin Hilderbrand published it on October 14, 2014 with Little, Brown and Company, and the first hardcover runs 256 pages. It was her first holiday book and the opening move of a four novel sequence that follows the same family through four Decembers. What surprised me was not the cozy setup but how fast she knocks it over. The inn is strung with garlands within a paragraph or two, and by the time the whole family has assembled somebody has already been found kissing the wrong person in Room 10.

That discovery is the engine of the book, and it is worth saying plainly because Hilderbrand uses it to pry open every other secret in the house. Winter Street is less a mystery than a family farce with real injuries underneath it. The Quinns love each other in the way families do when they have run out of ways to say it, and the holiday deadline forces all of them into the same rooms at the same time.

Room 10

Kelley Quinn owns the Winter Street Inn, a bed and breakfast on Nantucket that the family runs as a year round operation. He is in his sixties, easygoing, faintly vain about his innkeeping, and genuinely proud of his four grown children. He is also twice married. His first wife, Margaret, left when the marriage came apart while the children were still small, and the children themselves decided they wanted to stay on the island with Kelley. Margaret went on to become a celebrated news anchor, a life of travel and cameras and celebrity, and she never remarried. Kelley did. He married Mitzi, a former beauty queen whom everybody calls Mitzi the ditzy, and the two of them have spent twelve years running the inn together and raising a son, Bart.

The big event of their year is the Christmas Eve party, an enormous gathering that half the town seems to attend. Mitzi plans it down to the last sprig of evergreen, and she takes particular pleasure in dressing as Mrs. Claus. George, a family friend, plays Santa every year. On the afternoon of the party, Kelley goes looking for something in Room 10 and walks in on Mitzi and George kissing. It is not a quick peck. Mitzi has her bags packed. She tells Kelley she is leaving, and it comes out that the affair has been going on for the entire twelve years of their marriage.

Kelley falls into the exact tailspin you would expect. He posts on Facebook that the party is canceled. He drinks. He wanders the inn in a daze while the garlands hang and the mulled cider waits in the kitchen. The scene is funny and mean at once, and that mixture becomes the book's signature. Hilderbrand does not let the mistletoe soften the betrayal. She plants a cheating wife and a humiliated husband in the middle of a Christmas card and lets the colors clash. Mitzi is not written as a villain exactly, which is more unsettling. She is a woman who stopped wanting this life a long time ago and stayed for the inn and the son and the comfort of an arrangement nobody questioned.

The inn itself is almost a fifth character. It has hallways where people overhear each other, a kitchen where the staff sees everything, guest rooms that get pressed into service as hiding places, and a front desk where a raised voice carries. Hilderbrand clearly knows the rhythm of a small hotel in December, the deliveries and the complaints and the endless tightening of details before a crowd arrives. That physical knowledge is what makes the later chaos feel lived in rather than staged.

George deserves a note, because Hilderbrand gives him almost no interior life and that is precisely the joke. He is the neighbor who pulls on the red suit every year, the harmless man everyone waves at, and the affair has been hiding in plain sight in front of a houseful of people who prided themselves on noticing everything. Kelley's humiliation is sharpened by the fact that he handed George the costume himself. The party's Santa was never a stranger. He was a regular at the dinner table.

The three older children

A great deal of the novel is given over to the three children of Kelley's first marriage, each of whom arrives at the inn with a private disaster.

Patrick is the eldest. He runs a hedge fund, is married to Jen, and has three boys. He has also made a terrible call with twenty five million dollars of other people's money, and the Compliance Department and the Feds are now asking questions about his shady dealings. He tells Jen what he has done. She does not come to Nantucket for Christmas. She takes the boys to her parents in San Francisco instead. Patrick drinks and leans on Vicodin and feels thoroughly sorry for himself, and Hilderbrand plainly wants us to feel sorry for him too, guilty man though he is. I found this the strongest of the subplots, because it is the one where the consequences are real and cannot be fixed by a holiday toast. A broken marriage and a federal investigation are still waiting when the decorations come down.

Kevin, the middle child, tends bar at the inn. He married young, a woman named Norah Vale, and the divorce broke him badly enough that he swore off women altogether. Then he fell for Isabelle, the French housekeeper on the staff, and the two have been sleeping together in secret. Isabelle is pregnant, and Kevin wants to marry her. Of the three siblings, Kevin seems the most at home in the building, most at ease in the taproom and the kitchen, and his relationship with Isabelle is written with a steadiness that makes it the healthiest thing in the book. He is also the one who will take charge of wine and spirits when the party has to be rescued. His history with Norah gives him a wary gentleness, and the book lets him be happy in a quiet way that the other storylines rarely allow.

Ava teaches school and has been seeing Nathaniel Oscar for two years. He has no intention of committing, which appears obvious to everyone but her. Scott Skyler, the assistant principal at her school, is in love with her, and she feels nothing for him. The resulting triangle is less a passionate dilemma than a slow dawning, and Hilderbrand plays it for both comedy and a small genuine ache. Ava is the organizer of the family, the one who keeps the holiday machinery turning when the adults lose their grip. At one point she asks, half joking, whether anyone has a manual for dealing with a completely screwed up family situation. The line lands because she has been running that manual in her head for years.

The siblings' scenes together have a convincing shorthand. They bicker about the inn and about their father and about who is expected to do what. They share old grievances without fully explaining them, which is how siblings actually talk. Hilderbrand is at her best when she lets a room full of people be awkward together instead of resolving every exchange into a tidy confession.

She also understands that adult children never quite stop being children in their parents' house. Patrick arrives with the bearing of a man who runs a fund, and within a scene he is being treated like the boy who left his shoes in the hall. Ava slips back into the role of the reliable one without appearing to decide to. The inn assigns parts to people, and the novel is at its best when it notices how easily they step back into them.

Bart in Afghanistan

The fourth child is Bart, the only son of Kelley and Mitzi. He was a handful growing up, drinking and using drugs and smashing three cars before he turned seventeen. The Marine Corps straightened him out, or seemed to, and he is now stationed in Afghanistan, unreachable for Christmas. His absence is the quiet hole at the center of the book. People speak around him. Kelley worries in the way a father does when he cannot reach his child, and Mitzi's departure takes on a stranger cast when you remember where her son is.

Margaret, the ex wife, is in Hawaii on vacation when she hears a news report that forty four soldiers have gone missing. She immediately assumes Bart is one of them. She flies to Nantucket without telling anybody. This is the strand that gives the novel its real tension, because for several chapters the question of whether Bart is alive hangs over all the smaller romantic messes. Hilderbrand keeps it brief and refuses to milk it, which is the right call. The fear is present, it is sharp while it lasts, and then the book moves on rather than building a false climax around it.

Margaret comes home

Margaret arrives on Christmas morning and walks into the inn kitchen for a cup of coffee. Nobody knows she is in the house. Kelley is delighted to see her, and the years fall away quickly enough that their grown children start exchanging looks whenever their parents slip off for a private conversation. The reunion is the warmest thread in the book and also the most complicated, because they are divorced for reasons the novel does not pretend to erase. Hilderbrand lets the spark reignite without suggesting that a few days under the same roof repair a lifetime of separate lives. Margaret's career, which once pulled her around the world and helped end her marriage, is still the engine of her life. She cannot simply become the woman Kelley remembers.

The party itself is rescued by Ava. With Kelley posting cancellations online and Mitzi gone, she rebuilds the whole affair. She asks Scott to play Santa. Isabelle agrees to be Mrs. Santa. Ava and Isabelle take charge of the food while Kevin handles the drinks. Then Ava tries to play matchmaker, pushing Scott toward Isabelle, and discovers that watching the two of them together as Mr. and Mrs. Claus makes her jealous. That is when she admits to herself that her feelings for Scott may not be so empty after all. It is a tidy turn, and it arrives as a consequence of the party and the costumes rather than a speech about love.

The Christmas Eve scenes are the ones readers will likely remember. There is caroling that goes on longer than anyone wants, too much whiskey, food that has to be rescued at the last minute, and the particular chaos of a house full of adults who all believe they are the one holding it together. Hilderbrand stacks these moments with real skill. You can almost hear the piano in the next room and the ice in the glasses.

What the book does well, and where it strains

The publisher's description promises a love triangle, an unplanned pregnancy, a federal crime, a small house fire, a great deal of whiskey, and endless rounds of caroling. The book delivers on all of it, and that is both its pleasure and its problem. Hilderbrand is very good at the physical business of a family inn in December: the kitchen, the guest rooms, the staff, the wet boots in the hall, the bottles opened at odd hours, the way people who have known each other for decades can wound with a single remark at the dinner table. The dialogue has the speed of people who have heard the same excuses before and no longer have patience for them.

What strains is the engineering. The calamities arrive in sequence, almost as items being checked off a list, and some characters behave the way the plot needs rather than the way people do. Patrick's crisis and Bart's deployment carry more weight than the romantic entanglements, and the book never fully reconciles those two registers. The prose is plain to the point of flatness in places, with a habit of telling you how a character feels just after showing you. The final warmth feels dialed in rather than earned. If you want a holiday novel that trusts quiet moments and leaves room for silence, this one will strike you as too loud. If you want a big messy family comedy with carols and cocktails and a body count of revealed affairs, it knows exactly what it is doing.

Compared with Hilderbrand's Nantucket summer books, this one trades sun and rented cottages for closed curtains and a kitchen clock. Readers who come for the beach will find the cold weather a genuine change of setting rather than a costume. Readers who dislike the author's habit of giving every character a secret to reveal over a holiday meal will not find much here to change their minds.

There is also the matter of the series. Winter Street was followed by Winter Stroll, Winter Storms, and Winter Solstice, and the ending here is built to open doors rather than close them. Read on its own it still resolves the immediate questions about Mitzi and about Ava's love life, but several threads are clearly being kept warm for later books. That is fair enough in a sequence, though it does leave this installment feeling slightly provisional.

By the last pages, the party has happened, the truth about Mitzi and George is out, and the Quinns are still the Quinns. The inn stands on Winter Street with its lights on and its rooms full of people who have no intention of behaving differently next year. Nobody has been fixed. Hilderbrand seems content with that, and the book is better for it.

FAQ

When was Winter Street published?

It was published on October 14, 2014 by Little, Brown and Company. The first hardcover runs 256 pages.

Is Winter Street part of a series?

Yes. It is book 1 of the Winter series, followed by Winter Stroll, Winter Storms, and Winter Solstice.

Do I need to read the other Winter books first?

No. The Quinn family and this Christmas at the inn are self contained, though later books continue their stories.