Cover of Breathe by Abbi Glines

Breathe

2,983-word summary 13 min read 352 pages in the book

First published
2011
Publisher
Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers
Pages
352
ISBN
9781442488694
Series
Sea Breeze (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A job she never asked for
  2. The boy behind the guitars
  3. When the summer stops being private
  4. The breakup and the long fall
  5. The coma and the return
  6. What works, and what grates
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked this one up because a friend described it as the book that made her miss a whole summer of sleep, and because it kept turning up in recommendations whenever I browsed new adult romance. I expected a sunny beach read about a rich boy and a working girl. What I found was a book with a surprisingly hard center: a seventeen-year-old who has been parenting her own mother for years, and a famous musician who is desperate to be treated like a person instead of a product. Breathe first appeared on its own in 2011, published independently by Wild Child Publishing on 16 May, before Simon & Schuster picked it up and reissued it on 4 June 2013 as the opening volume of the Sea Breeze series. The edition I read is the 352-page Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers trade paperback, ISBN 9781442488694. Knowing that history helps explain the book's split personality, part self-published urgency and part polished mainstream romance.

A job she never asked for

Sadie White is seventeen and tired in a way teenagers should not have to be tired. Her mother, Jessica, was a beauty queen in Arkansas who got pregnant by a married man in Nashville, never received any support, and eventually drifted to the coast of southern Alabama with Sadie in tow. Now Jessica is pregnant again, by another man who has no intention of sticking around, and she has stopped pretending she can hold down the housekeeping job that keeps a roof over their heads. She simply sends Sadie in her place.

That is the engine of the whole story. Sadie is not looking for adventure or a summer fling. She is looking for money to pay the bills, cook the dinner, and keep the lights on. She shows up at a mansion on a private island off Sea Breeze, Alabama, and meets Ms. Mary, the stern but warm head of the household staff, who gives her a one-day trial. Sadie works so hard that Ms. Mary keeps her on for the summer. The job comes with rules, the most important being that the owner's privacy is absolute and any breach means instant dismissal.

The owner, Sadie soon learns, is Jax Stone, one of the biggest teen rock stars in the world. He has just come off a punishing concert tour, and wants nothing more than to disappear into his family's summer house. Glines does a clean job of making the island feel like a separate country, a place of service corridors and gates where ordinary Alabama life sits just across the water. Sadie moves through it as someone who is not quite a guest and not quite staff, and that in-between position is exactly what makes her interesting to the people who work and live there.

The opening chapters split between Jax and Sadie, and the contrast is the point. Jax arrives at the end of a tour, already sick of the screaming fans and the relentless schedule, and he announces that he plans to stay the whole summer rather than the few weeks his mother and agent expected. His younger brother Jason is the only person he trusts, and the two of them share a version of the same complaint: their mother tries to manage their lives long after she has any right to. Sadie, meanwhile, is standing in a kitchen in her mother's place, already used to being the grown-up in a house run by a childish adult. Both of them are trapped by the roles other people have assigned them. The romance works because each one recognizes that struggle in the other before either of them knows the other's name.

The boy behind the guitars

Their first real encounter happens while Sadie is cleaning Jax's bedroom. She finds childhood Little League jerseys and a wall of guitars, including the small worn instrument that started his career, and she is hurrying to leave before the family arrives when she turns and finds Jax watching her with an amused smile. It could have been a humiliating moment. Instead it sets the tone for everything between them, because Sadie does not gush, faint, or ask for an autograph. She is annoyed that a famous person might get her fired.

That evening she serves dinner alongside Marcus Hardy, a friendly college student who has worked at the house for several summers, and Ms. Mary's other staff members fill out the household. When Jax's mother retires for the night, Sadie serves Jax dessert alone. He assumes she has planted herself in the house as a fan, and she explains that she took the job to pay rent. That answer clearly surprises him. He says he wants a friend who does not care about his fame, and Sadie admits she has never really had a friend at all. It is a small exchange, but it is the foundation of the book. Jax is famous and lonely. Sadie is invisible and lonely. Neither has much practice being known.

Jax resolves to keep his distance after that, and he spends several days watching her from his window instead of going to find her. Glines lets that restraint sit for a while, which gives the slow burn room to breathe. Marcus, in the meantime, pulls Sadie into his circle of friends and gives her a first taste of ordinary teenage socializing. She has always been too busy for this kind of thing. The scenes with the household staff, with Marcus's younger sister Amanda, with Kane the bodyguard and driver, and with an elderly gardener who becomes her chess partner, are the warmest and easiest passages in the book. They give Sadie something like a family, which is exactly what she has been missing.

The moment Jax stops holding back comes on a walk along the private beach. Sadie tells him about her absent father and about being the sole provider at home. Later, at a grocery store, a little girl recognizes Jax, and he kneels to sign autographs and arrange backstage passes after learning that the girl's father was killed overseas. Sadie watches this and is moved to tears, and it is one of the few times the book shows rather than tells you why Jax is worth knowing. He can be ornery and controlling, but his kindness is real when it matters.

When the summer stops being private

From there the relationship moves quickly, and the book picks up speed with it. At a party Jax hosts, a guest grabs Sadie's arm too hard and Jax intervenes in a fury. He shows her tabloid magazines about his own life and tells her she is "everything I write about in my songs but can never have" (92). A few days later he interrupts just as Marcus is about to tell Sadie how he feels about her, admits he is jealous, and asks her to spend the summer with him. She whispers that she wants whatever part of him she can have. It is a yielding kind of confession, and it foreshadows the imbalance that will hurt them both later.

Once they are together, Jax shows up for breakfast every morning, plays guitar for her, and gives her an iPod loaded with his music. When he offers to pay her family's bills, she refuses flatly, insisting she has to earn her own money. That refusal is the best thing Sadie does in the first half of the book. It keeps her from becoming a charity case in her own love story, and it is consistent with the girl who has been scrubbing floors to keep the lights on. Their first kiss comes during a private movie screening Jax arranges, a gesture that is sweet and also a little grand, the sort of thing a very rich person does when he does not know how else to say he cares.

The first crack arrives when Star Holloway, a pop star the tabloids have long linked to Jax, turns up unannounced and Jax spends a whole day consoling her through a heartbreak without coming to find Sadie. Marcus fills Sadie in on the tabloid history, and she is hurt. Jax explains that Star has always been only a friend, and they reconcile. The scene matters because it is the first time Sadie has to decide whether to trust her own reading of events or the story the media has written for her. At a Fourth of July party, Jax accompanies her publicly for the first time, they dance on the moonlit beach, and back at the mansion they finally sleep together. They exchange declarations of love afterward, and for a chapter or two the book gives you the payoff it has been promising.

Then the photography starts. Publicity shots of Jax with actress Bailey Kirk, arranged by her publicist to promote a film, reach Sadie through Marcus, and she is devastated. Overcome by his own feelings, Marcus kisses her, and she pushes him away. Jax's brother Jason sees the kiss from a window and calls his brother. Jax explains about the staged shoot and is furious, and Marcus quits before he can be fired. The scene is melodramatic in the way this genre often is, with everyone arriving at exactly the wrong moment, but it also makes clear that Marcus has become a real third point in this triangle. His feelings are not a plot device. He has been Sadie's friend when no one else was, and that history gives the kiss weight.

The breakup and the long fall

The real damage is done by photographs from the Fourth of July party that find their way into national media. Coverage paints Sadie as a gold-digging maid or a naive girl used by a rock star, and the coverage does not care which version is true. In a painful conversation, Jax tells her that his life and hers do not fit, that the scrutiny will never stop, and that love is not enough. He asks her to get out of the car. His bodyguard Kane opens the door, Sadie stumbles back to her apartment, and she collapses into Jessica's arms. Jax leaves Sea Breeze. Jason tries to stop him and says Sadie brought back the real Jax, but he cannot stay.

This is where the book becomes more than the beach romance on the cover. Sadie retreats to her bedroom and refuses to eat or move for days. Jessica calls Marcus, who climbs through Sadie's window, coaxes her to drink water and eat something, and walks her down to the beach. Ms. Mary gets her a filing job at a local lawyer's office. A few days later Sadie hears Jax's new number one single, "Don't Cry," on the radio and recognizes chords he composed in the gazebo while they were together. It is a neat bit of plotting, the song as a message she can receive even when he will not say the words to her face.

Then Jessica gives birth weeks early to a boy she names Sam. Sadie falls in love with him instantly, which is the most convincing thing in this stretch of the novel. She is the responsible one again, and this time the responsibility is a baby she actually wants to protect. Sam develops colic and cries through the night, and Sadie takes every evening shift while Jessica sinks into postpartum depression, neglecting feedings and handing the baby over the moment Sadie gets home. Marcus leaves for college. School starts, and Sadie is treated as a local curiosity, with students asking for autographs and one jealous classmate shoving a magazine photo of Jax with another girl in her face. Amanda tells her she has to toughen up. Between school, work, and full-time care of Sam, Sadie runs on almost no sleep, and eventually her body gives out. She faints on her bike, cracks her skull on the pavement, and falls into a coma.

I found this section harder to read than the romance, and I mean that as a compliment. Glines does not dress up Sadie's exhaustion as a character flaw or a lesson about overachieving. This is what happens when a seventeen-year-old is doing three jobs without adult help. The postpartum depression is handled plainly too. Jessica is not villainized for being ill, and the book lets Sadie resent her and love her at the same time, which is closer to the truth of that situation than most fiction manages.

The coma and the return

Ms. Mary calls Jax, and he flies to Sea Breeze. He refuses to leave Sadie's bedside for a week, singing to her for hours each day. After seven days she squeezes his hand and opens her eyes. He explains that Sam is safe with Ms. Mary and that Jessica has been admitted to a clinic for postpartum depression treatment at his expense. It is the moment the book has been building toward, and Jax earns it by simply staying. He tells Sadie he can never walk away again. He will come back one week every month while she finishes her senior year, and Kane will drive her to school each day.

Marcus visits and admits he has let go of most of his resentment after seeing how devoted Jax has been. That matters, because it lets the ending avoid the easy move of making the rival disappear. Marcus keeps his place in Sadie's life as a friend, and the book is better for it. Jax, for his part, is no longer the boy who asked her to get out of a car. He has done the one thing he claimed he could not do, which was to choose her in public and in private, repeatedly, when it cost him something.

At the homecoming dance, Jax surprises Sadie by leaving a concert early and showing up in person. They dance, then walk down to the beach, where he tells her that when she graduates he intends to take her with him. Sadie says she wants to attend college in California to be near him, and he promises to make it happen. He tells her she is his present and his future, and they leave the dance together, stepping toward a life they have planned in the same sentence. It is a soft landing after a very hard stretch, and the book ends on it without pretending that all the practical problems between them have been solved.

What works, and what grates

The title makes sense only at the end. Breathe is about who gets to relax enough to take a breath, and who is always holding one in for somebody else. Sadie spends most of the book holding her breath for her mother, then for Sam, then for a relationship that could be taken away by a photographer. Jax holds his for the cameras, and for the moment he thinks he has to push her away to keep her safe. When they finally stand on the beach talking about college, both of them are breathing for the first time in a long while. Glines is not subtle about this, but the image is there in the text from the first page, and the payoff is earned.

The book's greatest strength is Sadie herself. She is practical to a fault, funny in a dry way, and stubborn about money in a way that makes her more than a love interest. The household around her is drawn with real care, from Ms. Mary's rules to Amanda's blunt advice to the gardener who plays chess with her. Even Jessica, who does very little to deserve sympathy early on, is given a history and an illness that complicate her. Jax is harder to admire. He watches Sadie from a window before they have spoken properly, he tells her what is best for her, and he breaks up with her in a car. The book asks you to forgive all of that because he is lonely and famous and comes back at the end. Some readers will accept that trade. I accepted it, but with reservations.

Those reservations grow in the middle chapters. The misunderstandings run long, especially the ones involving Star Holloway and Bailey Kirk, and both could have been cleared up with one honest conversation. That is a common weakness of the genre, but here it is made worse by how competent Sadie is everywhere else. A girl who manages bills, a household, and later a newborn should be able to ask a direct question. The pacing also tilts heavily toward the melodramatic, with phone calls at windows, tabloid reveals, a fainting spell, and a coma arriving in fairly quick succession. The last third of the book is so packed with crisis that the quieter moments of the relationship, the ones that made me believe in Jax in the first place, get squeezed out.

I would hand this to a reader who likes their romance with real obstacles and does not mind a few contrivances along the way. The Sea Breeze books are interconnected, and this one sets up the town and the circle of friends that later books draw on, so it is the right place to start. I would be more careful recommending it to someone who wants a clean, contemporary love story with emotionally fluent leads. Jax and Sadie both say the wrong thing at the wrong time, and the book sometimes mistakes intensity for intimacy. Even so, the core of it holds. A tired girl takes a job she never wanted, meets a boy who has everything she does not, and the two of them work out that being known is worth the trouble that comes with it. That is a sturdy story, and Glines tells it with enough warmth to carry the weaker stretches.

FAQ

When was Breathe first published?

It first appeared independently through Wild Child Publishing on 16 May 2011, then Simon & Schuster reissued it on 4 June 2013. This post cites the 352-page Simon & Schuster trade paperback, ISBN 9781442488694.

Is Breathe part of a series?

Yes. It is book one of the Sea Breeze series, set in a fictional coastal Alabama town, and it introduces the household staff and friends that later books follow.

Does Breathe have a happy ending?

It does, after a painful breakup, Sadie's coma, and her mother's postpartum illness. Jax returns, promises regular visits during Sadie's senior year, and the two leave the homecoming dance together with a plan for college in California.