Cover of Pretty Things by Janelle Brown

Pretty Things

2,725-word summary 12 min read 478 pages in the book

First published
2020
Publisher
Random House
Pages
478
ISBN
9780525479123
Reading options
What's inside (10 sections)
  1. A grifter with rules and a sick mother
  2. The girl who was run out of Tahoe
  3. Vanessa and the life she performs
  4. The con moves into the cottage
  5. Vanessa takes control of the game
  6. A mother's confession and the truth about the cancer
  7. The yacht, the oar, and the lake
  8. What the ending leaves behind
  9. Key takeaways
  10. FAQ

The book opens with a body going into Lake Tahoe. It sinks into the cold water and does not come back up, and for a long while you have no idea whose it is or how it got there. Only after several hundred pages, once you have lived inside two very different women's heads, does that first scene resolve into something you can name. Pretty Things was published in 2020 by Random House, and it looks at first like a sleek caper about con artists and social media. It turns into something harsher and more interesting, a book about class resentment and the way a life built for an audience can swallow the person living it.

A grifter with rules and a sick mother

Nina Ross makes her living by studying rich people online. She follows their accounts, notes what they own and where they keep it, and turns up at the right clubs at the right time. Her targets are young men with more money than sense, the sons of oligarchs and heirs who post every possession for anyone to see. She seduces them, drugs them, and drives them back to their mansions with her boyfriend Lachlan O'Malley, a charming Irishman who helps her strip the place. Her art history degree, useless in the ordinary job market, turns out to be excellent training for recognizing valuable furniture and jewelry.

She has rules, and she states them plainly. Take only what will not be missed. Never get greedy. Steal only from people who can afford it. The rules are what let her sleep at night, the line she draws between being a common criminal and being someone who is merely settling a score. What drives her toward the big score is her mother. Lily Ross was a con artist before Nina was, a woman who used her looks and her nerve to keep a roof over both their heads in an East Los Angeles bungalow. Now Lily has cancer, the experimental treatment is not covered by insurance, and the bills keep climbing. Nina loves her mother fiercely and resentfully at the same time, and she will do almost anything to pay for the treatment.

The con she settles on is personal. Nina knows the Liebling family, knows the layout of their Tahoe estate and the habits of its members, and knows a detail that most outsiders would never guess: the family kept a million dollars in a safe inside the house, and the combination was the birthday of the son, Benny. If the money is still there, it solves everything. It buys Lily's treatment, gets Nina out of Los Angeles before the police catch up with her, and lets her finally even an old score with the people who ruined her life. Lachlan is willing. The only obstacle is getting inside.

The girl who was run out of Tahoe

To understand why Nina wants revenge, the book doubles back more than a decade. As a teenager she was sent to Lake Tahoe so she could attend a prestigious prep school, the kind that feeds into Ivy League colleges and bright careers. A teacher saw her potential and helped arrange financial aid. Her mother took a job at a casino and pretended to be a woman with an ordinary, steady life. For a while it almost worked. Nina studied hard, and she became close to Benny Liebling, the odd, withdrawn son of the family who owned the local real estate fortune.

Benny had mental health problems that his father treated with a mixture of fear and contempt. William Liebling, the head of the family, was an imposing man who ran the Liebling Group, a San Francisco real estate investment firm, and he had no patience for a son who did not fit the mold. When he found Nina and Benny in bed together, he did not merely separate them. He ran Nina and her mother out of town. The episode ended Nina's chance at the life her mother had dreamed of for her. She went to an ordinary college instead, graduated with a degree in art history and a pile of student loans, and ended up as a third assistant to an interior designer who decorated vacation homes in the Hamptons.

That is the wound the novel keeps returning to. Nina wants more than the Lieblings' money. She wants them to understand what they took from her, and she has spent years building a story in which the Lieblings are the villains and she is the girl they discarded. Brown is careful to show both sides of that story. Nina's grievance is real, but so is the fact that she has polished it into a weapon she can use whenever she needs to excuse a bad decision. Her anger is genuine and also useful to her, and the book never lets her off the hook for it.

Vanessa and the life she performs

Vanessa Liebling is Nina's mirror and, for much of the novel, her enemy. She grew up with the kind of money that never has to think about itself. The Liebling Group made the family fortune in California real estate, and Stonehaven, the sprawling, dark mansion on the west shore of Lake Tahoe, is full of ancestral portraits and antiques and the kind of history that cannot be bought. Vanessa never quite believed she had anything substantial inside her. She admits as much to herself. What she had was the family name and a face that photographed well, and she turned those into a career as an Instagram influencer with roughly half a million followers.

Her feed is a triumph of staging. She travels, accepts free clothes and products, and poses in exotic places, all managed with a photographer who makes sure each image fits a cohesive and desirable brand. She understands exactly what her generation requires, which is the ability to perform authenticity convincingly even when the inner life is anything but authentic. The followers see the envy-inducing surface. They do not see what happened behind it. Her mother Judith died by suicide. Her brother Benny was diagnosed with schizophrenia and was placed in an institution. Her father died of cancer. Her fiance left her two weeks later, worried she would not make the right kind of wife for an up-and-coming politician.

Now Vanessa is nearly broke, alone, and back at Stonehaven, which she both loves and resents. The house costs a fortune to maintain, and she needs income, so she turns the caretaker's cottage into a rental. This is the door Nina needs. When a young couple calling themselves Ashley Smith and Michael O'Brien book the cottage, Vanessa has no reason to turn them away. Ashley is a yoga instructor with a calm, soothing manner. Michael is a writer and professor with a cultivated air. They seem like exactly the sort of people who would appreciate the view and the quiet.

The con moves into the cottage

Nina and Lachlan get to work. They plant cameras around Stonehaven, learn the routines of the house, and hunt for the safe. The plan is to take the cash and then, if all goes well, come back for the valuables. What complicates it is Vanessa herself. Up close she is not the smug cartoon Nina expected. She is lonely and unguarded, and when she starts confiding in Ashley about her family's tragedies, Nina finds herself seeing a person rather than a target. The woman on the social media feed and the woman sitting across the table in the big, cold house are not the same.

Lachlan notices the softening and tells Nina to toughen up. He is the practical one, the one who keeps his eye on the money and has no patience for sympathy with a mark. The tension between them becomes one of the quiet engines of the book. Nina is a grifter who has begun to doubt her own story, and her partner in crime is the person least interested in letting her doubt it.

When Nina finally opens the safe, there is no million dollars inside. There is only a letter from her mother. Lily, it turns out, had an affair with William Liebling and tried to blackmail him for five hundred thousand dollars. The revelation detonates everything Nina thought she knew. The family that supposedly destroyed her mother may have been destroyed by her mother in turn, and the woman Nina has been casting as a villain is another person who was used and discarded. Nina goes home to Los Angeles to confront Lily, leaving the con hanging in the balance.

Vanessa takes control of the game

Vanessa is not as naive as Nina assumed. A comment from Benny on one of Ashley's Instagram posts gives her the first thread, and an old photograph makes the resemblance impossible to ignore. She finds her mother's diaries in the house, pages in which Judith links her despair and her suicide to William's affair with a woman named Lily. Vanessa puts two and two together and realizes exactly who Ashley really is. What she does next is more brutal than anything Nina planned. She does not expose Ashley. She keeps the knowledge to herself, tells Michael that Ashley is Nina Ross, and then marries Michael in a small Reno chapel less than three weeks after meeting him.

She does not tell him she is pregnant, and she does not tell him that most of her money is gone. She wants to rescue Michael from Nina, take everything Nina had, and build the family she has always wanted. Benny questions the impulsive marriage, and that doubt sends Vanessa investigating her new husband. The more she looks, the more question marks appear. Michael has an answer for everything, and when she calls the police to report that her husband is a fraud, the detective laughs at her and hangs up. She begins to suspect she has married the wrong man entirely.

Meanwhile Lily confesses to Nina. Yes, she had the affair, and yes, she was in the room when William caught Nina and Benny together. Nina absorbs the fact that Vanessa never deserved to be targeted, and she decides to call off the grift. Before she can, the police arrest her. Lachlan tipped them off, using the name of Alexi Petrov, the Russian oligarch's son Nina robbed in the opening scenes. Nina sits in jail charged with grand theft, unable to sleep, with bail set at eighty thousand dollars. It is Vanessa who posts it, because she wants answers about Michael more than she wants revenge.

A mother's confession and the truth about the cancer

Out of jail, Nina and Vanessa break into Lachlan's apartment together. What they find explains almost everything. There is a shoebox full of cell phones, oatmeal boxes stuffed with cash, and a birth certificate showing that Lachlan's real name is Michael O'Brien, born in Washington in 1980. He used his real name with Vanessa. There are other women on the phones, other marks he has cleaned out. Nina takes Vanessa to see her mother, and the last and worst revelation waits on the porch.

Lily's cancer is gone. She has been in remission for a year, and Nina's careful examination of the scans shows dates that have been rubbed out. Lily admits the whole scheme. Lachlan used her to find women to con, and when the treatments were not covered, she offered him her own daughter. When the tests came back negative, she lied because she liked having Nina at home and because one last big score seemed worth having. She kept track of the Lieblings and pushed Lachlan toward Stonehaven, and even the earlier police scare that sent Nina running to Tahoe was a fiction. Getting arrested this time was not part of the plan. Lachlan panicked and called the police himself.

It is a nasty piece of writing, because Nina's motive for the entire novel turns out to have been manufactured by the person she was trying to save. Her mother did not need the money. The cancer was a story she told to get her daughter to commit a crime. Nina has spent the book telling herself she made her own choices, and here is the woman who taught her to con people proving that she was a mark all along.

The yacht, the oar, and the lake

The ending pulls the threads together on Michael's boat. Vanessa confronts him at Stonehaven, and Nina walks in with a pistol from the games room. Nina tells Michael she wants in on his con and threatens to go to the police if he refuses. He assumes she is greedy and desperate and tells her there is nothing left to take, because Vanessa is broke. Vanessa counters that there is money in the safe on her mother's yacht, the Judybird. On the water, Michael explains his plan at last. He intends to make Vanessa rewrite her will leaving him everything, then kill her and let it look like suicide, which given her family history no one would question.

What follows is a reversal that turns the predator into the prey. With Nina apparently holding the gun on Vanessa, Michael is sent down to the safe with the combination. The moment he is below, Nina kicks him and the two women jam an oar through the door handle and lock him in. Vanessa takes the boat out across the lake while Michael screams and beats on the door. Nina has been on Vanessa's side the whole time, and the plan was hatched back at the Chateau Marmont, where the two women decided that going to the police would only create another Liebling scandal. They offer Michael a chance to disappear. When he grabs his passport and throws it overboard and Nina slips trying to catch it, he gets the gun and fires. There are no bullets. Vanessa brings an oar down on his head, and the two of them dispose of his body in the water, which brings the novel back to the corpse in the opening scene.

What the ending leaves behind

In the epilogue Vanessa uses the cash from the oatmeal boxes to hire an expensive lawyer, and Nina receives a light sentence. Six weeks after Vanessa's daughter is born, the baby named Judith but called Daisy, Nina comes back to Stonehaven. Vanessa hires her as an archivist to catalog the objects in the house, pays her very little, and lets her live there. Benny is there too, drawing and reading to Daisy, and he and Nina have a quiet conversation and hold hands. The three of them have made something like a family, one built on the fact that they finally know one another's whole stories.

Vanessa has become a mommy blogger and is planning a line of children's clothes. She tells her followers the baby came from a sperm donor. Nina notes dryly that from the outside, nobody looking at the feed would ever guess that the two of them killed Daisy's father and dropped his body in the lake. That last beat is the book's final word on social media, and it is deliberately unsettled. Vanessa is still performing, still shaping a story for an audience, but now she knows exactly what the performance is hiding.

The novel is not without its faults. At close to five hundred pages it drags in the middle, and the long blocks devoted to first one woman's perspective and then the other's repeat events you have already seen. Several of the twists are telegraphed well before they arrive, and the resolution on the yacht is tidy in a way the rest of the book has not earned. Nina's grievances sometimes feel thin for all the damage they are supposed to justify, and a reader looking for a relentless thriller may find the social media satire a better description of what is on offer. That said, the two narrators are vivid company, the moral lines stay pleasingly blurred, and Stonehaven itself works as a gloomy, atmospheric presence. Brown is best when she is showing how two people can each be entirely sincere and entirely wrong, and Pretty Things is at its strongest when it refuses to tell you which woman deserves your loyalty.

FAQ

What is Pretty Things about?

It is a 2020 Random House novel about Nina Ross, a con artist who plots to rob a wealthy Instagram influencer at her family's Lake Tahoe mansion, only to find that the two women share an old and painful history.

Is Pretty Things a thriller or a mystery?

It is usually shelved as a suspense novel or psychological thriller, but a large part of it is a character study and a satire of social media, and some readers find it less action driven than the thriller label suggests.

Do the two main women ever reach an understanding?

Yes. After a violent confrontation on Vanessa's yacht, Nina and Vanessa stop deceiving each other and end up living together at Stonehaven with Vanessa's brother and baby daughter as something like a family.