Cover of You Are Not Alone by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen

You Are Not Alone

2,588-word summary 12 min read 352 pages in the book

First published
2020
Publisher
St. Martin's Press
Pages
352
ISBN
9781250202031
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A death in the subway
  2. The circle around the Moore sisters
  3. Becoming Amanda
  4. Who was really in charge
  5. The platform and what comes after
  6. What stayed with me
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked this one up because a friend kept insisting the last twenty pages were worth putting up with the rest for. She was right about the ending, though I would not call everything before it a slog exactly. This is the third novel Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen wrote together. St. Martin's Press published it on 3 March 2020, and the hardcover runs 352 pages. It arrived with a fair amount of noise around it, a New York Times bestseller and a Goodreads Choice Award nomination for best mystery and thriller, and the line about a woman who would die for her friends to like her stuck with me. I wanted to see how far the authors would push that idea. What I found was a book that opens with a real jolt of grief and then spends most of its length playing a long, careful game of cat and mouse.

The story belongs to Shay Miller, a young woman in New York whose life has quietly shrunk. Her job goes nowhere, her love life is empty, and her few friendships have thinned out until most of her evenings are spent alone. The authors do not spend pages building a case for how unhappy she is. They give her small, ordinary details and let the reader fill in the rest. She wants to be needed by somebody. That hunger is the hinge the whole book turns on, and it is the reason the ending lands harder than it otherwise might.

A death in the subway

The opening scene is the best thing in the book. Shay is in a subway station when she notices a woman standing near the edge of the platform. The woman looks at her, and Shay looks back. A moment later the woman steps in front of an oncoming train. It is sudden and blunt, with no warning and no time for Shay to do anything, and the authors never soften it. The woman's name turns out to be Amanda Evinger, and Shay learns it from the detective who questions her at the scene.

What follows is a kind of grief without a relationship to justify it. Shay did not know Amanda. She saw her for a few seconds. Yet she cannot let the image go, and she starts gathering everything she can find about a stranger who died in front of her. That fixation is strange, and the book treats it as strange rather than as a sweet impulse toward connection. Shay attends Amanda's memorial service, which is where her life takes its turn.

At the service she meets two sisters, Cassandra and Jane Moore. They are polished, warm, and seemingly eager to talk about the woman who died. They seem to understand Amanda in a way Shay does not, and they treat Shay as though she belongs in the conversation. For someone as lonely as Shay, the attention is almost overwhelming. She wants to impress them. She wants them to call her again. The authors are very good at showing how quickly a person who feels invisible can be won over by simple, focused attention.

There is a catch that Shay cannot see yet. Cassandra and Jane did not organize the memorial to mourn. They organized it to watch who showed up and to find out whether anyone knew more about Amanda than they did. They are worried that Amanda spoke out of turn. When Shay appears, they cannot work out how she knew the dead woman, so they decide to keep her close and find out what she knows.

The circle around the Moore sisters

Once the sisters take Shay under their wing, the book shifts into a different gear. Things improve for her in ways that feel almost too good. They help her find a house sitting job when she needs a place to stay. They give her a makeover that changes how she carries herself and makes her feel confident for the first time in years. They bring her into a social life that had stopped existing. She downloads a dating app and matches with someone promising. A headhunter contacts her on LinkedIn with a job that sounds like the break she has been waiting for. Shay reads all of this as proof that her luck has turned.

The book then starts pulling back the curtain on the people around the sisters. Cassandra and Jane move in a small circle of women, and the authors give each of them a history that explains why they are there. Daphne owns a chic boutique and survived a sexual assault. Beth is a public defender whose husband left her after her cancer diagnosis. Stacey is a computer whiz with a troubled past who was arrested after attacking a serial child abuser. Valerie works for the sisters in a do it all capacity, running errands and handling problems, and she appears under several different names depending on who she is talking to.

These women are not simply friends. They practice a rough kind of vigilante justice, and the sisters are the ones who recruit them. They get Stacey legal help after her arrest and then help her punish the man she attacked. They help Beth humiliate the husband who walked away when she was sick. They kill Daphne's rapist, a man named James Anders, who was found dead on a park bench two months before the book begins. Each of these acts is framed by the women as a favor, a way of settling a score that the law would not settle for them. Shay hears pieces of this and files them away without understanding what they add up to.

The structure of the novel is worth noting here. The present day story of Shay being drawn in is interrupted by chapters set in the past, told from the point of view of Amanda, Stacey, Beth, Daphne, and eventually Valerie. These flashbacks are how the authors do their slow reveal. At first they read as background on the supporting cast. Later they turn into the engine of the plot, because the things these women did are the things Shay will be framed for.

Becoming Amanda

The turn that made me sit up involves the makeover. Shay eventually looks in the mirror and realizes that the women have styled her to look like Amanda Evinger. Not vaguely like her. Like her. The hair, the clothes, the whole presentation have been arranged to turn Shay into a double of the woman who died in the subway. That detail is planted so casually that I missed it on a first pass, and going back it reframes every kind gesture the sisters made.

Shay finds an apartment listing online that turns out to be Amanda's old studio. With the sisters' encouragement, she moves in. In the mailbox she finds a package containing a bloody towel and a scalpel. She does not know what to make of it, and the authors let her sit with the discomfort instead of explaining it away. A few nights later Cassandra and Jane come over for drinks. Shay wakes up groggy, convinced she has been drugged, to find police officers in her apartment. The towel and the scalpel are lying on the floor. So are a watch and a wallet she has never seen before.

The police take her to the station for questioning. Detective Williams asks her to explain what happened, and Shay genuinely cannot. She has no memory of anything after her guests arrived. She calls Cassandra and Jane, expecting them to help, and instead they tell her coldly to stop stalking them. That phone call is where the warmth drains out of the book. The two women who made Shay feel seen now treat her as a problem to be shut down, and the reader finally sees how much of their kindness was a performance.

From here Shay stops being a character who is carried along and becomes a character who investigates. She goes for a run to get away from the sisters and think, and then she starts using the skills she has. She has a good memory and a habit of collecting data, both of which the book pays off later. Online searches lead her to a bar called Twist and to the murder of James Anders in Central Park, near that bar, on a night for which she has no solid alibi. The picture that forms is ugly: she is being set up to take the blame for a killing someone else committed.

Who was really in charge

The answer to why Shay was chosen comes from the past chapters and from her own digging. Valerie, the helper who seemed to drift in and out under different names, is Cassandra and Jane's older sister. James Anders was the sisters' former stepbrother. He had tried to rape Valerie when they were in high school, and years later he raped Daphne. When the women found his name, they built a case against him among themselves and decided to kill him. The plan went wrong. Amanda, a trained nurse who was part of the group, tried to save him after the others carved the word rapist into his forehead. He died anyway, and the women took his watch and wallet to make the scene look like a robbery.

Amanda could not live with what she had done. The others kept calling and stopping by, and her work at the hospital began to suffer. She realized that what the group wanted was not justice but revenge, and that they were not satisfied until they had ruined someone completely. She put the scalpel and the bloody towel into an envelope, left it in her mailbox, and arranged to meet Detective Williams to confess. Then she saw that she was being followed. She ran into a subway station, saw Valerie coming down the stairs, and stepped in front of a train. The suicide Shay witnessed at the start was not a random act of despair. It was a woman who knew she was going to be silenced and chose the timing herself.

The brains behind the whole operation is Valerie. She is the one who steered her younger sisters into this role, letting them believe they were the leaders while she made the important calls. She is a trained actress, and the different names and identities she used were part of the craft. When Shay became a loose end, Valerie was the one sent to handle it. Shay also learns that a detective who contacted her named Santiago was invented, a lure to get her into the open. The false call is a nasty little beat because Shay nearly falls for it after she has already learned to distrust almost everything.

The platform and what comes after

The final confrontation takes place in the same kind of setting as the opening. Valerie waits for Shay in a subway station with a gun and steers her toward the platform. Cassandra and Jane are at a nearby restaurant surrounded by people who can vouch for them, which leaves them clean if anything happens. Shay can see the train approaching on the display and understands that Valerie means to push her in front of it. A voice calls out Valerie's name and identifies itself as the police. In the struggle that follows, Valerie falls instead of Shay.

The police were there because Shay had called Detective Williams, who had promised to stay with her through the whole thing. She had gathered enough on her own to make the case stick, and her habit of holding onto details gave Williams what she needed. In the short epilogue, set two months later, Shay has a new job and a new apartment. The Moore sisters and the rest of the circle are heading to prison for decades. Shay also notes that the strength training she had done for years helped her hold her own against Valerie in that last moment, which is a quiet way of saying that the life she built while she was lonely was not wasted.

I liked the ending. It gives Shay a real part in her own rescue rather than handing it to a detective, and it closes the loop on the subway image so the book begins and ends with the same kind of danger. What I did not like is how much had to line up to get there. Shay just happens to witness the death of the one woman whose secret could unravel the group. She just happens to be styled as that woman's double. The coincidences pile up, and by the last third I had stopped being surprised by new connections and started waiting for the next one to be announced.

The other weakness is Shay herself in the early chapters. Her loneliness is drawn with enough care that I understood her choices, but understanding is not the same as enjoying. There are stretches where she ignores plain evidence because she wants the sisters to like her, and the authors keep asking the reader to be patient with a decision that was already made a hundred pages ago. The book is at its best when Shay stops waiting to be chosen and starts doing the work herself. Everything before that point is setup, and some of it runs long.

What stayed with me

The thing I keep thinking about is not the final twist but the makeover scene. The idea that a group of women could remake a lonely stranger into the image of someone they had killed, then welcome her into their circle as though she were a friend, is genuinely disturbing. It gives the title a nasty double meaning. Shay is not alone in the sense that people are around her, texting her and taking her out. She is not alone in the sense that nobody in her life has her interests at heart. The book is strongest when it sits with that difference instead of rushing to explain it.

The vigilante angle is handled less well. The women insist they are righting wrongs, and the book lets them off the hook more easily than I expected. James Anders was a rapist and what happened to him was brutal, but the chapter where the group carves a word into a dying man's forehead sits uneasily beside the idea that these women are heroes of a kind. Amanda's guilt is the only real moral weight in that part of the story, and once she dies the book mostly treats the others as clever criminals rather than as people who did something terrible. A reader looking for a careful argument about revenge will not find one here.

I would hand this to someone who likes twisty psychological thrillers and does not mind a book that keeps flipping whose version of events you are reading. The shifting viewpoints are the main pleasure, and the authors are skilled at making a small detail in one chapter matter much later. I would be careful with a reader who wants the twist count to feel earned rather than stacked. The last stretch throws a lot of revelations into a short space, and a few of them feel like they were saved for the reveal rather than planted for it. My friend was right about the ending being worth it. She was maybe too kind about the miles it takes to get there.

FAQ

Is You Are Not Alone part of a series?

No. It is a standalone psychological thriller co-written by Greer Hendricks and Sarah Pekkanen, their third novel together.

When was You Are Not Alone published?

St. Martin's Press published it in the United States on 3 March 2020, in a hardcover edition of 352 pages.

Who is really behind the Moore sisters' circle?

Valerie, their older sister and a trained actress, secretly directs the group while letting Cassandra and Jane believe they are the leaders.