Cover of The Obsession by Nora Roberts

The Obsession

2,230-word summary 10 min read 453 pages in the book

First published
2016
Publisher
Berkley
Pages
453
ISBN
9780399175169
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. The night Naomi followed her father into the woods
  2. Growing up in the shadow of a monster
  3. Sunrise Cove and the house on the bluff
  4. A body on the shore
  5. The person who has been watching
  6. The confrontation on the bluff
  7. What works and what drags
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I have a soft spot for Nora Roberts when she is working the suspense side of her catalog, the books where the romance has to survive a body count. I picked this one up after The Liar, curious to see how she would handle a heroine whose worst problem is not a killer chasing her but a family name she cannot escape. The Obsession came out in 2016 from Berkley, and it opens with a child standing at the edge of a dark stretch of woods, which is exactly the sort of cold open that tells you the rest of the book will not be gentle.

What surprised me is how much of the story happens before the present-day thriller even starts. Roberts spends a long stretch on the heroine's childhood, and that material turned out to be the part I remembered most. The murder plot that fills the back half is competent and tense, but the earlier pages are the ones with real weight to them.

The night Naomi followed her father into the woods

The heroine is Naomi Bowes, a girl of about eleven living with her family in rural West Virginia. One night she sees a flashlight moving outside and, being curious and a little fearless, follows her father out behind the house. His name is Thomas David Bowes, and to the outside world he is a respected church deacon. What she finds is a hidden root cellar beneath the ruins of an old cabin, and in it a young woman named Ashley McLean, bound, tortured, and left for dead.

Naomi frees Ashley and the two of them make it to the local sheriff. Naomi names her father as the attacker. The investigation that follows reveals that Thomas was a serial rapist and murderer, and the local church and community are thrown into shock. This is the moment Roberts builds the whole book around. A child does the right thing in the most literal sense, and it costs her the life she knew.

Her mother Susan does not cope well. At first she pressures Naomi to take the story back, which is a small, ugly detail that rings true. The family splinters under the media attention. Naomi, her younger brother Mason, and Susan are taken in by Susan's brother Seth Carson and his partner Harry Dobbs. They move to Georgetown and change their surname to Carson, trying to put distance between themselves and the Bowes name.

A note on the violence, because it matters for who should read this. Roberts does not linger on the worst of it in graphic detail, but rape, torture, and murder are the engine of the plot, and a true-crime industry grows up around them inside the story. If that material is hard for you, this book leans on it throughout.

Growing up in the shadow of a monster

The middle section follows the Carson family as they try to build something normal and keep failing. Susan sinks into a deep depression and, in a detail that made me uneasy, keeps in secret contact with Thomas in prison. A true-crime writer named Simon Vance gets hold of the story and publishes a book called Blood in the Ground, which keeps the family in the public eye and brings harassment down on them. Later a film adaptation retitles the story Daughter of Evil, and Naomi is dragged back into the spotlight yet again. The point Roberts keeps making is that other people profit from this family's pain, and the people who actually suffered it cannot opt out.

Susan eventually visits Thomas, who tells her he is divorcing her for another woman, and she dies by suicide, overdosing on medication. Naomi, now sixteen, comes home early with a classmate named Anson Chaffins, the editor of her school paper, and the two of them find her mother's body. Seth and Harry become the legal guardians of Naomi and Mason, which is one of the quiet strengths of the book. This family is not defined by blood but by the people who chose to stay.

Through all of it Naomi finds photography. She is good at it, sells images to stock vendors, and eventually takes up a travelling life, convinced that motion is the only way to stay private. The camera gives her a way to look at the world through a frame she controls, which is a small but telling detail. It also gives her a trade she can practice anywhere, so she never has to stay in one place long enough for anyone to read the local newspaper and put two and two together. I kept thinking about the cost of that freedom. She can go anywhere, which also means she belongs nowhere, and the book lets that trade sit uneasy rather than resolving it. Her brother Mason, meanwhile, cannot let the case go. He quietly researches their father's crimes and uncovers the full extent of their mother's prison visits, the hidden letters, the bus trips. When Anson tries to use Naomi's story for his own journalistic ambitions, she decides to write her own account for The New York Times instead. It is a small act of taking back control, and it hints at what the ending will ask of her.

I found this stretch uneven in pace. Roberts covers years of a life in brisk summary, then slows right down for a single scene. For a while I wondered whether the childhood material was simply backstory before the real novel. By the end I understood that it is the real novel, and the stalker plot is the device that forces Naomi to face it.

Sunrise Cove and the house on the bluff

In the present day, now in her late twenties, Naomi decides to stop running. She buys a big, run-down house on a bluff in Sunrise Cove, Washington, drawn to it on something close to a whim. She hires a local contractor named Kevin Banner to handle the renovation, and Kevin shares her sense of what the place could become. This is where Roberts shifts gears into the warmer small-town register she writes so well.

Naomi meets Xander Keaton after a blowout. He runs the local garage, plays in a band, and has a serious book collection, which is Roberts's shorthand for a man worth trusting. Soon after, the two of them rescue a starving stray dog that Naomi names Tag. The dog becomes more than a pet. He is the first living thing in years that Naomi lets depend on her, and the book is smart enough to give him a real part to play later.

She starts to belong. There are friendships with Kevin and his wife Jenny and others around town, small meals and conversations and the slow accumulation of people who know her name without knowing her history. Naomi keeps bracing for the moment they find out who her father was. She and Xander start a relationship, and her defenses come down in increments rather than all at once. Roberts gives these pages a lot of small texture: the slow progress of the renovation, the habits of a town that has known Xander since he was a boy, the way a stray dog forces a withdrawn woman to answer the door in the morning. None of it is flashy, and that is why it works. Roberts handles this better than the thriller elements. The interval where Naomi allows herself to want a home is the most convincing part of the present-day story.

A body on the shore

The peace does not last. While walking with Tag, Naomi finds the body of a young woman murdered on the shore below her property. The victim is Marla Roth, who had a public, drunken confrontation with Naomi at a local bar not long before she vanished. The method of the killing, binding and strangulation, closely resembles Thomas Bowes's crimes. Chief of Police Sam Winston leads the investigation, and Naomi quickly understands that her name will be all over it.

A second woman, Donna Lanier, is abducted and later found dead in the same manner. Now the town knows that the daughter of a notorious serial killer is living among them, and the old suspicion and fascination come rushing back. This is the part of the book that is really about the spectacle of trauma. Roberts is interested in how a news cycle and a true-crime public turn a victim's child into exhibit number one, and how hard it is to build a private life when your family name belongs to everyone.

Mason arrives in Sunrise Cove as an FBI agent specializing in behavioral analysis. His arrival brings the novel's procedural side to life, and the sibling bond between him and Naomi is one of the warmer threads here. He has spent years studying their father; she has spent years trying not to. Watching them work the same case from opposite emotional directions is genuinely good.

The person who has been watching

Mason works out what the local police cannot. The killer has been obsessed with Naomi for years, following her publicly posted photographs, choosing victims who resemble her and dumping bodies in places taken from her own images. He has been corresponding with Thomas in prison, travelling the country and imitating the father's methods as a kind of offering. He even poses as a reporter at press briefings in Sunrise Cove so he can watch the investigation he set in motion.

The reveal of who it is lands because Roberts planted the person early and in plain sight. The stalker is Anson Chaffins, the classmate who was with Naomi the day she found her mother's body all those years ago. His obsession began there, in the moment he saw her grief, and grew into something that could never be satisfied. It is a neat solution to the mystery, and it ties the childhood sections to the present plot in a way that makes the long setup feel earned.

Now I will be fair about the machinery. Once Anson is unmasked, he explains himself at length, and the speech runs longer than the character deserves. Roberts also stacks coincidences in the final act, and the copycat premise depends on a leap or two about a killer maintaining a years-long correspondence with an imprisoned man. None of this broke the book for me, but it did make the last stretch feel more constructed than the parts that came before.

The confrontation on the bluff

Anson makes his move by luring Xander away with a fake roadside assistance call, ambushing and injuring him, then breaking into Naomi's house. What follows is a confrontation in which he tries to make her understand that he has always been the one watching. Tag attacks him. Naomi throws herself in front of the dog, and a bullet goes through her and into Tag. Xander, wounded, gets back in time to subdue Anson badly enough that the police can take him into federal custody.

Both Naomi and Tag survive. In the aftermath Naomi confronts Anson again, refusing to let him keep any power over her, which is the emotional payoff the book has been building toward since those first woods. Her family gathers around her, Seth and Harry included, and the friends she found in Sunrise Cove close ranks without judgment. The ending brings Naomi and Xander together, with him moving into the house on the bluff and the two of them planning a marriage. It is a conventional happy ending, and after everything this heroine has survived, I was willing to grant it to her.

The novel was adapted into a television movie in 2022, which says something about how neatly it fits a certain kind of suspense romance. I can see why. The beats are clear and the images are strong, even when the prose is working in familiar patterns.

What works and what drags

Roberts is at her best here on belonging. The idea that a person could be permanently defined by a relative's crimes, and could find a place where nobody cares about that, gives the book its spine. Sunrise Cove is drawn with real affection, and the renovation of the old house works as a quiet metaphor for Naomi putting herself back together. The dog is a stroke of good writing, an uncomplicated bond in a story full of complicated ones.

The weak point is the thriller engineering. The final reveal is telegraphed, the killer's monologue overexplains, and the last third leans on coincidences that the earlier, more grounded chapters did not need. There are also large stretches of backstory delivered in summary, so the book sometimes tells you how Naomi felt rather than letting you watch it happen. For a book that moves quickly, that is a trade-off you notice.

Even so, the book held me. It is a romantic suspense novel with a serious question at its center: what does a person owe to a name she never chose? Roberts does not answer that with a speech. She answers it with Naomi buying a house, taking in a dog, letting a man get close, and standing in front of the people she loves when it counts. That is a more satisfying answer than the plot itself always manages.

FAQ

Is The Obsession a romance or a thriller?

It is both, marketed as romantic suspense. The romance between Naomi and Xander develops alongside a murder investigation and a stalker plot, and the book spends as much time on her childhood trauma as on the present-day case.

Is The Obsession based on a true story?

No, it is a work of fiction by Nora Roberts. It draws on the true-crime phenomenon, with an in-story author and a film adaptation that profit from the family's tragedy, but the characters and events are invented.

What is the house Naomi buys in Sunrise Cove?

She buys a large, run-down old house on a bluff in Sunrise Cove, Washington, and hires local contractor Kevin Banner to renovate it. The house becomes the place where she finally tries to put down roots.