Cover of Bringing Down the Duke by Evie Dunmore

Bringing Down the Duke

2,456-word summary 11 min read 368 pages in the book

First published
2019
Publisher
Berkley
Pages
368
ISBN
9781984805683
Series
A League of Extraordinary Women (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (10 sections)
  1. A scholarship with strings attached
  2. The duke, his lost castle, and the queen's bargain
  3. Claremont and a very bad first impression
  4. Dinner parties, a ball, and a maze
  5. Petitions, jealousy, and an arrest
  6. The secret she has never told anyone
  7. A fall, a lie, and a speech in the Lords
  8. What stays with you
  9. Key takeaways
  10. FAQ

I came to this book expecting a gentle romance about a governess and a lord, and instead found a novel that spends a surprising amount of its energy arguing about property law. That was the hook for me. Evie Dunmore's 2019 debut takes the familiar machinery of a historical romance, a clever heroine, a brooding aristocrat, a ballroom, and hangs a serious political argument off it: whether married women should be allowed to keep what is theirs. Set in 1879, just as Oxford was opening its doors to its first women students, the story follows Annabelle Archer and Sebastian Devereux, the Duke of Montgomery. It is the first book in the League of Extraordinary Women series, published by Berkley, and it runs to 368 pages. What surprised me was how seriously it takes both halves of its title. The duke really does get brought down, and the politics are never mere backdrop.

A scholarship with strings attached

Annabelle is the daughter of a country vicar, brilliant and nearly penniless, working as an unpaid companion and maid in the household of her cousin Gilbert in Kent. Her route out is a scholarship to Oxford, one of the first places in England to admit women. But the money comes from the National Society for Women's Suffrage, and it carries a condition: in exchange for her education, Annabelle must work for the vote. She keeps this part quiet from Gilbert, who controls her future and would treat activism as a scandal. It is a neat bit of construction, because it means every step of her education is entangled with the cause, and the romance cannot be separated from the politics even when she wants it to be.

At a rally in Parliament Square led by Lady Lucie Tedbury, the society's secretary, Annabelle meets Harriet "Hattie" Greenfield, the cheerful daughter of a banking magnate. The two become fast friends. While Annabelle is handing out pamphlets about amending the Married Women's Property Act, a bill that would let married women retain their own earnings and property, she is jostled by a passing aristocrat. His bodyguard shoves her, but the man catches her arm, warns her she is playing a dangerous game, and moves on. Hattie identifies him as the Duke of Montgomery, one of the most powerful men in Britain. Lucie writes him off as a lost cause. Annabelle, observing that he had bothered to stop and speak to her at all, suggests a different approach: win him over rather than shout at him. That decision sets the whole plot in motion.

Her arrangement with Gilbert is just as transactional, and Dunmore is clear-eyed about it. She wins his permission by arguing that an Oxford-certified governess could command a decent wage and send money home. Gilbert agrees to that, not to the cause she actually intends to serve. The scene establishes the central fact of Annabelle's life: every inch of freedom she has is paid for by pleasing a man who would take it back if he knew what she was doing. It gives her later refusals real weight, because she is not a heroine with a private fortune to fall back on.

The duke, his lost castle, and the queen's bargain

Sebastian Devereux is not the stock villain of a romance. He is a political operator, called to advise the Conservative election campaign at the Queen's command, and he carries a private grievance. The family seat, Montgomery Castle, was lost by his father in a card game years ago, and Queen Victoria has hinted that if the Tories win, she will help him get it back. She also leans on him to host a New Year's Eve party and, with rather less subtlety, to find a wife of suitable standing to secure the legacy he has spent years rebuilding. This is the engine of his resistance to Annabelle. He wants a duchess who will restore the family name, not a destitute, outspoken commoner with radical opinions.

That makes the attraction between them a genuine problem rather than a foregone conclusion. Dunmore gives them a shared language: both are strategists, both are lonely, and both are trapped by the roles their societies have written for them. Sebastian is appalled when he learns a group of suffragists has infiltrated his world, yet the person he cannot stop thinking about is the one arguing against everything he stands for. The tension works because the book lets each of them be right about part of the argument.

Claremont and a very bad first impression

At Oxford, Annabelle studies ancient Greek warfare under Professor Jenkins, a correspondent of her late father's, and befriends Lady Catriona Campbell, the reserved daughter of a Scottish earl. Together with Hattie, Catriona helps trade a borrowed wine cellar key to Sebastian's younger brother, Peregrin, in exchange for invitations to a house party at Claremont, Sebastian's Wiltshire estate. The plan depends on the duke being absent. He has been recalled from France by the queen, and Annabelle arrives, wanders into the library beneath a vaulted ceiling painted with gold-leaf stars, and falls asleep.

She wakes to find Sebastian standing over her. He assumes she is one of Peregrin's conquests and orders her off his land. The accusation lands hard, because it echoes something painful from her past, and she runs off across the grounds on foot. Sebastian realizes his mistake, rides after her, and makes a proper apology. She agrees to ride back, and neither of them behaves with complete sense after that. The following morning she collapses from exhaustion and poor diet, and he calls a physician and orders his staff to look after her. During her recovery they trade books and notes, and the rapport they build is intellectual before it is physical. He shows her the conservatory and the stables, where she discovers he keeps retired horses instead of sending them to slaughter. It is a small, patient detail that tells her more about him than his title ever could.

I liked that Dunmore lets the attraction build through conversation and observation rather than through proximity alone. Annabelle is a scholar, and the book gives her a genuine intellectual life: her Greek, her arguments with Jenkins, her ideas about what women could do with an education. Sebastian, for his part, is drawn to a woman who does not perform deference for him. Their exchanges have the quality of two people testing each other's minds, and that makes the later physical turn feel earned instead of inevitable.

Dinner parties, a ball, and a maze

The book is at its liveliest when it lets Annabelle argue in public. At a Christmas dinner hosted by Lady Lingham, a widowed neighbour of Sebastian's, a lord makes a pseudoscientific case for women's inferior intellect. Annabelle takes him apart, point by point, and Sebastian publicly salutes her reasoning. He invites her to his New Year's Eve party, and Hattie arranges a gown in exchange for Annabelle sitting as the model for a painting of Helen of Troy. At the ball, the rakish war hero Lord Tristan Ballentine tries to claim a waltz. Sebastian crosses the floor, cuts in, and leads her into an alcove where they share their first real kiss. It is the moment the book has been edging toward, and the restraint beforehand makes it land.

Hattie's Helen of Troy painting turns out to be more than a favour between friends. Annabelle sits for it to pay for the gown, and Sebastian later buys the canvas, an act that is part apology and part possession. The three women at the centre of the book keep choosing each other's company over the men pursuing them, which is a quiet but consistent undercurrent. Catriona in particular resists the easy caricature of the shy Scottish aristocrat and ends up one of the steadier presences in Annabelle's life.

The garden maze the next day looks like the moment when he will finally say what he feels. Instead his valet arrives with bad news: Peregrin has fled the Welsh estate where Sebastian had confined him, refusing the Royal Navy enlistment his brother had arranged for him. Sebastian leaves for London, promising to return. This nickel-and-diming of the romance by family obligation becomes a pattern, and it kept me guessing about which of them would blink first. What I liked is that the obstacles are not invented misunderstandings. They come from the characters' actual circumstances: a brother's rebellion, a cause that needs a public champion, and a woman who has learned to expect abandonment.

Petitions, jealousy, and an arrest

Back at Oxford, Annabelle is short of money and falling behind. Jenkins offers her a paid post as his research assistant on an excavation in the Peloponnese, which gives her a future that does not depend on a husband. Lucie sends her to petition Sebastian in the House of Lords. He will not publicly back the property amendment, but he offers strategic help, and their meeting turns raw. Annabelle lays out the indignities of her position and the cost of becoming his mistress, and Sebastian admits she never leaves his mind. He also makes clear that he cannot offer marriage. Before she goes, he tells her that if they were of equal station, he would have proposed during their walk in the maze. It is the book's cleanest statement of the problem: not a lack of feeling, but a structure that will not permit the match.

Jealousy follows. At a Mendelssohn concert Sebastian confronts her, consumed by her closeness to Jenkins, and admits that Lady Lingham is no longer his lover. Annabelle says the madness between them has to stop. Then the suffragists march on Parliament Square, a police officer assaults Hattie, and Annabelle punches him. She is arrested. Sebastian finds her at Millbank Penitentiary, has her record expunged, and posts bail for her and for a fellow prisoner who has no one to help her. That act does more to change Annabelle than any of his earlier gestures, and it complicates her certainty that he cares only about his own position. She has spent the book assuming that his power is a weapon aimed at her; here he spends it on a stranger with no claim on him at all. It is the first time the reader can imagine the two of them as allies rather than opponents.

The secret she has never told anyone

The night after her release, at his Belgravia town house, Annabelle goes to Sebastian's bedroom and they make love. Afterward she tells him what has shaped her: at seventeen she was seduced by a viscount's son with promises of elopement, then abandoned. She became pregnant, lost the child, and was sent away by her father, who died before she could return. The next morning Sebastian offers her a house and a yacht. She tells him she cannot be his mistress, because she has been discarded once already. He says he loves her, but she cannot say it back, and he reads her silence as refusal.

This is where the book's power imbalance becomes hard to ignore. Sebastian has the ability to solve her material problems with a sentence, while she can offer him nothing he needs except the truth about herself. Kirkus, in its review of the audiobook, noted that this imbalance may keep the story from working for every reader, and I think that is a fair reservation. Dunmore gives Annabelle real agency: she refuses, she argues, she walks away, and she has a life beyond him. But the romantic fantasy depends on a man with enormous power choosing to use it gently, and that will not sit equally well with everyone.

A fall, a lie, and a speech in the Lords

Annabelle is suspended from Oxford over the scandal, and Jenkins proposes a practical marriage to protect her reputation and keep her as his assistant. Sebastian buys Hattie's painting of Annabelle as Helen of Troy, then rides recklessly at Claremont and is thrown. He sees Annabelle's face in what he believes are his last moments, but the soft ground breaks his fall. That night he proposes, saying the fall clarified everything. She refuses, convinced the scandal would wreck the legacy he has spent his life building. To drive him away she lies, saying she never loved him and used him for the cause. He walks out.

The turn comes through Peregrin. Annabelle spots him at St. John's College and, confronting him, says aloud for the first time that she loves the duke. Peregrin returns to Claremont, finds Sebastian devastated, and offers the crucial reading of the situation: Annabelle rejected him because of the dukedom, not in spite of it, because she could not bear to destroy everything he had built. Meanwhile a letter from Gilbert disowns her after an anonymous tip about her scandals, and Sebastian learns that Lady Lingham told the queen about his prison visit, so he cuts her off. In the House of Lords he speaks in favour of the property amendment, invoking John Stuart Mill's argument that married women are legal slaves, resigns as the Tory campaign adviser, and leaves the party. Annabelle, watching from the gallery, runs out into the rain. Sebastian follows and tells her Montgomery Castle is lost, but that he has chosen which side of history to stand on. She says she would have him with nothing but the clothes on his back, and admits she loves him so much she would rather be alone than with anyone else.

What stays with you

The epilogue, set in April, finds them married and honeymooning on a yacht in the Aegean, with Peregrin happily working as Jenkins's excavation apprentice nearby. Sebastian reflects that changing his place in history for Annabelle was the best decision he made, and suspects history will eventually agree with him. I found that ending satisfying precisely because it does not erase the cost. He gives up the castle; she gives up the shield of a respectable future. Neither gets a painless victory.

For a debut, the book is more assured than it has any right to be. The suffrage plot is not decoration, the friendships among Annabelle, Hattie, and Catriona carry real warmth, and the argument about property rights gives the romance a spine. If the pacing drags in the middle, and if you are impatient with heroes who need a near-death experience to say what they mean, there are stretches that test that patience. Still, it is hard not to admire how Dunmore keeps the personal and the political braided together. For readers who want their historical romance with an actual argument inside it, this one delivers.

FAQ

Is Bringing Down the Duke part of a series?

Yes. It is the first book in Evie Dunmore's A League of Extraordinary Women series, published in 2019 by Berkley.

Does the romance have a serious political plot?

Yes. Much of the conflict centres on a campaign to amend the Married Women's Property Act so married women can keep their own property.

Does the book have a happy ending?

Yes. An epilogue set in April shows Annabelle and Sebastian married and honeymooning on a yacht in the Aegean Sea.