Cover of On the Island by Tracey Garvis Graves

On the Island

2,171-word summary 10 min read 352 pages in the book

First published
2011
Publisher
Plume
Pages
352
ISBN
9780142196724
Series
On the Island (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A tutoring job that turns into a nightmare
  2. Learning the basics the hard way
  3. Two people who change shape
  4. The wave that takes them back
  5. The part that is harder than survival
  6. What grates, and what stays
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I came to this book with a raised eyebrow. It had a reputation as the self-published novel that sold millions and got plucked into a Penguin deal, and the pitch sounded like a trap: a thirty-year-old teacher and her sixteen-year-old student, stranded alone on a desert island, falling in love. That premise makes me wary, and I say that as someone who otherwise likes a survival story. What got me past the first chapter was the attention to the small, unglamorous work of staying alive. Graves wrote the water and the fire and the fish better than she wrote the romance, and for a while that was enough.

Tracey Garvis Graves self-published the book in September 2011, then watched it climb the charts until Penguin offered her a two-book deal in 2012 and reissued it under the Plume imprint. The edition I read is the 352-page Plume paperback. It became a New York Times bestseller and was optioned by MGM. All of that is worth knowing because the book's ordinary origins explain its shape: it is built to be read fast and talked about, and it delivers.

The praise it collected was telling. Kirkus called Graves the patron saint of independent authors, and one British paper described the book as a hybrid of The Beach, Robinson Crusoe and Room. Those comparisons point to exactly what the book is: a castaway story with a locked-room intimacy and a romance growing out of forced proximity. Knowing that makes it easier to settle into what the author is doing. She is not trying to reinvent the survival novel. She is trying to make a familiar setup feel lived in, and for long stretches she succeeds.

A tutoring job that turns into a nightmare

The story opens in 2001. Anna Emerson is thirty, an English teacher in Chicago, worn down by cold winters and an eight-year relationship with a man who keeps not proposing. When T.J. Callahan's parents offer her a summer job tutoring their son at the family's rental in the Maldives, she takes it without much thought. A working vacation on a tropical island beats the library.

T.J. is almost seventeen. He has spent much of the past year in treatment for cancer and is now in remission, and the last thing he wants is to spend his first well summer with his parents and a stack of overdue assignments. His parents travel ahead. Anna and T.J. fly separately and board a small seaplane for the last leg of the trip. Over the Indian Ocean the pilot suffers a fatal heart attack. The plane goes down in shark-infested water.

What follows is told in alternating first-person chapters, Anna and T.J. taking turns, and that choice does a lot of work. We get the crash from both sides. Life jackets keep them afloat through a night in the water. They wash ashore on a small island that is uninhabited, with no working phone and no reliable rescue in sight. The pilot does not survive. Anna and T.J. bury him, and that act seems to mark the moment they stop expecting to be picked up by the end of the week.

I want to be precise about the tone here because the publisher's description leans hard on the romance. The early chapters are closer to a castaway manual than a love story.

Learning the basics the hard way

Graves is at her best in these pages. Anna and T.J. start with almost nothing and have to work out, by trial and error, how to get fresh water, food, fire and shelter. They collect rain and learn to live on coconuts and breadfruit. Fishing is clumsy at first, then gradually less so. They build a fire, improve their shelter, and try to signal passing aircraft. A plane does go over without stopping, and that failure is handled well: it is the moment the prospect of rescue starts to recede and the real work begins.

Later a suitcase from the wreck washes up with useful things in it, including a first aid kit and a datebook, and the book uses those objects to make their situation feel physical rather than abstract. They mark time with T.J.'s birthdays and holidays, because there is no other calendar out there.

Graves quietly tracks the moment hope curdles. At first Anna and T.J. assume rescue is only a matter of hours, then days. When the search does not come, they have to accept that their families may be grieving for them back home, and that no one is scanning the water for a plane that vanished over the Maldives. The book handles that realization without a speech. It shows up in the way they start tending the shelter as if they intend to live in it, and in the way they stop scanning the horizon quite so often. That is when the story becomes genuinely interesting, because survival stops being a holding pattern and turns into a life.

The island throws a run of hazards at them. Anna is stung by a jellyfish. T.J. comes down with a serious illness, described in the book as dengue hemorrhagic fever, and Anna has to nurse him with no doctor and no medicine, terrified that it is something worse. A nine-foot shark takes up residence in their lagoon. There are dolphins, and there is a pet chicken that never lays an egg. Some of this is genuinely tense. Some of it reads like a checklist of castaway problems, and I could feel the author ticking them off. The shark in particular strains things, and more than one reviewer has singled that scene out as the moment the book asks you to believe too much.

Through all of it the fear that T.J.'s cancer might return hangs over them. That is the threat no amount of resourcefulness can answer, and it is the one that gives the survival plot its quiet weight.

Two people who change shape

The reason the age gap works as well as it does, and it only works up to a point, is that Graves gives both characters a voice. Anna starts as the adult in charge, the teacher who makes the decisions. T.J. starts as a resentful teenager who has been told what to do all summer. Over the years on the island their roles shift. T.J. grows into the person who can fish, build and protect them, while Anna has to accept that she is no longer the only one keeping them alive.

The romance arrives only after T.J. is grown. Graves was careful about this, and she has said she deliberately put two people who should never be together on an island to see whether readers would root for them. The book delays the physical relationship until T.J. is an adult, and it has Anna and T.J. talk openly about the difference in their ages. One scene has Anna pointing out that she is thirteen years older and getting older every day, and T.J. answering that if she thinks he only cares about how she looks, he does not know her as well as he thought. That exchange is representative: the book keeps the awkwardness in view instead of pretending it away.

What makes the shift believable in chapters is the accumulation of small things. T.J. learns to cook what they catch. Anna stops being the person who always decides and starts asking him what he thinks. They argue, they get on each other's nerves, and they share jokes that would mean nothing to anyone else. The physical relationship, when it comes, grows out of that daily closeness rather than a single sudden lurch. Graves understands that two people alone together for years would either destroy each other or become inseparable, and she takes the second path while keeping the first one visible as a possibility.

Even so, I never completely stopped noticing the setup. A reader can accept the logic of the thing and still feel the unease of a former teacher and a much younger former student becoming lovers. The alternating chapters help because they let us see T.J.'s maturity arrive slowly, but they do not erase the underlying power imbalance. This is the book's central gamble, and whether it pays off depends a lot on how much you are willing to grant the island its own rules.

The wave that takes them back

After more than three years, a massive tsunami hits the island. It sweeps both of them into the water and separates them, and each believes the other is dead. This is the turning point of the book, and the way it is staged is efficient rather than gentle. Anna is pulled from the water by rescuers and taken by helicopter to a hospital in Malé. Her first question is about T.J. When a rescuer mentions another helicopter that picked up a man asking for Anna, she understands that he may be alive.

T.J. has been rescued separately. They reunite in the hospital and learn that the outside world had presumed them dead. The reunion is a relief, but Graves is more interested in what comes after. Suddenly there are doctors, phones, family members, food and a flood of attention. They have to reconnect with people who have mourned them while also answering questions about the years they spent alone together. The world they left has not stood still, and the private life they built on the island has no obvious place in it.

The part that is harder than survival

Back in Chicago, the book changes gears. The media gets hold of the story. The focus falls on the age gap and on the fact that T.J. was her student, and what she survived becomes beside the point. The scrutiny costs Anna her teaching job, and that consequence is one of the more honest touches in the novel. She cannot simply return to her old life and pick up where she left off.

T.J., meanwhile, is trying to settle into a life he missed, working and figuring out who he is outside the island. Anna worries that staying with her will keep him from living fully as a young man. They separate for a while. Anna starts volunteering at a homeless shelter, T.J. takes work, and neither of them manages to move on. On Christmas Day T.J. comes to her door, and they decide to try again. The epilogue shows them married and raising a family.

That ending is unapologetically romantic, and it is also where the book is most open to the charge of wish fulfillment. The public judgment that looked so serious earlier is resolved largely by the two of them choosing each other and the passage of time doing the rest. I found the reentry material stronger than the fairy-tale finish, which ties things up more neatly than the first three quarters earn.

What grates, and what stays

The writing divides readers, and I understand both sides. The dialogue can be wooden, especially in the scenes where characters are meant to be working through big feelings. Graves also makes large time jumps, and the book covers years in a relatively short span, so whole stretches of island life happen between chapters rather than on the page. Several reviewers have complained about those chunky time lapses, and I felt them too. There is a sense that the author is rushing through the years to get to the part she most wants to write.

The second half, set in Chicago, is weaker than the island section. The survival plot gave the book a natural engine: hunger, weather, illness, the sea. Once they are safe, that engine is gone and the story has to run on social conflict and interior doubt, which are less gripping. The cheese is more visible too. This is a book that will make some readers laugh at moments meant to be serious, and the shark scene is the usual example.

For all that, the survival writing is vivid and the alternating points of view give the relationship a credibility it would not have had in a single voice. The book is compulsively readable, and its flaws are the kind you can forgive while you are turning pages. It is honest about the ethical problem at its center even if the ending chooses to look past it. I closed it thinking less about the romance than about the practical details of keeping a fire going and a body fed, which is probably a fair measure of where its real strength lies.

I would hand it to a reader who likes survival stories with a romance attached and who can tolerate a heavy dose of sentiment. I would be cautious with a reader who finds the teacher-student age gap a hard stop, because no amount of good writing about coconuts will make that premise comfortable for everyone.

FAQ

Was On the Island self-published before Penguin picked it up?

Yes. Graves published it herself in September 2011, then Penguin offered her a two-book deal in 2012 and reissued it through the Plume imprint as a 352-page paperback.

How long are Anna and T.J. stranded on the island?

More than three years. A tsunami eventually sweeps them into the sea, and they are rescued separately by helicopter and reunited in a hospital in Malé.

Why is the book controversial?

Anna is thirty and T.J. is sixteen when they meet as tutor and student, with a thirteen-year age gap. The novel delays their romance until he is an adult and has them face public judgment after rescue, but some readers still find the premise uncomfortable.