Cover of House of Hollow by Krystal Sutherland

House of Hollow

2,514-word summary 11 min read 304 pages in the book

First published
2021
Publisher
G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers
Pages
304
ISBN
9780593110348
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. The woman in white and the thing at the throat
  2. A horned mask, a dead man, and flowers in the walls
  3. Gabe's journal and the door in the burned flat
  4. North to Edinburgh and the girl with the shotgun
  5. The Halfway, the graves, and the locket
  6. What Grey did, and what happens after
  7. What stays with you, and what grates
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this one up because someone described it as a fairy tale written by a person who had spent too long staring at fashion magazines and crime scene photographs. That is a fair description, though it leaves out how dry and funny the first hundred pages are. Krystal Sutherland published House of Hollow in 2021 with G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers. The first hardcover runs 304 pages, which is short for a book that manages to feel both cramped and enormous. London is mostly a backdrop here: the tube, a school corridor, a gig, a run across Hampstead Heath. The strangeness lives in the sisters.

The premise is the sort of thing that circulates as a rumour at school. Three girls disappeared for a month when they were children, on a suburban street in Scotland, and came back with no memory of where they had been. Their dark hair turned white. Their blue eyes slowly went black. They ate constantly and never gained weight, and people found them beautiful in a way that felt less like admiration and more like a compulsion, as if looking at them were a physical need. The neighbourhood settled on witches. The police file noted that cadaver dogs reacted to the three of them. Their father Gabe insisted that their eyes and teeth had changed. Years later their parents died in a suicide pact, leaving Grey, Vivi and Iris to grow up strange in public.

The woman in white and the thing at the throat

Sutherland opens with a scene set years before the main story. A woman in white comes into young Iris's bedroom at midnight, cuts a lock of her hair, tastes it, and touches a half-moon scar at the girl's throat. The family subdues her and reports it as a stalker incident. It reads like a creepy anecdote until the rest of the book starts circling back to it, at which point you realise the woman was checking a disguise.

In the present, seventeen-year-old Iris Hollow is trying to finish high school on time, something her two older sisters never bothered with. Grey is a famous fashion designer who sews secret messages and occult symbols into her clothes and appears on the cover of Vogue. Vivi plays gigs and drifts through London with the confidence of someone who has never been told no. Iris hides the magazine from their mother Cate, who burns anything connected to Grey. The family has built an entire domestic architecture out of not talking.

That opening, and the arrival of the Vogue, do a lot of work with very little page space. Sutherland understands that the most unsettling thing about a family secret is not the secret. It is the choreography around it: the drawer shut a little too quickly, the phone call taken in another room, the photograph pulled from a folder. Iris's life is a series of small negotiations with a mother who would rather have nothing than admit to wanting something back.

A horned mask, a dead man, and flowers in the walls

Iris is jogging on Hampstead Heath one morning when she sees a pale, shirtless man wearing a horned skull mask. She runs. That night at Vivi's gig the same man appears in the crowd, and Vivi has a panic attack. Grey never shows up, which is how the search begins. In Grey's immaculate apartment there is nothing that looks like Grey at all, no mess, no trace of a person. At the Cuckoo Club a hostess mentions a man with black eyes asking after her. Tyler Yang, Grey's ex-boyfriend, says they split days ago and that he saw someone leaving the flat.

Then the clues start arriving like threats. A picture of three women burning at stakes turns up in Iris's bag. Vivi goes unreachable, and when Iris gets home she finds her sister inside Grey's locked bedroom, which has opened itself. A hidden compartment holds a dried flower, a knife and a key with a note in Grey's handwriting: bring the key, save her. The address leads to a second flat in Shoreditch, where the sisters find blood on the walls, a smashed phone and passport, and a dead man in the closet with his throat cut and white flowers growing out of his body. A man in a bull's skull walks in, sets the corpse on fire, and leaves without a word.

They escape with a journal and a handful of drawings. Vivi has been shot in the arm, and Iris notices a small flower pushing its way out of the wound, which she hides. This is where the book stops being a mystery about a missing designer and becomes something stranger. A quilt in the flat shows a ruined stone doorway, one of Grey's childhood stories about a place called the Halfway, a threshold between life and death. The clues are grotesque and domestic at once. Nobody in this novel is haunted by a ghost in a conventional sense. They are haunted by rooms that have been occupied by something that learned how to eat dinner and wear clothes.

Gabe's journal and the door in the burned flat

The papers they take from Shoreditch include the journal of Gabe Hollow, the sisters' father, who slowly came to believe that the girls who returned from Scotland were not his daughters. That is a brutal thing to read in your own father's handwriting, and Sutherland lets it sit for a page before piling on the rest. Grey's notes are clippings about missing people and sketches of doors. The family holds a press conference about Grey's disappearance, where Iris slips into the old disappearance of the three sisters and their parents' suicide pact. Afterwards she finds a note sewn into her dress in Grey's hand.

Tyler turns up drunk and insists Grey faked the whole thing. He passes out, and in the morning supplies the name that moves the plot sideways: Yulia Vasylyk, a Ukrainian model who went missing, reappeared a week later, and once shared a flat with Grey. Yulia says she followed Grey one night, vanished for a week, and came back with bloody runes written on her body in Grey's blood. In the empty flat the walls are growing carrion flowers. Back at the burned apartment, Iris and Vivi find a wooden doorframe hidden in the wreckage, thick with the same flowers. Iris calls out, and Grey crawls out with bloody fingertips and one warning: run, he is coming.

The hospital section is where the body horror gets personal. Iris wakes to find ants coming out of a pustule on her throat scar, and underneath, a second layer of skin. Grey has torn out of her restraints and is holding a scalpel. The man in the bull skull arrives, kills an officer, and comes for them. The sisters and Tyler run. Grey kills a woman they meet on the street without hesitating and stops a car by kissing the driver. It is a striking reversal of the usual teen-heroine rulebook: the missing sister is not the victim to be rescued but the most dangerous person in the room.

North to Edinburgh and the girl with the shotgun

They drive north in a stolen car and run out of fuel near Northampton. At a service station Tyler finds rotting leaves and flowers in Grey's throat when she sleeps, a detail that made me put the book down for a second. They reach Edinburgh at dawn and are met by a young girl with a shotgun. She lets them in and gives Grey a herbal remedy that makes her vomit rot and worms. The girl is Agnes Young, missing for decades, and she says she carries the same rot. She knows about the bull-skulled man: he has Grey's blood, and he will find her.

While Grey sleeps, Tyler tells Iris about his sister Rosie, who drowned, and Iris quietly removes her mother from her location-sharing app. A call to Cate brings another warning to run from Grey. Iris reads up on the Minotaur, and the underground language of the book finally snaps into focus: the mask, the labyrinth, the family at its centre. Agnes explains that she was trapped in the Halfway until Grey used blood runes to pull her back. Then the horned man attacks, takes Grey and Vivi, and vanishes. Agnes dies in the struggle. They burn her body in the yard.

Iris proposes drowning herself to reach the land of the dead. Tyler refuses and insists they go together, which is both tender and a problem, since he is in love with Grey. They return to the street where the sisters vanished as children, find the plaque, study photographs of a freestanding door, and enter the rebuilt house. Iris uses her strange power of suggestion on a woman who sees them, telling her to forget. In Grey's journal they find a sketch of Saint Anthony's Chapel. At the ruins, they wait for sunrise and step through a door together.

The Halfway, the graves, and the locket

The Halfway is a decaying place full of pale, dead-eyed spirits and a river swollen with bodies. Iris follows a strip of red-and-black tartan tied to a branch, a piece of the coat she wore when she disappeared. In the marsh they find a naked child on a mud island, and Tyler recognises her as Rosie. He insists on carrying her even though Iris wants to leave her. Inside a roofless stone house Iris finds blood on the hearth, a tuft of wine-coloured fur, and three blood-stiffened children's garments under a floorboard. There is a gravestone with the names GREY, VIVI and IRIS on it, but when they dig, the graves are old and empty.

The man in the shattered bull mask attacks. Tyler's shotgun breaks the mask off, and Iris sees his face and names him: Gabriel Hollow, her father. He appears in his true form out of the water, with Rosie screaming in Vivi's old coat, and says he has them before vanishing again. Iris makes him dig up the grave properly. Inside are three small bodies wrapped in a blanket, each wearing a heart-shaped gold locket. The smallest locket is engraved IRIS, and that body is missing its two baby teeth. Iris puts it together on the spot: she is not Iris Hollow.

She wades into the dark water and accepts what Gabe had known from the day they came home. The three girls who returned were impostors. She reburies the real children with their locket, and Rosie speaks for the first time, hugs Tyler, and dies. Tyler bandages Iris's broken ribs and they nearly kiss, but he stops because he loves Grey. Iris falls asleep, wakes alone, and goes after her sisters by marking trees with strips of Tyler's shirt.

What Grey did, and what happens after

At the end Iris finds Grey and Vivi tied to stakes in a clearing, with carrion flowers growing on them and a third stake left empty. Gabe steps out wearing Tyler's skin. He has killed Tyler and flayed him, and he explains that the sisters were changelings who killed the real Hollow children and wore their skins to escape. He lights the pyre. Iris uses the one power she has, suggestion, which works on the living but not the dead. She touches his cheek and calls him Papa. He hesitates, and that is enough.

Back in the human world, Grey mixes a potion of herbs and vinegar that makes Vivi and Iris vomit up the rot and flowers growing inside them. Then she tells the truth. On New Year's Eve, years ago, she lured the three original girls through a door, killed them, and took their skins so that she and her two companions could cross into the living world. To escape the Halfway they had to become liminal, halfway between life and death. That is why they are always starving. Grey also admits she killed Gabe with a suggestion after he dragged her back, and that Cate has known the truth since the night she threw Grey out. Iris says she never wants to see her again. Grey says she has no regrets and will wait, because they are sisters in this life and the last.

The aftermath is deliberately untidy. Iris recovers in hospital with fractured ribs, tells Cate the girls died without pain, and gives her strips of cloth from the real daughters' coats. At school she confronts the girl who bullied her but decides not to use her power to hurt anyone. Grey announces an eight-figure book deal and a film deal about her supposed kidnapping, charms the police into believing a stalker killed Tyler, and turns up at his funeral veiled as a grieving widow and acting as a pallbearer. In the last pages Iris and Vivi tour a tidal mill in Bromley-by-Bow, find a freestanding Saxon door in the basement, get their mother's permission by text, and step through it at sunset because Iris thinks Tyler's soul might still be in there.

What stays with you, and what grates

The imagery is the reason to read this book. Carrion flowers pushing out of a wound, a mask made from a bull's skull, a half-moon scar that turns out to be a seam, a door standing alone in a room: these are images that lodge. Sutherland also has a good ear for the way families talk around a subject, and the relationship between Iris and Vivi, two people who have been through the same unreachable event and remember it differently, is the emotional centre that holds the horror still.

The middle does sag. Once the search starts, the book falls into a rhythm of clue, mask sighting, flight, new clue, and the chase to Edinburgh runs long enough that the supernatural rules start to blur. Agnes explains the Halfway in one rushed conversation after three hundred pages of hints, and Grey's motive, once spoken, is almost shockingly small next to the build-up. Tyler is useful as a driver and a walking explanation of the Minotaur myth, but he spends a lot of the book waiting to be told what is happening.

The book is also trying to do more than its length comfortably holds. There is the school bullying, the parents' suicide, the fashion world, the True Crime obsession, the body horror, and the question of what a changeling actually is. Some of those threads get a paragraph and some get a chapter. Still, the ending refuses the easy move of making the sisters either innocent or evil. They are dead things wearing stolen faces who love each other with complete sincerity, and Grey's lack of remorse is the most unsettling beat in the book because she is also the only one who did anything. That knot is not untied at the end, and I think that is the point.

FAQ

Is House of Hollow part of a series?

No. It is a standalone novel with a complete story, though the final page leaves one doorway deliberately open.

What is the Halfway in House of Hollow?

It is a decaying place between life and death that the sisters reached as children through a door, and later learned to travel again.

How much horror is in the book?

Quite a lot: body horror involving skin, rot and insects, plus a masked killer, though the opening half reads more like an eerie family mystery.