Cover of Hawaii by James A. Michener

Hawaii

2,295-word summary 10 min read 937 pages in the book

First published
1959
Publisher
Random House
Pages
937
ISBN
9780394427973
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. How the book was built
  2. The island arrives, and the first voyage
  3. The missionaries and the farm of bitterness
  4. Plantations, leprosy, and a kingdom lost
  5. The golden men and where it ends
  6. What I think now
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

A friend of mine told me that reading this book is like watching a whole island grow in fast forward, and I think that is the best short description I have heard. It was published in 1959 by Random House, in the same year that Hawaii became the fiftieth state, and the first edition runs to 937 pages. That is a lot of pages, and I will not pretend I sailed through them. I read it slowly, a chapter at a time, and what struck me most was that Michener is not really writing about one person. He is writing about a place, and about the many groups of people who arrived there over centuries and decided to stay. Once I accepted that, the length stopped feeling like a burden and started feeling like the point.

The timing of the book is part of its identity. It appeared in November 1959, within weeks of Hawaii entering the Union as the fiftieth state, and it was translated into more than thirty languages. Two films were made from it: Hawaii in 1966, which concentrated on the missionary chapter, and The Hawaiians in 1970, which picked up the later arrivals. I have not seen either recently, but knowing they exist explains why certain scenes feel staged for a camera. Michener was writing at the moment when the islands were being reinvented politically, and the novel keeps looking backward and forward at the same time.

The book is built as six long sections, each one covering a different wave of arrival. The first section is short. The others are closer to short novels on their own. The story starts with the formation of the islands millions of years ago and ends in the mid 1950s, so the sweep is enormous. Some readers love that. Others find it cold. I landed somewhere in the middle, and I want to explain why.

How the book was built

Before I get into the story, it helps to know how Michener wrote it. He did real research for this book. He worked at the Hawaiian-Mission Historical Library and talked to specialists on volcanoes, botany, pineapples, and Chinese culture. His technical adviser was a Hawaiian scholar named Clarice B. Taylor, who explained customs, language, family names, and the small nuances of island life to him. Taylor told him that the things he wanted were not going to be found in books, and that the material he needed had to come out of her own head. That sentence explains a great deal about the finished novel. There is an enormous amount of observed detail here, and much of it is the kind of detail a library cannot give you.

Michener also based several characters on real people. The missionary Abner Hale is a caricature of Hiram Bingham, a real figure in Hawaiian history, and another missionary named Asa Thurston helped shape the character as well. The Chinese businessman Hong Kong Kee is widely thought to have been inspired by Chinn Ho, who was known as the Chinese Rockefeller. Knowing this changed how I read the book. It made the fictional families feel like doorways into actual history rather than inventions dressed up in period costume.

That structure is worth understanding before you begin. Except for the opening geological chapter, each section is roughly the length of a standalone novella, with its own setting, its own cast, and its own argument. Characters from one section occasionally turn up in the next, but nobody carries the whole book. This is why Michener can cover a thousand years without ever pretending that one family lived through all of it. He is writing a history of arrivals, and the form follows that decision. It also means you can put the book down for a week between sections without losing the thread, which is how I ended up reading it.

There is a caveat worth stating early. The sections about the earliest Polynesian inhabitants draw more on folklore than on anthropology, and some events are fictionalized. Michener was writing a novel, not a textbook, and he was writing in 1959, when the scholarly picture was thinner than it is now. I kept that in mind when the early chapters started to feel more like a legend than a record.

The island arrives, and the first voyage

The opening section, called From the Boundless Deep, is the shortest and in some ways the most beautiful. It describes lava pushing up out of the ocean, the slow creation of land, and the patient work of life taking hold. Michener writes about the first small organisms that can survive on bare rock, about lichens and ferns, about soil forming over an unimaginable stretch of time, until at last there is a forest and rain and a place where people might live. There are no characters in this section. It is pure description, and it works because the author clearly found the subject fascinating.

Then the book jumps to Bora Bora and the section called From the Sunswept Lagoon. King Tamatoa and his brother Teroro are unhappy with the neighboring islands. Tahiti and Havaiki are pressuring the Bora Borans to give up their old gods, Tane and Taaroa, and worship Oro instead, a fire god who demands human sacrifice. Tamatoa proposes that they simply leave and find a place where they can practice their own religion in peace. There is a wonderful stretch where the decision is argued over, agreed to, and then nearly undone by fear. Teroro, unable to let the insult pass, secretly sets fire to Havaiki on the way out.

The argument about leaving is one of the liveliest parts of the book, because it is really an argument about what a people owes to its gods and to its dead. Tamatoa is a king who has run out of patience with the demands coming from Tahiti, and Teroro is the hotter head who cannot let an insult go unanswered. Michener gives both men convincing reasons, which makes the voyage feel like a choice rather than an escape.

They sail for the Hawaiian islands in a canoe named Wait for the West Wind. Later, some of them return to Bora Bora to fetch women and children and an idol of the volcano goddess Pele. This is the part of the book that reads most like a founding myth, and I mean that as a compliment. Michener gives the voyage a physical reality: the cramped boat, the navigation by stars and swells, the exhaustion, the arguments about whether they will ever see land. By the time they arrive, I understood why these people would build a whole culture around the idea of a long journey.

The missionaries and the farm of bitterness

The third section, From the Farm of Bitterness, moves to the early 1800s and the arrival of American missionaries. This is the part of the novel that became the 1966 film starring Max von Sydow and Julie Andrews, which tells you something about where the drama sits. Abner Hale is a stern, narrow man who believes he is saving souls, and his wife arrives full of the same certainty. They set about changing daily life on the islands, and the book is careful to show both sides of that project. The missionaries build schools and write down a language that had until then been spoken. They also condemn ordinary customs and treat a proud culture as though it were a child needing correction.

I found this section uncomfortable in a way I suspect Michener intended. He is not writing a simple hero story. The Hales and the Whipples become founding families, and their descendants shape the islands for generations, but the cost of their certainty is written into every page. There is a scene in which the old ways are publicly renounced that is hard to read without thinking about how quickly a culture can be made to feel ashamed of itself. At the same time, Michener gives the missionaries real fears and real hardships. They die of disease, they bury children, and they never quite stop wondering whether they did more harm than good. That complexity kept the section from becoming a lecture.

Plantations, leprosy, and a kingdom lost

From the Starving Village is about the Chinese who came to work the pineapple and sugarcane plantations. The Kee family is at the center of it, and the patriarch eventually contracts leprosy, called the Chinese sickness in the book, and is sent to the leper colony at Molokai. That storyline is the emotional heart of the section. It shows how quickly a working life can turn into exile, and how a family holds together when one of its members is treated as untouchable. Michener also folds in a fictionalized version of the 1893 overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaii, so the personal story and the political one keep intersecting.

I was surprised by how much I cared about the Kee family. Michener gives them ordinary ambitions and ordinary quarrels, which is his way of making a large historical shift feel close to the reader. When the patriarch is diagnosed and shipped off to Molokai, the book does not look away from the humiliation of that journey. It also shows the family arguing about what the diagnosis means and how much of their old life they are willing to give up. The overthrow of the kingdom enters the story in the same way, through its effects on people trying to run a business and keep a household together rather than through a formal account of the politics.

Then comes From the Inland Sea, which follows the Japanese workers brought in to replace Chinese laborers who had begun setting up their own businesses. Kamejiro Sakagawa is one of the figures here, a man whose family story runs through the section and into the next. Michener traces the shift from imported labor to settled communities, with all the friction that involves. The section also covers the bombing of Pearl Harbor, and it is striking how the war arrives in a book that has spent hundreds of pages building a world of plantations and family arguments. The attack is not treated as a surprise to the people living there. They had been watching the sky for a long time.

These two sections are the ones I would recommend to someone who wants to understand why the book has endured. Michener is at his best with the small mechanics of a community forming: who owns the land, who gets the contract, whose child marries whose, which language is spoken at home and which at school. He understands that history happens in those details more than in treaties.

The golden men and where it ends

The final section, The Golden Men, deals with intermarriage among the island's groups and the culture and economy that emerge from it. The title refers to the mixed-race descendants of these unions, and Michener treats them as the answer to the question the whole book has been asking: what does it mean to belong somewhere? By this point the story has moved into the twentieth century and then into the 1950s. The islands are no longer a kingdom, no longer a territory in quite the old sense, and on the edge of statehood.

I have to be honest that this was my least favorite section. It reads more like a summary of social change than a story. Where the earlier chapters gave me Teroro or Abner Hale or the Kee family to hold on to, this one kept pulling back to a wide angle and explaining. Some of that is the author's impatience to reach the present, and some of it may be that he simply had more lived material for the earlier waves of arrival. The book ends without a single triumphant note, which I respected. It stops in the mid 1950s with the islands changed forever and the people still arguing about what they are.

What I think now

I should say something about the sound of the prose, because it is a real part of the experience. Michener writes long, declarative sentences and repeats key phrases until they acquire the weight of a refrain. In the geological opening that patient rhythm is perfect, because he is describing processes that take an age. In the later chapters it can feel heavy, especially when he is listing the contents of a household or the details of a plantation contract. I found myself skimming a few of those passages and then going back, because the accumulated detail is the whole method. Strip it out and the book would be a much thinner thing.

Would I hand this to a friend? Yes, with warnings. It is long, it is episodic, and it asks you to care about a place rather than a hero. The early chapters lean on folklore, and the last one leans on exposition. There are stretches where Michener's research sits on the page a little too heavily, and the whole book carries the assumptions of its time about which cultures count as civilized.

But the ambition is real, and so is the result. I finished it knowing far more than I did before about how the islands were formed, why the missionaries arrived, what drew Chinese and Japanese workers across the ocean, and how a kingdom became a state. There is a 1970 sequel film called The Hawaiians that picks up the later chapters, but the novel is the fuller experience. The best way to read it is the way I ended up reading it: slowly, one wave of arrivals at a time, letting each group have its turn before moving on.

FAQ

When was Hawaii published?

It was published by Random House in November 1959, the year Hawaii became a state. The first edition runs 937 pages and carries ISBN 9780394427973.

Is Hawaii a historical novel?

Yes, though it is episodic. Six sections follow the islands from their volcanic formation to the mid 1950s, and the earliest Polynesian sections rely more on folklore than on strict anthropology.

Has the book been adapted for film?

Twice. The 1966 film Hawaii starred Max von Sydow and Julie Andrews and focused on the missionary chapter. The 1970 follow up The Hawaiians starred Charlton Heston.