Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
I read this one on a long flight, which seemed like a good idea at the time and turned out to be a slightly nervous-making one. It is a thriller built on a single clean premise, the kind you can explain in a sentence and then spend three hundred pages watching get complicated. Falling came out in July 2021 from Avid Reader Press, an imprint of Simon & Schuster, and runs 304 pages in the hardcover. It was Newman's first novel, and the story of how she wrote it is almost as striking as the book itself. She was working as a flight attendant at the time and thought of the idea on a flight from Los Angeles to New York. She scribbled scenes on cocktail napkins and catering bills and typed them up during layovers. The manuscript was turned down by forty-one agents before Shane Salerno took it on. When it appeared it went straight to number two on the New York Times bestseller list, and Universal and Working Title paid a reported $1.5 million for the film rights, with Newman hired to write the script.
That backstory explains a lot about the book's strengths and its limits. Newman knows what a crew says to each other in a galley, and she knows the small humiliations of being a passenger. What she does not always know is how people talk when they are not pilots or flight attendants, and the dialogue can flatten out in the scenes away from the airplane. More on that later.
A morning that starts slightly wrong
The book opens with a nightmare, five pages of a plane going down in flames. It turns out to be a recurring dream that Bill Hoffman, a commercial pilot for Coastal Airways, has been having. The dream is a cheat in one sense, because it tells you where the book is heading, but it also sets the tone: this is a story about a man who already knows, somewhere in his gut, how this day is going to end.
Bill is called in on his day off. The airline's chief pilot, Walt O'Malley, asks him personally to fly a Saturday Los Angeles to New York run, and Bill says yes because he believes he cannot say no. The cost is that he misses his ten-year-old son Scott's first little league baseball game of the season. His wife Carrie is angry. They have a short, tense exchange in the kitchen while a stranger sits in the other room, a technician from the cable company named Sam who has come to fix the internet. Bill leaves without really making amends, promising to FaceTime later. He never speaks to Scott before he goes.
The moment Bill is out the door, Sam pulls a gun on Carrie. She is stuck in the house with Scott and their ten-month-old daughter Elise, and the man who was fixing their internet is now holding them hostage.
At the airport Bill moves through the security line with the easy confidence of someone who flies for a living, pleased to be waved past the metal detectors that ordinary passengers have to endure. He tries to call Carrie and gets no answer. He walks the plane before boarding, checking for problems, and is glad to find Jo Watkins working the flight. Jo is a veteran flight attendant who has flown with Bill for more than twenty years, and she is the head of the cabin crew. In the cockpit, first officer Ben Miro is running the preflight checklist. Bill signs off the load sheet, hands it to Jo, and a young boy is brought up front to meet the pilots. Bill gives the kid a pair of plastic wings. Then the plane takes off.
The photograph and the call
A few minutes into the flight, Bill's laptop pings. There is an email from Carrie's account with no text, only a photograph: Carrie and Scott with hoods over their heads, and what looks like an explosive vest strapped to Carrie's chest. Another message tells him to put in his earphones. Then comes a FaceTime call.
The man on the screen is Saman Khani, who calls himself Sam. He is wearing an explosive vest of his own, and he is politely, almost conversationally, telling Bill that he will kill Bill's family unless Bill crashes the plane. Sam has been busy. Before Bill left the house that morning, Sam slipped several things into his flight bag: a privacy screen to put over the laptop so nobody can read the conversation, a vial of poison meant for Ben, and a canister of poison gas for the passengers.
Bill insists on seeing his family properly. Sam pulls the hoods off Carrie and Scott, and Bill sees his wife gagged and restrained, holding the crying baby Elise. He recognizes Carrie's pink-painted toenails, which is the small concrete detail that makes the threat real for him. Sam says he wants the plane brought down in Washington, D.C. Later the target changes to Yankee Stadium. When Bill asks what happens if he refuses, Sam says there is a backup on the plane. When Bill asks what Sam wants, the answer is that he wants to see what happens when a good man is put in a situation where there is no good choice.
There is a motive, eventually. Sam and Ben are Kurds from Iran who say they lost family members after the American withdrawal from the region, and the recorded statement Bill is forced to make speaks of thousands of Kurdish men, women and children killed. Sam also got to this flight through blackmail: he had child pornography on the airline's chief pilot's computer and used it to force O'Malley to put Bill on the roster. That is a lot of machinery for a hostage plot, but it gives the book its engine.
Sam orders Bill to record a video statement, to be released after the crash. Bill refuses until Sam pours hot tea on Carrie's leg and hangs up. Then Bill records it and sends it, timing it so Ben is briefly out of the cockpit on a break.
Jo takes charge of the cabin
Bill breaks Sam's rule almost immediately by going back and telling Jo what is happening. He is careful to say he will never crash the plane, but he needs her to prepare the cabin in case he has to deploy the gas canister. Jo does the obvious thing and texts her nephew Theo Baldwin, an FBI agent in Los Angeles. Theo is in the office on a Saturday trying to recover from a bad drug raid that put him on probation. His supervisor, Assistant Director Michelle Liu, is reluctant but decides she cannot ignore the message. A tactical team heads for Bill's house.
The ground operation goes badly. A local politician wanders up to the house while the team is moving into position, Theo tries to redirect him, and the house explodes. Bill gets text messages from neighbors about the fire and assumes the worst. A later call shows him that Carrie and the children are alive, though Sam is angry that Bill has not followed orders.
Jo brings the other two flight attendants into the plan: Kellie, who is new, and Michael Rodenburg, whom everyone calls Big Daddy, a veteran of twenty years. The cockpit door is locked and cannot be opened from the cabin, so the crew are on their own. They decide to drop the oxygen masks manually and tell passengers there is a problem with the oxygen release system. They cannot use the public address system because Sam is listening through Bill's computer, so they walk row by row.
That is when the ordinary human behavior starts causing trouble. A passenger who is some kind of social media influencer takes a photo of himself in a mask and posts it. Airline employees reply that the cover story is nonsense, the news picks it up, and suddenly a good number of the passengers know something is wrong. Jo and Big Daddy face a cabin that is turning against them, and eventually Jo goes live on television to tell the whole country what is happening, because that is the only way she can get the same information to every passenger at once. That decision pushes Liu and her superiors toward the possibility of shooting the plane down.
Morse code and a parking lot by the beach
While all that is happening in the cabin, Bill is doing something quiet in the cockpit. The back of the book keeps a running thread of air traffic controllers in New York, and they notice that Bill is tapping out Morse code on the backup frequency radio, with the volume turned down so Ben cannot hear it through his headset. Through that slow, old-fashioned signal he passes along what he can about his family: they are in a moving van, somewhere near Los Angeles International Airport.
Theo pieces it together. He works out that Carrie and the kids are in a parking lot near Dockweiler Beach. Liu is hesitant to act on what she considers a hunch, but Theo drives out there anyway. He arrives as Carrie is confronting Sam. He shoots Sam in the leg, Sam grabs the gun during a struggle, and then Sam turns it on himself. The hostage threat, everyone assumes, is over.
Except it is not. The reveal that has been building since the first FaceTime call lands here: Ben is part of it. He pulls a gun on Bill in the cockpit and reveals that he and Sam were together in this. Ben remembers coming home to find Sam trying to kill himself over the deaths of their families, and he promised he would die with him. That is why he will not be talked down. Sam is dead and Ben keeps flying the plan anyway, and for a stretch of the book it looks as though the only way out is the one Bill has been refusing.
There is a second canister of gas. Bill has thrown the first one, and the crew's quick work with the masks has limited the damage, but Ben tosses the second and more people are hurt. Then he tells Bill the real target: Yankee Stadium, where the seventh game of the World Series is under way. The baseball scenes, cut in between the cockpit chapters, have a strange, old movie quality about them, with the players noticing the crowd leaving and deciding to keep playing anyway. I found them oddly moving while I was reading and a bit silly in retrospect, which may be exactly the effect Newman was after.
The pen, the gun, and the landing
The ending comes together fast. Four F-16 fighters are escorting the plane, and the order to shoot it down is close. Jo tells Big Daddy and Kellie that Ben is one of the terrorists and that he has a gun. She decides to use the override code to get into the cockpit, even though Ben can block her from the inside.
Ben enters the code to lock her out, an alarm sounds, and Bill uses the distraction to grab him. They struggle. Bill gets his hands around Ben's neck, loses his grip, then stabs Ben in the neck with a pen at the same moment Ben fires the gun. Bill is hit in the shoulder and slumps into his seat. An F-16 pilot moves up to look into the cockpit and reports that it appears empty. Jo gets the door open, finds Ben dead, and pulls Bill upright, asking him to talk her through the landing.
Bill pulls the plane up over the stadium, then turns toward John F. Kennedy International Airport with the fighters alongside. He is fading in and out, and he has to talk Jo through the controls as they descend. The landing is rough. The nose drops onto the runway and then rights itself. The forward door opens, the yellow slide unfolds, and Big Daddy and Kellie start getting passengers off while Jo and the others carry Bill out of the cockpit. Bobby Adelson, the Yankees center fielder mentioned in those baseball interludes, ends up on the winning side of a Series decided while everyone is watching the sky.
What happens after, and what I think of it
In the final chapter, Jo visits Bill in the hospital. She admits she never thought about her own family during the crisis, and Bill thanks her for believing in him. Theo gets a promotion along with a one-month suspension. The crew are given four months off. O'Malley is arrested. Kellie and Big Daddy are still recovering from the gas. Bill has a dream in which Ben and Sam sit together sharing hot drinks and laughing, and when he wakes up he goes back to the articles he has been reading about the Kurdish-Turkish conflict. He tells Carrie he does not know how to fix what happened in Kurdistan. She tells him he cannot fix it himself, but he can find the people who can.
I want to be fair about the parts that did not work for me. The twists are telegraphed early. Anyone who has read a few thrillers will guess Ben's allegiance well before the reveal, and the person the crew distrusts turning out to be brave, and the reverse, follows a pattern you can see coming. Some of the dialogue, especially between the FBI agents and in the kitchen at the start, sounds like people reading lines rather than talking. The book also leans on a broad, simplified picture of Middle Eastern people that flattens real anger into terrorist archetypes, and the content note in at least one study guide flags exactly that. The baseball subplot has a sentimental, flag-waving quality that sits awkwardly with the rest.
What works is the stuff Newman knows first hand. The galley conversations, the way a crew handles a cabin in trouble, the small procedures and the language of aviation, all of it feels lived in. The book moves at almost exactly the speed of the flight it describes, and when it is in the air it is genuinely hard to put down. The moral argument is simple but effective: Bill is asked to choose between strangers and his own children, and the book keeps finding ways to make that choice worse. It is a very well made machine for making you turn pages, with a real affection for the crew at its center, and that is enough to carry the weaker stretches.
Would I hand it to someone about to board a plane? Probably not. Would I hand it to a reader who likes a high concept thriller with a ticking clock and a crew worth caring about? Yes, and I would tell them to read it quickly, before they have too much time to think about the plot.
FAQ
What is the basic premise of Falling?
A man holds pilot Bill Hoffman's wife and children hostage and orders him to crash his Los Angeles to New York flight. The novel follows the hours in the air and on the ground as the crew and the FBI try to find a way out.
Is Falling based on a true story?
No. It is a work of fiction and Newman's debut novel, published in 2021. She drew on her own years as a flight attendant for the cabin and cockpit details, but the plot and characters are invented.
Who is Jo Watkins and why does she matter?
Jo is the veteran flight attendant leading the cabin crew and an old friend of Bill's. She texts her FBI-agent nephew for help, keeps the passengers calm and finally enters the cockpit to help the wounded Bill land the plane.





























