Cover of Audition by Katie Kitamura

Audition

2,315-word summary 10 min read 208 pages in the book

First published
2025
Publisher
Riverhead Books
Pages
208
ISBN
9780593852323
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A lunch that refuses to settle
  2. The magazine profile and the word that changed
  3. The play she cannot finish
  4. The second half resets the table
  5. The ambiguity and the chill
  6. Who this is for
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked up Audition because it kept turning up in the talk around the 2025 Booker shortlist, and because a novel of 208 pages that supposedly rearranges its own first half sounded like a bet worth taking. Katie Kitamura's fifth novel came out from Riverhead Books on 8 April 2025, it is set in New York City, and it is built around a single lunch that gets told twice. By the time I closed it I was not sure whether I had read one story or two, and I think that uncertainty is exactly what the book is after.

The narrator is unnamed, an actress in her late forties who has been married for a long time to an art critic named Tomas. The book opens with her meeting a young man for lunch. He is twenty-five, a film student, and he goes by the name Xavier. The restaurant sits in the financial district, that part of lower Manhattan which empties out at night and feels oddly hushed in the middle of a weekday. She orders two gin and tonics. She cannot quite get through the meal. That is the starting image, and Kitamura returns to it in the second half with changes that look small on the page and turn out to be enormous.

What I noticed first is how little the book explains. There is no heading to tell you which version of events you are inside, and no narrator stepping forward to say that the story has started over. The shift simply happens, and the reader is expected to feel it. Some people will find that bracing. Others will feel that the author has declined to do her job, and I have some sympathy with both reactions.

A lunch that refuses to settle

The first half gives us the meal as a kind of standoff. The actress is meeting Xavier because he asked, or because she agreed to it, and the reason becomes clear only gradually. Across the table is a young man who believes he has a claim on her. She is a woman who has spent decades learning to manage what other people project onto her, and now here is a stranger with a theory about her life that she did not invite.

The gin and tonics do a lot of quiet work. She orders two, one for each of them, and the act of sitting there with a drink she is not really drinking gives her somewhere to put her attention. It is a small physical detail, but it anchors the whole scene. I kept picturing the two glasses and the way the meal drags, the way a lunch can stretch when the person opposite you wants something you cannot give.

Kitamura is good on the texture of that kind of encounter. Xavier is young and earnest and armed with research. The actress is careful, professional, and used to being looked at. Neither of them says quite what they mean at first. The conversation moves around the edges of the real question, which is whether she is the woman he thinks she is.

There is a question of age that hangs over the whole book. The actress is forty-nine, and she is aware, in a way the narrative keeps returning to, that the judgment passed on an age difference is always harsher when the woman is the older person. She has thought about this before, probably more than once and in more than one context. It colours how she reads Xavier's interest and how she polices her own responses to him. A younger man can be forgiven a great deal in fiction. Kitamura's narrator knows she will not be granted the same forgiveness, and she adjusts accordingly.

The magazine profile and the word that changed

Here is the mechanism of the whole mistake. Xavier has read an old magazine profile of the actress. In that profile she appears to say that she gave up a child for adoption. What she actually told the journalist was that she had an abortion, and the magazine softened the word into something vaguer. That single editorial decision, made years ago by someone she may barely know, becomes the foundation of a young man's entire understanding of his own origins.

Xavier grew up in an adoptive family. He compared faces, he compared dates, and he assembled a case. To him the profile confirmed what the photographs had already suggested. This is the part of the book that interested me most, because Kitamura is not really writing about a mistaken identity. She is writing about how a person builds a certainty out of scraps and then refuses to let go of it. The evidence is thin, but the need behind it is very thick.

I found it hard not to feel for him, even while recognizing that he is wrong about her. He has taken the one story that was available to him and built a self around it. The actress, for her part, has to sit across a table from a stranger who is treating a piece of softened journalism as a fact about her body and her history. She knows the truth. She also knows that correcting it will not necessarily help, because people who have built a theory do not give it up when you hand them a better fact.

The magazine detail is also a quiet indictment of how language gets used. A journalist chose a gentle phrase, the kind of phrase that spares a reader discomfort, and in doing so handed a future reader the wrong story. The actress is living with the consequences of a euphemism. I kept thinking about how many real lives must turn on similarly small acts of softening, and how rarely anyone goes back to fix the word.

The play she cannot finish

Running alongside the lunch is the actress's work. She is rehearsing a difficult play called The Opposite Shore, and she cannot make a key transformation scene work. This is not a minor subplot. It is the other half of the book's argument, because the problem on stage and the problem in the restaurant are the same problem in different costumes.

A transformation scene asks an actor to become someone else in front of an audience, to make a change believable. The actress cannot find the truth of it. Meanwhile Xavier is asking her, without any right to, to accept a transformation she never wrote for herself, to become a mother he has already decided she is. She is a woman who cannot convincingly change on stage being asked to change off it by a person who has no claim on her.

I liked this part more than I expected to, partly because Kitamura does not explain the connection for us. She sets the rehearsal problem beside the lunch and trusts the reader to see the echo. The play she is rehearsing is about crossing over, about reaching a far side, and the title keeps its distance from her. The Opposite Shore is somewhere she cannot get to, both in the rehearsal room and in the conversation with Xavier.

There is also something about being an actress that the book uses well. She is a person whose job is to be legible to others, to be read correctly. Now she is being read incorrectly, and the skill that usually serves her, the ability to project a self, is no use against a young man who has decided what that self must be. I suspect Kitamura is interested in the profession less for its glamour than for the way it makes identity into something you can be audited on.

The second half resets the table

Then the book starts again. The same restaurant, the same lunch, the same two people across the table. But the play is now called The Rivers, and it is a success. Xavier is no longer a stranger with a theory. He is treated as the couple's son. Tomas, the art critic husband, is part of the picture now, and the actress and Tomas discuss Xavier's studies together as parents would. They persuade him to give up his apartment and move back in with them.

That last detail is the one that unsettled me most. In the first half, Xavier is an outsider trying to get in. In the second, he is already inside, and the people he wanted to belong to are making plans for him. He is being drawn into a family the way a person gets drawn into any family, through small practical decisions about where he lives and what he studies. The move back in is not presented as a crisis. It is presented as something sensible, something a mother and father would say.

The two halves are not polished into a neat puzzle with a single key. They sit next to each other, and the differences accumulate. A play that failed becomes a play that worked. A claim that was frightening becomes an arrangement that is warm. A woman who could not finish a transformation scene suddenly has a son, a husband who shares the parenting, and a grown child to steer. Kitamura never tells us which half is the real one, or whether both are, or whether that question even makes sense.

What she does instead is show how quickly a family can harden around a person. Once Xavier is installed as the son, the role comes with a whole set of expectations. He is a student, he needs somewhere to live, he needs guidance. The actress and Tomas slip into the parts without ceremony. I read this as a suggestion that family is less a fact of biology than a story that everyone agrees to keep telling, but the book is careful not to say so in so many words.

The ambiguity and the chill

This is where the book divides people. Kitamura's deliberate ambiguity can be genuinely frustrating. You want a verdict. You want someone to say whether the son is real, whether the abortion happened, whether the second lunch is a fantasy or a correction. The novel withholds all of that, and it withholds it patiently, almost politely.

Kirkus called the book chilly, and I understand the word. The narrator at one point wonders whether a family is "a shared delusion, a mutual construction," and that line sits close to the centre of the whole design. It is a clever idea, and Kitamura is elegant with it. But a trick can be more elegant than it is emotionally satisfying, and some readers will feel that the restraint costs the book something. I felt it in the second half, where the warmth of the family arrangement is so controlled that it is hard to know whether we are meant to trust it.

The New York Review of Books piece on the novel is titled around the idea of shared delusions, which tells you how strongly this reading has taken hold. The actress's situation lends itself to it. She is a woman whose private fact was rewritten by a magazine, then rewritten again by a young man who needed a mother, and then possibly rewritten a third time by a version of her life in which all of it working out. Each layer is a story about her that she did not author.

The unfinished play matters here too. If the transformation scene never comes right in one half and the play succeeds in the other, then the book is asking what it means for a performance to work. Maybe a transformation is convincing only when the audience agrees to believe in it. Xavier is the audience for his own theory, and in the second half Tomas joins him. The family becomes the rehearsal that finally found its ending.

I want to be fair about the chill, though. It is a risk Kitamura is taking on purpose. A warmer book would have told us how the actress felt about being claimed, would have given her a confidant or a scene of reckoning. This book refuses that. What it offers instead is a very precise account of how a person can be boxed in by other people's certainties, and of how easily the box can be mistaken for home.

Who this is for

Audition is a short novel with a large appetite for questions it will not close. It will suit a reader who enjoys formal experiments and who can sit with a book that changes its own rules halfway through. It will frustrate a reader who wants a clear answer about the son, or a conventional emotional payoff, or a narrator who explains herself. Those are not small differences in taste, and I would hand this to the first reader with more enthusiasm than the second.

I also think the book is better on the mechanics of self-deception than it is on feeling. The scene in the restaurant is sharply observed, the magazine detail is a genuinely good idea, and the way the second half rewires the first is satisfying to watch. But the people in it can seem like positions in an argument rather than people you miss when the book is over. That is a limitation, and it is the same limitation that the word chilly is getting at.

Still, there is something in it that stayed with me. It is the picture of a woman sitting with two gin and tonics across from a young man who has decided who she is, knowing the truth and understanding that the truth may not be enough. Kitamura does not rescue that moment with a speech or a reveal. She leaves it there, slightly cold, completely clear, and lets the reader work out what it means to be auditioned for a part in someone else's story.

FAQ

What is the central misunderstanding in Audition?

A twenty-five-year-old film student named Xavier believes the narrator is his mother because he read an old magazine profile that turned her account of an abortion into a story about giving up a child for adoption. She told the journalist the truth, and the magazine softened it.

Why does the book tell the same lunch twice?

The two halves reset the same restaurant scene with different outcomes. In the first the narrator struggles through the meal; in the second Xavier is treated as the son of her and her husband Tomas, and the couple urge him to give up his apartment and move back in. Kitamura never says which version is real.

Was Audition shortlisted for any prizes?

Yes, it was shortlisted for the 2025 Booker Prize. It was published by Riverhead Books in April 2025 at 208 pages.