Cover of Counting by 7s by Holly Goldberg Sloan

Counting by 7s

2,306-word summary 10 min read 384 pages in the book

First published
2013
Publisher
Dial Books for Young Readers
Pages
384
ISBN
9780803738553
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. A girl who counts by sevens
  2. Dell, Mai, Quang-ha, and a runaway cat
  3. The news on the front walk
  4. Cleaning up Dell's apartment
  5. Sunflowers in the courtyard
  6. The courthouse and the number seven
  7. What works and what grates
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I had been told this was a book about a girl who counts by sevens, and I honestly thought the title was a gimmick. I could not have been more wrong about that, though in a way the number does end up meaning exactly what the title promises. Holly Goldberg Sloan published it in 2013 with Dial Books for Young Readers, a middle grade novel of 384 pages in its first hardcover edition, and it found a large audience, including a stretch on the New York Times bestseller list. Reading it now, I can see why people hand it to twelve-year-olds, but I also think plenty of adults will recognize the feeling it is describing, which is what it is like to be the odd person in a room and then, suddenly, to lose the few people who made that oddness feel safe.

A girl who counts by sevens

Willow Chance is twelve and brilliant, and the book does not let you forget either fact. She knows the Latin names of plants, she can rattle off the symptoms of rare medical conditions, and she finds the number seven soothing. When the world gets loud or confusing, she counts by sevens: seven, fourteen, twenty-one, and so on, until her breathing settles. It is a small private ritual, the kind a child invents before she knows why she needs it. Sloan treats it with respect rather than as a cute quirk.

Willow is not good at school in the way schools usually reward. She is new at Sequoia Middle School, and the other kids strike her as loud and unhygienic, which is how she sees most of them. She is not trying to be cruel; she is reporting what her senses tell her. When she earns a perfect score on a test, her teacher suspects her of cheating and sends her to see the school's behavioral counselor. That is how Willow first meets Dell Duke, a man who will become one of the most important people in her life despite being, at this point, almost comically unsuited to the job.

I liked this opening a lot. Sloan does not ask us to find Willow adorable. She gives us a child who is difficult, who judges people by their smell and their noise, and who is also clearly lonely under all that certainty. The tension between those two things carries the early chapters.

Dell, Mai, Quang-ha, and a runaway cat

Dell Duke is a school counselor with no real talent for counseling. He is lonely, disorganized, and deeply set in his routines, and he has a bachelor apartment full of things he never throws away. Willow unnerves him because she is smarter than he is and because she sees right through him. He does not know what to do with her, and that very uncertainty is the beginning of a change in him.

Two other students enter the story through Dell's office. Mai Nguyen is a high school girl with a blunt, fearless way of talking. Quang-ha is her brother, guarded and angry, and a regular visitor to Dell. Willow takes to Mai immediately and starts teaching herself Vietnamese so she can speak with her in her first language, and Mai eventually starts giving her lessons. This detail mattered to me because it shows how Willow shows love: not with hugs or words, but by mastering something that belongs to the person she cares about.

Dell tries to impress the kids one day by bringing in an orange cat he has adopted named Cheddar. The cat escapes, and Dell gives up looking for him almost at once, which tells you a lot about Dell. The kids search, and the search becomes one of their first shared activities. Willow also starts calling a taxi to get from school to Dell's office, and she gets to know the driver, Jairo Hernandez. She studies him the way she studies plants, noticing a suspicious mole on his skin and urging him to have it checked. That single act of attention, a listless girl telling a taxi driver to look at a spot on his arm, turns out to be one of the hinges of the whole book.

Then there is the ice cream. Mai talks Dell into taking the group for ice cream, and for a few pages the story is as light as anything. Dell drives Willow home afterward. When they pull up, there are police cars outside her house.

The news on the front walk

The officers tell Willow that her mother and father have been killed in a car crash. Her adoptive parents, Roberta and Jimmy, were the only people who had ever made her feel fully accepted, and now they are gone. Willow's response is not a movie scene. She goes quiet, she counts, and she keeps asking to rewind, as if the day were a recording she could play backward. Sloan lets that shock sit for a while before anything moves forward.

What happens next is the part of the book that could so easily turn sweet and soft, and mostly does not. Willow has no relatives who can take her. Mai, thinking fast, tells the police that Willow is part of her family. Mai's mother, Pattie Nguyen, runs a nail salon and lives with her two kids in a cramped garage behind it. Pattie agrees to take Willow in temporarily. Willow ends up sharing Mai's room, sleeping in a house that smells of polish and hair product, surrounded by red lanterns and photographs. It is nothing like the orderly home she knew, and it is exactly what she needs.

I want to be honest that there is a convenient quality to this. A child with no family is swept up by a classmate's mother within a single afternoon, and the legal system looks the other way. Sloan is writing a fable about chosen family, not a case file, and once I accepted that, the arrangement stopped bothering me. Readers who want a realistic account of foster care will find the machinery here very thin.

Cleaning up Dell's apartment

The Nguyens' real home, that garage, would never pass a child welfare inspection. Pattie solves the problem by putting down Dell's address, an apartment in a complex called the Gardens of Glenwood, as her own. When the social worker Lenore schedules a visit, the whole group has a few hours to turn Dell's junk-filled bachelor pad into something that looks like a family home. They clean, they rearrange, they shop for furniture, and they move Dell down the hall into a new room shared with a man named Sadhu. They pass the inspection. The lie on paper is the truth in practice, which is the book's favorite kind of joke.

During this period Willow is out of school and spends time at the library. She keeps taking taxis, and her friendship with Jairo deepens. After she helps him spot that dangerous mole, he goes to the doctor, and the news is good. Later he walks into a college bookstore on a whim, buys biology textbooks, and is named the store's one-millionth customer, winning twenty thousand dollars. He decides to use the money for school and to stop driving a cab, and he comes to see Willow as a kind of angel. It is a big coincidence, the lottery-style prize, and I noticed it as a strain on the story's credibility. Jairo's transformation still works because Sloan has earned it through all the small conversations between them.

Another small object does quieter work. Mai watches an acorn get run over by a car and stay intact, retrieves it, and hides it for Willow to find. Willow decides it is her lucky acorn, and she carries it. By the end it will have a job to do.

Sunflowers in the courtyard

The heart of the book, for me, is the garden. Willow looks at the dead courtyard outside the Gardens of Glenwood, with its lava rock and plastic liner, and decides to grow sunflowers there. This is not a cute hobby. It is the first time since her parents died that she plans for a future, since seeds are a bet on months she cannot see. Sloan understands that a garden is a strange and hopeful thing for a grieving child to want.

The project is absurdly complicated. Dell worries about digging up property the bank owns, so Willow writes a proposal and makes Dell present it to the bank. He becomes the building representative, which is the first real responsibility the story gives him, and he rises to it. The group hauls containers from a recycling dumpster, tests and tills the soil, and then pressure washes the building after a dirt storm, which reveals peeling paint and turns one job into a whole exterior cleanup. Quang-ha, who has been angry and withdrawn, digs in. He refuses Willow's careful three-seed method and puts all his hopes into a single seed, and of course it is the strongest plant in the courtyard. Willow keeps his doodle of a seedling sprouting from a man's head pinned to her wall.

The garden changes people in ways that are funny before they are profound. Willow audits the lease at Pattie's nail salon and rewrites its health and safety guide, which brings in more customers. Dell starts running, first for eleven wheezing minutes, then every day, and quietly stops eating meatloaf and uses the computer Willow built from salvaged parts. He makes a new category in the private filing system he keeps in his head, calling himself a mutant, and you can feel him deciding he belongs somewhere. Willow herself tries running in a pair of blinding pink shoes, gets cramps and spasms before she finishes the first loop, and vows to keep going. Every seed sprouts.

That scene, where the group stands around dirt and argues about seeds, is the best thing in the book. Nobody gives a speech about grief. They just show up, week after week, and the sunflowers bloom, and then Willow keeps adding plants until the whole courtyard is a garden.

The courthouse and the number seven

The plot has been moving toward a court date that will decide where Willow lives. She is told that Child Services has found a permanent placement for her, and she assumes the worst, that she will be taken from these people and put in a facility. On the day of the hearing she senses that something is being kept from her. Pattie and Jairo, who have secretly been seeing each other, appear with Mai, Quang-ha, and Dell, and they ask the court for custody of Willow. The judge allows them to take her home. On the ride back, Pattie reveals that she has been saving money and has made an offer to buy the Gardens of Glenwood itself, so the household can stay exactly where it is.

Willow's last act is to plant the lucky acorn in the garden. She also counts again, and this time the counting has changed. She names seven people who hold her life together: her late parents Roberta and Jimmy, Mai, Dell, Quang-ha, Pattie, and Jairo. The number that once helped her organize a lonely world now counts the people she belongs to. It is a neat ending, and Sloan has done the work to make it feel earned rather than pasted on.

What works and what grates

I should say who this book is for and where it stumbles. It is middle grade fiction, aimed roughly at readers aged ten to fourteen, and it wears that age very well. The heroine is twelve, the problems are legible, and the humor is at the level of a smart kid's joke. Adults will notice the grown-up ache underneath, but a younger reader will mostly see a story about a girl who gets a family.

The criticism that sticks most came from Publishers Weekly, which said that Sloan's somewhat portentous storytelling gets in the way of letting readers reach their own conclusions about the ways people save each other. I felt that. There are moments when the book seems to nudge us toward a lesson about resilience and community a little too firmly. Kirkus called the conclusion bright and heartfelt but predictable, and that is fair too. Once the garden starts growing, you can see where the court hearing is headed. The coincidence of the twenty-thousand-dollar prize is the one plot turn I never fully bought.

The book also shifts viewpoints, moving from Willow's sharp first person into third-person chapters about Dell, Jairo, and Pattie. That choice lets us see how one strange girl changes the adults around her, which is one of the book's real strengths. It also slows some chapters down when I was eager to get back to Willow. And yes, the whole thing leans toward the sentimental. A child loses her parents, finds a loud patchwork family, and grows a garden in a courtyard. The praise from Booklist and School Library Journal called it graceful and free of cloying lessons, and I think that is mostly deserved, though not entirely.

What I keep coming back to is the acorn. Willow pockets small things, a feather, an acorn, and she counts by sevens, and at the end those habits turn out to be ways of holding on to people. Sloan never explains the number away. She just lets it become a measure of connection. That restraint is why I forgave the book its coincidences and its tidy ending. If you want a story about grief that refuses to be a tragedy, and you can accept a few convenient turns along the way, this one delivers.

FAQ

Is Counting by 7s appropriate for a twelve-year-old reader?

Yes. It is middle grade fiction aimed at readers aged ten to fourteen, though the grief at its center may feel heavier than the cheerful title suggests.

What does the number seven mean in the book?

Willow counts by sevens to calm herself, and at the end she uses the number to name the seven people who now make up her family.

Does Willow find a permanent home by the end?

Yes. Pattie Nguyen and Jairo Hernandez seek custody at the court hearing, and Willow returns to the Gardens of Glenwood with the family she has built.