Cover of The Sandman, Vol. 4: Season of Mists by Neil Gaiman

The Sandman, Vol. 4: Season of Mists

2,351-word summary 10 min read 224 pages in the book

First published
1992
Publisher
DC Comics
Pages
224
ISBN
9781563890352
Series
The Sandman (#4)
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
  1. A family dinner that goes badly
  2. Lucifer simply leaves
  3. Everyone wants the key
  4. A school story in the middle
  5. Nada, and what Dream decides
  6. Rules, responsibility, and who should read it
  7. Key takeaways
  8. FAQ

I picked this up straight after Dream Country, which is a short, strange collection where Dream himself barely appears. I expected more stand-alone fables. Instead the fourth Sandman book opens with the whole Endless family sitting down together, and a family argument sends Dream into Hell. It is the first time in the series that the stakes felt genuinely large to me, and also the first time I felt sorry for him rather than simply impressed by him.

For the record, these are issues 21 through 28 of The Sandman, originally published by DC Comics across 1990 and 1991 and gathered into a collection in 1992. The edition I read runs about 224 pages. The title is taken from the opening line of Keats's "To Autumn," and the collection carries an introduction by Harlan Ellison. Dave McKean supplied the cover, as he had for the earlier volumes.

A family dinner that goes badly

The book starts with a meeting of the Endless. Destiny and Delirium are introduced here, and the family gathers around Desire, who has always seemed to me the most needling of the siblings. Desire taunts Dream, called Morpheus in this part of the story, about how he treated a former lover, the African queen Nada. Her story was set up in the prologue to The Doll's House, so this is not a random accusation. Dream's pride has real consequences, and the rest of the family knows it.

Death then does something that clearly irritates him. She agrees with Desire. That is enough to push Dream into a decision: he will go to Hell and set right what he did to Nada. The meeting also makes the second reference in the series to the "prodigal," an Endless sibling who walked away from his duties. That word hangs over the whole volume, because Dream is about to make a choice about his own duties.

I liked this opening more than I expected to. It is basically a family dinner where everyone knows one secret and nobody says it directly. Gaiman writes the Endless as people who have known each other far too long, which gives their jabs a weary, domestic feel. Dream arrives already braced for the fight, and the reader can tell he is more rattled than he wants to admit.

It helps to know a little of what came before, though the book gives you enough to follow. The Endless are siblings who are older than the gods and bound to the work their names describe. Dream rules sleep and story, Death ushers the dead, and Desire deals in wanting. They meet rarely, and when they do, old grievances come out. Gaiman gives each of them a distinct way of speaking, so even a short exchange carries the weight of a very long family history. The dialogue here is sharper than in the earlier volumes, less interested in being cryptic and more willing to be honest about resentment.

Lucifer simply leaves

When Dream reaches Hell, he finds that Lucifer has already emptied it. The fallen angels and the damned souls are being expelled, and Lucifer abdicates his rule, handing Dream the key to the gates. This is a striking image, and it is handled with a strange matter-of-factness: Hell as a place someone can just walk out of, leaving the keys with a visitor. The episode later became the basis for the Lucifer spin-off comic written by Mike Carey, which tells you how much the publishers saw in it.

Lucifer himself ends the story sitting on an Australian beach, wingless, grudgingly admiring a sunset. That small closing beat is one of my favorites in the book. After all the grandstanding about rule and punishment, the most powerful rebel in the cosmology is reduced to a man watching the light go down, and he seems almost relieved.

The empty Hell is a strange thing to picture, and Gaiman spends very little time on spectacle. There is no grand battle for the throne. Instead there is an exodus, and then a conversation about who is qualified to take charge of a place nobody seems to want to run for the right reasons. Kelley Jones draws the departing demons with a loose, almost cartoonish energy that keeps the scene from turning solemn. That choice matters, because the volume is full of beings who take themselves very seriously. The art keeps letting some air out of the room.

Word of the abdication spreads among the immortals, and this is where the volume turns into a negotiation. Dream holds a key that a great many beings want, and they all come to the Dreaming to make their case. The book is at its best when it treats gods as petitioners with their own awkward agendas rather than as distant symbols.

Everyone wants the key

The parade of visitors is the part of Season of Mists I remember most clearly. Odin comes from Norse myth hoping to control Hell so that he can avoid Ragnarok, and he brings Loki and Thor with him. Anubis, Bast and Bes arrive from Egyptian mythology offering information in exchange for the key. Susanoo-no-mikoto asks to add Hell to a new underworld his family is putting together. Azazel turns up with Choronzon and Merkin and demands the key in trade for Nada. It is a crowded room, and Gaiman clearly enjoys the collisions.

Two of the visitors are more abstract. Order appears as an empty cardboard box carried by a djinn-like being, and offers to trade the dreams of the newly dead. Chaos shows up as a small girl in clown makeup, threatens Dream, and gives him a balloon. Those two scenes are funny in a way that the rest of the volume is not, and they work because the absurd form and the serious offer sit side by side without comment.

Then there are the fairies. Cluracan and his sister Nuala ask Dream to give control of Hell to no one at all, and Cluracan goes so far as to offer his sister in exchange. Both characters matter in later Sandman stories, so this is their first appearance rather than a throwaway gag. Two angels, Duma and Remiel, are present to observe the proceedings. They are quietly important too, as they turn up again in the Lucifer spin-off.

What interests me is how few of the visitors actually make a moral case. Most of them want the key for reasons of state, or security, or revenge. Odin wants to head off Ragnarok. Susanoo-no-mikoto wants territory for his family. Anubis offers information, which is a polite way of saying a bribe. Azazel is the only one who makes the trade personal, offering Nada herself. Dream listens to all of them, and for a while it looks as if he might hand the key to whoever argues best. That is what makes his final decision, to give it to two angels who were only watching, so satisfying.

I have to say that the sheer number of mythologies on display can be a lot. Norse, Egyptian, Japanese, Christian and faerie representatives all file through, and if you like your fantasy concentrated on a few characters, the middle of this book may feel crowded. For me that congestion is part of the charm. The point is that everyone has a claim, and Dream has to decide whose claim he will honor.

A school story in the middle

Between the negotiations sits a chapter called "In Which the Dead Return; and Charles Rowland Concludes His Education," drawn by Matt Wagner and inked by Malcolm Jones III. It takes place at a traditional English boarding school and follows two schoolboys who are ghosts. The tale is meant to show what happens when Hell closes its doors, and it borrows the shape of the old boarding-school ghost story.

This chapter interrupted me the first time through. I was in the middle of the key negotiations and wanted to get back to them, and the shift in both setting and artwork felt abrupt. Reading it a second time, I could see the logic: the dead need somewhere to go, and closing Hell creates problems for people who are not gods. The two boys never return in the main Sandman series, but they reappear in The Children's Crusade and later in a mini-series called The Dead Boy Detectives, so Gaiman was planting seeds.

The story itself is a compact little mystery, and Charles Rowland is the boy whose education ends badly before the ghost part really begins. What matters is that the pair are trapped in a place that has stopped making sense now that the dead have nowhere to go. The chapter works best as an example of scale. A cosmic decision about the ownership of Hell lands on two schoolboys who mostly want someone to notice them.

The artwork across the collection deserves a mention here. Kelley Jones penciled most of the story, and his oversized, grotesque figures suit gods and demons surprisingly well; there is a dry humor in his shapes that keeps the heavy material from turning solemn. Mike Dringenberg drew the prologue and epilogue, with inks from Malcolm Jones III and George Pratt respectively. The change of hands is noticeable, but it also makes the school interlude feel like a deliberate pause rather than a mistake.

Nada, and what Dream decides

After the private talks, Dream hands the key to Duma and Remiel rather than to any of the gods who argued for it. Then he fights Azazel, enters inside him, and frees Nada while trapping Azazel in his own domain instead. This is the moment the volume has been building toward, and it is more satisfying for being quiet. Dream does not win by declaring a principle. He goes in, gets her out, and deals with the consequence.

He then apologizes to Nada for what he did to her. She is reincarnated as a newborn human child, with permission to enter the Dreaming whenever she wishes. I found this ending moving, though I also think it is a little too neat. A woman who spent a very long time punished for a relationship is made new, and the man who punished her is allowed to feel he has balanced the ledger. The book acknowledges his fault, which matters, but it also gives him a clean way to live with it.

Azazel is the one opponent here with any real physical presence, and the sequence where Dream enters him is the closest the volume comes to a conventional fight. It is brief. That brevity is a feature of the whole book: the big moments keep happening just offstage or in a few tight panels, while the talking goes on at length. I noticed the same rhythm in the earlier collections. Gaiman trusts a face and a pause more than an explosion.

There is a second, quieter ending running alongside that one. Dream discovers that Loki has slipped out of the punishment he was given, and he chooses not to reveal it. He even proposes a negotiation to set Loki free. That thread pays off in the final Sandman collection, so it is deliberately loose here. I noticed it on rereading and missed it completely the first time, which is probably the intention.

The epilogue shows Duma and Remiel settled in as the new rulers of Hell, starting a regimen of punishment meant to redeem the condemned. The condemned are not pleased. That final joke is a sharp one, because it suggests that even a place built on suffering can be reorganized by people who believe they are doing good.

Rules, responsibility, and who should read it

Season of Mists is the first place in the series where the theme of rules and responsibility comes to the front. Dream spends the book deciding what he owes, first to Nada and then to the key he has been handed. The family gathering makes that visible: the Endless are bound by duties they cannot simply quit, and the "prodigal" remark is a warning about what happens when one of them tries.

That is the part that stayed with me. Dream is often written as cold and exacting, and he is here too, but he is also shown as someone learning that a rule is something you maintain rather than something you simply enforce. He ends up less powerful than he could be and more responsible than he wanted to be. I think that is a better story than another display of his authority.

The Keats line in the title is worth a thought as well. It is about autumn, about a moment of fullness that is already tipping toward decay. Dream's decision here feels like that season. He gets the key, he loses the chance to rule, and he gains something he did not expect in Nada's freedom. The book is more interested in that trade than in who wins.

My criticisms are real though. The mythological roll call can feel like a catalog, and the school interlude genuinely drags if you are reading straight through for the key plot. The apology to Nada is handled in a few pages after hundreds of pages of build-up, which left me wanting more of her own voice in the decision. And you really should not start the series here. The weight of the family meeting and the Nada history comes from the two earlier collections.

The 224 page volume suits older teens and adults better than younger readers. There is horror in the imagery, a fair amount of discussion of past abuse of power, and a story about a man who kept a woman imprisoned for centuries. Those are not small things, and the book is at its strongest when it refuses to treat them as decoration. If you have read Preludes and Nocturnes, The Doll's House and Dream Country, this is the point where the series grows up, and it rewards the patience.

FAQ

Do I need to read the first three Sandman volumes before this one?

Yes. The family meeting and Nada's history depend on The Doll's House, so start with volume one and read in order.

Is Season of Mists part of a series?

Yes. It is The Sandman volume four, following Dream Country and preceding A Game of You, collecting issues 21 through 28.

Why does Lucifer leave Hell?

He grows tired of ruling and expels the demons and damned souls, giving Dream the key before settling on an Australian beach.