Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist
2,355-word summary 10 min read 183 pages in the book
- First published
- 2006
- Publisher
- Alfred A. Knopf Books for Young Readers
- Pages
- 183
- ISBN
- 9780375835315
Reading options
What's inside (8 sections)
I picked this one up because the 2008 film, with Michael Cera and Kat Dennings, had been in my head for years, and I wanted to know what the book underneath it actually looked like. The two are not the same experience. The novel arrived in 2006 from Knopf, runs about 183 pages in the first hardcover, and is credited on the cover to Rachel Cohn even though David Levithan wrote half of it. They split the chapters by point of view: Cohn takes Norah, Levithan takes Nick. That arrangement turns out to be the whole engine of the book. You never get a neutral narrator smoothing things over. You get two people talking over each other, correcting each other, and sometimes missing each other completely. The whole story is wrapped around the idea of a playlist that could keep growing for as long as two people keep choosing each other.
The action happens over one night in New York City, mostly around the Lower East Side, and it is built almost entirely out of music talk. If you have ever had a friend explain a song to you with total conviction, as if one lyric explained the entire world, you will recognise these two. They are the kind of teenagers who communicate in references. A thrown-away mix CD becomes a declaration. A hidden bonus track becomes a love letter. I found that charming for most of the book and a little exhausting in the last third, but I never doubted that these were real kids to the authors.
The girl who needed a ride
Nick O'Leary is the straight bassist in a queercore band, the only straight member, and he is three weeks out of a breakup with a girl named Tris. He has been coping by burning mix CDs for her and sending them anyway. Tris has been throwing them away. At a club set, Nick spots Tris in the crowd with a new date, and when she heads toward the bar after the show he panics. He turns to the stranger beside him, a girl in a flannel shirt, and asks her to be his girlfriend for the next five minutes.
The girl is Norah Silverberg, eighteen, a valedictorian from New Jersey who goes to a Catholic girls' school with Tris. She is there to look after her drunk best friend, Caroline. She agrees to Nick's request for a purely practical reason: she needs his car to get Caroline home. Then she kisses him, hard, to sell the lie, and the kiss turns out to be anything but fake. Norah knows who Nick is before he knows who she is. She has been carrying around one of the mix CDs Tris tossed aside, and she knows the lyrics and the playlists Tris shared.
What I liked here is that the authors resist the easy move. Norah does not instantly fall for a mysterious stranger. She falls for someone whose taste she has already been studying from a distance. When Tris confronts them, Norah touches Nick's neck like she owns the place, and Tris storms off. Outside, Tris tries to borrow Nick's car, and Norah tells her off. The car, a battered Yugo that Nick has named Jessie, refuses to start. Scot, Thom's boyfriend, shows up with jumper cables. Thom slips Norah fifty dollars to spend on a night with Nick while he and Scot take Caroline home. It is a strange, generous little arrangement, and it sets the whole evening in motion.
Before they can leave, Tal shows up at the window. Tal is Norah's on-again, off-again ex, and also the nephew of the club owner, Crazy Lou. He calls her the Tin Woman, which is both an insult and an old joke between them. Norah shuts him down. Jessie finally turns over, and they peel away into the night.
Slow dancing with nuns
Nick drives them to Camera Obscura, a burlesque club where the bouncer, Toni, is a drag queen who once interned for Norah's father. Toni seats them like royalty. It is here that the two discover they are both straight edge, which in their world means no drinking, no drugs, no cigarettes. That shared fact matters more than it sounds. It means neither of them is going to be the person who gets too drunk to remember the night, and it quietly separates them from the crowd around them.
Then the nuns come out. Performers dressed as nuns grind onstage to a dance version of The Sound of Music, and Nick offers Norah his hand. They slow-dance in the middle of this absurd scene. He puts his Texaco jacket over her shoulders, the one with Salvatore stitched on it. When the song ends, Norah panics at how close this has all become, pushes him away, and runs to the bathroom.
This is where the alternating voices start to pay off. Alone in the bathroom, Norah works through the mess she has made of her own life. She turned down Brown University for a gap year on a kibbutz, a plan tangled up with Tal, and she is only now admitting that Tal is controlling and that she went along with the plan to be near him. Nick, meanwhile, is getting advice from Toni in a mock confessional. He admits he does not know if he is ready for Norah. Toni tells him there is no such thing as ready, only willing. It is the best line in the book, and it lands because Nick does not know what to do with it.
Norah comes back out with an honest speech about how kindness scares her because trust is harder than distrust. She also has news: she spotted graffiti announcing a surprise set by Where's Fluffy, the punk band she worships. Nick answers with a long, tender explanation of why he cannot leave her side. Bandmates Dev and Hunter turn up, the room heats up, and Where's Fluffy explodes into their set. Nick fights through the mosh pit to reach Norah, and they kiss while the band plays. Then the band swings into a song called Take Me Back, Bitch, and Nick flinches, because Tris is suddenly back in his head. The connection cracks right down the middle.
A no that is actually kindness
Norah leads Nick to a backstage dressing room and starts to take things further, but Nick stops her. He can tell that something desperate is driving her, not wanting. He says no. In a lesser book this would be a cheap moment of noble restraint, but here it feels like the truest thing either of them does all night. They are both acting out of old wounds, and one of them finally notices.
Norah asks if he saw Tal at the club. She says yes, though in truth she saw Tris, and she lets Nick believe the problem is her baggage rather than his own unfinished business. Hurt and humiliated, she drags Tris out of a crowd surf and takes her to a 24-hour Korean grocery. Tris explains herself in plain terms. Nick said I love you, she did not feel it back, and ending things then felt kinder than letting him build a life on a lie. Norah tells her to go say that to Nick himself.
Outside, Norah finds Nick but cannot face another try. She traces the sign of the cross on him, tells him he is absolved, and takes a cab still wearing his jacket. It is a lovely, strange gesture, half joke and half prayer. On the Ludlow Street curb, Tris sits down beside Nick and gives him the same hard talk. He was holding on to something that was never really there, she says, and Norah is a runner who does not actually want to run. She tells him to go find her.
The cab driver takes Norah toward Tal's place, but she stops herself and redirects to Veselka, the 24-hour Ukrainian restaurant in the East Village. In the jacket pocket she finds Nick's cell phone. Back on Ludlow, Dev sits with Nick and says that I Wanna Hold Your Hand is the greatest love song ever written, because all anyone really wants is to hold someone's hand. Nick finds a pay phone and calls his own number. Speaking about himself in the third person, he tells Norah that Nick blew it and is relieved to be free of Tris. She tells him where she is.
Veselka, March Eighteenth, and tikkun olam
They eat like people who have not eaten all day, and then they introduce themselves properly. Norah reveals that she knew Nick long before the club, through the playlists and lyrics Tris passed along. She names a song called March Eighteenth, a track Nick wrote and hid as a bonus, as her favorite. Tris never even mentioned it. Nick admits that his love songs were about a feeling he projected onto Tris, not about Tris herself. Norah confesses that what she loved about Tal was mostly the way he said goodnight. This conversation is the quiet centre of the novel. Two kids who have been performing heartbreak for each other finally say what actually happened.
Tris shows up and pulls Norah into the bathroom for a tutorial on kissing, then warns her not to rush things with Nick. It is a funny scene and also a tender one, because Tris turns out to be a better friend in the aftermath than she was as a girlfriend. They ride the 6 train uptown and walk along Park Avenue. Norah explains tikkun olam, the Jewish idea that the world has been broken into pieces and that each person has a job to help put it back together. Nick answers that maybe they are the pieces, and that coming together is how the breaking stops. I rolled my eyes a little at this, I will admit. It is the most explicitly thematic line in the book. But in the moment, after a night of honest talk, it felt earned rather than pasted on.
Norah's father calls. He reveals that he intercepted her rejection letter from Brown and replaced it with an acceptance. Norah is furious and relieved at once, which is probably the exact right response. She looks up and sees Nick dancing in a sudden downpour. They kiss in the rain. He takes her into the Marriott Marquis, to an ice room lit by a Pepsi machine, and they slowly undress each other. An elderly couple opens the door, and both of them burst out laughing and agree that this is all happening too soon. That interruption is the book at its best, funny and honest about how fast a night can move.
The jump at Canal Street
At dawn they walk south through the city. Nick programs Norah's number into his phone under the name Salvatore, which is his way of keeping the joke alive. Jessie still will not start. While hunting for jumper cables at a Korean grocery, Norah listens to a voicemail from Caroline, a warm message saying she is glad Norah is finally taking care of herself. It is a small scene, but it closes the Caroline thread with real affection. They abandon the car and run for the Canal Street subway station.
Nick swipes his MetroCard and goes through the turnstile. Norah tries to follow, and the card reads Insufficient Fare. A train is coming. Nick puts his hand on hers through the bars of the turnstile. Norah hesitates, because this is the moment where a leap of faith stops being a phrase and becomes a physical act. Nick asks, Are we in this or not? She takes his hand, takes a breath, and jumps.
The book ends there. No wedding, no montage, no promise written on a napkin. Just two kids at a turnstile, choosing each other for the next few seconds and letting that be enough. Given how much of the novel is about not knowing what comes next, it is the right ending. If you want a tidy resolution, you will not get one.
What works, and what gets in the way
The best thing here is the conversation. Cohn and Levithan write teenagers who actually sound like people, funny and guarded, quick to change the subject. The five-minute girlfriend lie, the Yugo that never starts, the drag queen giving relationship advice, and the elderly couple in the ice room are specific, alive scenes. The alternating chapters let the two leads be wrong about each other in ways a single narrator could not manage. When Nick misreads why Norah pulls away, we know better because we have just been inside her head. That dramatic irony is the book's quiet strength.
The music is both the joy and the problem. I loved the mix CDs and the deep-cut references, and I believe these kids would really talk this way. But there are long stretches where the references pile up faster than a reader who is not a music geek can follow. At times it feels less like sharing a passion than performing it for someone who is supposed to be impressed. The straight edge detail, which is handled well early on, mostly disappears as the night goes on, and a few of the thematic lines, like the tikkun olam exchange, sit a little too neatly on the page.
I would hand this to a reader who likes their romance messy and loud, and who does not mind a book that assumes you know your indie rock history. I would be careful with a reader who wants a plot with more than one night in it, or who is tired of the doomed-ex pattern. What stayed with me was not the title's clever idea about endless playlists but the simpler thing underneath it: two people who have been hurt, choosing to be willing even though they are nowhere near ready. That is a small, decent outcome, and the book is smart enough to leave it at that.
FAQ
Is Nick and Norah's Infinite Playlist written by one author?
No. Rachel Cohn and David Levithan co-wrote it, alternating chapters: Cohn wrote Norah's first-person sections and Levithan wrote Nick's.
What does the infinite playlist in the title refer to?
It grows out of the mix CDs Nick keeps making and the playlist Norah wants to build for him, a set of songs that could keep expanding as long as they do.
How does the book compare with the 2008 movie?
The film starring Michael Cera and Kat Dennings keeps the basic setup, but it trims the straight edge detail and much of the dense music talk, and it changes several scenes.





























