Cover of Detransition, Baby by Torrey Peters

Detransition, Baby

2,925-word summary 13 min read 352 pages in the book

First published
2021
Publisher
One World
Pages
352
ISBN
9780593133378
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. Three people and one improbable proposal
  2. How Reese and Amy came apart
  3. Elephants, Chicago, and a mother's advice
  4. Trying the family on for size
  5. The cowboy at the essential oils party
  6. Cold water and an unfinished answer
  7. What the book is really doing
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I nearly stopped reading in the first chapter. Not because the writing was weak, but because Reese, the woman the book opens with, was behaving in a way I found hard to forgive. She was sleeping with a married man and describing it as a way of managing her loneliness, all while carrying a wish so specific it sounded almost old-fashioned: she wanted to be a mother. I kept going because the gap between those two things seemed to be the whole point, and because Torrey Peters was plainly not interested in making Reese likable. This is Peters's debut novel, published on January 12, 2021 by One World, an imprint of Random House, and it runs to 352 pages in the hardcover edition. It is set mostly in Brooklyn, and it concerns three adults in their thirties trying to work out whether a family can be assembled from people who fit very badly into the roles they have been handed.

Three people and one improbable proposal

The book has three central figures. Reese is a trans woman who works with children and has wanted a baby for as long as she can remember. Ames is the man Reese used to love, who lived for six years as a trans woman named Amy before detransitioning and now tries to pass as an ordinary man. Katrina is Ames's boss and lover, a Chinese Jewish cis woman who has just discovered she is pregnant with his child. All three are in their thirties, all three live in Brooklyn, and none of them is having a comfortable year.

The pregnancy is the engine of the whole story. Ames had been told by a doctor that he would be sterile after years on hormone replacement therapy, so the news arrives like a practical joke played by his own body. Katrina is not certain she wants to keep the baby. Ames is not certain he wants to be a father, and the word itself bothers him because it comes wrapped in a set of masculine expectations he has spent years trying to get away from. Reese, meanwhile, has put together what the publisher's description calls a life of mundane, bourgeois comforts, and the one thing missing from it is a child.

Ames's solution is the sort of idea that sounds absurd until you sit with it. He goes to Reese and proposes that the three of them raise the baby together. Reese, who has wanted a child for years and cannot become pregnant herself, is drawn to the idea even while she finds it strange. Katrina, who knows almost nothing about Ames's past at this point, is much less drawn to it. That proposal is the device that holds the book together. Peters uses it to push three people into a conversation they would never have had on their own, and to make each of them say out loud what they actually want, which is rarely what they say they want at first.

What I liked immediately is that nobody here is a saint. Reese is lonely and dishonest with herself. Ames is scared and a little self-pitying. Katrina is practical to the point of cruelty when she feels cornered. Peters, who has said she wanted to imagine trans people as ordinary, flawed people rather than as an embattled group, gives them all the small vanities and bad habits of real adults. The book is funny far more often than I expected, and its comedy comes from the awkwardness of these negotiations rather than from any punchline about gender.

How Reese and Amy came apart

The novel keeps stepping backward. It is divided into eleven chapters, narrated in the third person, and the narration moves between the present and several years earlier, so the story of how Reese and Amy broke up emerges in pieces. Those flashbacks are not filler. They explain why the proposal matters so much to the three people making it.

Reese's early life set the pattern. In her twenties she became involved with a man named Stanley, who was going through a divorce and was, by turns, dependable and controlling. She met him through a website aimed at cisgender men who fetishize trans women, and she stayed with him long after it was clear the arrangement was bad for her, because having someone who seemed solid mattered more to her than being treated well. Then she met Amy at a picnic. The two were instantly taken with each other, and Reese moved in with Amy while she was still technically involved with Stanley. Amy reminded her of a foreign exchange student she had known as a boy, which is the kind of small, odd detail Peters uses to make a attraction feel specific rather than generic.

The years that followed were the closest thing to a ordinary life either woman had known. They talked about adopting a child. They had an apartment and jobs and the small routines that Reese had once thought were out of reach for someone like her. But Reese went back to Stanley, secretly at first, and had an affair with him. When Amy found out, the confrontation turned physical in a park, and Stanley fought both women, leaving Amy hurt. That episode is the hinge of the book. Amy had already been struggling with the vulnerability that came with being loved, and the violence of the encounter pushed her toward a hard decision. She began to embrace masculinity as a form of protection, applied for a job under a male name, and told Reese what she had done. Reese left not long after.

Reading those chapters, I found the ending of the relationship less dramatic than the slow accumulation of small failures that led to it. Peters is good on the way a person can be both deeply in love and quietly contemptuous of the person they love. Reese wants Amy to be the woman she needs, and Amy cannot sustain the role when the world makes it dangerous. Neither of them is entirely wrong, and that is why the breakup still aches years later. When Ames calls Reese at the start of the novel, the old feeling is still there on both sides, tangled up with resentment and with the fact that Ames detransitioned partly because of fear of violence, not because he was certain he was a man.

Elephants, Chicago, and a mother's advice

One of the passages readers talk about most arrives in the third chapter, during a work trip that Ames takes with Katrina to Chicago. Ames tries to explain to Katrina why he became distant from other trans women, and he reaches for an article he once read about gangs of juvenile elephants in places such as South Africa, Uganda and Sierra Leone. Poachers had killed the mothers and older elephants, and the young ones, left without elders to teach them how to behave, had become violent and disruptive. Ames calls his own generation a lost generation in the same sense. Peters gives him a line that has stayed with me: trans women of his age are fifteen thousand pounds of muscle and bone forged from rage and trauma. The older generation, he says, died of HIV, poverty, suicide and repression, or disappeared into quiet stealth lives, leaving the younger women with no one to teach them how to live.

The argument is deliberately arguable. Ames and Reese both walk it back a little, noting that it mainly describes white trans women, and the book never quite endorses it as fact. It works better as a portrait of how Ames thinks than as a sociological claim. He has built a story about why his community feels rootless, and he uses that story to justify his own retreat from it. I found the passage persuasive and a little self-serving at the same time, which is exactly how a person's private theory usually looks to a friend.

The Chicago trip does something else too. Katrina, drunk and still hurt that Ames kept his past from her, outs him to their straight male clients at a work event. It is a nasty moment, and the book does not soften it. The next day the two of them finally talk properly. Ames tells her more about the years he spent as Amy, and he floats the idea of raising the child with Reese. Katrina is angry at first, partly because the proposal sounds like Ames trying to keep a foothold in a life he claimed to have left. Then she calls her mother, Maya, who encourages her to at least consider it. That phone call matters. Maya is one of the few steady presences in the book, and her advice is practical rather than grand: think about whether this arrangement could actually work before you refuse it.

Trying the family on for size

Once Katrina is willing to consider the arrangement, the novel moves into a stretch that reads almost like a social comedy. The three meet at the GLAAD Media Awards to talk about co-parenting with all of them in the room for the first time. Reese and Katrina argue about whose claim to motherhood counts more, and both of them cry, and both of them end up liking each other a little more than they expected. Ames later tells Reese he thought the meeting went well, which is his usual way of avoiding a harder conversation.

Two scenes complicate the mood. Reese goes to the funeral of a trans girl named Tammi, who died in a car accident, and the gathering is a reminder of how precarious the lives of people like her can be. It is one of the few moments where the book lets the danger sit in the room without turning it into an argument. Soon after, Katrina calls Reese because a rumor has started at their agency that Ames is a trans man, spread from something Katrina said while drunk in Chicago. Reese finds the whole thing funny, which says a great deal about how differently these two women see the world. Katrina invites Reese to come along to an ultrasound appointment, and the invitation is the clearest sign that the plan is becoming real.

The baby registry scene is the best small portrait of their unlikely partnership. At Maya's suggestion, Reese and Katrina go shopping for the things a baby will need, and they disagree about a crib. Reese thinks babies should sleep in bed with their parents; Katrina is afraid of rolling over in her sleep and hurting the child. Reese gives in, assuming this is how it will always be, that Katrina will have the last word because she is the one who is actually pregnant. Later she notices that Katrina has quietly removed the crib from the registry. Neither of them says much about it. That silent edit tells you more about the shape of their relationship than any of their long conversations do.

The cowboy at the essential oils party

The arrangement nearly collapses at a doTERRA party thrown by one of Katrina's friends. Reese is out of her element among straight professional couples, and when the guests are asked to list their medical ailments, Katrina announces that she is pregnant. Asked who the father is, she turns to Reese, who has to explain that she is trans and will be a co-parent but is not the actual father. At a cafe afterward, Katrina tells her friends she is excited not to do the conventional thing, and Reese realizes she is watching her come out as queer. Most of the friends come around. One of them, Diana, is not sure, because her husband once cheated on her with a trans woman.

Then Diana's husband arrives to pick her up, and Reese recognizes him as Garrett, the married man she has been seeing, the one she calls her cowboy. He is the man who contracted HIV from another trans woman and passed none of this on to the woman he lives with. Reese slips out before anyone can make the connection, but the connection is made anyway. Katrina is furious, both because Reese has been dishonest and because she believes the baby has been put at risk. She threatens to end the pregnancy.

Reese's response is to write an email accusing Ames and Katrina of treating queerness as something to sample only while it is convenient, of what she calls the gentrification of queerness. She does not send it at first. The next morning, after texts from Ames telling her to fix what she has done, she sends it to both of them. This is the book at its most uncomfortable, and I think deliberately so. Reese's charge has some truth in it, but she also uses it to dodge the specific thing she did. Peters refuses to tell us which of them is right, and the argument is better for it.

Cold water and an unfinished answer

The final chapter is titled twelve weeks after conception, and it pulls the threads together in a way that surprised me. Ames goes to see an old college friend named Jon, with whom he has talked through his uncertainties for years. Jon gives him the plainest advice in the book: be honest with the women in your life about what you want. Ames takes it badly but takes it. He tells Katrina that he can commit to raising the child with her, but that he cannot promise he will not question his gender again, or that he will not one day live as a woman. It is the most truthful thing he says in the novel, and it is not the answer Katrina wanted.

Then the call comes that Reese is in the hospital. The day after sending her email, she had gone with a friend to Riis Beach, and overcome with the sense that she had lost the child she had already begun to love, she walked into the cold water to numb herself, using a breathing technique she had seen in a video about the endurance teacher Wim Hof. People on the beach thought she was drowning and called an ambulance. Reese insists she was not trying to kill herself, and the book gives us no reason to disbelieve her, though it also does not make the distinction feel tidy. Ames and Katrina pick her up, she apologizes for the email, and Katrina admits that some of what Reese wrote was fair.

Katrina schedules an abortion and asks both of them to come with her. On the morning of the appointment, the three of them sit together in her apartment. Reese asks her to wait, to think it over, and the novel ends without telling us what she decides. The last lines describe three people, close and yet far apart, each thinking about herself and then about the baby, and each realizing that her own fragile sense of womanhood has come to depend on whether this small person exists. It is an ending that refuses the easy payoff. I found it honest, and I also found it frustrating, which I suspect is the response Peters was aiming for.

What the book is really doing

Detransition, Baby is dedicated to divorced cis women, and Peters has explained why: they have to start over in adulthood at a point when they were supposed to be settled, which is something she connects to the experience of trans women. That comparison is the quiet argument underneath the plot. The novel is interested in who gets to be a mother, what happens when the people who want a family least resemble the families we expect, and how much of gender is a private fact versus a social arrangement other people keep insisting on.

The form is part of the experience. Peters has said she thought of the book as a soap opera, and that her characters talk the way her friends talk. The dialogue is sharp, gossipy and often very funny, and the shifts back in time give the present-day negotiations a weight they would not have if we only saw the three of them in the room. The book won the PEN/Hemingway Award, was a finalist for several other major prizes, and was longlisted for the Women's Prize for Fiction, where Peters became the first openly trans writer to be nominated. That nomination drew a public letter from people who disputed her eligibility, which the prize organizers rejected. I mention it because the book itself is far more interested in ordinary domestic mess than in any argument about who belongs, and the contrast is striking.

My criticism is that the novel sometimes leans too hard on the cleverness of its own arrangement. There are moments when a character stops living and starts delivering a position, and the juvenile elephants passage is the clearest example. The ending, too, holds back so carefully that the emotional payoff feels withheld, and some readers will find that choice frustrating rather than brave. But the book earns its place through the three people at its centre. Reese, Ames and Katrina are selfish, funny, frightened and capable of real kindness, often in the same paragraph. Peters is not asking us to admire them. She is asking us to watch what happens when three lonely adults try to make something sturdier than the lives they have, and she leaves the answer open because the arrangement she describes is still being made.

FAQ

Is Detransition, Baby Torrey Peters's first novel?

Yes, it was her debut, published on January 12, 2021 by One World, an imprint of Random House, and set mostly in Brooklyn.

Who are the three people at the centre of the book?

Reese is a trans woman who wants a child, Ames is her former partner who detransitioned and now lives as a man, and Katrina is Ames's boss and lover who discovers she is pregnant with his baby.

Does the novel say whether the baby is kept?

No. It ends with the three of them sitting together on the morning of a planned abortion, and the decision is left open.