Cover of The Unknown by Riley Sager

The Unknown

2,424-word summary 11 min read 368 pages in the book

First published
2026
Publisher
Dutton
Pages
368
ISBN
9798217044092
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. A film crew on an island with an old ghost story
  2. Marin Keane, the actress nobody recognizes
  3. Daisy's diary and the voice called Azra
  4. The island starts to bite
  5. The grief everybody brings to the island
  6. The con, and what Violet was really after
  7. The second reveal and what got left in the lake
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this one up because the cover promised a locked-island gothic, and the first chapter delivered exactly that: a woman arriving on a remote island to make a film about five women who vanished there a century earlier. The Unknown was published in 2026 by Dutton, runs 368 pages, and carries ISBN 9798217044092. It is Riley Sager's tenth novel under that name, and it is built around two disappearances set a hundred years apart. What I did not expect was how much of the book would turn out to be about acting, and about what people will believe when they are frightened in a group.

A film crew on an island with an old ghost story

The premise is a performer's nightmare and a horror fan's delight. Director Ronan Peters is making a film called Darkness. It tells the story of the 1926 vanishing of five women from New Avalon, a remote island on Lake Faraday in Vermont. According to the island's legend, the women were spiritual mediums gathered around a figure named Ruth Hume Semple. They vanished after a séance unleashed something supernatural. All that was left behind were five dresses hanging from an old oak tree and the diary of one of the women, Daisy Rue.

Ronan runs the production like a cult leader, or at least like a director who has read too many books about Method acting. Phones are surrendered. Electricity is restricted. The cast and crew will spend a week on the island with no easy way off. This is the kind of setup where a reader immediately starts guessing who will disappear first, and Sager knows it. He gives the isolated-production rule a practical excuse, then lets the isolation do what isolation always does in this genre: turn small frictions into large suspicions.

The cast is a convenient bundle of egos and grudges. There is Violet Wright, a veteran star with a long memory. There are Julianne Brown and Heather Benchley, and there is Susie Hutchinson, who is abrasive from her first scene and clearly enjoys being disliked. Producer Loretta Zeverin handles the logistics, the kind of person who is always checking whether the boat is still running. A working actor will recognize the hierarchy immediately, from the star with the trailer to the crew member quietly counting the hours.

There is a film-inside-a-film quality to these early pages that I enjoyed. The cast is making a movie about a haunting, which means every prop and every line of dialogue has two meanings at once. A dress hanging in a tree is scenery for the film and evidence for the legend. A séance is a rehearsal and a genuine attempt to contact something. Sager keeps both possibilities alive, and that doubleness is the source of the book's best unease. Even Loretta Zeverin, who seems purely practical, becomes more interesting once you realize she has been placed on the island to watch the others.

Marin Keane, the actress nobody recognizes

The point of view character is Marin Keane, a struggling actress whose career high point is an eczema commercial. That detail is funny for about half a page and then sad, because it tells you exactly how Marin measures her own worth. She is always almost working, always one audition from being forgotten. When Ronan Peters offers her the role of Daisy Rue, she takes it.

There is one warning she ignores. The part was originally cast with an actress named Lindy Garrett, who tells Marin not to go. It is the kind of warning that exists in thrillers solely so the protagonist can override it, and Marin does. Her reasons are professional and personal at once: this is the biggest role she has been offered, and she needs to believe she is someone who can carry a film. That need is the engine of the whole book. Marin wants to be seen, and the story keeps asking what she will trade for it.

Her guilt has an older source. When Marin was four, her sister Molly drowned in the family pool. Marin has carried that since childhood, a vague, unshakeable sense that she should have done something. Sager does not over-explain it. He lets it surface in the way Marin half believes she sees Molly around the island, a figure at the edge of a scene that she cannot quite make out. The drowning is the private wound that makes the public haunting feel personal to her.

Daisy's diary and the voice called Azra

The novel's best structural choice is to alternate Marin's present-day chapters with Daisy Rue's 1926 diary. The diary sections are the quieter, stranger half of the book. They describe Daisy arriving at New Avalon and meeting the women who have gathered there: Katrina Fiske, Jonquil Collins, Mrs Minafer, and others around Ruth Hume Semple. The prose takes on a period texture that sets it apart from Marin's sections, and the contrast keeps the two timelines distinct. Daisy's entries have a diary's intimacy, the sense of a young woman writing down what she has seen before she forgets it. Katrina Fiske, Jonquil Collins and Mrs Minafer each get a few sharp strokes, enough to make the reader understand the small hierarchy of the group around Ruth Hume Semple. I found myself caring about these women in the way I cared about the film crew, which made the later questions about what really happened in 1926 feel personal rather than academic.

Into the diary comes a force called Azra, something that speaks during the séances. Azra warns Daisy that she will be last. That single line does an enormous amount of work. It gives the diary a countdown and gives the reader a question to carry across a century: what happens to the woman who is last? The answer the book eventually offers is more complicated than a ghost story, and the complicated answer is both the strength and the weakness of the final stretch.

Marin, reading the diary on the island, discovers that Ronan has invented an ending for it. The real diary is incomplete. Ronan has supplied a conclusion that suits the film he wants to make. This is the moment when the idea of performance starts to infect the mystery itself. If the diary has been edited, then the legend has been shaped, and if the legend has been shaped, then perhaps the haunting has been shaped too. Sager plants this early enough that a careful reader can start pulling at the thread long before the official reveal.

The island starts to bite

Once a health emergency strands the crew, the atmosphere tightens. With the boat unable to leave and no outside help coming, the island stops being a location and starts being a container. Strange noises come from nowhere. Daisy-wheel symbols appear, marked in places where nobody admits to marking them. Séances are staged, first as rehearsal and then as something harder to dismiss. The health emergency matters because it removes the easy exit. Before it, every strange sound could be explained away by people who wanted to go home. After it, the cast has no choice but to keep interpreting the signs together. Sager is good at the physical business of fear: the creak of a floorboard in a cottage, the sudden certainty that a door was left open, the way a group of tired people will agree on a story simply because nobody wants to be the one who says it out loud.

The disappearances come in a deliberate order. Susie goes first, the abrasive one nobody will miss immediately, and a dress appears hanging from the old oak tree, just as it does in the legend. Ronan is seen entering her cottage, and he explains it away by claiming she tried to seduce him. The claim is self-serving and everybody knows it, but the production limps on. Heather and Julianne vanish next, and the pattern starts to feel less like a haunting and more like a message aimed at one person.

What struck me here is how quickly the group manufactures a supernatural explanation. The island, the dresses, the diary, the symbols, the noises: they all point toward Azra, and the cast has a ready-made story to fit every new frightening fact. Sager is interested in the psychology of that. People who are scared together will build a shared explanation out of whatever materials they have, especially when each of them arrives with a private grief that makes the explanation feel true.

The grief everybody brings to the island

That private grief is the book's real subject for a while. Marin has Molly, the sister in the pool. Other characters carry their own losses, and Sager lets those losses leak into the séances. The group does not just fear Azra. It wants Azra to be real, because a supernatural explanation would give shape to grief that otherwise has none. If a voice can speak from beyond, then a dead sister or a lost mother is not entirely gone.

This is the most interesting idea in The Unknown, and it is also where the book starts to overreach. Marin's half-sightings of Molly are genuinely unsettling because they are so plausible. A person who has carried a childhood guilt will see what she expects to see in a dark cottage. The novel understands that. But it also keeps stacking one trauma on top of another until the emotional logic starts to feel engineered, as though every character has been assigned a wound for the séance scene to exploit.

Still, the device works for a while. The séances become a place where the cast's private griefs and the public legend feed each other. Marin, who began the book desperate to be noticed, finds herself at the centre of a story that is beginning to notice her for the wrong reasons. The question of what she wants, which starts as career ambition, quietly becomes a question about whether she wants to be believed.

The con, and what Violet was really after

The turn comes when Marin finds evidence that the missing women are alive. The haunting has been staged. The entire production was a trap for Ronan, engineered by Violet and a small group of people connected to a woman named Elise Haines. Ronan had filmed himself having sex with Elise and circulated the recording. Elise died by suicide. She was Violet's secret daughter.

Elise Haines is the key to that section, and Sager gives her the kind of off-page weight that a good thriller villain deserves. Ronan filmed himself having sex with her, circulated the recording, and left her to live with what he had done. Her suicide is the fact that turns a group of pranksters into something more deliberate. Violet's grief has been sitting in the room the whole time, disguised as professional caution, and the reveal lets you see every earlier scene differently. Her watchfulness was not the wariness of an older actress. It was the patience of a mother building a case.

That changes the meaning of everything that came before. The fake haunting was not a prank or a publicity stunt. It was designed to frighten Ronan into confessing what he did to Elise. The dresses, the noises, the symbols, the diary's invented ending: all of it was a trap built around a man who made a career out of other people's vulnerabilities. Violet's performance as the veteran star, calm and watchful through every strange event, turns out to have been the most important performance in the book.

I found this reveal satisfying in a straightforward way. It pays off the acting theme. The whole novel has been about people playing roles, and the person playing the most convincing role was the one quietly assembling the evidence. At a final séance, Violet appears to be possessed by Daisy and then stabs Ronan with an ice pick. Marin helps move the body so that his death looks accidental. It is a grim little piece of theatre, and the book treats it as exactly that: one last scene before the cameras are gone.

The second reveal and what got left in the lake

Then Sager does something riskier. He rewrites 1926. Semple's hidden journal and remains found beneath a structure show that the five women were bound up with Azra Kovacic, a psychiatric patient, and that several figures in Daisy's diary were fragments of a fractured mind, Daisy among them. In other words, the historical mystery gets a psychological explanation, not a supernatural one. Violet throws the journal into the lake, refusing to let the story be told.

This is where a lot of readers part company with the book. The late pileup of revelations is engineered to keep you guessing, and it does, but the psychological explanation of the historical mystery arrives rushed. A century of atmosphere, of dresses on an oak tree and a voice promising that Daisy will be last, gets resolved in a few brisk pages about a fractured mind. The finale feels overstuffed, as though Sager had three good endings and could not bring himself to cut any of them.

What stayed with me was not the explanation but the choice Marin makes with the evidence. She keeps Susie's camcorder SD card. When someone asks what she wants, she says she wants to be known. After a book about a woman who was almost known for an eczema commercial, that line lands. Four years later, Marin is an Oscar-nominated star, Ronan's death has been ruled an accident, and the film was never made. A 1931 photograph of a woman named Zara McCutcheon, who resembles Daisy, hints that something of her survived the lake and the journal and the official story.

That final photograph is either a clever last turn or a cheap tease, depending on how much you trust the book's appetite for one more mystery. I leaned toward clever. The Unknown is at its best when it is about performance and evidence, about how a story can be assembled to make people believe almost anything. When it tries to explain its century-old ghost with a case file, it loses some of the atmosphere that made the island worth visiting. I would still recommend it to anyone who likes a gothic thriller with a strong sense of place. Just go in expecting the last fifty pages to be busier than the first three hundred.

FAQ

Is The Unknown based on a true story?

No. The 1926 vanishing of five mediums from New Avalon and the island on Lake Faraday are fictional. Sager built the gothic setup from the conventions of island mysteries and stage thrillers.

What is Azra in the book?

Azra begins as the name of a voice that speaks during the 1926 séances in Daisy's diary and warns her she will be last. The final reveal connects it to Azra Kovacic, a psychiatric patient, and to the fractured mind behind parts of the diary.

Why does the ending divide readers?

The book stacks several reveals in its last section, including a psychological explanation for the historical mystery. Many readers found that rush overstuffed, while others enjoyed how performance and evidence are woven together.