Cover of The Maze of Bones by Rick Riordan

The Maze of Bones

2,831-word summary 13 min read 220 pages in the book

First published
2008
Publisher
Scholastic
Pages
220
ISBN
9780545060394
Series
The 39 Clues (#1)
Reading options
What's inside (9 sections)
  1. A deathbed change to the will
  2. A burning house and the trail of Benjamin Franklin
  3. Across the Atlantic, into a trap
  4. Skulls, a number puzzle, and a photograph in the tracks
  5. The church beneath Montmartre
  6. What Amy kept in her pocket
  7. Where it works and where it stumbles
  8. Key takeaways
  9. FAQ

I picked this one up because I remembered the racket around The 39 Clues when it first appeared, the trading cards and the hidden bookmarks and the online game that was supposed to make reading feel like a hunt. I wanted to find out whether the book that started it all could hold up once you stripped away the marketing. The Maze of Bones was published by Scholastic on September 9, 2008, the first novel in the series, and it is a slim 220-page hardcover in the first edition. Rick Riordan, better known for Percy Jackson, wrote this opening volume of what was planned as a ten-book relay, with a different author taking the baton each time. What I found was a quick, smart adventure that makes history feel like a treasure map, and that mostly works, even though it leaves a few of its big promises hanging.

The hook is the kind that grabs you right away. Grace Cahill, the elderly matriarch of a family that supposedly produced everyone from Napoleon to Houdini, is dying. In her last moments she asks her lawyer, William McIntyre, to change her will to an alternate version. She dies, and a man in a dark suit steps in to talk with McIntyre about something the family is not meant to know. That man, and the plan he and the lawyer are cooking up, hover over the entire book without ever being explained. It is a tidy piece of setup, and it puts a low hum of menace under all the puzzle-solving.

A deathbed change to the will

The story really gets going at Grace's funeral, where her orphaned grandchildren, Amy and Dan Cahill, turn up under the care of their guardian, Aunt Beatrice. Amy is fourteen and bookish, the kind of kid who reads the plaques in a museum. Dan is eleven, restless, and always hungry. They are also the grandchildren Grace favored, which becomes clear as the day goes on. At the service they bump into a crowd of other Cahills. There are the Holt siblings, Hamilton, Reagan, and Madison, all athletic and military about everything. There are the Kabra siblings, Ian and Natalie, wealthy and cool and already looking down their noses. There are the Starling triplets, who are academic and painfully proper. Jonah Wizard, a famous singer, is there too, along with Alistair Oh, a polite older man with a talent for gadgets, and Irina Spasky, who has the stillness of a trained KGB spy.

A chosen few are called into a private reading of the will. McIntyre plays a video of Grace, who tells the assembled relatives that they have a decision to make. Each of them can take one million dollars, or each can take a single clue. Most of the family, sensibly, takes the money. Ian and Natalie Kabra are the first to grab a clue, and they are quickly followed by the Holts, the Starlings, Jonah, Alistair, and Irina. That leaves seven teams in the race. Amy and Dan at first want the money like everyone else, but they realize that Grace would have wanted them to choose the clue, so they turn down their million dollars and accept a sealed manila envelope.

Before they leave, McIntyre gives them a private warning. "Beware the Madrigals," he says, and refuses to say more. It is a great little hook, a name that promises danger and then stays stubbornly unexplained for the rest of the book. I liked the mystery of it, and I also felt the small frustration of being dangled a threat that never pays off here. That is a pattern in The Maze of Bones: it is very good at opening doors and not always in a hurry to walk through them.

A burning house and the trail of Benjamin Franklin

With their envelope in hand, Amy and Dan head to Grace's mansion and poke around the library. Amy finds a secret passage, and in the library she discovers an annotated copy of Benjamin Franklin's Poor Richard's Almanack. Alistair Oh shows up in the passage, and Amy hands him the almanack to look at, a decision that will come back to bite her. Before the two teams can settle anything, the mansion catches fire. They escape separately, and Amy and Dan spot a mysterious figure in a dark suit watching from outside.

They run home to their au pair, Nellie Gomez, who is young and more than a little out of her depth. Amy and Dan spill the whole story, and to her credit Nellie agrees to come with them. The first clue points to Benjamin Franklin, who, they learn, was a Cahill himself. That is the series' central trick, the idea that history's great minds and movers were all members of this one sprawling family, each branch with its own gift. The Ekaterina branch, for instance, is the one for inventors and tinkerers. The clue sends the siblings to the Franklin Institute in Philadelphia, where they dig through Franklin's papers and uncover secret messages. The Starlings, hunting the same lead, get taken out when a bomb goes off in the museum. It is a rough introduction to how dangerous this contest is meant to be.

The Franklin material is where the book's research shows. Riordan sprinkles in real details about Franklin's life, his inventions, and his writing, and he makes the puzzle-solving feel active rather than passive. Amy and Dan are not told where to go; they work it out from odd references to a "maze of bones" and from annotations in old books. When it is done well, you can almost see the trail they are following. The historical tidbits are the best part of the book, and they are what kept me turning pages even when the plot started to feel mechanical.

Across the Atlantic, into a trap

All the teams end up in Paris, where Irina Spasky has somehow gotten hold of the almanack. Jonah Wizard offers Amy, Dan, and Nellie a ride to their hotel, but Dan spots Irina, and he quietly asks the singer to drop them at a different hotel instead. That is the sort of quick thinking that makes Dan a satisfying protagonist. He is the kid who notices things. They tail Irina to a stronghold used by the Lucian branch of the family, steal a strange orb from it, and use it to find a set of coordinates pointing to an island. They follow the lead into what turns out to be a trap. The ground gives way beneath them and they land in a pit. Their relative attacks are constant and sometimes absurd, and the Holts try to steal their clue while they are stuck, only to be scattered by shadowy attackers. Dan uses a concussive grenade to buy them a way out, and once again the man in the dark suit is seen watching from the edges.

This section has the breathless, one-thing-after-another pace of a good chase, but it also shows the book's weakness for piling on coincidences. Every corridor has an enemy, every enemy has a gadget, and the siblings escape each scrape with a bit of luck. It is fun in the moment. It is less convincing when you stop to think about how many narrow escapes a pair of kids can have in a single afternoon. Still, Riordan keeps the stakes clear and the geography easy to follow, which is more than I can say for a lot of children's adventures.

Skulls, a number puzzle, and a photograph in the tracks

The trail leads Amy and Dan into the catacombs, the tunnels under Paris lined with the stacked bones and skulls of millions of people. It is the perfect setting for a book whose title promises a maze of bones, and Riordan makes the most of the creepiness. Amy, who has a head for patterns, spots an array of skulls with numbers carved into them. She realizes it is a magic box, a number puzzle that Franklin himself invented, something like sudoku, and that three numbers are missing. Those missing numbers turn out to be coordinates to the next clue.

The Kabras ambush them in the tunnels. Amy threatens to smash the skulls rather than let Ian and Natalie copy the numbers, and Alistair Oh suddenly appears and tackles Natalie before she can fire a dart gun at Amy. The alliances shift constantly in this book, which keeps you guessing about who is really on whose side. Amy, Dan, and Nellie flee through the tunnels and end up in a train tunnel with a train bearing down on them. Dan's backpack gets caught in the tracks, and he cannot yank it free. Amy pulls him out just in time, but the train takes the backpack with it, and with it the last photograph Dan had of his parents.

That loss is the most genuinely affecting moment in the book. Up until then Dan has been the comic relief, the kid cracking jokes and eating everything in sight. When he breaks down over the photo, the story suddenly shows what has been driving him beneath all the cleverness. Amy comforts him, and it is the closest the two siblings come to a quiet, honest scene. I wished there were more of that. The book is so busy moving from one puzzle to the next that it rarely lets the grief sit still, and the emotional beats land best when they are allowed to breathe.

The church beneath Montmartre

Back in the library, Amy studies Franklin's papers and keeps seeing the same odd phrase on his shopping lists: iron solute. Nellie, who has been more useful than anyone expected, points out that iron solute has uses in metalworking and printing. A surveyor's map made by scientists who worked with Franklin's lightning rods gives them a grid, and the coordinates lead to the church of Saint-Pierre de Montmartre. Dan finds a grave with a Lucian crest and no name, and the siblings borrow tools from the church shed and dig until they uncover stairs leading back into the catacombs.

Below the church they find a small chamber with faded murals. Amy reads the pictures and realizes they show four original Cahill siblings, each holding a symbol of a different talent. One holds a dagger, one a bronze mechanism, one a sword, and one a harp, and they stand for the four branches of the family: Lucian, Ekaterina, Tomas, and Janus. Behind them a house burns, echoing both Grace's mansion and the fire that killed Amy and Dan's parents. In the middle of the room, on a pedestal, sits a vase decorated with images of Franklin. Amy finds sheet music on its base and a glass vial wrapped in paper inside. Scrambled letters on the vial give instructions for charging it.

Jonah Wizard turns up to steal the clue, and Amy does something she has not managed to do all book: she finds her voice. She stands up to him, threatens to break the vial, and makes him back off. The Holts arrive in an ice cream truck, and inside the church Alistair and Irina have formed an alliance and demand the vial. A crate of ice cream hurtles across the room and knocks both of them senseless, which is as ridiculous as it sounds, and Nellie calls the police. Amy and Dan climb the bell tower, where Amy figures out that charging the vial means hanging it from one of Franklin's lightning rods on the roof. Lightning strikes, the vial glows green, and she grabs it and climbs back inside.

Ian Kabra then arrives on a kite, ties Dan up, and claims he has poisoned him. He says he will trade the antidote for the vial. Amy hands it over to save her brother, only for Dan to reveal that Ian was bluffing. The police show up, the relatives scatter, and the siblings escape with what turns out to be the real prize.

What Amy kept in her pocket

The ending is a small, clever win. Ian flew off with the glowing vial, but Amy held on to the paper it was wrapped in, and that paper is the actual clue. Over pain au chocolat with Nellie, Amy works out that the sheet music comes from an adagio for the armonica, an instrument Franklin invented. Dan recognizes the tune because their father used to play it, which turns a puzzle into something personal. Amy also cracks the word play at last. The word "Resolution" from the original clue is an anagram for "iron solute," the ingredient they kept seeing in Franklin's notes. And initials on the sheet music point to none other than Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Vienna is their next stop.

McIntyre turns up at their table, offers to help them pawn a jade necklace for cash, and is turned down. He gives back Saladin, the family cat, which cheers Dan up after the lost photograph. Then the book cuts to McIntyre meeting the man in the dark suit on the Eiffel Tower observation deck, saying the siblings no longer trust him and that he will have to take more drastic steps to control them. The clue race continues elsewhere, the Madrigals are still a mystery, and the source of the Cahill family's power is nowhere near found. The Maze of Bones ends the way a first installment has to end: it solves one small piece and opens a dozen new questions.

Critics were mostly kind when the book came out. It entered the New York Times children's chapter book list at number one on September 28, 2008, and stayed on the list for twenty-four weeks. Publishers Weekly called it a mix of "suspense, perils, and puzzles" and a "rollicking good read," while noting that the story "does not end so much as drop off a cliff." School Library Journal said the book dazzles and stands on its own. Mary Quattlebaum, writing in the Washington Post, thought the villainous relatives were rather flat but that the historical details and swift plot would keep readers engaged. Austin Grossman, in the New York Times, was more mixed. He liked the dramatic premise but called Amy and Dan "agreeably flawed" while pointing to a manufactured, focus-grouped quality, and he thought the supporting characters were stereotypes and the writing carefully bland. A graphic novel adaptation by Ethan Young arrived in 2023.

I think both readings have a point. The book is undeniably engineered. There is a clue, a chase, a narrow escape, and a new clue, repeated with the reliability of clockwork, and the villains are mostly types rather than people. The manufactured feel Grossman noticed is real. But the engineering also produces a genuinely addictive read, and the historical material gives it a texture that a lesser puzzle hunt would lack. The themes of talent and power give the family concept some weight, since the whole premise is that whoever assembles the clues will gain enormous influence, and Amy and Dan have to discover what their own gifts are along the way.

Where it works and where it stumbles

What I would tell a reader considering this book is to enjoy it for what it is: a fast, smart romp through history with a puzzle in every chapter and two likable kids at the center. It is best read quickly and with a willingness to accept that not everything will be explained. The fun is in the hunt, the coded messages, the magic boxes, and the little shocks of recognition when a famous name turns out to be a Cahill. Amy's habit of reading the world closely is a pleasure to watch, and Dan's hunger and impulsiveness give the pair a decent rhythm.

The frustrations are real, though. The man in the dark suit and the Madrigals are dangled as threats and never resolved here. The relatives are cartoonishly nasty, with few shades of gray. The ending is a deliberate cliffhanger, so anyone looking for a complete story in one volume will be disappointed. And the emotional moments, especially the business with the lost photograph, are the parts that linger, yet they get far less space than the chases. The book is at its best when it slows down enough to let Amy and Dan be kids who lost their parents, and at its weakest when it is racing to the next puzzle.

I finished it understanding why the series took off. It hands a young reader a reason to care about Franklin and Mozart and the catacombs of Paris, and it wraps the history in a game with real stakes. It is not a book that offers deep character study or a tidy conclusion. It is a first step, confident and a little cocky, in a much longer race, and as a first step it does its job well.

FAQ

Is The Maze of Bones a complete story or part of a series?

It is the first novel in The 39 Clues, a ten-book series in which different authors wrote different volumes, and it ends on a cliffhanger with the larger hunt unresolved.

Who are Amy and Dan Cahill?

They are orphaned siblings, fourteen and eleven, who turn down a million dollars at their grandmother's will reading and chase clues about their family's hidden power.

What is the answer to the first clue?

Amy decodes the word Resolution as an anagram for iron solute, an ingredient in the Cahill family's mysterious serum, which points them toward Mozart and Vienna.